Skip to main content
Loading video...

Biblios: Quill and Parchment - Discussion

Transcript 16:58

viewer discretion is advised everyone welcome to the discussion for biblios quill and parchment this is the newest iteration of biblios and uh oh man is it light years ahead of the original um which isn't really saying a whole lot because the original is okay at best um but something i got i gotta say right up front is if you are expecting anything close to uh the original you're like oh is this just a nicer looking version of a copy i already love this is absolutely nothing like that game uh not even not even close like it's so i think two similarities and they're not even identical they're just similar yeah that's true it's like how you yeah it's the it's the uh theme yeah and yeah the the score that does right scoring the dice but even then it's like you don't even score them the same way it's uh how you move them up and down is not even remotely close uh and for me obviously i believe that this version is just way better so what do you guys think i liked it a lot better than the original biblios a lot better um i think it still struggles with theme because i mean it is just very much just something pasted onto a paper and yeah i called it earlier um biblio's dungeons and dragons because i felt like

i was filling out like a character sheet doing this yeah it's it's a roland right yeah i liked it though yes i actually i actually like this one um this feels closer to the theme though than the other one did like it has some markings of okay getting closer to the altar getting closer to god at least the other one because biblios was meant as like a library kind of thing at least you're collecting books kind of a book stack because you just stack books in the library and then the monastery stuff of traveling from town to town to preach you know the or collect books or whatever it is at least somewhat and like the more influence you have i like that it's influenced instead of money yes yeah it makes more sense yeah um yeah yeah so it's just it at least in that way it is closer to theme and uh just everything you do about it there's just more game here like i bro what do you think i agree um it's it's it's what you were probably hoping that the other one was i don't know what i was hoping the other one was but uh it's just at the time i was like yeah this is what this is a filler auction game yeah and actually i will say the auction is right out the window there is no bidding yeah well i guess there is for turn order right um but that it you're not bidding for individual cards i really like i like the two phases yeah like it's the most streamlined process it's like i guess if you think really think about it it does have the same kind of tone

of the first edition because it's like the first the first part of the first game in actually first part of both games is you prepping for the second phase right um but i feel like in this one you can you still feel like you're gaining something um and why i like this one a lot more is you actually what your opponents have is more open knowledge right like i can actually you can actually look and strategize on oh you have a lot of blue um so that i'm not gonna i'm a bit hired to take this away from you so you don't get more points for that right or i'm gonna take this one because i'm gonna try and outbeat you in blue instead of just being like yeah i have no idea what [ __ ] cards you have in your hand i'm just gonna hope that what i have in my hand pays off uh the like what what do you think of like in in terms of like the the influence like what do you guys think of that influence versus like the cards or the the money because essentially you use influence here the bid for rows of dice instead of bidding for individual cards uh i think it's got a a better balance toward the strategic than than the money cards yeah before which was too luck based yeah um because essentially if you had no money then it's like well i'm not getting any of these cards yeah and it's possible to draft money yeah and that was a nice buffer for that game but this one it's a whole lot better and clearer to see where everybody's at and see what the possibilities are and it probably surprised everybody that

i didn't bid yeah i was like interesting because you get to look at and be like oh okay you have three options versus just the one right and you're kind of like and i can make something decent out of all any of those yeah so i tell you what i'm going to save my influence for later when i really want something right or just points at the end yeah i mean if you have 40 points in influence and you're just like i'm fine with getting any of these you're going to get 10 points at the end of the game exactly like this is not necessarily a high scoring game a lot of small avenues at how to get points and each game we've played has always been close yeah like 57 and the one we record 57 55 to 42 is and then the one we played right before that was like 49 to 45 to 40. yeah um so it's always really close um the what do you guys think of the dice because it is rolling right you think the dice sway oh this yes i think the fact that you're allowed to either re-roll all of them or just one of them or just keep what you get i think that that's enough mitigation to make them just fine yeah yeah the strategy gamer in me wants to have more options for re-rolling at any given time yeah but it's not that kind of a strategic game no just slow it down no and i think actually whenever we're like because the other one uh the original was about 25 as they say 30 minutes on the box of well i feel like i don't really feel like i wasted 20 minutes but i don't feel like i made use of that 20 minutes here the game takes about the same amount of time but you're actually you do something

there's just more meat to a filler game for what i prefer in filler games like if i can feel like i use my brain at all then i then i'm like yeah that's a good filler yeah instead of just mindlessly yeah and laura got seven and orange and just a difference in definition i wouldn't call this a filler game because it's just got the complexity enough to put it out of that category yeah but it's certainly not a complex game at all not even close but it's not it's not a main hour and a half game it's right it's a fun little but it's one you you throw out when you're waiting for other people to finish their games and we can all get together and do something right yeah it's definitely like a beginner game like it's a good gateway yeah yeah i mean because you actually can try and go for dip like it's like oh man i got i rolled all three of these and i got you know two blue ooh do i want to keep rolling this one and hope i get a blue um or do i want to try and get some chapels and race to to the 10 points up there um i also like in in games like this that you're you always get something like uh you never really get negative points um unless you do yeah yeah well unless you actively choose to to avoid that but even then even the negative points is not such a direct like it's not great western trail where you oh you keep selling in kansas city yeah negative 80 points like whenever people fill out the score [ __ ] and it's like what do you think of the game oh it's like something else it's like oh okay yeah let's just rip it i love just hanging out with you tonight

yeah uh like and it's it's like it's not hard like if you get no blue i think that's the hardest one the harshest negative points yeah which is only three which is only three i mean how many negative points did you get uh two so one in each category funny enough the two points you did lose actually did end up causing you to to lose i don't even know what yeah suck it but if i had taken those points instead of building up the two columns i did i would have gotten first place in those columns yeah and it's and it's interesting because decent balance of decision making yeah uh the tiebreaker is the person's closest to the altar and so which that's why you move back and forth moving up because in this case it would have been me because i'm closer because one furthest to the right is the one furthest from the altar in terms of tie breaking um that makes sense i i enjoy because other games like orleans has one goo gong also has that where you're kind of moving throughout like a map to gather stuff you have a little bit of that here with the monk yeah um and it's not just a one shot you go the same route you you have some ways of actually moving uh like a few paths like a shorter path but it doesn't gain you as much it's it's nice i'm pleasantly surprised but i do think if you are a huge fan of the original like it's your favorite game of all time then this is by the name alone is going to throw you off right i don't

like how he called it the exact same thing yeah uh because it's not the same game yeah it really is biblio's just for people who liked it and they were like oh another one yeah but i mean and it's it's it's literally the same size yeah it has i mean it looks better like it's a lot more colorful it is a lot more color yeah i appreciate that it does that look looks interesting it does there's no hot guys on it yeah that's true well there's that guy yeah there's no hot guys he's only got like some side stuff going on i need like a whole bowl cut in a shaved top right i also like the fact that you're i really like the influence in in this one i i think that might be one of my favorite things because you get to dictate how much you're spending and that that reads into more of trying to compare what your opponents have oh how much do you have any influence you have 20 uh because there were times where it's like i was i was bidding like eight and it's just like if you bid none or you bid more and it's like well [ __ ] cause you can look at what's available before you bid and it's like why'd i bid eight when i knew both of you guys wanted those right so i was gonna be left with something anyway i wasn't gonna bid higher so it's like i could have kept that and gotten two points out of it yeah uh that's the kind of bidding that that i enjoy i don't really care for like round robin like bidding okay um and again simultaneous so it's

quicker yeah it keeps moving you're engaged right right and i will say this game it's funny because we just played uh the pinball game that was also rolling right and i'm sitting there and i'm like this is a solo game like because of how one person's game can go longer than everyone's it's like why play with other people just play yourself um this one everything everything is simultaneous as well but it's like yeah play with more play with other people like i'm not sitting here like oh there's no point playing with you guys i'll just play the solo mode which just does have a solo mode i don't know uh how it works but i'll probably i might do a um a solo variant or a solo run-through separately but um you can also there is a b-side which which which instead and a b side on the monastery card as well so there are different ways to play this game for a very small footprint this game is not expensive right at all yeah yeah like i know but i mean you're like yeah yeah i look up how much all your games cost no but she probably pays the bills oh yeah you're right totally uh let's see i will say if you uh take a look at the uh at the front uh that cat at the bottom i don't know what the hell is that [ __ ] wrong ass eye derpy cross eyes yeah i

know and he's real [ __ ] long well i'm glad you found a negative yeah i don't even know what this is person riding on the snail i was coloring this there is a little person there's also dragons there's three on this is there three no there's not yes and then there's a little mouse and she's been studying a lot i was tracing these earlier yeah i i enjoy i enjoy this game this is this is uh this is a solid one yeah so i also enjoy it now uh with that being said out of the two which one would you prefer the first one that's a good one yeah the good one the one that you guys are gonna say no yeah this one uh okay um on a scale of one to ten i'm already ready eight eight yes eight i'm still not that high because i don't see myself playing this as much uh i'd give it a seven though yeah uh like it it is good but once again still it is a filler game right to me that i'm not gonna but if if if i want to you this for me because i will never play a board game if i have 30 minutes to kill right i just i will not do that i am a millennial i'll get on my phone and watch a 20-minute youtube video and re-watch boberg specials uh but what this game is perfect for is kind of a palette cleanser in between games or how you mentioned it like if you're at a game group and you're like oh how much do you how long before this game's over about 20 minutes we think oh okay perfect let's just kind of play this and uh so we can play a bigger game

together yeah that's where this one would come and come in handy and i could also see it as a gateway for new gamers absolutely because it's it's got enough complexity that you feel like you've got some control you've got enough luck that you feel like you're trying to control this right but it's like not overly complex you roll two ones of influence and you're like okay reroll this one oh it's a two that's not better i guess i'll reroll all of them well two is better than one it is yeah and then you're like oh okay good and wow that was three chapels my book dies so uh oh actually one thing i will say is i like that if let's say i move up i get this and i move up all the way on the chapel almost immediately i like that you are compensated for a die you can't use like you can either move up move your noble up or um fill in the the cross so two four six two four six eight ten so you can get a potential 12 points if you cannot use dice yep um and i really like that like uh now granted if you have all those filled and you can't move up or anything then it's just a dead die but i feel like that would be you'd have to get like the worst luck imaginable yeah that's hard to imagine in a game this short yeah exactly like oh man i'm only ever rolling the blue books like so i'm oh i'm maxed out all the time um but i will yeah i i like how this is like because unlike other rolling rights i don't really care for like on tour where it's just you roll two dice and you're like nothing i can do about that like because i'm just [ __ ] like this one or

um i mean cartographers is a flipping right same with welcome to flipping right right they're all just [ __ ] the same but i like whenever like they're quick there's there's somewhat they have some a little taste of theme in there to for that type of genre and yeah you you feel like you were engaged the whole time canvas i would say is a potential filler game um or um uh no calico isn't but canvas is pretty close um to that yeah but it's just like yeah this is perfect like you're you're not just you're not just oh all right that's the end of the game glad i set this up nah this one this one i like yeah so you guys get anything else cool well that's our thoughts on biblio's quill and parchment let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day just for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top 10s or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever

time of day it is for you

Progress saved