Skip to main content
Loading video...

Land and Freedom | Review

Transcript 18:24

thank you hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and this week on the Pod we're gonna be reviewing land and freedom published by blue panther games and designed by Alex Knight all right so this is a setup for Landon Freedom the Spanish Revolution and Civil War and in this game the moderates the Communist and the anarchists are all trying to keep the Republic going uh in the face of war from the fascists so all three of these movements have to work together in order to defeat fascism however they all also want to come out on top in a surviving Republican government and so they're all competing to get the most glory in order to win the game so basically in order to win this game you need to deal with all the war stuff happening on various fronts in Spain and it's a lot harder than it looks basically if you lose Madrid you're done if you lose two other fronts you're also done or if you finish the game and you don't have all these areas under control so basically there aren't any fascists overwhelming any of them at the moment you're also done but if you manage to militarily survive all of this then you're going to be drawing throughout the game from this bag of Glory and basically Whoever has drawn the most of their um chits from that bag by the very end of the game is gonna be the winner because they'll have achieved the most glory and been given credit for the most

Glory we're all competing to get and keep initiative we're all putting our tokens into the bag of glory and we're hoping that we come out on top so initiative comes from dominance on these tracks over here on the top right each of the factions is going to have kind of two tracks that are in their purview so I'm set up for the anarchist so I'm going to be looking really hard at this Liberty and collectivization pairing up here basically as long as I can keep them both at six or above initiative is mine Anarchy Reigns meanwhile the Communists and moderates are going to be trying to bring me down up on those tracks while they are building up either Soviet support for the Communists or foreign aid for the mods and then here in the middle they've got a bit of a tug of war going on over control of the government so the moderates start out in control but it's really not as secure as one might think this is going to flip-flop a lot and basically if I do not have initiative by having six or higher on my tracks then whoever controls the government will have initiative instead so they're going to be things on all of our cards that let us push and pull and fight it out and it's a little bit nasty but it's also pretty good fun the way that the turn structure works in this game is that uh every turn you're going to draw a card from the fascist deck so you have three different gears worth you're trying to survive three years of this war so the first deck is the nicest the second is the nastiest and of course the third is terrible but you know what a fun game kind of way but basically you flip one of these cards at the beginning of each turn and it's going to tell you where you're going to put opposing forces so the the

front closest to the feet or Madrid it can also mess with your tracks so there are things that are going to happen that go down at the left at the beginning of every turn as part of the fascist taking their actions there's also a test at the bottom of the card which at the end of everybody's turns we're gonna have to see if we passed or failed so on this one if you pass it if the Madrid front is negative one or better than the moderates get to draw a card if you are not passing and the Madrid front is negative two or worse then control of the government swings towards the center what that means is that this is the center a move towards the center can cross the center line so you know with this test maybe nobody wants the moderates to draw a card because why would we help them but it's also possible that the Communists actively want this test to fail because right now the government is close to the center but in moderate control If It Moves towards the center it'll actually bump over to the Communist side and they'll take initiative so the scheme creates like a wild little semi-cooperative experience because there are situations where maybe you don't want everything to go really well or maybe you need to put something in your tracks and get initiative and that means that you can't put as much energy into the actual war effort and balancing all that is what makes the game really challenging it's hard to get to a point where anybody wins other than the fascists because those tensions are so high and because people are so tempted to be selfish at the same time this game does try to prevent that kind

of like oh forget it I'm not going to win so nobody should win phenomenon by having this bag of Glory because you don't really know who's gonna win as long as you manage to get some chits in here and everybody starts with one you're gonna get something the other thing that makes this game interesting is the way that your cards play if you're a human player so at the beginning of each year you draw a hand of cards so I would start with five of them and sadly I didn't get very many uh action points on these cards but that would mean that my better cards are still hiding in the deck but essentially on each turn each of the players chooses a card they want to play and then at the moment of their turn they can choose to play it one of two ways you can either play it for the event that's in the middle of the card but this means that you Trash the card and without something special from elsewhere in your deck you're not getting it back so you can take a one-time more powerful action and you do the things on the card from top to bottom or you can choose to play the card to your Tableau over here for some action points and then for possible bonuses down the side of the card so this has a number one on it so if I played this I could do one thing it's like one of these tracks or two you know one of the fronts I could add a little bit of support it's not a ton of power but um if the morale bonus happens to be turned on so these bonuses can turn off and on if the morale bonus is turned on then in addition to the one action point that I had I'm able to activate one of the bonuses down the side of the card so I

could add an extra troop to a friend I could mess with Soviet support because that's funny to me or I could draw a card and then as your Tableau grows it gets a little bit more powerful so let's say I want to play another little one value card I could do something with my action point and this time with the morale bonuses on if I activate my little helmet to indicate support to one of the fronts I can actually do it twice because that because that symbol exists on this card but it's also on the first one that I played in the Tableau so as you grow that Tableau you can take increasingly powerful actions if you plan it right that said at the end of each year you do have to clear out a lot of the cards that you have in your hand in your Tableau so um you know don't get too dependent on any one year's situation because things will change from year to year and then there are the non-players and so these are basically Bots but they act in very simple ways basically as long as you know the game then the solo is not bad it might be a little bit hard to learn it all from the ground up but that's a different story so basically with the non-player Bots instead of having a hand of cards that you have to manage or having a tableau that you have to deal with or any of that basically with them you just flip a card and you play the event and then there are little priorities that are listed over here telling you how to decide what that bot is going to do so since everything's all stacked over here I'll show you the non-player anarchist side so here you'll play an event it's going to tell you how to um

how to handle your uh your event and like what things to prioritize and what to do one thing it's going to tell you instead of drawing cards you gain an equal number of hero points which is one other thing I want to talk about in a moment it has a front bonus if it's plus one strings to a front it's going to tell you how to do that um if it is going to go for medallions so if you max out one of these tracks you get one of the medallions here in the middle it's a reward it's going to tell you kind of which one the bot might want and like how do I use it it'll tell you how to spin hero points which I will show you shortly and then it'll tell you how it prioritizes and what it's going to do in its final bid for Glory at the end of year three so basically you have a handy little guide to what the Bots motivations are what it's going to do but this also reminded me to talk about one more fun little mechanism in the game which is hero points so you earn these for fighting on various fronts sometimes from your cards there's just ways to get hero points and you spend them on a number of things on the boards you can just spin one here point to draw a card but there are also Little Hero Point prices on the board that indicate how many hero points you have to spend to manipulate these tracks and to turn bonuses on and off so having hero points if you don't have a card that does something you might have hero points that get you somewhere you need to go as well I think if we spin to any point during your turn so this is a game where their yes is a lot going on but once you start to play it it turns into this really fun dance with the other players of how much are we going to work together versus what do I need to make sure that so and so doesn't have the

initiative again this turn and they get another token in the bag of glory and I don't have any in there yet so even as the fascists get nastier and nastier uh you and your fellow players will also become nastier because you're all fighting for the power and position that you need in order to make sure that you win the game uh if you do collectively win it against fascism so that's a basic overview of land and freedom uh let's have some final thoughts all right so now for some final thoughts over overall I really think that land and freedom is a fantastic game just as a historical game as a game that's really trying to get to the heart of a historical problem I really think that it is an excellent piece of work and I have a ton of respect for this design I think that it does a really good job of creating tension between whether you want to help your Republican government fight the fascists or whether you want to prioritize the needs of your own movement and this is essentially going to be constantly present and they're going to be really hard and you have to really time when you are going to be selfish and you're going to be really mad when in your mind another player chooses the absolute wrong time to do that so I have played this game both as intended which is with three players and solo and so I want to make sure that I contrast those so that you know exactly what you're getting if you get this game so does Landon Freedom play solo yes I don't know that I would get it for just solo but the solo mode is totally decent

it's good there are Bots that function very well their priorities make a lot of sense so basically you can play against the Bots just by drawing cards and by doing the events on the cards in order um with priorities as given in the bot rolls on the player AIDS and in the end of the rule book so you can play a very functional game with Bots and they actually do make it really really hard for you so it is tough to both beat the bots in terms of their um you know they're getting initiative and they're challenging you for Supremacy within your government you know they're actually really going to give you a hard time and they're also going to really force you to have to put in a lot of work at the various fronts in Spain in order to keep the fascist problem under control and so you know they make the game very puzzly and very challenging but they do lack one really essential part of the game which is the Betrayal and the ability to put peer pressure on people the social aspects that really really starts to shine when you're playing with three players so when you have a full contingent of three people playing this game it is mean and it's spicy and it's just really really good um the semi-cooperative aspect of it really shines in a way that I really do deeply appreciate um I think that Alex did a very good job of kind of pushing to the heart of do I go and look out for myself or do I look out for all of us just in the way the

cards are written so there are very tough choices to make on every single card in your deck because every single one of them gives you something that's pretty good for you but probably the expense of something that's good for everybody else and you also have to make really tough decisions about okay do I trash this card by playing it for the event even though this event is damn good is that really what I want um or am I going to take more of a slow walk and play a longer game and put this in my Tableau and try to stack symbols so I can take these massive moves late in each year and so this game really challenges you on multiple fronts to make decisions that are going to have some really serious consequences because this game is hard to win no matter what your player count is it's so hard for anyone to win because the fascists are extremely powerful and you actually really do have to work together to defeat them it's just that you're not gonna want to and uh you know the fact this game creates that feeling so well and that feeling of frustration so well I think is great um you know you're absolutely going to want to peer pressure people and yell at them and harangue them and like get into fights about whatever happened to the game with them um because you get really invested and so do they and it's just very frustrating to like you know for example lose the southern front because the Communists didn't do anything last turn and they're not sorry about it David Thompson um uh and so you know this game will create memories as well as you play and I think that that's something really special I also think that Alex did a good job of kind of solving the um the semi-cooperative problem which is

where if you feel convinced that you are going to lose the game then suddenly you just say screw it and like everybody else can lose too the way that he prevents this is that the winner is not the actually the person who contributes the most to the revolution the person who wins is the one whose chits get drawn the most from the bag of Glory which you can contribute to by having the initiative but there are other ways to contribute to it there's a bidding war for one of those slots at the beginning of year three um you know if you are seizing initiative right at the end you get to add extra tokens so basically if you even if you only get the initiative like once and just go For Broke and it's the end of a year and you get to add two tokens you could still technically win the game and so uh this one really keeps you fighting because you're trying to build that bag and put the odds in your favor but even if you are behind and you know it there's still just just enough of a chance that you could win and I think that that keeps you invested and it keeps the game going in a way that um you know it's an interesting solution to the semi Co-op problem I can see you feeling a little cheated if you've really built the bag in your favor and you still don't win but I also think that politics and history are like that sometimes and that it adds sort of a sense of drama and amusement to the game um as well so I just think that this design is really really good um you know the solo is totally doable even with Bots and it's interesting and

it's still a good puzzle it absolutely Sparkles with three players which is how really this one probably should be played the majority of the time the cards are all very meaningful the actions you can take in this game are very meaningful um you know it's such an interesting little way of boiling down a thorny problem like the Spanish Civil War I just think it's fantastic um I will say that there are just a couple of issues with it that are pretty minor one is that the rulebook has a few parts that are described a little bit messily like you can easily get your answer you can easily get your questions answered on bgt and stuff like that um but you know like for example um there are three different years in here and there are three different fascist decks you're gonna pull full you're only gonna pull four cards from each Year's deck um in any given game there's only 12 turns but you know in the setup rules it says oh you know shovel the three fascist decks and doesn't really like tell you how to do that I had already played the game so I understood instinctively what to do but like there are little moments where you might have to make a little leap or an assumption in order to understand exactly what the rulebook wants of you or there are situations where I wanted information and I would find it but not necessarily like right where I thought it would be or like it would be kind of buried in some text and so I do think that the the rules could have been better and you know there are some interesting little printing issues at least in my copy so for example uh my little Ernest Hemingway card I always know it's him because there's like a little yellow

marker on the back and my quest offensive card also has like a funny little misprint mark on it like you know it's it this is to me this is really minor but you should be aware like this is not the most luxurious of printings of this game at the same time that's not a problem for me because that's not the point that's not the point for related Freedom the point is this is a really really interesting historical game that boils down a thorny messy situation um to make a historical point that I personally find very interesting and I think it's very beautifully communicated mechanically through the game so that makes this work that I really admire this is Alex Knight's first design and I'm really excited to see what he'll do next because I thought this was really something if you're interested in historical games in games and what they're able to do and communicate then this is something that is a must look for you and it is actually really fun to play as as well as well thank you so much for watching uh please like subscribe comment give on patreon if you're feeling generous and most of all happy gaming foreign

Progress saved