Skip to main content
Loading video...

Moustache Review: Tricked Out Cookie Duster

Transcript 19:03

Hello everybody. Welcome back to the Dice Tower. My name is Zee Garcia. And I'm Camilla. Today we're taking a look at a card game here, a trick-taking game called Mustache. Very shiny box and you very shiny cards you'll see in one moment. In this game you are going to be forming partnerships that change from hand to hand and trying to win uh the most victory points which translates into a trophy which translates into victory points and if you have the most of those you win. It's not very complicated, it just sounds like that. Let me show you what the game looks like on the table. Uh we'll come on back after that. We'll tell you what we thought of it. To set up the game we're going to prepare for the four rounds of play by putting the tokens above randomly selected cards, two from the white deck and two from the black deck. Then we can set the rest of these aside. They will not be needed. These are going to contain rules that change the gameplay throughout the entirety of the game. We also have a deck of cards that is going to be shuffled up and dealt out based on this player aid here. This tells you how many players you're playing across the top, how many cards they'll get, and the distribution of partnerships which changes from hand to hand here. So, I'm going to be showing you the easiest way to play with four players where you're going to be dealing out with from these cards two from this set with one of them having the crown and two from this set.

These randomly go out to the four players and they did not know who the partners are. So, these two players end up with these and then I end up with this one and this player ends up with this, we're partners for this first round and they're partners and we'll both win or lose together this hand, but this will change every time we go on to a new round in the game. Now, if you're playing with three or five, then the groups will be uh different sizes, but these wild cards will be dealt out to the smaller teams uh as you see down here to make up for that deficit and they can play these whenever they want to even uh for a special ability even if it could follow suit, they can play these uh and they're very very shiny. So, I'm not going to explain these right now.

We're going to just stick with a basic game at four players here. So, we shuffle up the uh deck of cards. Everybody's going to get 10 and then we reveal the first card here. This is going to have a special rule that affects the game for this hand and every subsequent hand because as we reveal these, we do not turn off the previous ones. They keep stacking up. All right, so we've got our partnership set, us two and these two players and we are ready to go. We have our 10 cards that have been dealt to us. We have our first rule for the game. Normally, you want the most stars to be captured. You want to take the most, but in this case for this whole game, the green stars on those green cards are going to be bad. You don't want to take those. And then on this card on the back of that, we've got a little breakdown of the cards that are in the deck, which ones have stars, and then also the ranking of these suits, meaning [snorts] the highest card in the best suit is going to be the winning card. So, let's go ahead and take a look at that in practice. I'll be beginning the game. I'm going to play a card from my hand and I am going to lead with that card. Then this player must play and again, if they can, they have to follow suit. They are going to play that card there. Then their partner would play next. They're going to take They're going to play that one.

And then my partner over here will play and they are going to oofs. They are going to play that one. We're going to be winning anyway, it looks like us two and we don't want those green cards. I took a gamble and it was not a very good gamble. So, this player wins and we just took two of the green, no, three of the green stars which unfortunately are bad. If all the cards are of the same suit, the highest one would win. This player played the eight. If they're not all of the same suit, then the suits are ranked within them uh and then [snorts] uh if they're all green, then the obviously the highest green, but if there's any blues, they beat any of the other ones. If there's no blues, then the highest orange and so on ranked strongest to weakest as you see there. This player sets those aside. They are going to lead a new card here and they are going to play oh, let's go with and a strong card.

Uh I have to follow suit again if I can, so I'm going to play that. Then this player is going to go. They are going to play that. And then lastly, this player goes. Their partner's winning right now, so we might as well feed some stars into this hand so they can take some of those stars. Hey, look at that. They got three good stars, three positive stars. They set that aside and lead again, whoever won and so on around the table. Once this hand is over and we played out all the cards, let's say that uh we count up our score here among our us two and we can just combine our tricks, really. Uh and then those two players do and they win. They have more stars with us counting greens and them counting greens as negative points. If they win, then they're each going to gain one of these tokens randomly from here like so.

And then this one can just be removed from the game. Then we are going to grab all the cards, shuffle all this up again, redeal out the partnership so it's randomized one more once more, and then get ready for the second hand uh with a new rule in play. The cards on the orange cards uh or the stars rather on the orange cards are doubled. Okay. Green is bad, orange is doubled. We play again and then we do it again a third time. If a player can't follow suit, then the color of the card becomes the new leading suit. You have to follow that color now, whereas normally you have to follow the leading color. And then over here, the last one. And again, these things all stack up. At the start of the round, each player has to select one card from their hand face down underneath their team card and it has to be the last card they play in that hand.

You have to decide that at the beginning though. Okay, fine. With all of that done and these divvied out, let's say I ended up winning the in the second round with my partner and in the fourth round with my partner. At the end of the game I'm going to reveal these. I'm going to figure out my score is and whoever has the highest score from everything they won, let's say I ended up partnered with this player and they won these, then they have 6 7 8 9 10 and let's say I I'm second highest with seven. They're obviously going to win the game. If you have a tie, then it's just a tie and you should play another game. All right, so first and foremost, we should probably mention because again, it's a trick-taking game. It's a very specific kind of game that lately gets a lot of attention also.

I like trick-taking games. I would not call myself a trick-taking game fanatic, but I like them. You traditionally don't like trick-taking games. There's a few you like, but they're in the minority, right?

They they are the exception to to I I would say generally I don't like trick-taking. There are a couple exceptions to that.

And I would say the opposite of that. I generally like them. There's certainly exceptions to that. So, that's a baseline just to help you frame everything, you know, we're going to say about this. Um I'm going to start from the things I really like about this game and they are uh there's quite a few things I really like about this game. I like the changing partnerships. I think that that is fun. I like that that creates a lot of levity in this game and makes this game feel less important with a capital I than a lot of other trick-taking games tend to feel, tend to take themselves much more seriously. Changing partnerships means that you don't know who you're going to be paired up with next. You might be alone in a team. Uh there's also that feeling of you you win and you get a trophy, but it's there's a there's a grading scale there.

You could get four, five, or six points based on which trophy you randomly pull. So, winning has some shades of well, you did great, but is the point being I don't I don't mind that. It's not a negative, mind you. I think the game puts that foot forward in a way that makes the whole thing a little more disarming. It's the same that important. You did great. You won by a point or two because you got a little lucky here. I think it does help spread that skill, if you will, as well. You know, I mean, if you're good at trick-taking games, you're going to have the upper hand in this game, you know, in trick-taking games. And so, or if you like them and have played a lot, that kind of stuff. Just you bring your experience to it, right? And so, I think that having that switching partnerships does level the playing field a little bit. And again, is very inviting. Yeah.

because it's like, "Hey, maybe I have a chance here. I don't know." You know, I I I like that about it. It makes it feel more approachable. Exactly. That's that's what I was attempting to get at and I agree with you. Yeah. Um I think four rounds is a good length. I think four rounds works well for me generally speaking. You could get into a little repetition, which is one of my negatives. You could if the cards if those sort of like changing rules as they come up aren't too funky, you could get into a little repetition. But four uh hands I think feels pretty good. And I also really love This is probably my favorite part of this game, actually. That this game has special effects that mess with the the normalcy of the game, but they ramp up.

Right, with the the black or the white cards first and the black cards later. Yeah, so it's And when you play the first hand, it's like one little rule, right? Above and beyond the normal rules. Um and it's also the round that matters the least because the fewest points are at stake. I love that this game starts off the least punishing, the least demanding, and ramps up. The second round matters a little more cuz there's more points at stake, and there's a second rule in play. Then a little more, then the big round at the end with all the rules in play, all the big points at stake. I like that. I like that that that that ramping up effect means you don't have to be scared of the beginning. Making a mistake early isn't necessarily devastating. Right, but also being good early isn't that rewarding either, you know? I mean, I there've definitely been those games where it's like, "Ooh, I've got off to a good start, you know, first round." And you're like, "Uh I got the 1.1. Cool.

Why did I even win?" Like, you know, that doesn't feel super good. Um and I will push back a little bit or I guess different opinion here. I I do think that this stays overstays its welcome for me. I think four rounds is too long. I do like the building of the we'll call them powers, the switching rules. I like that, but by the fourth round it's like, "Okay, all right, cool. There's just one more, you know?" Um three rounds I think is a little bit more comfortable.

Okay. Okay. Yeah. Um I also really like the way this game scales, actually.

Yes. Uh the idea that when you have an an uneven team, two on one, which is surprisingly good, I think, in this game, that one, the player playing alone, has those funky special ability cards that have those uh those jokers, so to speak, and they can play those whenever. They have some neat powers that nobody else has access to. I really like that. That works out very well. Uh and so you you can still do a partnership game with three, or with five, I guess, you know, but um yeah, that's neat. That that it really surprised me how much I liked that. Cuz I remember, you know, reading it, looking at it, and being like, "I guess it's an even player number of game even player game count, you know?" Um I was actually really surprised by how much I liked those odd variants. You know, to the point that sometimes I might prefer that. Because it is just a little bit of spice in there, There's a lot of There's a lot of trick-taking games that play with four people. That's kind of a go-to. Two on two is a very common uh trick-taking game number.

This this could be the trick-taking game for three, you know what I mean? Or one of them, you know? There's There's some that are for three and then work well for three. But partnership for three, that's neat.

It was It was really good. I I was surprised by how much I liked that. And how excited I was to be in the partnership when it was the three. It's like, "Okay, good. I have someone to bounce with because we're passing cards back and forth."

Yeah. Or also how excited I was with "Oh, cool. I get the special cards this time. I'm excited." Like, I was excited no matter which what I was, you know, which which side I got, which I think is very hard to do right. And and yeah, kudos to them for that.

I agree. I agree. So, a couple of negatives uh pivoting here. Um the game does have a lot of randomness, like we like we already kind of alluded to. It's kind of random on random. The The hand you're dealt is random. And then the points you win, if you win, are random. Within a range, but still random. You could lose to that. The scores in this game are low. It'll be like eight to nine points at the end of the game or whatever. That's That's a random pull difference. It's not you know, it's if you have pulled the different token, you could have won a couple times in the game is my point. So, you can't put a lot of stock in who won or who lost. And then I think some of the special ability cards, some of these cards are not winners. I think they're not all great. I think some of them are kind of lame, and I don't like them. Um and there's not that many. There's, you know, there's a few, but there's not that many. I feel like there could be more, you know? This is something that a little tuck box, you know, expansion or something like that. I think it would It would do well um for it. It does There's not many, but of those few, there's a couple that I just don't want to play with, you know? Yeah, I think so. And if that came up, I'd be like, "Nah, we're not going to do that one." Yeah.

So, ultimately, the game kind of feels a little bit like a recent darling, uh Rebel Princess, but I like this better than Rebel Princess because um it takes away the players' power, this idea that you have a special card, you need to know when to trigger your own special ability, and it puts it on the table. It grows with the play throughout the play, uh so that at the beginning you don't have to concern yourself with too much, and by the fourth round there's quite a bit happening. You got to manage what you want to do. I just It tickles us the same part of the brain, trick-taking with funky abilities, but it simplifies and streamlines that. It takes it I don't know, it just makes it a little more digestible, I thought.

Right. I would agree with that, for

Um final thoughts. Where are you coming down on this one? Um this one actually surprised me how much I enjoyed it. It's a seven for me. I, like I said, not a trick-taker, I found this to be very approachable, and one that as by a very wide margin the worst trick-taker here in the office, you know, um I I did not feel immediately intimidated to sit down and play. I felt like I was um I won't say welcome at the table as if you guys are ever not welcoming at all,

BUT I I DEFINITELY DIDN'T feel like I was completely out of my element. So, I appreciated those random bits, but they're random bits were also out there for everyone to see. So, we're all dealing with the same thing, so I can also ask a question, you know, like, "Why would I want to do that? Wait, what was that again? Remind me of that." So, it is by no means cooperative, but it has kind of that feel to it where you are um working with the same handicaps, in a way. And I really liked that. I think that it did level the playing field. At the end of the day, I don't think it makes me like any trick-taking any more, but it is one that I would happily play. I would sit down and play. Um I just think does I do think it overstays its welcome just a little bit, and the randomness is is quite high, which is maybe why I like it, because it takes some of the trick-taking skill out of it, but also you can't take the game seriously. Yes.

And I think those those two last points are really important, I think. Yeah.

It's borderline party game kind of feel.

Yeah. And and the look and the the silly theme, non-theme, it's hard work, you know? The shiny cards, the giant mustaches on the critters helps you kind of get into that mindset of don't take this seriously. It's kind of party game adjacent.

And that is so satisfying to organize your hand though. And if you have a lot of one color, and you can just like see the little baby mouths, and then by the end you have those like big luscious, you know, mustaches. I love that. I love it. So, it's not thematic at all, but uh but it is it is cool. You do yeah. Super cute. Um I think this is uh first of all, I'm coming in at a 7.5, so I'm coming in a little bit higher than you. I I like it. I like the game. I think it is not a trick-taking game for trick-taking fans, okay? If you are someone who considers yourself a trick-taking fanatic, you have a collection of them, you know the latest ones that just came out from this company or that company. If you know trick-taking designers by name, you do not need this, I think, and it probably will be I want to say beneath you. That sounds awful. Um It's not going to

say beneath you. Yeah, I can say that. That's what you're going to say.

It's one that I think you might not, you know, really It might not quite be for you, I guess. Um However, if I was recommending a trick-taking game to mid-stage family that maybe has played some traditional card games, but doesn't really know what just came out from this publisher or that, this would be a good recommendation for that, you know? Some special abilities, which are going to feel to someone who's only played games with like traditional decks of cards, mind-blowing. They'll be like, "Oh, wow. The rules change throughout the game? That's cool."

Yeah. The shiny cards, the silliness, the changing partnerships. Now now I'm teamed up with Dad. Okay. And then next round, "Ooh, I have to play alone? Okay, but I have these special cards. Okay, cool." That's neat. There's some neat stuff in here, you know? Yes, with some of the things we're talking about, repetition being one of them, randomness being one of them, but you can you can spin that to be a positive sometimes, you know? So, yeah, seven, 7.5 from me. I like this one. I think it's very charming. It's a nice little nice little trick-taking card game. That is going to be a seal of approval from us here, everybody, at The Dice Tower. Thank you for tuning in and checking this one out with us. My name is Zee Garcia.

And I'm Camilla. Get yourself a luscious mustache.

Hey. Uh thanks for watching another video here on The Dice Tower. Uh we really appreciate you stopping by and checking our things out. Thanks so much for joining us today. And hey, if you really like what we're doing here at The Dice Tower, then there are different ways to support The Dice Tower. One of those ways is through Patreon. We have links in the description to this video. We have links to lots of other things we do down there, so definitely check it out. But either way, we're glad you watch us. Tell your friends about The Dice Tower. Until next time, though, I'm Tom Vassal, and I hope you enjoyed this video.

Progress saved