Good, Bad, Potato - BGG How to Play
Transcript
In Good, Bad, Potato, three to five players try to create and keep their own cosmic balance through card play. Sounds simple enough, but wait. All players are trying to push all other players off balance by playing and activating cards that mess with others' cosmic balance and points.
When the deck runs out, the player with the most points wins. Hi, I'm Nikki Pontius, here to teach you how to play Good, Bad, Potato. It's for three to five players, takes 20 to 30 minutes to play, for ages 10 and up, and is designed by Colum Lundberg and Steve Jackson. The game is published by Steve Jackson Games, which sponsored this video. The deck of 60 cards has 30 cards aligned with good and 30 cards aligned with bad. Both alignments are further broken down into keywords, like small, large, condition, object, sound, and many others.
Underneath the name of the card are instructions on how to play the card and what the effect will be, whether on yourself, another player, or all players. The number on the top of the card is its point value, which will be added together with all of your other cards at the end of the game. Setup is simple. Shuffle all the cards together and build a deck by removing some cards. The number of cards used to play is based on how many players there are. 36 cards for three players, 48 cards for four players, you use all 60 cards for a five-player game. Any unused cards go back into the box.
Deal five face-down cards to each player. The remaining cards are placed in the center of the table as a draw deck. The player who last did something really good or really bad shares that story with the others around the table, then takes the first turn. On your turn, you will choose a card from your hand, read it, resolve its instructions, and then place it in play in front of you. You must always play a card, whether an effect happens or not. For example, playing the good cop as the first card played will have no effect, but you have now begun your balance of good and bad, and you now have three points. Some cards take effect later.
For instance, land mine. When removed from play, will allow that player to remove a card from the player removing the land mine. True, you have just lost two points, but what havoc can you wreak on their array? Taking a big point card can be good, but maybe removing a card with fewer points in favor of messing with the cosmic balance is a better choice. Removed cards go face up in the discard pile. After you play a card, it is time to check for cosmic balance. First, check if all your cards in play are bad or good. If this is the case, nothing happens. If you have a mix of both bad and good cards in play, add all the points on your good cards in play, then add all the points of your bad cards you have in play.
Then compare the totals. If neither side has twice as many points as the other, nothing happens. You are balanced enough. If one side is more than twice as many points as the other side, you must discard a card of your choice from the lesser side. If your array looked something like this, for example, and the total was eight to three, you would have to remove a card from the lesser side. This may force you to be more out of cosmic balance than you may have already been. So, perhaps on your next turn, you would want to play a card that adds to or gets rid of cards from the lesser side of your array. For instance, if you play dinosaur to the cheese plate, you now have seven points on the good side and eight points on the bad side. Your bad cards are no longer twice as many points as your good cards.
Let's say you played the good card jaunty hat. That would make your total five points
on the good side. The text on the card says, "Give a card from your hand to any player. Steal any card that player has in play with a value equal to or less than the card you gave them." If you steal their fire truck, you will remain in cosmic balance and will have gained three points. In addition, you have left that player cosmically out of balance. Then they will have to do something about that on their turn. Stolen cards are added to your array, but do not activate unless the stolen card has text saying otherwise. If you steal their bad card vacuum, you will be out of cosmic balance and will have to remove a card from the lesser side of your array.
Lastly, it is possible to take the effect of a card for yourself. In this example, you are still out of balance, but instead of adding to your good cards, you choose to play plastic straw. It is a bad small object, and it will allow you to remove one good card with a value of one or two. Remove the office supplies card, the only good card you have. You now have nine points and no good cards. There's no hostility, so you don't have to discard any cards. When your turn is done, drop back up to five cards, and the next player in clockwise order takes their turn.
The game ends when there are no more cards left to draw from the draw deck. Play continues until everyone has an equal number of turns. Add all your points together, both good and bad. The person with the highest score wins. Understanding all that you are able to do with your hand of cards and the combinations of effects you can create in good bad potato is your key to success in the game. If you would like to learn more about good bad potato, visit its game page on BoardGameGeek. I'm Nikki Pontius from BoardGameGeek, wondering whether you are a good potato or a bad potato.