Skip to main content
Loading video...

Superman - Secret Identity and All-Star Superman

Transcript 12:26

Hey folks, welcome back to the dungeon dive. Daniel here. I hope you're doing well and if you're not, I hope you are soon. Okay, so I've been reading a lot of comic books lately. I've been reading through Alan Moore's Saga of the Swamp thing. I've been reading through the Mirage issues of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and some Usagi Yojimbo and recently I read uh Secret Identity by Kurt Buick with art by Stuart Imonin and I wanted to talk a little bit about Superman today and kind of compare contrast one of my all-time favorite comics and that is allstar Superman from Grant Morrison, Frank Quietly and Jaime Grant. So, uh, growing up, I was not a fan of Superman. I thought Superman was kind of a boring character. He was too powerful. He could do anything. There wasn't a lot at stake. And I just didn't appreciate Superman like I do now. And the thing that really made me think about Superman in a different light and made me appreciate him as a character was another comic from Kurt Buick and that is his Astro City. And in the first is issue of Astro City, it focuses on a character called the Samaritan. And the Samaritan is kind of Kurt Buick's take on a Superman style character. And what that comic made me realize is there is a great burden involved in being a Superman. Uh if you have the power to do

basically anything and to save anyone, but you can't be everywhere at the same time. You can't save everyone. You can save anyone, but you can't save everyone at the same time. Um, a Superman would have to make a choice. They would have to choose who to save and who to let perish. Uh, you know, if you had two people who were in peril on opposite sides of the earth and within seconds, both of them were going to die and you had to make a splitsecond decision of who to save and who to let die. That would be a great great burden. uh because what if the uh person that you survived uh grew up or changed to become an evil person and you made the wrong choice of who to save. You know that is a great burden and especially when you uh temper that with Superman being an outsider, being an alien and being this kind of god alien that is sent to live amongst humanity. uh that yeah that that one issue completely made me rethink my opinion on Superman or a Superman style character. And so after I read that, I did read a handful of the great Superman stories. And to this day, I think Allstar Superman is my favorite and Secret Identity is right up there. And I wanted to talk a little bit about both of these books and how they contrast to one another because I think these uh

read together make a perfect pairing because Allstar Superman really does focus on Superman's alieness and the kind of cosmic qualities of a superhero with an alien origin. And so this book is very cosmic. It's very highflying. It is more like a work of kind of planetary romance. There are different dimensions and alien beings with strange powers. Uh Superman goes to Bizarro world and and and faces off against Bizarro's Superman here. Yeah, it's just very cosmic. It's very alien. All-star Superman focuses on the alien side of Superman and what that means to him being a superhero on Earth. And it's very good, very well written, of course, by Grant Morrison. And Frank Quietley's art is fantastic. And the digital coloring by Jamie Grant is amazing. Now, a friend of the channel, he recommended that I should read Secret Identity because I talked very highly about Allstar Superman. Come to find out, Secret Identity by Kurt Busk with art by Stuart Ionan is very, very hard to find.

It's uh it's out of print. You can get it digitally. So, if you are interested, you can buy the digital comic and read it on a on a on a tablet or on your computer or something. But uh luckily my uh my best friend and his wife, they collect a lot of comics and they had a reader copy and this is actually a copy from the Seattle Public Library that they bought in one of the friends of the library sales and luckily they had it and they loaned it to me and man this thing really hit me hard. It is a fantastic comic. I kind of got choked up reading through this a couple of times. And in contrasting with All-Star Superman, Secret Identity focuses solely on Superman's humanity and what it means to be a human with superhuman powers. As a matter of fact, uh, Secret Identity here it is. I would say it's probably one of DC's, uh, I think it's elsewhere stories. They're non-cononical stories.

These are stories that take place kind of in a different world, a different version of our earth. And in this world, a boy is born and his parents name him Clark Kent. But he is not an alien. He's not the Clark Kent from the original DC universe. He is born into a small rural town. It's not Smallville. in the world that this Clark Kint is in. Uh superheroes are known only through comic books just like our world. And so Superman is known, Clark Kent is known. And because his name is Clark Kent, he gets bullied and he gets picked on, you know, hey, come on Superman, you know, do your thing. How come you're not flying or how come you're not doing your thing? And maybe you should save yourself or or beat up the bully. And so he has to deal with all kinds of things associated with being uh named Clark Kent. As a matter of fact, later as Clark Kent uh grows up, his friends set him up on dates as jokes with women named Lois. Well, it turns out he actually ends up marrying a Lo a Lois.

But through some kind of weird phenomenon, this Clark Kent develops powers. Something happened. It's not really touched upon, and I'm glad it's not touched upon. the origin isn't uh what's po what's important here. What's important is that this Clark Kent starts to develop as he gets older the powers of Superman and he takes on the persona of Superman. He becomes a reporter just like Clark Ken and at the newspaper everybody makes fun of him. He constantly gets a presence from his friends and relatives Superman comic books and he just kind of shoves them in the in the closet cuz haha yes the joke. Yes, my name is Clark Kent. Uh, he dresses up like Superman for Halloween and ends up saving somebody uh during a Halloween uh kind of fire at this house and a reporter ends up uh capturing it on on film. And so he has to kind of balance his humanity side of being Clark Kent with his new developing powers as a Superman. Now, what's interesting about Secret Identity when compared to All-Star Superman is Secret identity doesn't have anything cosmic in it whatsoever. There are no super villains.

There are no alternate alternate dimensions or weird aliens or weird things that he has to deal with. What this uh book focuses on is Clark Kent as a human growing older trying to keep his secret identity. He works out a deal with the US government where he offers to help them deal with crises around the world in exchange for them leaving him and his family alone. The book covers about 50 years. And I think that's one of the things that really touched me is it focuses on the idea of this non-alien superman actually growing old. And by the end of the book, we see a very aged Superman kind of always looking out. And whenever things trouble him, he takes to the sky and watches sunsets and watches sunrises. Uh he ends up having twin daughters, which is interesting because he and Lois wonder if his twin daughters will eventually uh develop powers of their own because the source of the power and how it trans uh how it how it transfers for maybe one generation to the next is not known. Uh he gets captured at one point by the US government and he has to break free. But the the way that Q Kurt Buusic focuses on Superman's humanity is

really touching. This book is heartfelt. There's a lot of emotion in this book. The art is fantastic. There's a lot of writing. A lot of the narration in Secret identity is told through u journals that uh Clark Kent is writing as he comes to grips with his newfound powers and what it means for him to have that responsibility and for him to have that that burden that Buk touched upon in Astro City number one with the Samaritan. And so if you haven't read Superman, maybe you feel like I did when I was younger, that Superman just wasn't a very interesting character, I would greatly encourage you to to first check out that Astro City number one. You can get it in a collection. And I think it's in the first trade, uh, the Samaritan.

And you can kind of see how that, uh, that idea of the burden of being a Superman on Earth would impact a person's life. And then reading these two back to back to get two very different takes on what it means to be an alien on Earth in the form of a human who has superhuman powers and has to deal with a big cosmic things and super villains and aliens and alternate dimensions and all kinds of weird wacky things. I mean, yeah, this uh Allstar Superman is just insane. It's so wacky and cool and it's like Superman at his most cosmic and most super dealing with with huge huge monstrous threats that are that that are threatening to destroy the entire existence of the universe.

Whereas Kurt Buick's Secret Identity is a much smaller, more humansized uh tale about what it means to be a human with superpowers. And both of these books are fantastic. I can recommend them both. It's too bad that Secret Identity is out of print right now. It's very expensive if you were to buy it, but maybe check your local library uh your your local library. Maybe they have it or maybe uh you know, if you have a friend who collects comic books and you can borrow it from them or you can get the digital version. But both of these are fantastic. They're very different and it's like the the opposite sides of this same Supermanshaped coin. And I greatly appreciate both of these books. So, all right everyone. I hope you enjoyed taking a brief look at Allstar Superman and Secret identity. We will talk to you later. Bye-bye.

Progress saved