AD&D 1st Edition Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the channel and this is a channel where we give you a reviews playthroughs unboxings we generally like to talk a load of bollocks about tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about an old school role playing game we're going to be talking about advanced dungeons and dragons first edition this is a game that was released originally in 1977 written by gary gargax and it took the world by storm changing the face of gaming for ever in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief a very brief overview of the rules and a little bit of history as well but tell you what we do like we don't like and we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not first edition add is still worth playing 40 odd years after it was first released in 1977 so remember if you are new here please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below hit the like button all that [ __ ] we'll see you after this bollocks so a d and d first edition how'd you play this game so dungeons and dragons is a role-playing game that was first produced in 1973 slash 1974. it was first released as a white box set and in this box set you had three different volumes you had men and magic you had the monsters and treasures and then you had a pamphlet which discussed underworld and wilderness
adventures there were several supplements that were released at a later date one of the most popular being the dave anderson blackmore supplement it was dirties and demigods and stuff to do with uh builds rich magic and stuff like that right 1977 gary gargas took it upon himself to create a d and d there's varying accounts of why he did this some people say it's to do with him trying to get the profits away from dave anderson i don't know don't care but in 1977 the monster manual of the first edition add was released this was a tome of monsters funnily enough that you could use in your campaign to try and do over your players right format for the monster manual was an a to z of different creatures you had all the different stats like the frequency the armor class the amount of hit dice the alignment you know you sometimes had a picture of these creatures and then you add a block of text that would give you a brief description and tell you any sort of special traits or weapons or special abilities that these creatures might have had a lot of these monsters that were included in the muscle manual are derivatives of the classical greek creatures and creatures that are lifted from fault law but there are some original monsters in here as well a lot of this is devoted to dragons and golems and demons the demons were removed from the second edition of add due to what was known as the satanic panic in the 80s where certain groups of people in the united states and europe lobbied against dungeons and dragons and classed it as evil made the headlines but it didn't do anything i only served to increase the popularity did he and uh
yeah cheers for that so the second volume that was released is the player's handbook this is a book that tells you basically how to create your character first stage of the book gives you different options on how to roll your dice you could maybe just roll free dc and that would generate your stats like strength constitution dexterity intelligence wisdom charisma and all that sort of thing or maybe you could roll four dice and take the best three you'll also have a number of hit points this is derived from hit dice each character has a number of hit dots are going to roll depending on what level they are at and that will tell you how hard your character is and how much damage it can withstand in a pub brawl so once you've generated your stats then you'll choose a character class and a race a character class is essentially a job you've got a basic classes like fighter magic user thief cleric and then you've got some sort of sub character classes like druid monk assassin all that sort of stuff right dependent on what statue roll you'll be able to choose a race you can be human dwarf elf halfling and dependent on what race you end up with there'll be a restriction on what level you can reach demi humans generally can't advance as far as humans to something that was removed in later iterations of dnd right so once you have chosen your character class and your character's race you will then be given a bit of dosh so you can go down the shop and buy a load of weapons right gary gargas came from a war gaming background so if you look at the equipment table you'll see that there are a huge array
of halberd pole arm type weapons that you can use but it's all a bit weird really so the book then goes on to describe all the different spells that the spell casting classes can use you're gonna have the spells listed from level one to level eight and the higher the level you are the more powerful spells you can cast so for example a level one magic user spell may be read magic this says by means of read magic spell the magic user is able to read magical inscriptions on objects like books scrolls and weapons and the like or you might have darkness this says the spell causes total impenetrable darkness in the area of its effect in contrast to this when you have been playing for about a year in gargak's own words you might be able to have a knife level magic use a spell that is if your magic user doesn't get killed when they only have a 1d4 of hit dice you might choose the shape change spell and it says with this spell the magic user is able to assume the form of any creature of a demi-god greater devil demon prince singular dragon type greater demon and the like that's pretty powerful now you wouldn't want to be dying for a crab if you use the spell to turn into a dragon would ya or you might end up with the trap the soul spell this spell is similar to the magic jar except that the trap the soul spell forces the subject's creature's life force into a special prison magicked by the spellcaster it's a bit like sitting in this [ __ ] room so after you've chosen all your spells this book will then go into a few different concepts like morale and there's an appendix that goes on about psyonix and all that i don't think gargax wanted to put that in there but
he was pressured to do it by his mate so you put it in there anyway there's some stuff about encumbrance in revision and all that sort of stuff but yeah it's essentially just a guide on how to create a character and a big chunk of spells that you can choose anyway the sort of third and final release in the chord books was the dungeon masters guide right this is a well first time it's quite a big time that was released and it gives you all the information that the dm needs to run a campaign or just a one-shot venture after a long rambling beginning where he goes on about die integers and bell curves and [ __ ] like that guy gets fleshes out the character classes talks about followers and all that sort of thing mentions hillings and henchmen goes on about some sort of spell explanations and it just gives you a little bit more meat on the bones with spells in there and thankfully guy catching starts talking about the adventures themselves talks about adventures in the air adventures underwater talks about adventures in the wilderness and all that sort of thing and then he goes into our combat is performed right there are loads and loads of combat tables in there it reads like a bit of a spreadsheet type thing it's a bit of a mess and uh yeah guy gacks then goes on about experience and living and up and then there is a first dungeon you can explore it sort of goes into semi detail about how the game's played and how the game is run it's not really that much detail in how to actually play the game in this book there are a few examples of how the game's played like sort of fake characters like a dm asking players what they want to do and then the players tell them what they want to do and all that so even though it's not completely clear there are sort of walkthrough examples
on gameplay and for a pre-internet dated book it's it's all right so really the rest of this book is taken up by different types of treasure that you may or may not encounter on your journey and you'll be collecting treasure and trading for experience points it will also be killing monsters to do that and all so yeah a d and d then became very very popular it spawned loads of supplements like the wilderness survival guide to dungeoneers survival guide oriented adventures and truckloads of other supplements and modules that you could buy different to what's available now you know fifth edition d d comes in these massive expensive books but the first edition a dnd came in these tiny little wafer thin modules that gave you you know not a campaign but just a few days worth of gameplay and it was a lot cheaper and arguably better right so yeah that's advanced dungeons and dragons first edition so what do we like about ad first edition so the first thing that we really like about the first edition of advanced dungeons and dragons is the amount of content that was made available for this game all you got to do is go over to draw through rpg and have a look and see how much stuff there was actually made for this and like we said earlier it wasn't the case that they produced two or three books a year there was a huge huge amount of modules and accessories produced for first edition d d throughout its 12 13-year lifespan and it's just something that we don't really see much anymore i mean
okay there is third party stuff made for fifth edition dnd but i think it might be better if they maybe released a few smaller paperback books that you could just digest easy rather than having these huge labyrinthine times that i see you know really do like looking back and seeing the huge amount of content that was available and obviously where guy gas was sort of a pioneer in a sense he laid the groundwork for all the adventures that came afterwards and it's almost like the the stuff that add first edition created it's been recycled through the years which had a bad thing but there's something charming about the stuff that was created especially like tomb of horrors which was the first meat grinder module that i was ever created right so yeah huge amount of content for a d and d so the second thing that we really like about the first edition advanced dnd is that it stands in direct contrast to other fantasy settings that were around at the time like jarrod tolkien's lord of the rings that had a monarchistic tone where you were looking up at the kings and queens of middle earth seeing how they wielded power and all the other plebs were just left to fight for them and perish shouldn't go to their dome right in dnd it turned that on its head it took the ordinary person gave them the will to explore and allowed them to progress and get better with experience and this spoke to me as a kid you know so coming from a working class background i didn't really connect with the tolkien
high fantasy i was more interested in the down and dirty stuff that was at the bottom of the pile you know just ordinary people want to better themselves going out and taking risks and trying to do better so that spoke to me more as a kid than the nonsense that was in lord of the rings you know so the third thing that we really like about add is the fact that it is so rules like this system gets criticized for being light on rules but i really enjoy the fact that gargax himself said that this system is more a set of guidelines than a set of rules it also gets criticized for being unbalanced and sort of chaotic yeah but i quite like that i like the fact that whilst it's fantasy it taps into the psyche of real life you know the fact that real life isn't balanced it's not fair most people's lives are made up of complete chaos add speaks to me in those sort of terms you know even though you're playing a made-up character in a fantasy setting you can sort of quite easily see yourself in that character if you know what i mean and yeah i really like that about a d and d right so the final thing that we really like about advanced dungeons and dragons is that this system does not hold your hand there is a real and present danger of death in this game if you're a first level magic user you're going to get one to four hit points so you've got to be bloody careful at every turn it's not like the later iterations of dnd and other role-playing games where your character is essentially
some sort of suit up superhero even at level one in this game you are just an ordinary person that has maybe a little bit of skill but you are always staring death in the face and when we played it we didn't wrap ourselves up in cottonwood when we played this we were very very careful we were always respectful of the game yeah so yeah i like the fact that ad took a lot of risks back in the 80s and i think that's what made it wildly popular so what don't we like about a d and d first edition so the first thing that we don't like about add first edition is that it is pretty much an unorganized mess it's very difficult to find what you want in the book when you need it and that's something that the later editions of dnd have got down really well some of the rules are really confusing and convoluted like say the rules for surprise and combat it really really is difficult to make any kind of sense at all about what gargax was going on about i think somebody online has has made a summary of the surprise and combat rules i think it goes up to like 20 pages and even then it's still very very confusing and a lot of people back in the 70s and 80s house ruled the combat rules and i don't think anyone played the combat rules as they were meant to be played right so yeah bit of a mess organization is pretty much non-existent and some of the rules are head-scratchingly confusing so the next thing that we don't like about ad and d is that the xp tables
don't really make a lot of sense at all whilst we said we like the unbalanced nature of the game when you're talking about xp tables it takes less experience to advance from maybe second to third level when it does from first to second level that makes absolutely no sense whatsoever so i remember reading an article online years and years ago where some bloke had actually gone back and rewritten all the experience tables and i can remember distinctly him saying that the system that he revised works quite well so it's almost like the original writers of dnd didn't really have much of a grasp on accounting yeah so the xp tables yeah a little bit [ __ ] so the next thing that we don't like about a d and d is that the monster manual by today's standards is a little bit thin on the ground there's a lot of ordinary creatures in there like worms and rats and stuff and a lot of the entries are taken up by creatures that you're unlikely to encounter there's a lot of space dedicated to dragons that you're probably not gonna ever encounter because you're probably gonna die before you ever get to the level that you'll be able to have a scrap of them there's the infamous demons and devils stuff that was taken out in the second edition probably never ever gonna meet bowser bob or asthma dias right so it's a little bit thin on the ground i suppose we are looking at it from a perspective of today but i suppose back in the day it wasn't really anything like this and if you're coming into a fantasy rpg the monster manual
must have seemed fascinating at the time but from our perspective now looking back it is a little bit feeble so final thing we don't like about add is it doesn't really tell you how to play the game especially the dungeon masters guide he starts waffling on about bell curves and integers and stuff like that and i remember getting this as a 10 year old thinking what the [ __ ] is he talking about so as you said before there is a few examples on how to play the game but you're not really told step by step what to do you had to know somebody who already knew how to play d d back in the 80s in order to learn to play this and we came to this from the red box d and d we already knew how role playing worked and how the d d system worked but if you came into this blind it's going to be very very confusing very difficult to understand what the hell gargas was talking about especially if you are a kid right so to summarize is ad still worth your time with bother today and in the future so we're going to say yes absolutely this is by far and away my favorite role-playing system of all time as well maybe aside from the basic dnd but then that's a case of nostalgia i suppose this is a case of nostalgia as well i prefer first edition 18d over any other iteration of dnd i've got everything to do with fifth edition d d but there's just something about fifth edition dungeons and dragons it doesn't really sit right with me it's more like playing a cartoon character and there's something outlandish about i know it's a fantasy
role-playing game yet but it doesn't have that grounded dirty rough feel that ad had back in the day right and that's something that i don't think dungeons and dragons is ever going to recapture i love the fact that this rule set is so bare bones that you can basically put anything into it that you want gogats was very very clear that this is just a set of guidelines a skeleton system that you can use to create your own adventures and it worked really really well for the time it was a bit of a disorganized mess but once you got your head around the rules once somebody else taught you how to play the game that wasn't necessarily a problem so yeah do i recommend a dnd today yeah i absolutely do i mean don't worry about nostalgia you know if you want an easy to learn role-playing game that doesn't have a lot of bloke isn't weighed down by the problems of the world today then ad may just be the role playing game for you so there you go that's add first edition remember if you're new and please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below i'll see you next tuesday
you