The Witching Hour partial play and review - One Stop Co-Op Shop
Transcript
Hey everybody, this is Mike from the Onetop Co-op Shop and today I'm doing a beginning play and review of The Witching Hour, the latest game from Post Curious. And as always, I take no money from publishers for my coverage. I just want to help you make an informed decision and show off the game. And if you like the content on the OneTop Co-op shop, consider supporting us through Patreon. You get early access to our videos and exclusive videos every month you can't see anywhere else. You can also listen to our weekly podcast for reviews and design discussions, or join the conversation and say hi on our Discord. So, this is again the latest game coming from Post Curious. They make my favorite narrative adventure puzzle games out there. The last game I covered from them was the Storm Lamp Rituals. I think that's what it was called. And unfortunately, I still haven't finished that one. Uh I done a preview without completing the entire thing cuz that's a much longer game than normal. I am playing through it with my wife and she's in the middle of uh doing edits for her second book. So, even with several months to play, we're still only a bit over halfway through. This one I'm going to play on my own so I can hopefully finish this entire game before this video. Uh, you're seeing this as I start my journey if you don't want to see any spoilers, then use the timestamps to skip ahead to the future when I've either finished the game or at least gotten as far as I could before the crowdfunding page was going to launch. And future Mike will tell you what he thought about this. But for now, let's jump in. They tell me to grab cards one through four. There's going to be some reading and some Mike being dumb as he tries to solve stuff. Hopefully that'll be fun.
September 1999. Your name is Theodora Rivers and you are 15 years and 364 days old. Or in other words, it's your 16th birthday tomorrow. You can't wait. Children from your village always feel incredibly relieved when they turn 16 and know they are safe from the maze forever. The maze is a local legend often whispered about fearfully in the school playground or threatened as a punishment by angry parents. They say that it was made by the witches to lure in innocent children. They say that nobody over the age of 16 can pass through the entrance. They say that the maze appears only twice a century and a child always goes missing that night and never returns. Some of the oldest villagers still remember the last time it happened. Poor little Lily Forester, only 9 years old. You've been counting down the days to your birthday, secretly anxious about the maze making a lastminute appearance, but not seriously believing that it'll actually happen.
Local superstitions are laughable to the modern-day teenager, right? The problem is that Lily, the girl who went missing in the maze last time, was your grandmother's little sister. Maybe the witches have developed a taste for the blood that flows in your veins. Your final day as a 15-year-old is a Saturday, and you spend it at your best friend, Isabella Blackwell's house in Mira. You have so much fun, and her grandmother even makes you a delicious chocolate birthday cake. Afterward, you take your time on your way home through the labyrinthine wheat fields, looking out for poppies, which are your younger sister Clara's favorite flower. It's a bit late in the season for them, but some still remain. How many can you manage to pick up when you take the quickest way home? As you can probably guess from looking at these, they clearly I assume, yep, all little entrances connect go together. So, I have to go from there to there through the maze and counting the number of poppies I pick for my sister. Okay.
Well, there's no way to make this interesting on camera, so uh give me a minute to figure it out. All right, and I'm back. That was more annoying than I thought it would be. Uh kind of annoying for the very first puzzle of the game. Might just be because my eyes are going a little bit and I had to take off my glasses and kind of peer at and squint at these things. Uh but yeah, it was a very ciruitous path as you might imagine. And uh the thing is first I had to find the path. Uh but it was really annoying to count the poppies as I found it because I would have to like uncount them as I went backwards if I went the wrong way and backtracked. So what I just ended up doing was going through the path once trying to remember where I went and then going through again and counting. And I think it was 16. So they have this big deck of cards and when the clue is a number, you're supposed to take the card of that number and see what it says. which kind of reminds me of the unlock series. So, here we go.
Let's see if card 16 is right. All right, this is interesting. I don't see anything that confirms that I'm right. I mean, it looks like I'm right. Yeah, it talks about getting poppies and stuff, but still. Usually, they would have a more definitive clarification. Also, the rules said that it'll tell you if you discard cards. This one doesn't say anything about discarding one through four. So, they have these dividers in the card box. I can put these behind the revealed box, and it means I can refer back to them as needed. You make it back home without getting lost, and you put the poppies you collected into a nice vase for Clara. She'll love them. You grab the newspaper and cut away the page containing your favorite weekly puzzle. You take it up to your room, but your mother follows you. Thea, I thought you might be interested in these family keepsakes I found in the loft. She smiles sadly. My sister Eleanor ran away when I was a child, and we never heard from her again. I've long since come to terms with the fact that she probably didn't make it across the desolate moore and fell victim to the witches there.
Such a tragedy, but she left me some kind of coded note and a locket with an inscription inside. I was never as clever as her, so I couldn't work it out. But maybe you'll find it an interesting puzzle. She hands the items to you and leaves the room. Take card 103. You wonder if she's trying to distract you from your anxiety about being taken by the maze just before you turn 16, which she is somehow divine despite all your attempts to pretend you aren't bothered. Well, she must have had a 16th birthday herself once, so maybe she felt the same as you. You lay out the items on your desk. Then, after a moment's thought, you go down to the kitchen and fetch the family tree your sister once made for a school project from its display spot on the fridge. Looking at the newspaper, you can't help but notice something odd about the sports results. They seem to have a weird border around them that you've never seen before. All of these things should definitely help to distract you for a while. Anyway, maybe you'll learn something interesting about your ancestors, too. Open envelope tree.
So, the box has a giant stack of these envelopes. See what's in here. All right. We got a family tree. We got a newspaper. Oh, with puzzles. My favorite puzzle. We got the letter from my mom's sister, my aunt. And then in a plastic bag, we have this pendant. Has some kind of message around the side. And then, how do you open it? Is it Is it like a button? Open says me. Okay, you can just pull it. and pictures. Oh, it's got num like times, I guess, maybe. And the inside of the envelope does show you which components are supposed to go back in it if you're resetting. It said the entire game is resettable, which is very nice. All right, we'll try to go a bit into this first bigger puzzle and then maybe call a stop there and I'll finish the rest off camera. So, let's see what we got in this letter first. Sorry, it's a little bit too wide to get a nice zoomedin image of the writing, but I'll do my best. Dear Sophia, I've been heading for a breakdown due to being stuck in this awful, suffocating place.
Every day, the rising sun in the east taunts me, saying, "Come and escape across the desolate moore. There's more world out here." I really can't find any evidence telling me to believe that the black wilderness around us is dangerous, and that evil witches are out there roaming the Moore. When the bitter cold wind blows across it, surely it's too miserable to support life. If you're really so completely ready to believe that witches have nothing better to do than hang around out there to snatch travelers, I'll admit that I'm disappointed in you. Yes, I know the oldies claim the truth is that Lily was taken by the maze. But was she really? I for one don't believe that story. Even our stupidest theory would pass the idiot test better than the idea of a magical vanishing maze. I'm not taking the word of mom who will not deny she was only a kid at the time. Her memories could be repressed trauma which can be very unreliable. The two or three adult witnesses there probably just hushed up some bad accident or something. I can't tolerate one more day here. Two more minutes even. Join me when you're bored of being controlled. Sofh, look deeper and I'll bet you won't miss the secret message I've left behind. You may think you're bad at puzzles, but I believe in you. Love, Eleanor. Well, apparently you shouldn't believe in her cuz she gave up right away, but I won't. Maybe. All right, so clearly we've got underlined letters. So, let me grab a piece of paper and try to hack these out. Here we go. We've got decoding locket reveals position of I messed up a few. I thought they were a one word. Uh, two keywords per line in this letter. Decoding locket reveals position of two keywords per
line in this letter. Okay. All right. So, we've got these words first. Some things are capitalized and some are not. Uh, okay. Mother of witches bows to cruel fate fates. Yeah, fates. Uh, bargain and capitulates. Mother of witches bows to cruel fates. Bargain and capitulates. Okay. Or any of those words. I've been heading for a breakdown due to being stuck in this awful suffocating place. Every day the rising. Okay. So that two keywords per line. Okay. And then um I feel like the times don't matter yet. So maybe it's the capital letters. So M O are the first letters if I'm starting with the word mother. There any M O lines? No. Huh. There is a hint system by the way. I'll just show you kind of how it starts out. So the very first thing you pull up uh just tells you what you need for the puzzle. And there's looks like four eight cuz they're double-sided. So what? 18 main puzzles in the game. All right. Well, I don't want to take forever on this. So I am going to use some hints. Let me go look.
All right. Mike the Cheater is back. And it says that maybe all thought of this. These correlate to this in that the time matches up with a letter. So like what would be 12:40? Oh, I see the like little lines. I should have noticed that before. So 12 would be M O and 40 would be RG Morg. Maybe I should have read a few more hints. 2125 military time that'd be 9:25. So an N and then 25 CR and then gosh is that 1910. Then what is that? 1320. Okay, let me go ahead and try to do the rest of these and then I'll show you the message. All we got Morgan crest crows roses crest claws. Maybe we got some crests. Uh there's crows. Morgan crest crows and rose. A rose crest claws. Is it like the number? Uh 40 cuz four crows. Two claws. 42. Okay. There is no card 42. So probably not Mike. Uh I mean does he have claws on his feet? Could it be 44? Nope. I just glimpsed it and that card has nothing to do with anything I'm talking about. Okay. Decoding locket reveals position. Oh, position of two keywords per line in this letter. So, is it like the fourth and then the second line? Heading have east in find really there are your life. I'm not feeling
I don't think I got that right. Okay. I was getting annoyed and I checked the hints and it's eight clause, four per hand. That's on me. Okay, so let's try the fourth and the eighth word. Heading to east. Okay, this already seems better. Let me go and write this down. All right, I got it. Heading to east. Come find me there. Uh, when you're ready to admit the truth. Ooh, our password will be 212. I'll miss you. 212. Okay. Is that a card or should I try to like do something with the puzzle? Well, let's let's check it. See if it's relevant. Okay, good. This time it directly references stuff I just used. So, I think I'm on the right card. Although, again, I do really wish I sure I'll mention this in my review if it keeps on happening. I wish that they had some kind of like, you know, like a lot of games will put a number in the corner and be like, "Hey, if you got here from this, you're not a dummy." Wow. You've never really heard much about Aunt Anor other than that she ran away and never came back. But she seems so certain that it was safe to cross the desolate moore.
You can't imagine how devastated your grandmother must have felt, especially as she'd already lost her little sister, Lily, to the maze. Your grandmother is called Ada and lives in a cottage not far from your house. She only wears black, and you're not surprised considering that she lost both her sister and a daughter. Ada gave you one of her old diaries once, saying she wouldn't mind you reading it if you were clever enough to work out the code to unlock it. The cover has Lily's pictured on it. Maybe some information about your great aunt Lily could help you. Discard Elnor's letter and the locket and take card 52. So, discard means I should not have to use them at all anymore, but I guess the family tree and the newspaper still matter. All right, Adah Forester. What does that say? Shift for code. Shift skip for code. I have the I mean the one two one, but I already used that. What is this?
Ry newb Q to Z. So, it's probably a substitution cipher, right? Right. So, I have to go forward. How many letters is that? I'll have to look at it. Okay. So, yeah, give me a second to work that out. Okay. I'm a dummy, so I had to write out the entire alphabet. And ah, WD WZKW. Feel like I'm reading a station name for a radio. Uh, yeah, that doesn't doesn't help it. All right. Unless these are I mean, I'm just assuming that I did that wrong, but are these initials? Is there an ah? Uh, don't see one. Is there a WD? Let me go back to this. It says, "Maybe some information about your great aunt Lily could help you." Okay, so here's Ada. Lily maybe died when she was 10. Adah Forester. Lilian Forester. I don't know what other uh information I could get. I haven't looked at this yet, but it wouldn't make any sense for this to help cuz why would a modern newspaper puzzle help you to figure out your family tree stuff? Shift for code. I mean, I shifted. Did I shift wrong? Okay, I just wanted to look at like me having the correct stuff. And it does say I need to have solved Claraara's paper route puzzle. All right, let's see what this says. Your weekly maze puzzle. Hello, puzzlers. As you know, I'm trying to demystify the often taboo topic of mazes by making them fun. Continue my exploration in modern mazes. I have an unusual one for you all this week. But don't worry, it has paths and dead ends just like a normal maze. Are you ready?
If you can find the hidden word, then you'll know how many cakes the judges were overwhelmed with at the fair. Don't understand what they're saying? Okay, the rules. Start at the number three in the bottom left corner. You can travel in a straight line orthogonally or diagonally, but you must always travel the exact number of squares shown on the square you're currently on. You cannot overshoot. Your final destination is a big asterisk in the top right corner. Once you've worked out a route, check your stops along the way against the letter grid below to spell out a word. The shortest possible route to the asterk will give you the hidden word. Oh, no. Okay. Uh, so I did like one, two, three, two. Okay. And then I can't just get there. That'd be too easy. Three, two, three. Nope. Three, five, three.
Um, well, maybe like a lot of these things, it's easier to work backwards. So, what could land on here? Uh, can any of these things going right? Okay, so that's a dead end. Any of these going up? Um, nope. So then it's got to be diagonal. Five, four. Okay. So I need to get to this spot to be able to go directly onto the asterisk. Okay. And I see three, five, three, one, four. Is there anything faster than that? That's 1 2 3 4 five steps. It seems pretty quick. I think that's got to be it. Okay, so that was S. Um, E. Oh, wait, no, no. over here. S I um X S I X Oh, six T Y 60.
Do I Do I take card 60? Okay, it appears. So, your dad comes into the room just as you finish your puzzle. He smiles at you and gives you a small card. "Hey, Thea," he says. Look what I just found. It's an old promo card from that computer game you used to love when you were a child. Do you remember Falcons versus Crows? You used to play for ages trying to get the Falcon to safety. Thanks, Dad," you say, eagerly taking it from him. He gives you a hug and leaves the room. How convenient that he just happened to find it when you were most in need of a distraction. Take card 301. Falcons versus crows. Guide your falcon between the trees. I just want to open a diary to a safe exit, but watch out. Don't get into the sighteline of three or more crows at once. They'll gang up on you and it will be game over. Oh jeez. Come on, bro. I'm all right. just just this one and and then we'll open the diary and we'll call it a night. All right, so you can't get in sight of three or more crows at once.
So going down here, it seems like right here I would die cuz one, two, three would all intersect. Okay, so going over here. Still in view of just one. Just one. Oh, can we get over here? I'm assuming not. That would be just two. That would be two. That'd be three. Yep. Okay, so that one doesn't work either. Okay, so we're going down here. That's two sight lines. That's three. Okay. So, I can't get that way. Just kind of eliminating exits here. But let's see. If I go down there, it's only two birds if I'm in this column. Then I can go over here. Uh, but if I go right there, they three see me. Okay. So, I can't get to that one or that one. So, we're down to just these exits. And that's only two birds. That's only two birds. Wait, how would I even gotten over here? Oh, I couldn't have because I'd be seen right there. Okay, so I think that's it then.
There's no card 12. Where did I mess up? Let me go check that. Oh, stupid, stupid. Right here. They would both be looking and so would that guy. Okay, so what if I cut over here? There we go. That's safe. Nine. As you guide the falcon to safety, completing the puzzle from your father, it sparks a memory. Fia, come back. You were probably only five or six at the time, and you never heard your dad sound scared before. Oh, that was my dad speaking. That's what made you come back from racing around on the edge of the moore. Your dad pulled you close to him, and you could feel his arm shaking slightly. You must never go out on the desolate moore, he said quietly but firmly. It's very dangerous. The witches out there might get you. Please promise me that you won't go running out there again. You looked up at him and realized this was important. Despite the pretty butterflies and green horizons that called you, you slely promised that you would stay away from the Moore. Okay, I'm discarding card 60. Card 301. Take card seven and discard this. And again, these nice little dividers keep everything organized. Thinking about it now, you realize that your dad must have really believed you were in danger. He's always cared about you and tried to keep you safe, and tonight is no exception.
It was very sweet of him to distract you with that game, but it seems he's not the only one in the family trying to alleviate your fears. Glancing at your pillow, you notice a few scraps of paper left by your little sister, Clara. Seeing them makes you feel warm inside. This makes me feel warm inside. Okay, so it's a map key. Oh, this is cute. Oh, road to the outside world. Danger. Here be witches. Do not cross the desolate mo like people never leave the town. Is the town miring miring? Little miring meer veil meer probably miring old miring greater miring the meadows. Okay, we got key. So here's Stonehenge. What's the meaning of Stonehenge? Okay, here's a little letter. Clara's Saturday paper route. I start at the place I need to collect my papers. I follow my ears to the next stop, then continue on to the place where they grow the expensive crops. Then I go to a place where cold water falls before going to visit our great grandmother. Next I visit the side of a river, then a place that our great-grandmother may have lived. I drop by their feathery neighbors, too, and afterwards I visit somewhere a romantic king would go, then somewhere I'd go when I want to tell the time. After that, I visit a group of fish, followed by somewhere you could buy a letter of the alphabet. I then head to the oldest part of the whole of Greater Miring, and I finish at the place where conditions are right for the best crops. Sounds like pretty advanced uh metaphors and symbolism for this little child. Oh my gosh. Okay. All right. So, she starts where she needs to collect her papers, which has to be the printing press. Then she follows her ears. So, to the bell
in. Okay. Then it says where they grow the expensive crops. Probably the Richmond farm. Then it says uh the place where cold water falls. Does it mean snow drop farm? Cold water is snow. Okay. So, that's like a C. I don't know if I'm supposed to be getting like a letter or just finding out where she ends up before going to visit our greatg grandmother. Oh man, where does it say she lived? Okay. Well, they said to keep these cards if they were revealed. Uh ah your grandmother's called Aida and lives in a cottage not far from your house. Cottage. Cottage. Oh, that's the graveyard. Maybe not there. Shoot, man. I don't know. It says that her house is by or a cottage by our house. That's our house. But none of these other things have a name that sounds like a cottage. They're all like farms or I mean this is the watch house. That's not grandmother wouldn't live in the watch house, right?
Oh, I'm stupid. I'm stupid. Wants to visit our great grandmother, not our grandmother. So, her great-g grandandmother's dead. Okay. So, it's likeoop boop boop. So, that's a what is that? A Q. An angry upside down P. All right. This one's taking a little bit longer. And I think I actually need to draw on this, but I thought everything was resettable. Maybe they gave me like a tracing paper I didn't know about. But let's stop there. We'll leave the mystery of how to get into our aunt's uh diary and whether me or my sister is going to get kidnapped by witches uh for the future. So yes, I will return having beaten this or stumbled my way through with lots of hints either way. And I'll give you my thoughts. You'll see them right away, but for me it might be a week from now.
All right, I am back. Uh how many days later? four or five, I think, after finishing the whole thing. By the way, if my voice sounds a little different, I did lose it in the intervening days, uh, from I guess talking too loudly at school. So, yeah, it's still coming back slowly but surely, but I did finish the entire witching hour. And how long did it take me? I didn't keep track exactly. I would guess maybe 4 hours. Uh, so maybe a little bit lower than their estimated amount of time for completion. But also, I was using hints pretty liberally. That's how I tend to play these games when I'm under a deadline. So, I bet if I hadn't used hints, it might have gone to five or six. And let's talk about some things without going into spoilers. Uh, first of all, the overall narrative. It felt like a slow start for me. I didn't necessarily love where it was going in the first part. Uh, but the second part I found much more engaging without any details.
It kind of goes into this past present thing and kind of looking back on the past. I found all of that very engaging and the revelations and surprises are actually pretty awesome. The only part of the latter half that I didn't love was the very end. I thought it was maybe a little bit too quick, a little bit too pat, but that's the only complaint. I thought this was a very strong story. I wouldn't quite call it top tier for me like Morrison Game Factory, Emerald Echoes, The Light in the Mist, but it was very good. I like the focus on family. It did some fun things with historical events that I won't mention. Now, in terms of the actual mechanics, uh, the hint system worked great. I do really like this way they've done the hints, kind of pulling things out to get one hint after another. The first hint always just tells you what you need for the puzzle, which is very much appreciated. And yeah, I might say this is my favorite hint system in a post curious game ever. Usually, I've preferred the ones that were online because they can be so nuanced and break down so many steps. This clearly had fewer steps in helping you, but it was still enough for me to feel like I had solved the puzzle in some way, even when I used several hints. And it's by far the easiest hint system to use. I don't have to go to a website. I don't have to flip through a book. I just find the matching icon. I pull out a piece of paper a little bit, and I get my hints.
It's great. The puzzle design in this one was good. Now, at first, and you saw my stupidity in the video, I forgot that they had given a clear sheet of plastic and a dry erase marker so you could mark things up and then erase it, which by the way is genius. Uh, I would love to use these on all the other post curious games going forward. But with that, while I was playing the first half, I was pretty annoyed. You might have felt this a bit in the video, that there was so much draw on this, draw lines between this. Those kind of puzzles popped up pretty constantly. I think the most I can remember of any post curious maybe. But once I realized how the plastic was used, cuz I finally read the directions better, stupid Mike, then I didn't mind them as much, although they still are my favorite. But, uh, in the middle to end, the puzzles get awesome. There's again keeping spoilers free. There is a bit of an exploration element and a movement element that I thought was super cool and felt very unique. And then my favorite thing of the entire game, there was a sort of murder mystery like suspect elimination thing. And man, was it cool and it tied together elements of multiple previous things. So overall, by the end, I was a very big fan of the puzzle design. Although again, at least for me, and maybe just because I didn't know that this was in the game, I didn't love some of the early puzzles with lots of drawing and lines. As usual, the production was beautiful. Things are super well organized. Each of these envelopes tells you exactly what's supposed to go in it. So, the game is very easy to tear back down. And if you're smart and use the dry erase from the beginning, then nothing in the game is marked up or damaged, and you can pass it on. Sadly, because I was stupid, I did write on a few things. So, if I were to pass this to a friend, they're going to have a few puzzles they won't be able to do. But this does remove the
need for reset packs. So that's great. Again, the organization is awesome. It makes it very easy to reset the game. And having these discard piles to get rid of materials that you don't need anymore makes the current puzzles a lot easier to focus on. So that was nice. The use of the cards was pretty good. It did, as I mentioned, remind me of an unlock game because there were moments where you would look at a picture and there'd be like six or seven numbers on there and you'd have to find them all, which might be a little bit annoying having to dig through these many numbers cuz it does go up to the 300s. But it also made usability easier in some cases, like there are situations where you have to guess something and if your guess is wrong, you go to this card and you see what it says and it'll tell you your guess is wrong. And I think in the end, that's probably easier than flipping through a book. definitely easier than it would have been if I had to check an online website to see if I was right or wrong. And again, this does replace the entire narrative book that a lot of these games have. So, I think, you know, it's a bit of a wash, but I think the card deck worked pretty well.
And overall, there's another great release from Post Curious. And again, it's in some ways friendlier than previous releases cuz you still don't need any online connectivity. The hint system works great. You don't need to write on anything and you can pass it on if you're not dumb like Mike. It's super organized. It's beautifully put together. Oh, and I should mention there are, as there often are in these games, some really lovely manipulatives and physical objects you use in the puzzles in here. So, Post Curious does it again. If you like their other stuff, you're definitely going to love this. And if you've never tried one of their games before, I think this is a pretty easy in. It's not crazy long like the Storm Lamp Rituals or Light in the Mist. And it's maybe a little bit easier to get into with some of the new production decisions. So, go check out the crowdfunding page and see what you think. And thanks for watching everybody. Special thank you to our biggest Patreon supporters, Matt G, Dan J, William F, Steve Ren, Andrew R, and Chris C.