Age of Sigmar General's Handbook - What I Think
Transcript
in this video I'm going to tell you what I think about the General's handbook the Warhammer age of Sigmar General's handbook came out like last week I picked I picked mine up on the weekend for my friendly local game store and uh it's $25 retail and uh it's perfect bound that's what they call it when it's got a floppy cover like this but it comes to this Square kind of edge that's perfect bound if it was like a big giant staple or something like that that's called saddle stitch in case you cared anyway uh full color all throughout um I don't know how many pages 170ish and as you've already heard it comes with three main sections it comes with the open playay section which is new information for open playay it comes with the kind of narrative SL campaign section which gives you a lot of new options and things like that that we've never really had before there was nothing in the original four page page Rules book about booklet package sheet whatever about narrative campaign play anything along those lines and then of course there's the by certain people much sought after points uh section so I've gone through it quite a bit lovely photography lovely artwork um mostly photography honestly I get the feeling that it is probably cheaper for them to do like some of these like really big you know like huge images of sometimes
in some of these situations hundreds of models it's probably quicker or at least cheaper maybe for them to put all these things together and to shoot them than it is to contract uh an artist to A piece of artwork for four different things on just this spread Alone um you know like here there's probably a couple hundred models in there you it's let's just it's a lot of skeletons let's just say that so my point is is that it's it's a beautiful looking book no nobody should dispute The Games Workshop doesn't know how to make a beautiful looking book they do great work um I went through a bunch of it I went through the open play stuff because I'm kind of a big dork for that stuff I like the the no points and what they've done in there is they've added in a bunch of extra basically scenarios and things like that they added in the ability for multiplayer which when I first heard it I thought but the game is multiplayer cuz there's two of us but I'm thinking of video games where there's a single player and a multiplayer in this what rules are is it's like this is how you play with more than two players whether you play with Team games they give you information on how to do that they give you information on how to play just a big free-for-all you got five people and they all bring some forces great knock yourself out the second section is called narrative play and it's all about obviously kind of telling a story with your uh your games or a series of games which in many situations people refer to as Campaign games because it's like this game and then the results from that affect the next one and the next one and the next one it's a really interesting way to play and um there's a lot of
games out there obviously morheim Frost grave necromunda all the other ones that I can't think of off the top of my head lots of games have been doing it for a long time and a lot of people who are not super into tournaments are super into campaign play because it's I don't know I mean honestly I think that for me it reminds me a little bit of like back when I was in fifth grade playing Dungeons and Dragons and going through all that stuff and further on it wasn't like I just played with I was in fifth grade I played for years and years in that kind of stuff but this sort of thing gives you the ability to kind of do a little bit that personalize your Miniatures H personaliz you know and and you really get these kind of storylines going on behind them especially when you're telling a linked campaign narrative through your play it's great to see that they're doing stuff like that again a bunch of scenarios in here uh battle plans as they like to call them and um I can't wait to start working with some of my friends to kind of build some of these linked narrative campaigns and and work with some of the stuff out of this book so I think that's going to be really cool now the section that is probably most controversial uh and also that I have not looked into as much as I should there's this kind of one sort of sticking point that I haven't quite figured out yet but I'll get into it the points matched play as it's referred to in the book so in matched play it talks about how to play games where you're matched you have a force of thousand points I have a course of a th000 points and we play they they kind of lay it out as as this they they
say you can play 1,000 point games 2,000 point games 3,000 point games now again those are suggestions pretty much everything that you come across in this book which I really appreciate they're always like well you can do it this way it's optional you can use this part or just this part or both parts or whatever you want early on in the book they're really like use this as a guide do what you want have a good time you know I mean and I appreciate that I think it's good that they do that in a book like this because it still gives you the ability to play any different way you want I know myself included a lot of the people who are you know Pro no points that even is a thing uh we thinking you know I don't know man bringing points in is going to be problematic and to some degree that still may be the case you may have people that just don't want to play unless you're playing P points and if you don't want to play points well you're going to have some issues but generally I think hopefully either you'll be able to compromise or you'll be able to you know find other people to play with or whatever the deal is because there's a lot to this book and maybe you and your friend he wants to do points and you want to do no points but maybe you guys can even just compromise and go well what if we do a campaign narrative play you know I mean there's a lot of different options that all being said the point section in here is pretty robust um initially I thought that there were certain figures that were left out an opponent of mine that I play quite frequently he goes uh chaos trolls and I went through the entire chaos section and I couldn't find the chaos trolls and I thought well maybe the just because they're kind of overpowered even in with no points I feel like they're a little overpowered as it turns out the reason
that they weren't didn't show up in the chaos section is because they showed up in what's known as the compendium section compendium seems to be kind of um you know like it's just kind of where extra stuff sort of ends up which that's what I haven't been able to figure out yet like they have a section for order a section for chaos a section for death and a section for Destruction and then they have this compendium which starts off with beastmen which in my mind would be chaos but it's not the beastmen it's just specific named beastmen goris War hoof gorthor the Beast Lord uh karak the one eye that kind of stuff and in that section this compendium section there is uh some scaven there's some uh Orcs and goblins and at some point there are warriors of chaos so I don't know what the compendium is I don't know if these have been things that have been taken out you're not supposed to use him in tournament play I haven't figured that part out like I said I haven't dug as deeply into the um the RO the the point section of the book as I have the other two sections which I've looked over quite a bit um here's a picture of a war band that I used at my local shop a while back this was off of my Instagram um I it consists of let me hang on a second here it consists of 10 beastmen uh 10 chaos Warriors five putri Blake Kings uh gut rot spume uh Lord of plagues AKA Lord drippy um the Rott Brer sorcerer who my personal rot Brer
sorcerer has done some really nice work in the last couple of games I got to come up with a specific personalized name for him uh let's see here who else is in there uh three venard um oh and a demon Prince that whole group put together I looked up in the points comes to uh 1,280 points now the the one issue that I see with points and the way that they're doing it in in this book for those of you who've been playing for a long time playing other games like 40K or whatever like in 40K they'd say you got to have a minimum of let's say Five Guys in this group but they cost this much each so if you brought seven let's say they cost 10 points each minimum would be 50 but if you brought seven of them it would be 70 not so here in the point section for the General's handbook minimum let's say just you know my my my goat people uh the gors as I like to call them the goat people the they come as a minimum unit size of 10 and that costs 80 points okay makes sense well you pay in multiples so if I was to bring 12 I would have to pay for the next 10 so 80 points gets me 10 if I bring two more because I happen to have the models if I want to field them I have to pay for up to the next 10 which would be another 80 points so 10 of them costs 80 and 12 of them or 13 of them or 14 of them or 15 of them Etc until you hit 20 costs
another 80 which that's 160 points now obviously they're eight points a piece because it's 80 points for 10 of them so I don't know why you can't just say that they cost this much each but you can't the rules show and there's even a little call out box that says hey by the way this is how it works which I applaud Games Workshop for you know writing some rules and saying hey there's this thing that's a little ambiguous and we're going to tell you exactly so it's not ambiguous cuz in previous rules as many of you veterans know that was never the case so it's interesting to me that and I don't know if it's just a sales technique to get you to buy more models but setting up these th000 Point 2,000 Point 3,000 Point battles is going to be tough because there's going to be times like I've got a 1280 list right with my guys that are in the were in that picture I can take out the demon Prince for 160 and I could take out I don't know something else maybe I think the I think the Lord of plagues Lord drippy I think he's 100 points so I could pull them out but that's still I'm 20 points over and there's no way to reduce you know what I mean so because the point values are far less granular than they used to be I think it's going to be much harder to hit these you know specific th000 2,000 3,000 Point uh things so I don't know I'm going to have to look into it more um again this is all you know I'm glad that they're doing this because a lot of people were asking for it and that's great for me I'm still
a little like I don't know if I'm even going to bother because it seems like a lot of extra math and if it would have been a situation where you paid per guy minimum is 30 or let's say minimum is 10 you know unit in a unit and maximum is 30 but they cost this much each how hard is that for math that's not hard at all I don't know why they didn't do it that way h if you know in the comments I'd like you to tell me because it doesn't make any sense to me I think it's based off of the South Coast GT Rules From what I understand um and they kind of had these pools and all that stuff I didn't understand it then and I still don't understand it now like why aren't gors eight points each why are they 80 for 10 and 160 for 12 that doesn't make any sense like why just because you have a couple more you immediately have to bump up to the next multiple of 10 that doesn't to me that doesn't sit well and I kind of don't like that otherwise I do really like the book I think there's a lot of great stuff in here like I said the first two sections kind of blowing my socks off lots of cool besides the imagery and some stories and things like that there's also just great um battle plans tons of them if you've been kind of like well I've been playing the battle plans out of the original book a lot or if you've just been playing I go over and try to kill you and you try to kill me there's a ton of stuff in here again open and comp narrative Play From what I understand there's even good battle plans I believe yeah and Pitch there's there's battle plans for the the um you know the Matched play and stuff like that so there's a lot going on in here if you're into agis Sigmar this is pretty much an
auto buy you really want to get this it's 25 bucks American um a lot of places you can get a discount I did from my local shop because that's what they do with Games Workshop seriously like I bought the uh chaos Tome or whatever which was also soft cover Thicker Than This considerably and it was 30 $3 to me that felt like a giant waste of money cuz it was basically just all the war Scrolls that are in the app and I could have just looked them up from there and I didn't really get much else there were no battle plans in there it just wasn't much that was useful in that this doesn't feel like that this feels like a great buy if you're into age of Sigmar or if you've been staying away from AG of Sigmar because you're like well yeah but yeah points I really like points well here you go you and your friends can start doing that and it's great um you know that you have that ability now if you are just like I want to find out more stuff to do maybe my gaming is turning a little stagnant or you've been thinking about age of Sigmar but you're like I don't know four pages of rules sounds like a little janky yeah this is the thing you want to go with so um other people who've been buying it like I said it's been out almost a week at this point in the comments let me know what you think about it let me know what you think about that points thing um yeah it's I'm just glad that they're doing this from what I understand from their most recent um earnings report for the quarter earnings are for a of Sigmar are like at 30% of their sales which in comparison to the way it was before a of Sigmar fantasy was like at around 17 so seems to be doing well and I know that they seem to be pushing more into it there's the big summer campaign if you
haven't heard about that take a look on the app if you're interested you can play at your local stores and change the history of the age of Sigmar so if you're interested you should definitely look at it I think it's a great buy and I'm super glad I got my copy n