Sea Salt & Paper Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today I am taking a look at sea salt and paper which is a very small box card game designed by Bruno cathala and T Rivier this one accommodates two to four players and takes around 30 minutes to play according to the box now before I get started on my review of sea salt and paper I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor kendra. co.uk who are my goto online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order so sea salt and paper is a set collection card game where you're trying to get the most points by collecting cards not only in your hand but also play cards out in the table so your your combined score between the two will be your final score for the round you're going to keep on playing rounds until you've reached a set amount of points depending on the player count now the setup is very simple you're going to give the deck of cards a shuffle you're going to reveal two which are going to be the two disc card piles now on your turn you can do one of two things in ways of acquiring cards you can draw two and then put one of them back on one of the um on one of the discard piles so in this example I've drawn two um very similar cards there so I might want to put this one here and keep this one in my hand now the other option is to draw a card from one of the discard piles and you have to draw the top card um if you are doing that now there are a bunch of different cards available which I've put
a few out here now generally speaking um a lot of the cards will have these abilities in the top left hand corner you got these crabs the fish the boats and also the shark and swimmer now when you acquire these cards if you have a pair of them then after you've drawn your card you can you can actually choose to play as many pairs of cards as you want and get a special power now the special powers will let you either go through uh the the discard piles and pick one of those cards it will let you pick a card off the top of the deck it will let you get a backto back turn or it will let you steal a card off another player also when you play a pair of cards um they'll be worth an extra point at the end of the game now let's have a look at some of the other cards available here so there are actually four of these mermaid cards now these mermaid cards will give you a point for your most numerous um color suit in your hand so if I had say you know four of these dark blue cards that would be an extra four points and if I collected more of these mermaid cards then it'll go down to my next strongest suit my next strongest suit and so on now there's also a shoot the moon scoring system where if you have four of these mermaid cards and you play them then you'll instantly um win the game now other cards include these set collection cards you have these penguins you have these shells these octopuses or octopi and also and you have these anchor cards which I've not put out here um and these
will score you simple set collection bonuses you can see here one penguin is going to be worth one point um all three penguins are going to be worth five points and you can see that in the bottom right hand corner you have the number of Cs in your hand there so you know you got to have all of them to get to those higher amount of points and the shells you can get up to 10 points if you collect six of them and the octopi you will collect up to five of them for a massive 12 points now on top of those set collection cards you actually have these um booster cards as well which will give you some additional points depending on the different types of cards you have in your hand like in this example I'll get two points for every penguin card I have so you know if I had all three of these and this one then that's quite a few points there so after you've drawn your card and you've played as many of these Duo cards as you want you optionally can choose to end the round and when you end the round round you have one of two options you can either say stop where each player will um stop and just score the cards you have not played in front of you as as well as the card you have in your hand um but you'll also um you can also do what's called a last chance and in this example every other player will have one extra turn before they reveal their cards now in this example you are somewhat wagering on yourself to be the strongest player and have the most points because if you have for the most points by the time everybody's had their final turn you will score all of the
cards in your hand and played in front of you as well as your strongest um color of um suit that you have in front of you you know a point for each of those um but your opponents will only score their strongest suit in terms of the colors they have so you know it's a big gamble but you can potentially um really hinder your opponent scoring some points if you are not correct in wagering in yourself as in you thought you'd have the most points but somebody actually had more points than you um then you only score your color bonus but all the opponents score the points on their cards so again a big big gamble and um it could it could pay off or it could not pay off and as I said you're going to keep on playing these rounds I'm having to shuffle the deck in between them um and you're going to keep on playing until you reach a certain amount of points depending on the player count so in a two-player game it'll be the first of 40 points in a three-player game it'll be 35 points and in a two player sorry in a four player game it will be 30 points okay so let's share some thoughts on sea salt and paper um let's start with some of the scoring I actually do quite enjoy this idea of um not only the cards you've played in front of you um scoring if you have the pairs of them of course but also the cards in your hand scoring so it adds some murkiness into how well each player is doing which of course will tie in to that end of round trigger which is kind of one of the quirky rules of this game you know have have I got enough confidence to bet on myself to think you
know I'm doing well here let's call the end of the round and hopefully I can um hinder everybody scoring all those points or you might think I'm not doing so well I think my opponents are really pulling away therefore I'm going to call the end of the round and we'll just score the points we have and we'll start again with a whole fresh rack of cards now I have seen this mechanism used before in a game called Cabo and I think in that game it is pulled off to an exceptional standard and is a really exciting part of the game now I do like it here but I feel like the actual scoring condition is a little bit clunky and even confusing initially now you think you know am I going to if I better on myself then if I'm correct then I'll score all my points plus my color bonus but only my opponents will score their color bonus if I'm incorrect I will score just my color bonus but my opponents will score their points now that's not the most intuitive of rules and maybe it should have been a kind of All or Nothing thing um I'm not quite sure in respect of that I do like the fact that the more information you reveal or the more kind of powers you're utilizing um you know you are showcasing the cars that you have you and know while these powers are pretty decent in terms of you know drawing exact cars that you want which can of course really boost the set collection cards um or just you know drawing another another card off the top of the deck getting another turn to get more cards is of course very important or even getting a lucky dip by um you know diving into someone's hand which you know when things like um if you have say two or three of the mermaids doing a lucky dip into someone's hand and you know snatching a card off them can be quite
exciting especially if you know that they've picked up a mermaid off one of those discard piles I do really like this shoot the moon mechanism now I've not actually managed to um pull that move off or seen it done but we've come very close before and you know even if you um almost tunnel vision yourself into picking up these mermaids even if you don't manage to um you know achieve that they are still worth quite a few points on their own because again if you are really stockpiling a certain color then you're going to get a point for your best color there um so again these are very um a strong card in the game I do really enjoy how fast the turns are here know the um the actions you take are pretty rapid you know just drawing cards and then just smashing a few pairs down and a lot of the time you don't even have a pair so you'll turn over is you turn is over pretty quickly and you're not just sat there waiting for somebody to take these long elaborate turns now that being said I do think the game does drag it heals a bit in terms of its length and because the length is kind of undetermined and it is player driven sometimes these rounds can outstay their welcome and it feels like is this is this a fast game or not I'm not quite sure um so I do think the potential for this game to go too long is um is quite a significant factor especially when you are playing out over several rounds and I've even had to house rule that by saying you know we're going to play two rounds whoever's got the most points out of those two rounds um will be the victor regardless or not if we hit that um you know official rule of hitting a certain amount of points I think maybe this could have been fixed by starting
with a couple of cards in your hand because you do start each round with nothing um so maybe that's a small house rule that you could actually um fix yourself the player interaction in this game is fine um you know you are sometimes competing over the same cards um again you do have the um the swimmer and the Shark cards where you can do um steal cards of other players which doesn't actually feel too bad in this game I don't generally like take that mechanisms but it's fine here because you do need to have a pair um but I do feel like um it does scale best at two players um I think when you start adding that third or fourth player in it gets a little bit wild in terms of the discard piles and I do like this the fact there's two discard piles here but if you are playing with you know get that three or four player count the chances of a card remaining there by the time it's back to your turn is is quite slim and that can get quite frustrating so I actually do think that the game scale is best at two players for that reason and also that the scoring is a bit more simple where you only have to wager on yourself to beat one player rather than an extra two or three players the production for this game is fine um it is in a very small box which is always um a welcome thing um the card stock is is adequate um they're not linen finish um a pretty cheap feeling card but the game is cheap in itself so um you know I can't really blame them for that in terms of the actual artwork I think it looks wonderful um you know all these kind of origami style um images that really clever and it looks quite distinct to a lot of other games out
there so I definitely like uh that they've done a good job for the symbology they've also done a good job of um you know using color blind friendly symbols here which is definitely a welcome addition for me so no complaints really you know not the best quality but it is a very small box and it is pretty affordable okay so let's share some final thoughts on SE salt and paper now this game actually um did intrigue me quite a lot because it's got a bit of a cult following it's got some traction and it definitely has its fans now sadly I have to say that I'm not a huge fan of this game and don't get me wrong I think it's probably slightly better than average and it definitely has some redeeming features um but I think the issues I have with it outweigh those positives um number one I do think the game is too long um it does really drag its heels and you kind of feel like you're just um you know going through the motions and not really knowing with any concrete evidence when you should um you know end the round and I do really like that mechanism as I said I've seen it used before in a game called Cabo and that's the best part of that game and I think if you like that mechanism definitely check out um Cabo a simple memory game I do like the fact that you um you know are playing these powers out giving a bit more information about how many points you have but getting quite strong ability at the same time um you know holding back these set collection cards in your hand and you could reveal a bunch of them at the same time using a bit of memory to track what other people are going for maybe try to cover up those cards but all of these things they're not quite enough to again counteract how long the game takes and
just how wooly and clunky that end of round scoring um feels so I think if I'm going to play a simple card game a simple set collection one I'll probably play something like coloretto or something like parade um over games like sea salt and paper um I really love the look of this one you know it has a very distinct um visual design here which is um very nice to look at um I do like the shoot the moon mechanism um but overall I think it's just I think it's just average I I really am not overly um impressed by it which I'm quite sad by because I do love a good um small box card game so um I definitely think this is going to have its fans and clearly has done and um you know there are certainly cool things here but um ultimately I have other games like the Apple mentioned parade um coloretto um that I'd rather play over sea salt and paper