Sherlock Holmes: Consulting Detective Review with Board Game Coffee
Transcript
today I'm reviewing Sherlock Holmes consulting detective mark Maia welcome to board game coffee Sherlock Holmes consulting detective is a 1 to 8 player game of mystery and intrigue basically it's a game where everybody takes turns reading passages out of a book and then working together solve its mysteries kinda sounds like Sunday school except for old murder no wait ok I'm just gonna lay it on you straight no matter how good everyone says it is Sherlock is not for everyone for one thing there's a lot of reading I mean a lot it's all you do you read take notes and discuss it's more like a group assignment than a game I'll be it an interesting work assignment but only if you have the right group and sure a bad group could ruin any game but I get the sense that the fragility of a Sherlock groups fun factor is tenuous compared to most other game night propositions so mitigate expectations when proposing said night of murder and mystery let your group know up front that we're playing your sherlock game there's a lot of reading involved note-taking and discussion and involves no dice miniatures or deck-building matter of fact it's more like an interactive storybook than a game and it's important that everyone knows this before showing up don't go setting up a board game night and then pull out old Shirley locks when everyone arrives because spending a night reading out loud to a group of people hanging on your every word might might be everyone's idea of a relaxing Friday night it's not mine but you know what I had a good group and we had a good time but no matter how good a time it was I cannot recommend this to everyone but if the idea of reading and solving a mystery with a group of friends sounds like a good time then I do recommend this King to you the
stories are actually war written which I'll admit I was not expecting now I did do a few things off book that I think really helped our group experience first I would not have made photocopies of the newspaper so everyone around the table would have a copy to scribble on I also went out and bought notebooks pencils and sharpeners for everyone then as a group we assigned two official note takers although everyone did keep their own notes as well just in case we also selected one person to be our directory licker upper and lastly what I thought brought the whole link together we had one person volunteer to do all the read and he did an amazing job accents and area and it gave us all a chance to get used to one voice and really focus on the story and as a host it's your duty as it was mine to make sure everyone at the table is engaged and feels included because if one person isn't talking there's a good chance they're just not having a good time and although I haven't done it myself I can see how Sherlock would be a great game to play solo but even better as a cop so how did I do at your look not so good I mean I sounded like I knew what I was talking about but I'm pretty sure I'm the one responsible for my team scoring negative five out of a possible hundred and forty and putting an innocent man behind bars so in short Sherlock is good it's better with the right people but it's not for everyone and it's really hard