Beyond Solitaire Podcast 130: Hamish Cameron on Gaming Ancient Borders
Transcript
thank you it's ad break time I'm pleased to announce the Beyond Solitaire podcast remains proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual they are up to amazing things if you want to improve your own skills as a game designer you should absolutely sign up for a Loyola Santa's upcoming class the art of game crafting for your classroom boardroom or game night the class starts October 9th and Eloy is a great teacher you'll also get credit towards a certificate in applied game design which is offered as a collaboration between CMU and Gen Con clgs's latest game 500 year old vampire just finished a very successful campaign but if you forgot to back it you can now pre-order through backer kit the link is in the show notes I also want to plug my own patreon your support means a lot to me both emotionally and financially patreon money is what makes it possible to keep improving my channel by upgrading the equipment and I'm also hoping to increase the amount of videos I can publish over the course of the next year if you want to help out head over to patreon.com Beyond Solitaire for now though let's get on with the show hey Gamers it's Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and I'm here with a very special guest this is Dr Hamish Karen he is a lecture classical studies at Victoria University of Wellington in New Zealand how you doing today Hamish I'm doing well it's a little bit early but it's uh it's all good hi Liz how's it how are you it's going great so we are I think are we 13 hours apart like no no we're like no it's no it's not like that uh you're on the East Coast right yeah eight
eight we're eight hours ahead which I usually calculate the other way uh just because no wait we are we're eight eight hours is the other way 16 hours we're 16 hours ahead I was behind but tomorrow so now that we're speaking across the Dateline what even this time
uh and with that we're going to be visiting the ancient world today since we can just do that so you are a lecture In classical studies but you do work that combines Classics and gaming so is that where you started or is that where you ended up and how did you get there uh that is a good question it's sort of a bit of both uh I would say that I started in my journey is a as a gaming person started before my journey as a classicist or historian uh and then uh continued parallel with me doing my PhD um and then recently I guess uh in my last job when I was teaching at Bates College up in Maine I combined the two and now that's what I do I mean I do other things as well but that since then has become a major teaching and research uh Focus as well um but I when I was in grad school I published a role-playing game and that meant that I had like a side thing as a game designer in a kind of formal way rather than the kind of fiddling that most tabletop role-playing folks GMS in particular do uh and yeah that's that's sort of the nutshell I guess so you were an RPG kid yeah what about board games or just RPG uh actually more uh Miniatures war games
um uh so I started off playing like yeah Miniatures war games with little plastic figures uh 20 mil World War II stuff and napoleonics back when I was like 10 or 11 or something like that and that's about the same time that I also discovered the fighting fantasy uh Choose Your Own Adventure books uh and got into those um and yeah haven't looked back really that's awesome and what kind of class did you think you were going to do before you combine with games what was your area well my and it still is my I mean I don't know what did I think I was gonna do actually let me back this up so when I started going I mean I'm one of those classicists and I have this discussion with my students uh all the time as I many of them are the same and I think mini classes are the same with the so many interesting things about Classics because it's really an area studies field that covers like history and uh culture and literature and all these things and so there's so many different parts of that that I find interesting um because I'm sort of interested in like what makes humans do things in lots of ways um in ideological structures uh and so when I first went to grad school I was thinking I will work on the western half of the Roman World um because I had done my ma on uh the on the coming of Roman imperialism and cilicia but I'd worked for a research project before that on um The Cult of Bacchus in Rome uh in its suppression
and I was thinking okay so I went East with the celicia M.A and now I want to go back West but that didn't happen and I just kept going further east uh and so my PhD was on uh the representation of the border between the Roman and the parthian empires and now a lot of the work that I do outside of games is related to that intersection between the Romans and the parthians um I'm writing something on the path in the Indian empire right now and I have a thing on Palmyra that came out uh recently and various other things like that so I'm sort of like in that space and I work on geography as well and the representation of space in the ancient world uh more broadly but that sort of yeah the things that I do as well as games there's a lot going on I know that's awesome also like I totally feel you about going east like frankly the Eastern Empire no offense anyone is more interesting there's so much going on there it's such a like all of the things that happen on the Eastern side that slowly draw Roman attention to the east it's when you look at it from that perspective it's no surprise that the survival of the of the Roman Empire was in Byzantium um and just the concerns of that Frontier are so pressing that everything just like the center of power just drifts in that direction oh yeah oh yeah and like you know I did my PhD she's in ancient Christianity so you know when you think about ancient Christianity and you live in the United States like maybe you're thinking about Roman Catholics or you know maybe that's about as far back as you go but I studied Coptic Egypt and also all those Creeds everybody's saying On Any Given
Sunday you know the Romans really the like Rome Romans like of the city didn't really have much to do with that like let's go to the syrians and the Egyptians and the just it's just a more like the story of all that is so much more complex than I think that we see if you focus too much on the west yeah uh so most of my work on the on the near East focuses on sort of Northern Syria so one of the things I did at grade school was it was a course on Syriac um so just just another one of those languages that is actually really important in the eastern half of the Empire um and all these places were represented at Rome as well and sort of Rome is the sort of Cosmopolitan thing but we don't see that represented in our Elite Roman sources who are just writing about what it means to be a super manly Roman who lives on the farm and then
you said you wish that you learned context I wish I learned Syriac but I only had so many uh taught so much time and I actually chose to do some Arabic which I also wish that I had done more of um there's just never enough language time like ever it's I did have the opportunity to learn uh old Persian uh in my first year of grade school but the class was at 8am and so I didn't
terrible mistake not taking the ADM class was a terrible mistake doing this night so how um so what kind of work are you doing with games then does it look very different from the areas of Classics where you're only studying or those things just kind of are they fellow Travelers for you yeah they're definitely fellow Travelers um most of what I do is about it's sort of like classical reception stuff where so how does this game represent the ancient world and in what ways does it do it what does it include what does it not include what is that what arguments is that making is the game making about usually the Contemporary moment using the ancient world um and for me my work on video games in particular about all games is deeply related to questions of historiography um so what do we how do we make meaning of the past like how do we analyze sources what does this information tell us like what can we tell about the source and its perspectives and how that influences our reading of it all that stuff so when I teach my class on um the ancient world through video games which also includes some analog games uh the first two weeks are basically all historiography and I'm really having them read the story of historiographical stuff um Adam Chapman's book for example like is a great intersection between those two where he talks about like doing the playing games is doing history in some sort of way
uh and so really it's it's a way of kind of like smuggling a hardcore historiography class under the guise of uh Cassandra leaping off buildings and knifing people I mean absolutely um so if your attention to in this context because I feel like you have a lot of options um so how do you choose which games about the Roman world are worthy of your intellectual engagement and taking seriously this way uh I think any game that that I mean I think any game is worthy of intellectual engagement mostly the ones that I choose for my classes are ones that I think a lot of students will already know about um but I do try and bring in a mix of some indie games they maybe haven't heard about but I don't want to have a class on games in the ancient world and not deal with God of War or uh Assassin's Creed all these kind of things um because I mean there's enough of that kind of like elitism around that I don't want to bring it to my interaction um with games I think anything that is a type of popular media that is engaged with by a large number of people is worth studying for that very reason it doesn't matter whether it's quote unquote good or quote unquote critically good or anything like that or serious um uh the fact that it is taken that people spend a lot of money and a lot of time on it makes it serious and so I think that those things are with your engagement and that's the main thing I
focus on sort of like popular culture receptions um through games I guess like they're worthy of interest because they are popular you hate them you've got to engage something like you've got it's in case something like God of War I feel like we're also in an age of very independent and Niche games and how do you sift through what's available and like choose what to give your attention to beyond what seems obvious yeah uh I think you I think you have to well I either play them myself or I get recommendations from other people who are in the space um and so it's one of those classic like you have to read the secondary literature to find out what people are talking about um and just like there's in if you're doing sort of like regular Classics uh you might not know about a particular fragment of a of some weird author until you read something about it and you're like oh this changes what I thought about this particular part of of whatever I'm looking at um similarly I think with games you might not know something exists and then find it that it exists and then it might change the way you think about some aspect of the sort of game landscape um but uh in terms of like trying to find I guess more Niche games I mean as as a Indie tabletop Creator myself I'm very sensitive to the to the way that games like Dungeons and Dragons or um uh Assassin's Creed kind of suck the air
out of the room in terms of talking about other things so I do try to uh to pay attention to what's happening in other spaces like steam um like every year that when sort of like E3 or it's zombie digital equivalent comes around um uh it's I sort of watch a bunch of the review shows to see what is coming out on with an idea classical stuff um but when I arrange my syllabus I definitely don't like Assassin's Creed gets a fair amount of time but it doesn't get time in proportion to its the number of people who play it it gets like a week and a half maybe maybe like three classes and God of War gets like one and Heaven's Vault gets one um because it's a fascinating engagement with um like language and how language can work as a language in archeology and inscriptions and all those those cool things that are related um to Classics um and analog games get some space as well even though those are like sort of orders of magnitude less popular than the big games yeah iterations that come into it about like the amount of how I divide up time in the classroom and so when I teach the class this class that I'm that I'm talking about which is a upper division uh Classics course so everybody
in it is a Classics major or almost a classic major um I have a certain like the way that those classes work at our University it's a few hours a week for kind of lectures and tutorials um so in that within those constraints I can't really do justice to analog games because to do justice to analog games uh the students need to play them um and that means I need like game Labs or something and so I have done that in previous classes like in especially in like short-term things um yeah I feel like I rambled way off topic there no no actually
games and andoretically it would be better for students to play the games in order to experience like what it is you're talking about and to move through this version of the ancient world that's being presented and that you're going to discuss in class so how does that work do students just buy games the way that you would buy textbooks and are they required to play did they watch Let's Plays do they just read is it a mix like how does that work I offer both options so I when I'm setting up any given week in my class I will have uh links to where they can buy the game if they want to buy the game but I will also have links to Let's Play videos uh or um some other other types of videos sometimes uh sort of like plot summary video type things spinning out what we want to talk about uh so that depending on the students exact level of interest and ability to financially engage with that stuff which is sort of like outside the bounds of like course costs um that somebody who has played all the games can or can play all the games can engage with the class on one level and a student who doesn't have the means whether that's a console or a or a game playing computer or space or like friends to play analog games but they can still engage play sort of watching material but then the key next step is that they make sure to
reinforcing class that the way that you're engaging with the material determines or the way that you're engaging with the games determines the kinds of arguments you can make because there are certainly some arguments that you can make just as well from having watched a playthrough of Assassin's Creed for example but there are some things that you can't make unless you've actually played them and you can't speak to some gameplay elements unless you have a more Hands-On knowledge of those gameplay elements oh that's really interesting so given that you spend a lot of time kind of creating these experiences for your students and deciding what they should be giving attention to uh why don't we just take this moment what are some video games that you feel represent the Roman world and extremely well the ancient world an extremely interesting ways that are worthy of note for people who are listening and want to go check something out um because I'm gonna guess Assassin's Creed maybe not I mean I didn't think there's anything I can say about Assassin's Creed that people wouldn't necessarily have already I mean that's probably not sure I have articles on it and stuff but I'm not here to pump for Ubisoft uh and insert standard disclaimer about uh shitty Ubisoft practices that have not yet been resolved I don't think um so I mean I think uh uh uh forgotten City we talked about a little bit in the sort of pre-show um is interesting and quick and has both interesting engagement with some
aspects of classical culture um sort of literary culture but also with archeology and that it really does some some interesting things with in a very short format um I think that's worth a look uh I think I will sort of echo um Kate Cook from uh the previous interview um that you had with her where she talked about the Expeditions Rome a little bit which definitely does some interesting things and I don't know if I was necessarily speaking to be as engaged with it as I was but I played through the whole thing and then played through the ending multiple times to see different endings which I don't necessarily always do um I haven't written anything about that it's usually the level I'll go to if I want to be writing something about it and I haven't written anything about that and I don't necessarily have any specific plans to um but those were a couple of just of relatively I mean they're both I don't know it's hard to judge how popular something is I guess I don't think neither of those are AAA games anyway yes but we're also talking about how much you like it so those are both on my like a list of things to explore at this point and then when you're writing what are you what sorts of things do you like to write about like I know that we talked about reception but within that there's so many things what are the kinds of things that you see in a game and it hooks you and you think oh I'm gonna be able to write about this um um I think it's usually things that
reflect assumptions about the ancient world that I think um misconceptions in some way and I'll see something such as the way that the Roman military is represented in Assassin's Creed origins or something um which is just a to think of one that's that I've done um where although that's not a misconception I guess well maybe the example from forgotten city um because this is published so people can go and see read my thoughts on it so the way that it sort of engages with slavery but doesn't really um is a pretty common thing to happen in games like things that are very common in the ancient world and that we as Scholars of the ancient world can sometimes take for granted uh that are definitely not common for good reason in the modern world um and are often avoided in the modern world um I guess you might also put into that same category uh Hades which is another game that is well worth playing if you haven't haven't played it um and the way that Hades engages with uh incestuous relationships in the uh ancient Mythic sources by completely ignoring and avoiding them um with sometimes little Sly notes in the game text that suggest that they're
for the knowing classicist audience like ah yes uh wink wink um you know what's going on here don't you uh but they are sort of keeping that out for modern reasons right that these are things that they as a company don't want to have the game involved with while also uh making other changes that specifically move things into a into a modern Direction um such as sort of querying everybody in that which is not not totally a historical but also very modern in the way that they do it that's really interesting yeah actually um I was very interested in your piece about forgotten City because um you know I've written a series myself about how Gladiators are presented in board games and you had a specific comment about a gladiator or Gladiators being you know doing it for the honor and the glory they're volunteer Fighters which you know if you've listened to this product I saw people out there or if you just want a hobby horse I'm gonna link both sessions
um but for me part of what makes reception studies so interesting is that I like to look at what we think of or even think of incorrectly about the Roman world or the Greek world or you know any part of the ancient world and then apply that to us and think about what what are we saying about ourselves when we change the record this way so do you have any sort of overarching ideas about that at this time like what it what of us do you see when you're looking at these these treatments of the ancient world oh I mean so much I mean history is always telling you what history is history can mean many things one of the things that history means is the story of what we say about the past and if you think about that meaning of History then it's always about the prison as well uh the present concerns are always reflected and this is a fundamental uh tenet of historiography as well right the reason the reason that we can look at tacitus and analyze them in the way that we can is because we know that tacitus was a product of his time and a lot of what he's saying reflects his time period and the things he specifically is concerned about the mission um and that sort of thing uh and so similarly for us like when some when a cultural product is made in the modern day whatever it talks about be it history or modern politics or like sci-fi it's always talking to Something in the present moment um and so that is uh something you just see all over the place as soon as you
start thinking about it like and as soon as you have some historical knowledge of the way things could have been represented in a different way that might be more authentic to the sources um as we interpret them today but when it's represented it's it's not necessarily concerned with that as much as as it's concerned with whatever particular topic the focus is um I feel like I want to give a specific example uh but maybe going back to Hades again um the way that Hades is interested in queer relationships is something that is specific to the modern day I mean not specific to the Monday but it's something that's very present in the modern day right and so that comes out in the game because that's an interest of the game developers and the game designers and the community that they're talking to that's really interesting so you in addition to being someone who analyzes games you're also somebody who designs games so what sorts of designs are you working on and are you doing them for a hobby context or for a classroom um yeah most of my games I mean in the same way that I uh mentioned before that I think of all games as being sort of worthy of analysis I don't make games just for classroom environments um I make games that I want well I mean like most game designers I want games I
make games that I want to play uh or because I have some particular desire or something that I think is missing from something right I see a niche or um as is the a popular um saying at least amongst role-playing Gamers that sometimes role-playing game designers that sometimes you design games out of spite because you see a game that doesn't do what you want it to do and you're like no I wanted to do this other thing I will make the game then that does this other thing um so none of the games that I made have been sort of strictly well let me rephrase that all of the games that I've made I make with an I2 somebody who is not a classicist playing them and that's very easy to see for most of my games because most of my games aren't at all about the ancient world um sometimes they're about uh I mean my game to sprawl which is a cyberpunk game is sort of fundamentally about um ideologies of neo-capitalism and how um the way the system sort of traps you in its in its workings that's not unrelated to my interest in the way that ideologies work in the ancient world and the way that systems of power work historically um but it's it's very different in a lot of ways um my game about I have a I have a board game that I'm working on about the Romano parthian Borderland that I designed for a classroom context but one of my design goals uh was that I wanted it to be generally appealing beyond that
because my publication goals for that game don't include are not restricted to classroom environments I'm not going to pitch that as a as an educational game although it probably will get pitched as a game that was written by a historian who is a specialist in the period but that's a slightly different thing if that makes sense indeed it is yes and you also mentioned that you got a ttrpg that's like a Mythos plus Rome um thing I want to hear about this yeah so this sort of um this is a game I'm working on with a colleague here uh a non-classicist colleague uh about the Roman world um it's sort of like a mashup of yeah Cthulhu Mythos stuff and and Roman's social history stuff that I don't see represented in games very well um so there's lots of one of the things that I that I uh have an interest in is Roman religion and the way that Roman religion is represented um in games is often considerably filtered through a sort of christianizing lens um and this is something about the way that religion is represented ancient religion is represented more widely right the structures that we think about religion often come from a Christian lens at least in um the sort of anglo-american world
um and it's something that I there are there are a few other games that are set in the Roman world but none of them really do what I want them to do in terms of highlighting things that are based on sort of up-to-date historical knowledge rather than somebody who likes Rome and went to school 20 years ago using textbooks that were 20 years old and now has is regurgitating a version of Rome that looks more like what we see in Gladiator than what I would see in us academic work that I look at today um so what aspects of Roman religion have particularly caught your interest and you know made it so far into this game um uh
I think one of the things that is not well conveyed by other work that I've seen in other design work that I've seen in the space is the kind of um ritual approach to religious activity um and a attention to the way that practice is more important than belief in many ways and that's not to say that belief is not important in the ancient world um it certainly is it's just much harder to see because people don't necessarily talk about it in the same way as they do talk about religious practices but it is something that when you talk about religion in the modern world people will often start immediately going into talking about belief and if Romans were talking about religion they're never talking about belief they are immediately going to practice um and so that distinction I think is something that that I want to bring out um and it's going to be it's going to be hard to explain in the text but that's also part of my role as a designer and part of why this is a game design project rather than a setting project because you can't just put that on top of something because if you just put that on top of an existing system you have to convey all of that in words and that is not going to be embedded in the system but if you come at it from a design perspective then you can embed all of that into the system itself so that when the player is engage with the mechanics
they are doing the thing that they need to do to engage with the um the historical material how apt apps gonna you know the main concept of Roman religion that I think a lot of people at least take one class on It Come Away with is that it is embedded the reason that we don't talk about belief when we talk about religion is that it's so taken for granted that it's really more a thing you do as opposed to a thing that you dwell on um but the things that you do in Roman religion are also so varied like you can have some sort of like creepy deifia Falcon and milk you can have like a flirtatious let me write on an apple and like toss it into my lover's lap and like wink a little bit um you know oh let me uh make a sacrifice but is it like a black animal and there's blood everywhere where the cemetery you know or are we doing something that's like uh a big public feast day and we're all gonna eat this barbecue after we sacrifice it and check the liver of course to make sure it's good so like what what range of activities are you trying to fit into this game and um where are you cutting yourself off since not everything can make it into a game yeah um so I will be will we including so I think the stuff that will be mechanized will be more about the processes behind sort of all of those things that you just mentioned because there are certain commonalities and one of the things that we can try and get across is that there'll be slight variations with all of this and
that's a benefit to us as designers in that we don't know everything about every ritual practice so if we design a system that allows you at the table to change it slightly the important thing is doing what you're supposed to be doing properly not exactly what you're supposed to be doing um so the game is going to be using or is using the powered by the apocalypse system so there's lots of ways that you can include like kind of lists of components that a ritual might have or lists of things that the the player should consider when they're thinking about what the ritual needs to have or what the uh what the um Master of Ceremonies needs to be thinking about in the case of rituals that they might come up with that the players might need to do to to dispel whatever great evil is threatening things um so all of those things hopefully will be able to be encompassed within the system that we're working on that structures the way the structure works rather than the specific details and then all of that stuff can be specific examples that we give as examples of the variety this the wide variety of potential approaches to it um yeah we'll see how successful it is I believe and then okay so that makes me wonder
virtual two kind of a Cthulhu Mythos and then what changes do you have to make to what the Romans have left us to make that work um yeah so the way that we're structuring this at the moment the because one of the things that I want to avoid is the kind of quote-unquote Barbarian like strain of thought like there's a very it's very Roman right to paint the outsider as other and Barbarian and I want to not not do that right the game is not about like oh the Roman gods are true and good and those Germanic gods are nasty and trained in the world or something like that right it's not it's not uh taking that perspective um at all so trying to I mean one of the things that we're that I'm thinking about is the way that we can use the fact that so much Roman in Greek literature is fragmentary um fits in very well with the kind of Call of Cthulhu like oh you find a partial note kind of thing um and the fact that we know about so many books that existed that we just do not have any evidence of except a title um and working with that kind of thing which is very similar to the way that um I call it Cthulhu will present itself or a Mythos game or present itself so trying to work with those and make sure that we have embedded in the in the text uh enough guidance to
differentiate things that are historical real world religious activities from the the Mythos stuff as existing like beyond that um so that the players can be appealing to their gods wherever they are whether it be they Gauls or syrians or Romans or Greeks and that's all just as valid and maybe all just as useless against whatever Cosmic horror is beyond yeah I sort of feel like this is like the Epicurean God turns its eye on you and you wish it had never cared yeah yeah that's a good way of looking at it actually yeah well I mean yeah and I think there's something to be done I don't we haven't done this so that may well be end up being in the game but you could probably look at all of the ancient philosophies that way as well like maybe the maybe the cosmic horror is the uh stoic conflagration right I mean I feel like you could just make it work right yeah totally yeah yeah I mean there's so much stuff like that all through I mean this is like any Rich historical topic there's going to be a ton of things that you can that you can find to work with any number of games and I think the way that there is so much unknown in the ancient world and I'm not talking about like spooky Superman natural unknown necessarily although the Romans didn't really have lots of stories about that but just things that gaps in our historical knowledge that are not actually suspicious or um or spooky but can be flavored in that way yeah well we're forever cursed by Lacuna we'll just oh yeah well blessed
so you mentioned that you overtly wanted to make this as Roman religionee as possible and kind of get it away from the Christian lens that we're constantly looking through I however I say this is like a person who is culturally but not spiritually Christian I think is probably like the best description of me and you know I went and got the went and got the doctor so I could like to go all the way down that rabbit hole how do you detach your understanding of Roman religion from your modern kind of christianized sensibilities and like I don't know that maybe that's that would ever be a fully successful project for anybody but what are you doing to try to like break and like what does that mean needs to be broken away I mean I think the main thing that uh the main way to to make that break is by trying to read the sources as closely and as uh carefully as you can with attention to what they are saying um and trying whenever possible to examine your own uh your own assumptions regarding the text um and I think this is something that uh teaching is good for as well because your students will often come up with questions that will cause you to re-examine something that you might have thought about the text and hopefully in the classroom we are also having the
students like challenge their assumptions um because there's so many assumptions about the ancient world that's one of the things that reception studies is kind of about and so thinking about thinking explicitly about what those are and then examining them and sometimes those assumptions you might examine them and think no actually I do do still agree with this and sometimes you might think well I didn't even well what about this other completely different option and sometimes that's a rabbit hole that leads nowhere and sometimes that is actually a productive line of inquiry um but like carefully reading sources and taking them seriously like what is the source saying why is the source saying it what does it mean by this what sort of context is it part of um and this is the I mean this is really the only way you can do it because we can never totally separate ourselves from our context but we can try to engage with the sources that we're reading in as serious a way as possible and to put them in their own context and to try to make that separation as much as we can yeah I mean history it's a topic it's a subject but I don't know I like to think of it as a practice um it's the the doing of it I guess is the value and like speaking of that I want to talk about the parthians some more now we've had a little bit of discussion about Barbarians in the context of your RPG um what are you trying to achieve with your parthens game and how mechanically are you doing it yeah okay so my parthian game is about it's about the Romano parthian Borderlands so it's about the places
between the Tigers and the Euphrates um particularly Northern Mesopotamia so uh cities like Odessa and nisibus and Karai um uh hatra um these are some of these other cities there if you have never studied the Roman near East you may have never heard of uh and they don't necessarily Exist by those names anymore but if you look at a map of the intersection of turkey and Syria and Iraq then that's that's the zone between those two rivers and so in the game you play as one of those kingdoms one of those little Borderland kingdoms um that is nominally a kingdom a subordinate Kingdom of the parthian Empire at the start of the game and then the game proceeds through a number of turns and in each each turn represents uh a quarter of a century and there's sort of like random cards that come out that show what is happening in the Roman world and what is happening in the parthian world and those things you and the as the players in the Borderlands see those things so you observe the events that are happening within the big Empires you can't affect them those things happen you decide what you're going to do in your area knowing that these things are happening and then these things happen to you or some sub-variant of them happen to you so it's sort of about the way their existence in a Borderlands situation like this is precarious and contingent on the activities of the empires you don't necessarily get to change what these what's happening to
you you just have to sort of Wither the waves of history and Invasion and various Roman emperors coming charging down the Euphrates uh and and try and make the best you can while also sort of competing with your fellow other kings in the area to I guess um come out on top in some way the victory Point mechanic is called Prestige so it is really about like um being able to say that you were more important no matter who you're now living under like whatever what you can gather for yourself essentially in a hostile environment oh that's really interesting so you know I feel like um I think this is because I'm trained as a classicist I'm not an expert on on Parthia um it feels to me like the Roman emperors get for good or ill right a lot of Personality like you at least know some sort of detail like this is the this this guy had an earring this one was over seven feet tall you know you learn things about it like do the parthians historically have personality that is given to them by any of the sources and if not did you inject some into the game out of like a sense of fairness to answer this uh in Reverse um the neither the Emperors nor the parthian Kings have much personality in the game um some of the events are labeled as being the wars of particular Emperors but that's more for sort of like for as a thing that players can like hook on to
like oh I know about trajan's Invasion oh this is this is the car that represents that oh cool um but there's the problem with studying the pantheons is that they didn't leave their own written records and it's their own written records of the Roman world it's the Romans written records of their world that uh give us all the personality uh for these Emperors so people like swaytonius or um like Plutarch less about Pluto's list about Emperors um uh Cassius Dio about the um the severins the uh very problematic Historia Augusta is always good for giving a bit of Personality even if it's very questionable but there's this whole tradition in Roman literature of personalizing the Emperors in a way I don't think they'd characterize it as that necessarily um but that's sort of what it's doing so these these Emperors all have a character so when we as you say when we we talk about like Nero that brings something to mind yeah whereas someone like method is the second uh you might know him as a uh like a famous conqueror and you might know some dates of things that he's he's conquered in some places and blah blah blah but you probably don't have any insight into his personality because that's just not what the sources give us um a lot of what we know about the parthian world either comes from Greco-Roman sources who are often the enemy of the parthians and so are somewhat hostile or it comes from coin evidence to establish chronologies or it comes from material culture there are some inscriptions that give a sense of
um Imperial imagery but it's hard to get personality out of an inscription that's talking about how great someone is because they all talk about how great somebody is and they're all sort of the same in a lot of ways um so yeah that's uh that's the situation there so basically in order to you have to kind of towards that way of telling history in order to kind of give them their due and even the playing field yeah if I was gonna make it hmm does this so this game is specifically about like the the Borderland kingdoms between the two so both the parthians and the Romans are sort of like a force of nature right it doesn't really do much here if I was going to try and make a game about the parthians I yeah I I guess I would have to start from a hmm I mean I guess it would be more of a it might be more of a it might be more wargamy or a bit more just a bit more detached from the personality layer I mean there's plenty of ways you could do that um even something like uh time of Crisis the GMT game um doesn't really have personality for those people like he gets across a lot about the third Century period but it doesn't have doesn't doesn't give those counters personality um so it might be something like that I'm not sure what the what the specific thing like I haven't I haven't been uh compelled to make a game about the party anyway yet so
that's true so not that you would I feel like it's very hard to get outside of ourselves but if somebody was going to look at the games that you're making and try to understand you through your history uh what would they conclude it's a really good question because I have a game about um I hit the scroll this game about cyberpunk capitalism and all that stuff and it's sort of like a I think I think the uh more ideological parts of it are sometimes a little bit obscured by the fact that it sort of does what like a shadow run or a cyberpunk 2020 does like it operates in that same mold um and so there's that and then I have dinosaur princesses which is a game about cooperation and it's a coloring book as well and that's like a radical departure and I have a game about crowd of fire gear which is about mutant cannibals eating each other to gain power uh and I have a game called the David Webb which came out last year which is basically about Paul greengrass's filmography or cinematography of the Bourne movies so it's about like being a camera guy watching things happen um and then I have this Roman game so I don't know I don't know what you make it there it's a it'll be a tough puzzle for a future historian I guess fortunately I've talked on podcasts a lot about these the game so maybe maybe they'll have all that extra power textural information no I've actually thought about how much fun
it would be to get some Miniatures from board games and find an archaeologist who doesn't play them and then ask them to interpret this uh this has ritual purpose we'll think that one day I mean that plastic's gonna Outlast us yeah uh and then one more serious question I mean I guess one of my questions are for that series but uh if somebody's if somebody's gonna play a game about Roman history tonight um and you want to help them have like a more intellectually satisfying experience as they do so what are some things that they should pay close attention to in order to maximize their their understanding and appreciation of that game oh that's tricky it's so much of a how much do they know and what are they interested in kind of Christian um I guess that I would maybe it just is a baseline encourage them not to think about um whether it gets specific particular things correct and to try and move away from that and think about what feeling is it trying to convey about the historical world and this sort of yeah I mean for more on that listen to your interview with Kate Cook who goes through this stuff about like authenticity and uh and accuracy and that like in other people I think that you've spoken to you've had that
conversation a few times that's definitely like a big that's probably the number one thing that I want people to to take away right that you can you can nitpick historical things but weird as they get you because how accurate is this game is a question that will be asked of me many times like how accurate is Assassin's Creed it's like well not very but a little bit and then the Christian is like we're and it's the same about movies like Herrick you're just Gladiator the character is wrong the TV show I mean the answer is always like like a little bit or somewhat yeah and it's sort of we're on that scale of like somewhat is it mostly not mostly yes like there are some things that are accurate and some things are not and the thing to think about is like why did they choose why did the game make it or the movie maker or the TV show maker choose to be accurate in the places they chose to be accurate like why did they decide that this was the thing they wanted to get right and this was something they didn't and does that tell you anything about the game or the game maker or what have you so yeah yeah yeah I feel like a long ways you know fiction is like this too right fiction doesn't have to be true to be true if that makes sense um and so I guess maybe akin to that is what who did the maker put at the center of their world yeah their version of this world and what what motivations did they give to the people to Center I mean you know who's important and what do they want yeah and is that is it is
that a modern desire or is it an attempt at finding an ancient one yeah I think it's the same for fiction I think it's the same for uh games I think it's the same for history as well like who does Tessa just put at the scene of his story and what does that say about what he's he's trying to say who does who does swaytonius put at the center who does Olivia put at the center of his episodes um all of these things uh same as like who did Rick Riordan put at the center and what does that say about like what argument he's trying to make um whether that's an implicit or an explicit argument um because that's one of the other things I guess that games are seldom going to explicitly tell you what their argument is just like tacitus actually is not going to specifically tell you what his argument is he's going to convince you of what he wants you to think by doing it and then maybe you'll notice it and maybe you won't uh and if you don't it doesn't matter because he's convinced you of the thing that's what he's trying to do and so that can work for games as well just maybe on a less I don't know the way I just put it there sounds very cynical from Tessa's perspective which is maybe how I think about this um but and I I don't think Jason just would disagree actually that he's he has a somewhat cynical approach oh yeah well I think that everybody's got a point to make they just don't always realize it it's just a matter of how explicit is it yeah no I agree and it's it is not even necessarily a point to make just something that does come across because of their context and their background yeah which is fundament functionally the
same thing so uh in terms of safety questions what are you playing for fun right now uh I am playing a lot of spirit Island um I'm in this enormous 68 player play by post Spirit Island game um which is fantastic and also something you could think about historically although I haven't really um and I am playing I'm sort of play testing my Mythos game um uh which currently has the name nephos um and yeah and I'm also play testing another game by a New Zealand designer about the late Roman um late Roman Empire called Fortuna um which we just started uh last week with session zero and so that's uh that's looking cool too um so yeah a couple of couple of Roman role-playing games which I actually don't usually play historical Roman games um in the room designing one and playing in another well I always worry about like being the guy who's like well this isn't actually how it happened um which I do a little bit but I have to like claim that down but less than I might have worried I think if I was playing these games before I started thinking about games AS Scholarship I would probably be far more of a of a back seat back seat historical GM which I desperately want to not do because that's not fun unless it is I guess this is fun for everybody else if it's
fun for everybody else if everybody else is here for our rants about what this game gets wrong then that's one thing but I don't want to inflict that on a group fair enough and if people want to hear your rants cranky or otherwise okay yeah the people who want to follow your work uh where can you be found online uh I'm currently still on um Twitter uh at Peregrine kiwi um I am on various other places uh as that as well um and my website is ourdens.org and that's where I have some game stuff fantastic oh and I guess my Humanity's common site as well has my academic stuff you can just Google my name with like I don't know actually what works for academic stuff uh Hamish Cameron Mesopotamia probably does it I will I will put the results of that in the show notes of links for you or something indeed oh and I of course if you're listening can be found anywhere is beyond Solitaire so hit me up internally online uh but Hamish thank you so much for coming on this has been a delightful conversation I'm really looking forward to that TT RPG actually so much stuff it's like so big already but yeah thanks Elizabeth it's been great to chat about all these things with you fantastic so if y'all want to have more nerd time uh please reach out to either of us on the internet and as uh as always please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming