Does chess suck? (replayability in games)
Transcript
so Marty do you know what really sucks what's that you depending on me to come up with these episodes yes that's correct we needed a little short episode here I've been the one tossing ideas so I threw it over to you I said Tony what would you like to discuss in our little short uh segment episode and I said does chess suck no so this is going to be a really short episode hey everybody thanks for listening and uh go follow some social media
so I will admit that this title was pure click bait on my part I know that but I've been wanting to discuss this topic for a while because of something somebody said that I saw online okay and I wanted to discuss about and it's not that chess does not suck at all so we've already answered the question so people who who listened for this part is the answer is is no so there's got to be more to this than right where did this even come from so it came from I was watching some videos on chess and I'm and fraught and thrilled and through enthralled thank you enthralled about people who you know are able to do this clock in under five minutes and you know they're out out at New York in the park playing and all these Grand Masters and somebody made a comment in one of those videos about you know there is no replayability in chess it's always the same defenses or offenses you just have to be able to recognize them and that's what the grand Masters are very good at doing now I don't know I know when we first met over in your college dorm you and your roommate had a chessboard set up and y'all would play do you still play um I I do not uh yeah what we would do is we'd have a chess board set up on the side of the room and we would just take a move and you know we'd leave and come back and we wouldn't play real time it's kind of like what we did with coin games where we take a move except we're video we're just sitting there in the room um I used to really enjoy playing chess with him I'm I'm no good
um but no I have not played in in forever but I kind of a little squirrel I it seems there has been kind of a Resurgence in the interest of chest and I know when Queen's Gambit came out on Netflix uh a lot of people were buying chess sets and stuff uh but at the um CEO fighting game championships that I went to in Daytona uh they had a big vendor Hall well one side of the hall they had a little space set up with like eight chess boards and clocks and I thought okay that's really interesting because this is a video game uh event where people are playing Street Fighter Mortal Kombat combating against each other it's all video game based and here's this little section with chess boards and there were always people sitting there playing and they were using the clocks so I mean it's not like they were like learning how to play there was nobody there there were just these random boards set up and people were sitting there playing all weekend so I thought that was really interesting that especially and this was all younger people probably in their 20s and stuff there's kind of this re-interest in chess um all of a sudden so I'm sorry for that little squirrel but it's just interesting that it seems to be perking back up again right and I mean I I'm I'm terrible at chess I I enjoy playing it I always wanted to have one of those extravagant chess sets where you know it's like the um I want the Lord of the Rings The Lord Oh The Lord of the Rings or when we were on um growing up you'd see the car um what was the commercials for the chess sets the it was the Smithsonian chess sets or something there was some you could order and you
get a piece at a time yeah I forgot about I forgot about that that's right it was like uh it wasn't necessarily Columbia house but you like you're right like once a month we'll send you a new piece and you pay monthly for that one piece yeah right and it was the Civil War sets or something like that and I know growing up so I my one of my one of my girlfriends loved playing chess and she played with her father and she would wipe the board with me she would decimate me and I was like well this is unreal I mean and she introduced me to the what is it the three move win where if somebody opens up with the pawn you're able to go in and quickly check make the king because they can't move anywhere and she recognized it and destroyed me with it well somebody had a commodore 64. and he had the chest cartridge first video games were always on chess you notice you know how that is and I got better because I would play the computer now let's bring it all the way back to the episode replayability what is replayability in board games because that was the whole discussion that chess it's the same stuff over and over and you hear this and you and I talk about this about replayability of the games that we get you know oh that didn't have any replayability or does it have replayability what is the replayability so I thought Marty let's you and I sit down and discuss what does replayability mean to us because when people hear it in our episode this will give them a baseline how you and I think about it and I will be honest with you in the 10 years we've been doing this mine's
changed tremendously okay mine has two and that's the topic I want to bring up because I I remember there was a discussion and uh basically about that how 10 years ago how we Define replayability is uh different and we can always kind of throw this back to chess because I think today's definition of rep playability does not match with what chess's replayability is okay so expand on that a little bit I want to make sure I understand so when guy I got to stop starting since this was so it's usually good so what were you going to say all right latest Kickstarter um I say oh I want to go buy this base game hey you want replayability right well here we're going to give you a solo mode oh look here's an expansion unlike this here's an expansion here's some additional cards replayability through extra things extra pieces are different variants of rules uh new boards new cards Etc that could be used in and out of the game as you go prime example uh Thunder Road uh Vendetta way different than the base game but what did they do to add some replayability you've got the different drivers you've got the different expansions that came with it right to try to increase the replayability it seems like there's a mindset now really playability means
additional modules or rule sets that every time you sit down and play you can make the game a little bit different okay all right well so I had not thought about that but then again that's not how I look at replayability but how do you how do you look at it what do you think a game is replay when when's the game replayable to you what how do you judge it personally for me personally a game is replayable for two conditions one it's just I enjoy playing it doesn't matter if I'm going through the exact same cards the same rules if I sit down and enjoy playing this game and every time I do it's replayable to me even though I may be doing the same motions which I think is what chess is chess is the exact same thing every time that you play but if you get enjoyment out of it it's replayable one other caveat replayability to me is trying to get better when I play so the more I play if I can see a a increase or a while just just lost words here if I could see myself getting better improvement over time by the more times I play that makes it replayable to me okay and see the reason why I made you go first is so I could just go ditto oh my gosh because I knew I really did I thought you might say that because that's the same for me replayability when I say a game is replayable for me that is that the game I had enjoyment
out of it that I will put it back on the table regardless of how bad I stunk or anything like that and that goes to your second point about being able to get better with it so it's not you know oh my gosh it's adding this in we're adding that in or or whatever no it is the enjoyment that I have taken away from that game because a lot of these games that are Classics or everybody loves that I don't love there's tons of replayability to them you've got an example of something oh easily easily for me uh werewolf okay you can you can play werewolf all the times because the people change even though the characters what expansions give you the ability but even the bass but if you have the bass you know you can keep doing it because your character is always changing whoever's the werewolf is always changing but for me replayability of that game is none because I don't like it so that game is not replayable for me I I have one I have nothing to do it and of course all Legacy games however you can replay a legacy game you just might be missing some components after you tore them up but that's okay so and I was actually thinking this applies to a lot of things that I enjoy doing over and over so you and I played countless games of softball together why did we keep doing it well I I know one was just enjoyment uh we gotta enjoyment the rules never changed every time we play softball it was the exact same thing we're doing the
exact same thing over and over personally for me I always try to get better hey can I get a can I get to a better my average this time can I make a better play in the field Etc so both those conditions made even Sports replayable to me if it's something I enjoy joy and I'll tell you one that I dropped because I did not enjoy it and that was golf golf got so frustrating to me I was not getting any better so for that case it was not replayable for for me so I think this applies to more than just board games and in in my situation too right but for us in the board game arena by the way I'll never be good at disc golf but I will always replay it I have not hit every tree on that course I can do it again okay that's all there is to it I have not lost all my plastic I can do I can definitely achieve that goal if I keep playing disc golf um so replayability for the board game though for me is always going to be about the enjoyment of the game now ten years ago I will admit based on what you were talking about earlier it was about how can I add to the game you know to make the game another challenge because I think about pandemic was you know always the game that we would play right sure but that didn't really change though did it I mean you could increase the difficulty but that was about I could add expansions like the also beyond the base game okay
but yeah so in the lab you know I could so that may so back then when I was playing it was okay I'm tired of playing bass pandemic I want to add in the lab but now I would just do the base game you know I I don't need all those expansions coming back in but back then it was I was always looking for to your point the definition of what is going to be a way for me to bring more enjoyment out of that game because I'm bored with it so it's not replayable anymore and I think that has changed because I to be honest with you I can't remember all the rules to the expansion so I know the base game let me go with that um so I'm good with that so I know I have tremendously changed from when we first started out when I look at you know um because uh what was a small world was it small world is that the one you hate somebody yeah that had a ton of replayability but you know what I didn't need all those factions in there now I think about it I don't need all those factions back then I would I would want to keep adding all okay adding all those factions in there so uh go with this um I'll do this one first because I remember what my other question was so does that mean that kickstarters currently now do not entice you with the additional stuff that you'll get with unlocks or pay an additional 25 and get this new module no I don't need it I I'm
not even going to do that matter of fact I I guess I look at it more like are they coming to retail because I will just go with the base game that's how I've shifted I don't how about you um man I'm all over the place now how I thought I had this clearly how I was thinking but you make a good point used to if Kickstarter came out that's like oh yeah I want that that that that oh we get this stretch goal we get the stretch goal we get the stretch goal over time I would get this stuff and never open some of the stretch goals I would never play the additional modules because I was just enjoying the base game or still trying to get through it that I didn't put enough time into the base game that I would go and open up a module so no it no longer matters to me uh but that's there so I have switched on that before I forget you talked about pandemic uh currently don't you and Donna just play the base game of Carcassonne or do you throw in expansions to keep your enjoyment up for replayability purposes we only play the bass game because she wants to get better at the base and I have expansions they didn't grab her or anything like that so I don't know why so I said you know what I don't need to buy any more expansions I've only got two there's like 532 expansions to Carcassonne now I will because I even I said okay on Carcassonne I'll even buy a different version to enhance the replayability of
Carcassonne you know Hunter and gather I bought it Donna did not like it one bit I thought she would enjoy it I've already traded that one away because it would not get replayed yep so I I don't need and that's once again I don't need that to be able to keep replaying that so I think to your as you were saying the common thing that I think a lot of people may consider now is expansions make a game replayable and I don't think it does well that's just my opinion of course no yeah uh all this is our opinion of course you'll say we have to clarify that constantly and because people just don't understand your words statement for everybody um this opinion accounts an opinion is like a butthole only yours smells good okay moving right along I like that I need to remember that okay uh so I think back to our early days of hobby gaming we had pandemic but one game that you and me and Ed and Cecil played constantly was Puerto Rico oh yeah we never included any expansions we kept playing the same base game over and over did two things for me I love sitting with you guys and playing the game because I just enjoyed that game and two I kept trying to best you guys or win or get better at it no expansion modules nothing like that and I was totally content with that back then and now that you've pointed this out to my past I do
see this part where it's like oh no I want expansions and all this I need replayability with more stuff and now I'm swinging back to you know what if I can just get enjoyment out of the base game try to get better at it that's really all I need for replayability okay but you bring up an excellent point which is beautiful segue into something else here so some games aren't replayable because one strategy always wins okay and Puerto Rico had that unless you um changed up I think it was one of the buildings people would research it and they know it and one that came to you know as I was getting ready for this I saw Russian railroads which is now I think ultimate railroads there there was a one strategy that always lets you win if you did that strategy and we talked about it with um Carson City if you use a certain expansion you know there's that strategy but I think that was just us not understanding the game very well the game you know all those games are very replayable but if there is a strategy that everybody knows that cannot be beat then I think that also hurts a game from replayability but we don't go to there I don't go to that level but some do I don't either and I remember we talked about the Puerto Rico before I never looked up what the strategy was because I didn't want to know because I remember early on in our show we were talking about Puerto Rico and somebody would say I can't believe you guys still like this game don't you know
about the way that there's just one thing that you can do with one of the buildings and I don't remember again I never researched it um so it didn't really matter and I didn't want to know because I didn't want to ever use it it's like it's one of those things if I discovered on my own great you know then then I would have done that but of course I never did um so yeah I guess if there is a game that it's like oh what this is the path you always take to win the game yeah that would definitely take it off my replayability list 100 100 because then I there's no way I can get better because it's like I just need to do this one thing now let's throw this back to chess didn't you say the grand Masters whole thing was oh well I'm gonna play the same game every time if they do this I will always do this if they do this I will always do this so does that hurt replayability for those guys or just they enjoy the game so much and trying to pick up on what those moves are that they need to counter not being a chess Aficionado I think it is that that they are trying to pick up on the strategy that they are having to face and that they are having to constantly think three moves ahead and how to adjust that strategy that's what makes that game such a challenge to master and be great at it so yeah but you're right if if you and I just sat down to play chess we're not going to know any of that we got no clue just like a lot of board games if you were to place you know Puerto Rico based Puerto Rico without any of the additional expansions or without the fix that came with it I wouldn't have a clue you wouldn't have and we would have a great time
but if we ended up playing someone who did know that then it would be a different story now I will say the one thing that I've always enjoyed we've always talked about our card games and we played many many hours of specific card games we could list them all again Lord of the Rings Netrunner Etc got massive enjoyment out of it but we did really enjoy when a new pack a new set or something came out to see hey how can I take what's here and use that and adjust it so there are times in my past and still to this day we were talking about possibly checking out the new Star Wars unlimited game or any other any other card game it would still have that appeal of replayability comes from additional packs additional cards and we've talked about this on the show too that ccgs and lcgs will live and die by that next set because people want to have that next thing and if they don't get it they do get tired of what they have so in that case you actually do need new product new cards new content to keep up the replayability of a game but it also enhances the challenges that they're facing how do I take those new cards and find out what way can break and then you gotta Nerf it and all that but yes yes that I agree with you do get for us it was always what was the next expansion that we needed to see okay that's I'm tired of I'm tired of jinteki
let me let me try this one I'll wait you know um that's just no fun I don't like the how that one plays so oh what's next for the genteky how can I use that to help go against your um group so yes I agree with you so it's it's it's somewhat kind of gray when it comes to that for me because yeah a perfect example I don't like playing gin techy and then all of a sudden the set comes out with a card and you go oh now this card I got this idea I got an idea that I want to I I want to build a gen techie deck because of this particular card that really does help with replayability but it took additional stuff additional product to keep that replayability up for me so I'm not hard and fast like the only two things are enjoyment and trying to get better at it sometimes the enjoyment is from this little extra little bonuses um so I guess so does it really all maybe it depends on the game maybe honestly depends on the game that we're playing I really can't think of a board game aside from the ones we've mentioned on our show in the past where for example Outer Rim when you play Outer Rim always use this expansion the latest unfinished business or whatever it was called there are some games where we say the expansion makes the bass better we'll never go back and play that but we'll always play it that way you know but it's not about replayability it's simply that they've they've fixed a mechanic in a game or how the game played to help make our enjoyment even more but it does help with replayability
because the the things they added in the outer rim expansion will make me want to replay that game more true true because if they didn't you wouldn't because you wouldn't be able to go from one side of the universe you'd have to slowly cross something simple like that or the other way to have another win condition or the uh the different uh Pilots that you would have that gives you the the variable win conditions which does add some variability to the game which does have playability but honestly even if we didn't have that just that one thing of being able to jump from one side to the other of the the map uh was a big help and I think we mentioned before too I'm trying to think of another example uh I won't yell it out Lorenzo elementifico the there's the expansion that came out that you kind of said I will always do this because you can randomize the board when you play it too so and make it work for me now I I cannot think of a specific mechanic or style of game or anything like that that says oh this will always achieve for playability for me like oh dice will always make it be replayable or any of those you know worker placements and how they put out the cards or anything like that you know worker placement always means replayability that does not matter I mean I know I've got it in our show notes is there one but I cannot think of anything that says okay this means replayability it's not because it comes once again back to how am I going to get it out there and if the mechanic regardless I could say Oh look The Dice
really made this game great for replayability oh in this game it made it stink it made it suck you know so I think um from my side I don't see a particular mechanic or style that says hey you know guess what yeah a game has to be this to be replayable I don't think that exists when you posted that for something to think about before recorded I couldn't come up with anything either and honestly it still came down to am I enjoying it and do I want to play to try to get better regardless of what the mechanisms or the board game is and again that's where I started thinking of oh crap that's that's sports that's me going out and trying to get better for example a disc golf or something like that if if I wasn't enjoying it then I would never do it but if I did but you had you had some points you said um I think that's more important to me than next was trying to get necessarily get better because I remember you say this all the time every time you play Tera mystica you say I will play this game but I suck at it so you at least will sit down and then play and try to enjoy it but it's not necessarily that I'm gonna try to get better but you so that's an example of that but you have said games in the past or the past 10 years where you say I want to play this again to try to get better at it you do make that comment a lot yes I do and case in point that a game I will not play Ragusa one of your favors all-time favorites you know you love that game that game was not very enjoyable for me
but it is according to y'all it has incredible replayability from the enjoyment but at what stuck in my brain was that because I couldn't do certain things to stay in touch with y'all or I didn't understand the mechanics I've felt that it was not and back then it was not replayable because that's the only way you could win you know that got stuck in my brain you got can only play to win this game if that happened and it was frustrating to me and I said that's it I'm done it's not replayable for me but it's not that it was just enjoyment it's yeah it's funny it's actually going to come down to something as simple as that isn't it replayability just comes from enjoyment even even if you knew that you were played regusa 10 times and every time you play you knew you would get better if you didn't enjoy it that's not enough reason right uh now it's funny now that we've gone 26 minutes I mean it really comes down do I enjoy playing the game yeah wow I hear what's going to try to be all heady and everything like that and come up these multiple conditions to say what were playable replayability means to me literally it's do I enjoy doing it I mean when we play in our game group we can have one of the worst board games on the table and I'll I'll say this but if we are trash talking and having a great time we may not play it again but it was fun but then we would throw
in that's not we're not going to play that again because it was just so bad even though we had a great time the game itself wasn't fun um even though we had we had a blast that's a good point so it's not necessarily okay let me get okay then I'll caveat that with a game I enjoy a game that I enjoy playing I think with all of us regardless of how bad the game is I think we'll have fun just because the people sitting around table and I probably everybody has that group that group of people if a dud is on the table if you got friends to play with and have some fun with even though the game might have stunk you might still had a good time but not because of the game but because of who's at the table so my replayability I will still come back to it's got to be what's on the table that I'm enjoying doing too to make me want to play that game again because I know regardless of what I throw on the table with my friends I'll have a good time right and so for me social deduction gains your enjoyment might just be watching me become frustrated and see how quickly I can get out of a game 100 and I will always try to do that that will make that game enjoyable for me is that how quickly can I eliminate myself you know and that will make it unenjoyable for others probably because of how I'm acting because I know how much I am not a fan of those games so I mean when it comes down to it if if there are certain game yes there are certain game types that I know I'm not going to enjoy and we all feel this way and we're like you know what I it's like Donna if I put on the table some big game with a whole bunch of little chits
and dice and maps and she's going to be like you you know right now we're we're really getting into our coin games and things along that nature there's no way absolutely no way she's going to enjoy it but I go baby it's got tiles but they're only this big she's like no I'm not going to enjoy that so you know I'm going to enjoy it they're going to be replayable and I completely know where I'm not I don't have a clue where I'm going with this this train has derailed around I'm just going to leave it at that we're so enjoyable if it's a game is enjoyable that is for me and how I if I go hey this game was enjoyable on rolling Dice and taking names from Tony's opinion I'm saying I really had a good time with it I really enjoyed how the mechanics came together regardless of you know is there a certain strategy or something like that that is what I'm talking about from replayability it is not all the expansions it is not all the stuff that comes with it um Thunder Road Vendetta you brought that up earlier had a blast playing that with uh Mark and Bert I put it on a table with Donna and a couple of people it was not it will not ever be replayed with her wow and and and because the people who we played with it wasn't well she said it wasn't a game it was the fact that they it was a husband and wife against a husband and wife and they teamed up against us and that made it unenjoyable she was always trying to help out her husband
and that's that makes the game unenjoyable yep yep it does and going back I guess all the way to the beginning does chess suck for some people it may now if there's if it's not an enjoyable experience for you then then it's going to suck but it has nothing to do with the game uh I think any game that we've mentioned you mentioned you do not care for werewolf you think werewolf sucks but many people don't so it really has nothing to do with the game itself unless it's just some really bad game but typically that's that's just not the case anymore most games are playable easily by a lot of people so does chess suck for you it may for most it doesn't no I can't say it for most for many it doesn't I can't say that because a lot of people just may not might not like playing it but I think that would apply to to every game and the only way that game is going to get back on the table is if it's something that you really enjoy