Skip to main content
Loading video...

War of the Ring The Card Game & Against the Shadow - TCbH Reviews

Transcript 8:30

the Lord of the Rings looms large in the tabletop gaming space you got the one ring still making big numbers in the RPG realm you got kenia's Cooperative Lord of the Rings being so influential that it spawned two new branches of the Box board game Hobby in spite of its insistence that fatty buer is somehow an acceptable fifth player character War the ring is so baller that it's long held a spot as one of the top 10 greatest board games of all time on BGG and real ogs are going to remember collecting Middle Earth during the ccg boom of the early 90s even if the sum total of actual human beings that learned how to play the game is zero and that's all fine and well but in this crowded Market of Hobbits and harf foots it could be hard to set yourself apart especially if you use a title that's already been used a billion times but 2022 saw the release of the war of the Ring the card game designed by Ian Brody the card game is faithful to the journey and aesthetic of the iconic board game if not much else up to four players control the two teams of free people versus Shadow typically running nine rounds that stage simultaneous narrative Battlegrounds one a literal uh Battleground representing iconic military conflicts from the story the other one of three possible paths that the ring bearer and Company Journey for this chapter from there players take

turns playing characters items and events to the locations which often is like a game of gondorian chicken trying to go your opponent into depleting their resources to commit to one or another while there are plenty of effects in each of the decks most conflicts end with players passing than a comparison of strength defense and wounds which impacts who claims the location for points and what characters die rather than going to the recycling pile for later use Boromir no oh n oh well what makes this such a compelling and contentious puzzle is the card constraint and Cycle System see unlike most card games there's no recurring production of resources and varying cost from each card you play see to play any card from your hand you must take another card and put it into your cycle pile a separate recurring discard pile that can be refreshed when your deck is depleted and then you can put that card into play either onto a path a Battlefield or in reserve or in the case of an event just resolving its effects fortunately this ties in really nicely with the game's theme both the original and the card game are very conscientious and trying to uh Faithfully portray the overall progression of tolkien's story starting at the humble beginnings with the hobbits departing the Shire while conflicts between light and Shadow are waged on many fronts this means most notable named characters have limitations on what stage of the game they can join the path and affiliations

dictating which battles they can participate in the result is a heavily thematic and contentious albeit not particularly combative area control game that's far more deterministic than the dice of its forbearer but with so many unique characters items equipment and events there's plenty of room for epic turns surprise outcomes and devious plays as someone who admires more than loves the war of the Ring this more contemplative pace of gameplay is more my thing though the game is not without its rough edges as with big brother it's a team game of two sides up to four players with factions split between two players on each team which in the board game makes consolidation for a head-to-head game a cinch but here you either play two-handed which is never a great time or combine your decks together and modify a couple of rules which works mostly great and is my preferred way to play but loses some of the deck's synergistic Edge also there are fewer exterior levers to pull the Dual progression of paths and battles with some cards straddling each is super cool but one of the dopest things about wour is rallying the varying factions into war in the first place the sense of grand diplomacy as a third pillar of the story alongside the war and personal journey is lost in either case with the release of against the shadow you can now journey to Mordor cooperative or on your own essentially boiling down to replacement cards for the entire Shadow

player's deck and some locations to Kit out the baddy side for automation against the shadow leaves the good little Hobbits of the world to play exactly the same whereas the evil automated player let's call him the soron maton populates a reserve and deploys cards to the path and battles based on a flowchart initially as dizzying as the depths of Moria seriously I played so so many board games so many solitire implementations of board games and wrapping my brain around this was initially very tough but with hardw in gumption it makes a decent amount of sense well functional sense essentially only playing and placing cards it's capable at deploying if it would eventually win given its opponent's your current standing most situations are accounted for but more often the most solo games you run into two or more equally valid plays and the tiebreaker is up to you this game sees that as a feature rather than some arborian bug asking you to make the most strategically beneficial decision for yourself overall I think the automation is clunky at best and more often than not is contradictory to the typical flow of the normal game the mechanical Mordor often finds itself making plays that a human player never would and especially early in the game has an overwhelming amount of cards in the reserve and solid play means exploiting what feels like

unintended behavioral patterns like getting them to deploy all of their Nas goul as early as possible forsaking some of the early paths in combat just so you can get out there and inflict death upon those getting them out of their deck and leaving them virtually defenseless when it comes to the later stages of the game if it were included in the base game to make it solo capable from the get-go I'd be more accepting maybe not thinking it's great but more accepting overall as something that you got to buy I just wish it were more fluid or let you play as all the factions or better yet giving you more interesting ways to play out the game and to make up for some of those thematic holes that are missing from the original maybe this was the opportunity to include that diplomacy rallying the r herim or lighting the beacons of Gondor but as it stands this is the only official solo mode for the game we got and I guess the ability to do some Cooperative questing during date night is a nice perk to have though I don't think that I'd recommend getting the warther in the card game and this expansion if this is the only way you intend on playing the game there's just better options out there however if you are playing the multiplayer competitive

game the war the ring the card game is great there's something a bit limited a bit restrictive given that we live in a world where most card games have a million different decks to mix and match but what's nice is the game feels cohesive thoughtful boldly thematic and deliberate and if more game designs valued that then the world would be a merrier place indeed and that's our review but let me know what is your favorite Tolan game your favorite Lord of the Rings or The Hobbit or maybe even s rillian games I got to look into what sort of expanded universe game is out there and what is your favorite Story by the legend himself put it in the comments and as always thanks for watching thanks for supporting it thanks for being such a great Community you know that I've been Jack for the cardboard Herald

Progress saved