Petrichor - Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games unlocked and we're doing a no run through review for petrichor uh this is actually going to be just over the base game um not the flowers expansion not the cows expansion not the honeybee expansion because i would rather put three bullets in my brain than even test this out with any of those expansions uh i despise this game it is so frustrating uh for many many reasons uh but while i cool off uh let's have you guys talk about the uh the the positives what do you guys think that is good about petrichor the art quality is nice that was literally going to be my first streak that was our thing within too deep it's pretty it's a that was it it's a mirthful theme it's a light it is a very unique theme it's light in theme uh its gameplay does not match its theme right which is kind of positive build quality seems excellent nice storage yeah very good uh yeah game tray insert uh everything fits in nothing too weird virtually everything except the game yeah so um in case anyone mentions oh you like the expansions fix all that for seven years as long as i've been on this channel i've always said that expansions shouldn't need to fix games they should
enhance games so if it's like oh no that was a big problem in the base game if you play with the honeybee expand no no because that means i have to give more money to the company on something i already dislike right so um so that that argument's already out the window all right uh let's let's see i i really can't think of of a positive um in terms of gameplay because i hate how it plays like i guess i guess a variety in tiles is is good i like the different scoring aspects of the different tiles yep but that also comes with a negative of well every one of them is how do i screw you you're right i can get some points right or i can just screw you right either way right and the game's too long like like you could attribute this same type of cutthroat area control nature to smash up and i love smash up but smash up is over like that it's like first one i think 15 30 minutes yeah um but you also have the variety of card combos you have ways to counteract what other people do this one it's like where am i in turn order oh i'm last okay yep i'll just watch you guys [ __ ] me in every way and i can't do a single thing about it right um yeah even your last second your last ditch effort of well i'm just gonna pass with all these cards yeah to force you guys to only do one more thing because if you do more you're going to hurt me more right i mean because that was the thing it's like i'm sitting here like every action that
everyone takes in this game is not what how do i gain from this it's how do i [ __ ] over these other players right not in a way that benefits me unless your way of thinking is hurting them benefits me just that action alone yeah and it's like so people who like that aspect people who like hitting each other as a game like like for game mechanics hate drafting that's this is this is hate drafting the game this is a game that you want to play with your enemies right because it's not so much hate drafting in your cards obviously you don't draft your cards right but and it's because it's not drafting but it's more of the idea that how can i subtract points from an opponent because their loss of points is my gain appointment right yeah it's like i'm not gaining points this round so the only way i can catch up is to cause them to lose points right and i despise like that way of playing if i'm drafting cards in seven wonders and let's say even if you're going for a science build and you getting a science card is super good for you me taking that science away from you and i don't get anything from it doesn't that's not the way i play some people love that they think oh that no that is a benefit for me it's like but you don't inherently gain anything um so like if we're playing seven wonders again and and it's like oh me taking military yeah it stops you from getting stronger well i'm also gaining more military right so now i can compete against that and it's like oh actually now that i have more
military i beat the person to my left i'm not beating you but at least i'm beating them this game from has none of that it's every single action i took like every single harvest every single wind dumbass weather event was not i don't think i gained anything from it except there was one time where i was like oh actually i can just pop over here and get eight points and it's like or it can cause both of us to gain eight points but even that's frustrating because i'm not catching up to you it's not even that you you gained eight points but really i also gained eight points right you took away was i was gonna get 12 points yes and which actually caused you to lose right um so that and brett you know taking that one last spot actually caused him to win right because he he maxed out he didn't need the three spaces he was going to tie with but i did right right and he also gained the the second wheat which is 12 points so there were way too many varieties and things to think about um for my own play that i went forward to the strategy of i'm just going to do everything i can to get these bonus points oh yeah and i did yeah but uh i really didn't worry about anything else i had zero points the first what three rounds yeah yeah yeah and think about that is such a drastic jump like from like from you at 15 he got literally like 21 more points right three spaces just for having one more vote right like
it's like which that wasn't even in my mind at the time i wasn't even trying to gain those majorities i know yeah i was trying to get one more spot over oh and by the way it coincidentally gives me 50 more points right right i wouldn't i knew i would want more of these right right i didn't realize that that would break it too yeah so like i went from far last place you were in 39 and you gained 30 uh yeah so you literally went all the way up to 75 points but counterpoint to it is also so i went up two spots i went from six to 15 points so i went 11 points in my one round just by having the joy and i saw that it's like okay this is last last round so all there are popping so that means all majorities now matter so i went and like okay i need to tie here and i need a tie here and i need a tie here yeah just to try that could have all changed how they not passed at the last round like i could have like i had uh six cards right and i was like you know what maybe i'm just gonna see how this works like i'm gonna see how forcing them to only do one more action see how that pans out for me uh and i didn't um and then one action later that it needed to be right but even then it's like okay then i could like the more i'm doing the more you guys are also doing right so this ends up being one of those games for you if you're i just i i i hate the card synergy um because like you were saying this is an area control kind of euro game card game um area control with water droplets i love the theme by the way that's like the highest the best thing i it's so weird but
the there's so much random and pointless actions that it becomes extremely frustrating because the euro game is supposed to be clean smooth and like here's here's like here's the engine that i can do well there's no engine in this right and literally there was a round it was after our first harvest um where no no no it was after a harvest where i had no presence on the board and i was like you know what that's fine didn't get a single winter card right so that in and of itself already sets me behind you guys right so i'm like okay well uh the three other [ __ ] cards i can't do anything with right so and i mean it could have been a lot worse if you couldn't substitute two cards for it for another action so at least they have that but the frustrating part is like you guys are doing one action at a time hand management whereas i'm like oh i have to burn two so that's two actions i'm not gonna get to do just to get one stupid [ __ ] water droplet out and then that could all be undone by you when you guys playing a win and just merging with it and then you just start moving my stuff so then i'm like why am i playing what am i doing here now i will say while all those are negatives if you look at the point spread it's not far no i mean and so and then and we alter the ready to get right to get to almost the same point right and so literally like the point spread actually could have been stopped if i didn't pass because i probably could have broken a tie on one of those events
just to move up i mean that in and of itself gives me seven more points which would have passed you right um it's not that this game is unbalanced right it's just it's [ __ ] you the game right but they mask it with clouds well to be fair which i guess rain is always an inconvenience so playing this game is an inconvenience to me for a different perspective i never want i don't believe that i ever once had the intention of screwing either of you or seeing what i could do to reduce your points i was always trying to do what was best for me right it just ended up screwing you yeah because that's how that's that that's how the game is played like so i didn't either but i saw most the ways like okay if i do this there were times where like i thought about okay if i take seth's piece off there i screw him so he's forced to put back in but then i thought but it also then goes to four so seth's like i don't care anymore right nobody nobody benefits from it right that's the thing is like you doing that in terms of the winter or the the wind event you wasted your turn right trying to you know maximize somewhere else you moving me out in the hopes that i don't move back in and all i go is no i'll go back in right and then we'll get five points and i mean there's multiple times like okay so i knew i had five here i have one droplet here it wasn't gonna help so if seth wanted to mess me up he could so i just moved one in so that was my only yeah that was my only hope right was oh
there's five there maybe he won't see it and i'll just move him out right and then it won't harvest right um but that's another thing this game immediately becomes um you know uh because brett could have seen that and been like because i think you moved over here i think um brett could have been like oh actually yeah i'm gonna move that one out and then that forces you to move one then i go in and just move you out the equally good plan would have been doing exactly what seth did which was moved that one droplet in the middle of nowhere up yeah and then we basically said guaranteed it's only happened right yeah i mean if you had knocked me down four points then i would no longer have one right oh right right yeah so it's like but everything every action you do and this is why this game is so frustrating it's like i i can do the area control i can do you know the the smash up style points that's all fine but it's always at the cost of someone else and i and i don't see i don't gain anything out of it yeah and there should be more more like fire and aged weapons it doesn't fit the beautiful nature theme so and the thing is it's it is very disjointed yeah so you have three cards that basically are all about you mm-hmm and then it's wind and when's what [ __ ] up everything else and so it's like like sun doesn't you know scorch like during this you know for the weather event it's not scorching it doubles yeah it's that burning stuff there right instead of removing right what's also yeah this is
another negative there's not enough removal right like if you want to be cutthroat there's the only way to affect anyone's clouds are the winds the wind of moving and merging clouds now i have presence so then i can kind of now we both control where this goes right but oh unlucky me i only had one win card you have four so now you really own the cloud i just get to participate um but yeah you're right there's no like well we're all vying for this let me play like like it like a sun could be add to to one you control or remove two to one you control um the only way because once these are here they're basic they're there right um and then the wind weather event is the only way it gets removed but it barely matters right like it's like okay yeah maybe and that's the only time i ever really find turn order to matter it's like oh i want to go last cause that's going off so i can have fun only during wind it doesn't matter yeah i mean maybe during the sun because you can double up and so once you hit the double it spills but yeah and then it's like and then if the sun's going off and that was their only cloud sure but once again it's it's extremely cutthroat right um almost always to a point of well i really just did that because i had nothing else to do right and i just oh look at that it kind of worked out i uh
it i just i feel like if there is more mitigation to fight for area control imagine if we were playing chemet and i put all my troops into one really good area and that they're there sorry i just i'm gonna win that right oh well what about combat no no we don't do that here there needs to be a very specific event that happens to have to come out for us to even compete for that area and it matters what who has turned order for that and turn order is so important and i despise how the turnover works in this game because passing is actually a punishment right because if i want to hold on to this to guarantee like because if you pass you burn your cards yes and it's not like i can hold on to these be like okay i'm not gonna get much this round but if i use these cards with other cards next round oh no because if i pass and i want to go first i can't keep these cards yeah it should be the other way around that's right people not passing get one more play and then toss their cards right or if everyone just wants to keep their cards and you go down to a hand of three or a hand of four um if you if i if i have this and i choose to willingly pass if i have to get rid of my cards at least let me hold on to the [ __ ] thing right like that's so mind-boggling to me it's like well how can we make this game more annoying like i used to think champion's a midgard have you guys played that okay um i used to think that that game was very frustrating because turn order mattered because if you're first player then you're the first one to go to the troll therefore you can pass shame around
um and therefore cause a bunch of people to lose points at the end well that really only matters in a two-player game in the three-player game all the shame kind of evens out right so first or first turn order you have to go to a spot and then you get to take it and you hold on to it it's not like if you go there and you take it it's like oh i already had it oh here you go other player let me reward you so stupid yeah um but the artwork's nice i guess but they also went with the latin terms of all these plants and it's like just say corn yeah like don't give me triticum estivum scorn like at least put both of them if you want to be scientific about it right uh yeah like this this game is just so infuriating uh in in we'll call it the three bullet rule well i'll say i mean someone take this theme and make a better game with it because the theme is good like i actually like the thing yeah now i will say when i first saw this i thought oh it's the air plant you know containers that hang the glass bubbles the airplanes yeah i thought okay that's a cool idea this is a gardening style game my yeah and it's like the idea of like merging clouds and all it's like it's all good in theory but in practice here's where i think it's even more frustrating if you had a set of actions and this was your traditional area control you get whatever action points and here's what
you can do fine but the fact is is that your your your entire strategy hinges on your hand of seven cards right and on the fact that well here's the seven i got i mean and the one time i didn't get uh frost that was one time in a six round game right like ever since then it was always kind of a sampler yeah um but then just based off turn order if i was going last it god forbid you go last in this game um there was one time i had a few areas to control i was like okay i know what i want to do with that because what i was going to do i think you popped here and i had like three wind in my hand so what i need to do i need to put uh i i was going last i needed to put a uh a cloud down but then you put one down right here right and i was like okay that's fine i can i can go up there and then brett put one down so then even me trying to get over to this area was impossible um because i would have had to burn three win cards i think this was actually the last round uh so i'd have to merge and i have to merge and i have to merge and in that entire time all i'm doing is helping you guys because then i can't win control because i was trying to go for the wheat and just by you oh yeah i want to put a cloud down just derailed my entire strategy right so it's like okay i'll pass right you know i i don't get to do what i want to do and i think it was the last round because i've seen the last rounds like i had i think three winter cards and i was like okay winter's going pop rain's going to pop so i need to put as many clouds out on
the board everywhere as possible because there's a lot that are just do you control the area yep good okay yeah you're gonna score something yeah and i'll have a score top i have to score something right yeah and in all the games that i uh that we've played of this the first person who jumps out to that lead is immediately the target right regardless because the chances are it's like brett and i were high up on this weather thing for the majority of the game and it took nothing for you to catch up right so this almost becomes a moot point anyway um i will say the last round i strongly focus like with spain two cars on one action to specifically balance that because otherwise i wasn't going right close and then the other thing is i never once strategized that right i just but i never tripped a die either never once yeah all i did was vote for whatever action i wanted to take right and it coincidentally worked my winning is absolute coincidence i never strategized any of that stuff honestly and i couldn't strategize because every time someone did an action it was like well okay yeah that's that's i guess i just won't get to do what i want to do because you have the disjoint if you're trying to area control for votes then you have to basically do an action you don't want to take right like i don't want to move a cloud around but i want to rain my thunder clouds well i guess i have to just burn this card just to then put one vote out
yes and at first i was like that's pretty unique okay that might be an interesting but then once you play and you realize this game is cutthroat and i guess str strategic then you [ __ ] then you just waste your entire main game turn all for the end game turn just for it to potentially not even matter right because it's so easy for someone to be like okay it's like like like let's say i did i played all three of those win cards i put three in there nothing stopping you guys from also playing win cards right just to then tie me right and then oh we both go up well i didn't gain anything because he's like if you're in if you're in last place it's almost guaranteed that you are not bridging that gap right no i i agree because it's like oh i'm gaining five there oh you are too okay that's moot like so hmm where can i try to gain a [ __ ] ton of points oh that one gives me seven if i'm in second well i'm the only one there so that's not giving me seven points like right it's yeah that was the most waste is that potato i have one thing for right turn and because i have one nobody else is going to put any on there yeah i was at first and then i went but i don't want to put more right yeah why the hell would i put the two that would make it actually right to give him seven points it's almost like they wanted they wanted people because the board is very tight it's only nine times it's almost like they wanted people to constantly be moving clouds into each other fighting to be the one with the least least
points you know when i have never done that in smash up ever i never if that one has the most score like if if first place is four points and second place is six i never try to get second uh because it's almost guaranteed to never happen it's just it's like a happenstance of oh this one busted which is what happened the first time i played i just again without really thinking about it i just did and i ended up getting second and that gave me an early lead what you do for the for the potato in that case is you merge with someone and then you move that cloud around and then oh hey rain's going off boom it drops and then look at that now i have i have second the second most layer that's seven points for me right but because it's so obvious unless we get to move one drop to another tile and then i move it back right but but it's so obvious that that's what someone's doing so unless you have to hope that they don't have a win card but because you could pay any two then it's like oh yeah i'm gonna do that they can be like oh i see what you're doing i'm gonna move i'm gonna play a win and move that down right yeah well okay in the meantime we're all just jocking for majority because we're doing the same action yeah exactly so you can't re i mean you can strategize for one or the other but very rarely do you get to actually capitalize off of both um and another thing that's frustrating about this we'll actually talk about the harvest in a sec but if you basically have majority in an area it's scoring yeah there's nothing anyone
can do unless all players just look at that one area and they're like well we can't let him get five points okay i'll move him out you move him away and then that means that we're tied and we both get one you don't get any points for it but you stopped one of us from getting four right um it's just talk [ __ ] yeah the uh so what do you guys think about the harvest like the harvest face the fact that there isn't a harvest phase every every round potentially not a harvest phase every round because you can at least get a point if you take a die down or it's too tough to get those down to right if they're like four on a regular basis yeah yeah if they're like at four it's like so that's why i realized too late like i didn't realize that until turn three that votes were more important than ticking that thing down well yeah yeah i had all of my water out on the board and like i could effectively not play cards right for an entire turn yeah i had no no no drops right and so it's like okay because if that's the case you just play the card to place a vote right right and that's mostly what i did it's like though because it's like they wanted it to be like okay this will gain you some points but it's one point it's not going to matter so then okay well there wasn't a harvest so let's roll oh it okay now there's guaranteed the harvest or it could be the opposite oh it was out of one it gets re-rolled then it rolls to a four i
would say there should be at least two before the final round right like i don't i i can see that i don't know how to fix the dice yeah like i would almost rather it be every two rounds two four and six i would say you're guaranteed a harvest um i don't know what the dice do for like thematically supposed to represent well if uh so if you score a scorpion your score point for getting it closer yeah so that's actual points right but it's not but it's one point you know it's frustrating it's not enough to care me ticking it down is basically guaranteed now i made it easier for you guys to take it down to the harvest to get two points exactly now i've argued this so yes it's one point if i put a vote higher as long as i'm past the first point it's two points for every vote it jumps two and more than three then four oh it's fine that's why it didn't bother the entire game i know i didn't catch that the first time um and so i'm like that's why i mean when i realized on turn three that taking it down was a pointless fact right the only way you would rush the uh the harvest dice is when you are like i need um like i need one to get beats back right or two like i i will win this and no one will capitalize off of it like for example um if wind wasn't going off then and i wasn't able to jump in there and prevent you from getting four points
that would be the only reason you would rush a harvest so this goes off you're guaranteed 12 because we can't affect it in any way right which is why dad turned two when it went off um because i did take it down to get the harvest right and there was no win and so nobody was going to collect my 12. oh right yeah yeah at the very beginning right right um turn one turn two is there is a good mitigation of that strategy in that the two that actually scored and and people benefited from all get removed the ones that are left they'll stay get to stay and so you've already got a huge advantage right if you did it before but it doesn't happen often enough right and it's also yeah to tie off of that let's say i have two in reign and and zach has one i didn't get any win cards so now i can't ensure my um my lead of that oh you guys got wind well now you guys actually steal it from me even though i spent those votes in the last round so actually like it's a perpetual waste of actions um and and that that did happen uh to me a few times by being like well the cards i have in the way that the board is laid out i can't ensure i'm going to win that so in fact there was one time where i i think you guys were gaining on me and son there's one i won sun by myself and i literally just burned two cards every time i do winter just to win sun i didn't give a [ __ ] about my clouds on the
tiles i was like i need to keep this lead because zach's at 15 i'm at three and brett said zero so it's like i need to try and catch up and try and win through end game right and it didn't work anyway um obviously passing when you have six cards is not that's not the way to go i was more just curious as to how that was gonna happen because i might have been able to one two three four five i would have tied with him because i probably could have won uh one of those which just encourages spending 20 minutes to do all the math before you take the last round and very there's very few games where i will do that where it's like where the game ends based off how the players are playing like players dictate when the game ends and i can't think of those games up top my head but yeah we'll sit there and be like okay this might be a risk because i don't i don't want to be like okay so he's gonna end with 60 points yeah i don't want to sit here and do that it's like i want to just kind of have a guess and be like i might win if i end it now right okay let's just try it and then sometimes it pays off sometimes it doesn't right but that's when everyone's controlling the end of the game um yeah i refuse very rarely do does almost every action in this game just make me more and more mad like because i will say it's not a long game like that that is a benefit but because i'm miserable the entire time where it's like okay i got [ __ ] on oh
look more [ __ ] it's not a short game though it is not it's not it's uh but it it's not three hours it's not three hours it's probably i think it's about an hour yeah so yeah i just there are games that i could be like you know what i can handle some randomness but if you're trying to be extremely strategic but you also make a cutthroat and also make it um random in what you're trying to do yeah that's just misery for me um you guys got anything else nope i'm trying to think yeah which is weird because actually we we did a three player short game it so it only goes to four rounds and i was like maybe this maybe you know maybe maybe it's just not because like when you play dinosaur island or uh for example you do a short game never do a short game because you can't play the game really so you do a medium or a long game um and for me dinosaur island's fantastic so you just don't play the short game and i thought maybe that's the same with this just don't do the short game maybe the longer it is the more uh you know actions you get to get more area control for me it just made it longer and i was more mad because i remember whenever we were actually sitting here trying to get anything out every time it was like trying to maneuver it's like you know what let's try and get some benefit from this what's the best optimal move for
someone to move a cube and we strategize together how to screw each of us the most right well if you do this that will cause me to lose four points you don't get anything out of it but uh yeah but you make me lose four points so what's interesting is when we did that is when you you guys have short game love ended because it was turning four yep oh right and so basically if i turn four we'd all come to the conclusion that i think we're just kind of done like we're gonna finish it right and i think brett still would have won that because he would have he was we didn't we were like down here yeah and he was like i think on 28 or once i saw him three yeah right so he was still higher up on that yeah and um i think he had the wheat that was my only long-term strategy literally yeah and that's that's def that's what i go for like those are in-game victory points are what i go for so whenever we got done with our first game of this i was like you know what i want to try the expansions i don't i i i cow no because that's methane nope i mean yeah that's methane and that's another board uh it it looks like it just makes it more it does add um uh climate events so like um but it's all centered around methane like you can have scorching warm temperate cold and frozen kind of uh climate events there's a harvest bonus but unless if literally someone comes in and they're like i promise i swear to the [ __ ] god that if you play with the honeybee expansion all your problems are resolved then i'd like you know what let's try it
but i can't imagine that they made these mini expansions and radically changed it right so oh yeah yep scale of one to ten uh zach two two yep oh come on it wasn't that bad three ah nah i'm good my two halfway between it should have never existed and it's not oh it's not awful uh god it's not a one because you can technically play it right it does it does inherently work um it's too honestly because of the art for me i i can't so i've given one game a one and that was more out of frustration um and i haven't given the game a one since i've given a few twos uh i'm gonna give her the two as well and the reason is because i'm if i'm mad while playing a game not like not like mad at what a player has done like if if ti and someone comes in and [ __ ] me over at least if there's a good reason if they're just like i just [ __ ] hate you and i'm gonna attack you and then i'm like so you're a dick that's it no if there's a good reason then i'm like damn that sucks that kind of screws me over super bad but in this game i know for a fact none of you had any ill intentions it was just the actual mechanics of the game that i'm like turn four we're all arguing how to screw
me over i'm arguing the hardest of how to screw myself this is the best bet it wasn't even like hey this is what screws me it was like this is what your most optimal moment is yeah you don't get no no you don't get anything you and you get the satisfaction of making me lose four points right and it's like oh well i can also just punch you in the throat right and then i'll get the same type of feeling yeah so if i'm if i'm just over it halfway through the game yeah i think i think i'm also going to agree with zach i'm going to take it down to it too yeah um because at this point production quality this is almost this is this isn't the bar this is the standard right so it's like yeah it's really good and i'm super glad they fit all the mini expansions they took into consideration some companies don't cool me or not and uh fancy flight uh but almost everyone else does it goo gong um yiddo uh vedic viticulture um vindication those kind of they're they're all doing it so it's like oh well this doesn't get an extra point because of that but enough i think this is actually i think mighty boards is just a company i'm gonna stay away from i think i've always just not liked their designs so yeah that's our thoughts on petra core uh the base game uh let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you hey everyone thank you for watching i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that
subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you