Skip to main content
Loading video...

Kashgar Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 10:23

Hey everybody and welcome to Chairman of the Board. Today I'm talking about Kashgar, Merchants of the Silk Road. Now this is a 2013 release board game by Grail Games. Plays two to four players. The box says it takes an hour to play but in my personal experience it takes a lot less than that, more around the half an hour mark. The idea of the game is you are racing to get to 25 points. You're going to get to points by fulfilling contracts, by collecting spices and then cashing them in to fulfill those contracts. The game has a pretty cool unique mechanism where you are collecting into three different columns called caravans. And in each of your turn you're going to activate one of the cards in the front of any of those caravans and then you're going to remove that card and put it to the back of the caravan.

And you can use them in any order whatsoever. And these cards as I said are going to give you lots of different powers and abilities such as collecting a certain type of herb or gold or um letting you fulfill contracts. And some certain cards let you add more cards to your hand and there's going to be a discard pile and some cards let you go through the discard pile and stuff like that. So as said it's that that race element is really there when you're trying to get to the 25 points. And it's all about how how to kind of get your engine rolling and how to most efficiently you know play things in a certain order to get those contracts done. There's not many games where you are building you know several different engines at the same time or several different different decks at the same times but this one does that really well. I mean especially considering this is as I said a half an hour game. I think this game has a lot going on in it and a lot to think about in a game of that time stamp which is a really nice kind of a nice kind of weight to it because mechanically this game is ultra simple.

Just activate one of these cards and do what it says on there. And ultimately they're all very very simple to use. You start with a basic kind of hand of or basic caravans of two cards each. And some will let you kind of I said go through a pile of cards and you draw two and you pick one. And add it to your caravan and the other one goes in the discard pile. And you can alternatively choose to flip that card or patriarch card over to a matriarch which lets you go through the the discard pile which can kind of give you a bit more autonomy on what cards you specifically want because obviously if you're top decking every time you are somewhat subjective to um to the luck of the draw. But considering this is you know such a quick game I think the the decisions is very good because it doesn't overwhelm you with so much decisions that it will bog the game down and just kind of drag this on. It gives you just enough to play with enough kind of you know decisions to tinker your caravans how you like. You can maybe go for a more you know long lavish caravan and just try to get loads of abilities or you can have nice and short succinct caravans and just cut all the fat out of your decks and just get a nice simple engine running um and so on. So there's kind of different approaches you can take to the game.

Some cards let you have additional caravans. You've got like special cards which are particularly powerful. Some of the cards have like parting actions so not only does it have like a basic action but you can take the kind of red action on those cards which will discard or get rid of that card from your hand for good but will give you a lot powerful more powerful returns. So again lots to think about in in a quick simple card game. And I think it's really nice as I said I often preach about on the show like you know I like games that are unique. Something that's not like anything else. In Kashgar I really can't think of anything much like it at all to be honest. Obviously you've got your deck building games. You've got your kind of racing style games. But this one kind of takes those two kind of ideas and just melts them together in a way that's not really been done before. This game does somewhat remind me of games like Splendor or um the First Century game Spice Road. But it kind of takes that kind of simple idea and kind of maybe takes it a step higher but still keeping the simple mechanisms. But you've got obviously got that the whole idea of the whole engine building going on where you or to an extra degree that you haven't got on those other other games. So I do really like that. I think the the idea of that of having those thoughts in such a short game is a really nice place on any game shelf because I like Euro games and often Euro games take about an hour and a half to play even more. But this one as I said you can get it done in half an hour so it does have that really nice niche.

I love the different approaches you can take as I said having the short short runs having the long runs. Just knowing which order to activate things in because you can say I'm going to activate this card then this card and then that will be that will be ready for this card and I can cash it in with this card and so on. So it's it's a really nice idea and just a really cool fresh approach to these style games. And considering this game is you know from 2013 it does still feel very fresh. Now this was I think when it was originally published it went out of print pretty quickly and you couldn't get an English version but I think in the last couple of years it has been reprinted and so it is readily available now. And something that does surprise me about this game is that it's not even ranked in the top 1000 games on BoardGameGeek which is ultra surprising because this is a really well designed game and I'll be you know I'm really surprised it's not higher. I think it's probably because it's kind of flown under the radar there's not that many people aware of it. But um yeah it's a rock solid game in the way it plays.

The the time investment as I said is fantastic especially in terms of downtime. There's literally no downtime in this game whatsoever. Turns really do fly by rapidly and as I said you're never going to have much time to get bored and bogged down by other players decisions because they're all pretty snappy pretty simple and again there's there's no downtime there at all. And housekeeping as well no issue because you just going to take a card and just keep putting it behind accumulate more cards. But there's there's next to no housekeeping whatsoever which is a really nice. Replayability wise as well there's a ton of cards in that deck which you're not going to see them all every game. Every time you're going to get a different array of cards. You can take different approaches. You know you're going to get different cards together.

And so yeah there's some really nice synergies there and lots of things to explore in terms of replayability. So that's really nice. Play interaction wise there are different elements to the game which can kind of leech off other players and stuff so certain cards might say take a certain type of spice and increase it to the number of another players players board. So that's quite nice and there's no kind of interaction that way or or mean interaction. But there is a kind of a module that comes with the game to really increase the player interaction and the kind of cutthroatness and the take that elements of the game which you can choose to include or not. I personally I leave that out because I like my kind of Euro feeling games to be relatively conflict free. But you know if you want that element to it you can kind of cater the game to how you like and just add that in to your heart's content. So that's really nice as well. You've got that bit of you know that that bit of flexibility if you want it or or depending on the players you're playing with.

Aesthetically it's very plain. I mean the artwork's perfectly nice but it's what you'd expect from a game like this. It's very generic in theme and you know they're just these general merchants and traders and you know dealers and stuff like that. And they're all these kind of you know general or generic men as you would you probably expect. Component quality is absolutely up to scratch. Card quality is very decent. The the um the tracks that hold all your resources stuff are really well done. They're nice and clear nice big size and all the different kind of wooden blocks that you know slide up and down the tracks are really nice as well. They're nice custom shapes. They're not they're not just generic little cubes which is just a nice extra touch.

And theme wise as well although it makes sense you know you're using all these different guys to get your resources and stuff it's it's pretty abstract in all kind of you know it does it doesn't it's not thematic. There's no flavor text or anything like that. But that doesn't need to be. It's all about getting that engine going and all about you know the the mechanisms themselves and just trying to fulfill those contracts. But yeah overall this game is it's really nice. I'm so impressed by it. I remember watching a review on this by Rahdo years and years ago and it really piqued my interest but I couldn't get hold of a copy. But again I found that there was a reprint of it and I just snapped up because I was worried about it going out of print and I'm so glad I did. It's going to stay on my shelf for sure because it's as I said it fits a really nice niche of being a quick game with enough decisions going on but not too much going on.

It's it's pretty light but again not not just mindless you know doing things going through the motions because again you can really get those engines going how you like. And the race element is there as well. I mean if you don't like racing games or games like Splendor games like Century then maybe this isn't for you. But in the same vein if you want just an element more to those games because maybe you've played them out and they're a bit I don't know you kind of rinse and repeat with them. This one is definitely something else to check out because it's a step above. And again every time the game is going to be a bit different based on the cards that you draw. So yeah I'm really impressed by this game. I said it's criminally underrated in terms of its ranking. I mean I I could only wish that this does blow up a bit more and word of mouth starts to spread and maybe people start to pick this up because it is a rock solid game and it definitely deserves to be talked about.

Um Ultimately yeah I couldn't recommend this one to or much more than I am because it's it's really well put together. A rock solid game. And for a half an hour game there's there's pretty much not much on the market quite up to you know this this level of thinkiness which is which is really nice. So definitely check this one out. It gets a very good rating from me. Which is I give it a 7.8 out of 10 so just missing that mark of excellence but you know, who knows with more plays it could creep up to that next bracket. So, yeah, definitely check this one out if it appeals to you. Very unique. That's Kashgar: Merchants of the Silk Road. Go check it out. If you have enjoyed this review, please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos, too. You can additionally support me on Patreon or follow me on Instagram. I'll leave the links below.

For everyone else, I'll see you next time on Chairman of the Board. Bye.

Progress saved