Tabannusi Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about tabanusi which is a board game designed by danielle toshini and david spada in 2021 this one accommodates one up to four players and takes around two hours to play now if you're relatively involved in the ballgame hobby you might be aware that every year board and dice publish a new game of the t series so this is the latest version of that um at the time of this recording anyway um and as you probably imagine this is a pretty heavy and involved euro involving dice before i get into how the game actually plays i need to give a shout out to kianda dot code at uk who spots the show so if you live in the uk and you regularly buy board games be sure to check out their great website but let's take a look at tabanusi so a game of tapanisi is going to look a bit like this once it's completed so i've just played a three player game here and this board is actually double sided so on one side you've got the one and two player board which is obviously a bit tighter and the three to four player board is going to look like this however again a lot has been developed here so it's not going to look quite like this at the start of the game so essentially the game is divided into five different areas or different zones you've got these three general note zones here which work in the exact same way um which we'll talk about a bit later you've got this little ziggurat section here which you can invest in different bonuses at the end of the game and how you can score different things and different criteria you've got the standard euro tracks here which you're trying to climb and increase your multipliers and you've got this little section of the board down here to the bottom right where you are investing in player powers and i can get scoring in
different ways additionally each player is going to have their own player area where you're going to have your own board here which is going to show where all your houses start at the beginning of the game and as you place more houses onto the board you can start unlocking these different bonuses you can also carry these other resources here um which basically proxy dice that you can acquire throughout the game and in this game as you'd expect with a lot of danielle designs dice are your resources um but let's talk about how the game actually plays i'll try to be as brief as i can because there's a lot going on here so a game of tabernucci is going to consist of five scoring phases and then there's going to be a final scoring um and i suppose the core mechanism of the game is dice drafting so what you're gonna do is on your turn you are going to i'll start anywhere on the board as a first off and then you can take one of the dice available um on these boats here so you can see that all these different areas correspond to a different color dice so you've got these ones here you've got the yellow ones that correspond to this area and so on and what you're going to do before you do anything is you're going to draft one of those die from the pool so let's just say i took this one here and again the yellow die is going to be a particular type of resource and when you go there when you take that particular value that is going to mean that you're going to have to go to that area next time so if you remember let's say the blue player took that one and that means they're going to have to move their little servant here to the one area which means that next turn they have to go to the one area and that's all the significance of that pit value so in a lot of tashini games
you are you know using this pit values for different things but in this one is purely to show which area you are forced to go to next now you can mitigate that by using gold which means you can go anywhere you want but as a general rule that is what you're gonna do and from after that you are going to take up to two actions um of your choice corresponding to the region you're in so most of these areas are the same but they do have one of these modular actions and which can be mixed up from game to game to show a bit of variety and they're going to do different things such as giving you points giving you clay markers and clay markers are a big part of the game because it's going to show your controller different things throughout the game and if you don't have them in your supply then you can't actually increase your influence on the board so it's quite important to have an income of those um clay markers you can do different things like in this area such as claiming these water tiles and grass tiles um which can increase and multiply your scoring um and this one here lets you kind of lose points to climb tracks and here just gives you gold and more clay markers i mean gold is a wild resource in this game so it's very useful but let's talk about what you're actually trying to do and how you're going to gain victory points so one of the main actions is to lay these plans down and they're going to come in three different colors the brown the yellow and the white and that is going to correspond to the track up here so there's kind of three main colors that you're trying to climb up um and what you're going to do is when you're in that particular area so let's just say again the yellow player took a plan action because he's in the one area so he's going to have to build in the one that is a restriction so you can only ever kind of interact with the area where your main worker currently is
and let's just say um he plays one of these yellow plans now when you play a a plan you are going to lay on one of these tiles let's just say we played a four player game we can use this spot here you are going to get any bonus that's beneath that plan um so this one's actually climate track this one gives you a gold this one gives you a clay marker that one lets you take a brown dye from the um from the from the ship there and so on and if there's ever an existing plan of that type there you're going to have to spawn off from it so you can't just spawn somewhere else and then you're going to put your little mark on there to show that you developed that plan and that's very important because this is a weird mechanism which actually encourages other players to build on your plans because they get to do it cheaper than if you were to build it yourself so let's say the blue player wants to now build in this area so first off again they're going to draft the um the die available so they're gonna take a five there and the five is going to correspond to this area here so they're gonna place their servant over here just to show that they're gonna go there next turn and then they can take carry on with their two actions if they wish to do so so um first off let's say they want to build on this area here so what that means is that they're going to have to spend a number of resources or local resources so in this one it's going to be this color here in order to build a house on this region so when they do that they are going to again spend those two resources let's just let's say they spent this one here and let's say they had a spare gold because again gold is wild so that's their two local resources and then they're going to put buildings on this on this um plan
area to show that is going to be theirs so it worked like this so basically these two are going to get replaced with with these two like so and anybody who's been displaced by doing so again the black player and the yellow player is going to climb up that corresponding track so again these are the yellow tiles so therefore the black player and the yellow player are going to go up that yellow track which again is going to increase their multipliers when it comes to scoring and then this blue player is going to claim those buildings as their own and i suppose now is the best time to explain how this scoring actually works so once one of these boats runs out of dice you're gonna score for that particular region so let's just say this one got took here then you are going to have a look at all the different buildings here and they're going to score so let's say uh this yellow one here so we've got a footprint of two so that's a two size building and then you're going to multiply that by the space on the track so the blue you're gonna have a two size building they're up to this two area on this track here which means they get two times two for four points now the gardens which is another action you can take is going to increase the footprint of that building by as many gardens as it's touching so let's say here this brown building and it's a two size brown building that the yellow controls here but it's touching one two three gardens which basically multiplies it up or kind of increases its uh footprint by that many squares so this is going to be a five size building okay one two three four five the buildings plus the gardens it's touching i'm gonna
multiply it by the space on that brown track because it's a brown building so that'll be five times two for ten points so gardens are really important um into mocking you increase your multipliers and get you more points um however if you do build a building build a garden by spending green dyes to collect the tiles or blue blue dyes to um collect the water tiles because gardens can only ever be built on water and water has to spawn from where water or gardens already are and then you're going to build on top of them again if there's a bonus on them they can claim the bonus um and but if somebody builds a building after you've built that garden connected to us let's say someone builds a building here then any person with a garden around it is going to get to climb a track of their choice to give now you can actually build on your own plans and however doing so is going to be more expensive for the person doing so so let's have a look here so normally again to build a building you're gonna have to spend two local resources in this example the two um the two brown colored dice but then you're gonna have to spend an additional cost of one matching die cutter equal to the tiles you're built on so again this one here is going to cost this black player another white dice because it's a white plan to build that building the number four area here is pretty simple and where you are either going to pay two gold in order to claim one of these technology tiles and put your disk on there and they're going to let you do different things such as you see the black player has invested in this technology so whenever he builds a house he gets two points and all that kind of stuff additionally you can spend
two local resources again the blue in this example in order to build a house on these outskirts on the on the kind of dock here and that's going to be another way to score points because whenever all the dice are exhausted here you're going to score this particular region which is going to work in this kind of cross-hatching system where whatever buildings you have on the vertical or horizontal axis you're going to score a point for each one so you can see here the yellow's got a building here so it's going to get one two three four five six points for that particular region and whenever you get a whole line or a whole column you can end up taking these bonus tiles which will give you bonuses used throughout the game but if you don't spend them you get three points for each of those additionally the ziggurat action works pretty simply where you are spending two local resources in order to build one of your houses in these particular colors so you've got the white area the brown area and the yellow area and that is going to give you certain ways to score points at the end of the game depending on a certain criteria and again you can see these are modular so this one is going to get you two three or four points depending on how many houses you have here for each building you have on that dock area so you can see here the black has invested or the black player has invested two uh two times in this particular region um to get three points for each of their houses in the dock area so therefore they'd only get three points there because they've only got one house there but you can see how that might multiply the more you invest in it and again you've got these additional tiles here where you can flip those neutral ones over all those ones you collect or or this one here lets you place a worker
anywhere and take one dice from the supply that of dice that have already been spent there are also a number of public objectives available to you and the first player to claim them is going to get a boost of points so this one for example says you know the first player to get eight um garden tiles down on the board is going to score 10 points and take one of those um bonus harbor tiles um as you can see here that the yellow players have got that achieved by getting one two three four five um six seven eight of these guards on the board so therefore on their turn as a free action they could clean that card and score that many points in that bonus and you can see some some of these um objectives are quite a bit different where this one requires three yellow buildings on the board and plus two of these orange colored technologies and one and two of these darker colored technologies as well not only are the tracks important to increase your multipliers of your coverage on the board and but also the lowest marker you have on a certain track when you get to these certain checkpoints you're gonna get bonuses such as getting more of these control markers you know gold and points etc and if you ever hit these spots here again you're gonna get those bonuses too and again once once five of those ships have been exhausted you're going to play another round and then every single region is going to score again and then of course the person with the most points is going to be the winner i think that's all i really want to cover about the rules you know there is a few more things i could have talked about but i think you probably got the gist of how it works and without going into too much detail but let's talk about my thoughts on tabanusi okay so out of all of the tea games i
must say this one is probably the easiest to learn but maybe the more difficult one to understand because there's quite some obtuse things going on here that don't quite fit into place when you play this for the first few times particularly with the way that everything interacts with each other because i do think the designers here have really tried to embed interaction into everything you do and try to make that part of the game shine because again whatever you do the game you are one way or another impacting or luring another player into taking a particular action particularly with this planning thing you know you're planning a certain region i'm hopefully getting the great reward at the bottom because that's really rewarding for you to do so but doing that is going to create an opportunity for other players because when they build on your plans they get to do it for cheaper um but and additionally you get rewarded by climbing up the corresponding track so this weird back and forth interaction is quite difficult to wrap your head around and it's hard to at least for me to understand who's getting the net gain out of that and i think that's probably where the game does shine but i think again that's not going to really um shine through or not really becomes as transparent as you might want it to and i think it's quite a brain burner to try and min max that additionally i think of all the dice grafting mechanisms or all the you know all the dice games that has made this one is probably the most cut back one the most simple one where you should be taking it for the resources which is purely the color of the dice and the only reason the pit value matters is to lay the foundation of where you're going to go next time now i'm not saying that's not important
or significant because of course if you want to go a particular region then you're going to have to make sure that dice is there and the six when you do get a six in the pool it does mean that you can take any of the unavailable actions so you do have some good flexibility but sometimes you can find yourself a bit pigeon-holed and not being able to go where you want to go and every second in this game is important because before you know it these pools of these um these boats and the dice are going to get exhausted and that's going to automatically trigger a scoring when you might not want it to because you might have the foundations there but you haven't got your building down yet or you haven't quite climbed the track yet to get those big multipliers so yeah i like the timing of this game and i like the fact that there is no real round structure you just keep playing and score only when those boats are exhausted and that really makes the game tick along nicely it makes it flow well and again it keeps players on their toes additionally i like the fact that when the regions do score then you have to put back any colored dice of that color back into the pool to be re-rolled and distributed again and that means that you've potentially wasted your draft and but you do get compensated by climbing the track of the relevant color so there is a little bit of give there just a little bit of forgiving but generally the resource gathering the resource management is very tight it's hard to get anything done in this game and you really do rely on those wild resources that gold and i think that's probably one of my main issues with the game i do think that the um the use of gold was a bit too much of a crutch and it really did kind of take away a lot from the resource management it
gives you a lot of options to get gold and i found probably 80 of the time whenever i was spending dice i would always spend one of the matching color that i needed and then probably a gold to accompany that and again that kind of watered it down a bit for me and it felt a bit i don't know it just felt like it softened the blow and it didn't feel quite as satisfying as i would have liked generally i like the way that the scoring works you know your footprint on the board multiplied by your point on the track that works really well for me and it does feel very satisfying when you end up building a nice big footprint of a building at the same time you're laying foundations for other players so that you're climbing up the relevant tracks as well because you know you do have to keep those plates very kind of evenly balanced so you know you're not having a massive footprint but you're multiplying it by next to nothing or vice versa so that works quite well and again it keeps you on your toes and keeps you trying to nudge up all the tracks not only for that reason but because you're gonna get the bonuses on the side as well the whole garden and water mechanism i think is okay i'm not enthralled by it um i do quite like the fact that you know when you build these gardens they're going to be a massive help because they do massively multiply your again your footprint of the building and if you lay them down you're going to invite people to build next to them because again it's going to increase their scoring but you're going gonna get to climb a track of your choice um additionally i like the fact that you have to commit one of these player markers on them and these are you know they're a finite resource so doing so is going to really limit your options later in the game because you've got all your things committed on the board so you do have to decide you know to balance and
use those discs as well as you can and balance them and keep a regular supply and so i think that's a really cool mechanism actually the fact that you do have to make sure you're constantly getting these influence markers into your pool to put them on the board or leave yourself without many options so i thought that the little duck area down here was somewhat underwhelming now this system is used in taken you you know when you've got this kind again this kind of cross-hatching mechanism um and you know i thought this was a bit it felt a bit tacked on and i additionally i thought that the technologies weren't too interesting so just just to contrast with the game like uh khan i always felt like every single technology in toyota cam like i needed to have they're all fantastic this one it was like yeah big whip i'm not too fussed on what they do you know for example you know this one here when you build a garden you just take one of the control markers from the general supply rather than your own personal um pool so it's like it's fine it's worth having but is it really worth the additional investment you know two goals to get that done now something i didn't mention is when you do build a building you do actually get to take one of these technologies if you spend one gold as long as it matches the footprint of the building and which i think is fine it certainly gets things fast-tracked and it's more inviting to do that but again i just didn't think this felt too strong and additionally the whole the amount of points you get from doing so just felt it felt small and you don't really find people really going down here too often um and trying to really
sink their teeth into this particular strategy because it just doesn't feel as strong as the other parts of the game now i do like these um tokens that you can get and add them to your board because again these just kind of proxy dice that you could have drafted and there is a particular region over here that lets you refresh them and exploit that to keep using those dice again and again and i thought that was a really cool thing and that's probably one of my favorite parts of the game actually similarly to the dock area i think the zeppelin area is again a bit weak it didn't feel very exciting for me now yeah sometimes it is more inviting you know when you spend these resources and you get some of these great bonuses such as climbing the tracks um but i just felt like the investment you put in was quite small you know get one point for each technology you have or you know potentially two or three if you go there again and again but i just never really felt the urge to do that um i think maybe one of the main reasons this one comes into play a bit more is when there is some kind of public objective that works off that you know like this one for example says you know get all of the different colors of the zep um ziggurats in there um and one of each color buildings and you can get this big injection of points which is again a bit more satisfying when you pull that off but to actually tailor your strategy to one of these i don't think it's really going to happen that often i think the uptime and general time investment of tabernucci is generally good but it certainly does feel like it ticks along nicely and you're kept on the edge of your seat as the game goes on and because again the time does really kind of go down the drain as the game goes on you feel like now i'm running out of time i still need to get ability down here i still need to climb into the next bracket on the track i still need enough time to get that objective done so yeah it does feel like you are constantly moving on to the next
thing and trying to spin those plates and get everything you've done within quite a tight amount of time to go back to this round structure i think that's really well done i love the fact that there is no real housekeeping there is no meticulous phase orders or anything like that just keep playing and when a scoring happens it happens um like it or not so that for me is a real change of pace in the again the kind of flow of these games and i thought it was a welcome edition and i'd like to see that used again the replayability of tabernucci is a bit of a strange one yeah there's the traditional tashini modularity you know you're moving these different actions around each game each game you've got different ziggurat tiles you've got different technology tiles that come out so again lots of variability that way you know objectives etc so there is some good modularity however i would say that you're probably going to get the most out of this game if you have the same group who enjoy it to play it again and again with to start understand or wrap your head around that obtuse and weird um interaction because i think if somebody's played this game and you're constantly introducing it to newer players then i think that player might have a distinct advantage on how the game works and how it operates yeah as you've probably understood from the explanation so far interaction is a big part of this game um not to mention again the laying their plans down building on the plans going up tracks um you know using your own tiles because other people's tiles all have their own bonuses and you know positives and negatives um there's also additional interaction in terms of the race for the objectives
there's the additional interaction in terms of triggering the scoring because if a person's going to a region you have a bunch of these resources you don't want that reason to score yet you know that's something you're going to have to bear in mind and going to have to overcome so yeah as people are doing their own thing in this game you are constantly going to be standing on each other's toes i mean are you going to be helping people by building gardens are you going to get more of it by climbing tracks um so yeah all of it is our interaction is generally embedded and injected into the very dna of the game the production and artwork of the game i'm generally happy with i love the way the board looks i'm generally board and dice do wonderful productions um i do like the way the buildings look um they do kind of connect to each other and things which can be a bit annoying at times because they have these little lips on um but no real issue there and one of the things i was slightly disappointed on was that the houses are these kind of cheap almost like lego pieces um they're plastic so it would be nice if they were wood but einstein was expensive at the moment so maybe that's not the or maybe that's the reason um but i generally like the way that the game develops and it kind of evolves as the game goes on starts to come alive and has a nice table presence um so yeah no real issues there um some of the symbology on the game wasn't the best particularly when it came to the technology tiles i did find myself looking at the rule book again and again to see what some of these did because it's not overtly obvious on what they do and sometimes when you think it means something it might mean something else so i don't think the symbology is the best it's not the worst by any means okay so let's go straight in to my final thoughts so if you're a regular fan of my show or watch my content regularly
you might be aware that these t-series games are amongst my very favorite of all time and of course in order to keep this series going the designers are going to have to try new things new ways they can use dice and new things they can do and just just general try new mechanisms and when that happens you normally find designers reaching further and further to find new things um in order just to be different and to stand out from amongst the pack now i'm not sure on this occasion that that paid off now i understand that they've tried to embed more interaction into the game and again as i said earlier try to make the interaction the very dna of what this game is all about and for me i think they've reached so far to the point that it's so obtuse that it almost takes away from the fun and it has this jarring and grinding feel to it where it's just so unintuitive that it doesn't quite make sense now i don't want it to sound overly negative because i do like it when designers try new things and i'm not saying by any means this is a bad game you know this is made by probably the best designer in the business at the moment or one of the best danny he's a genius he's brilliant what he does and i do like this dice drafting system here just take the resource and go to there next time simple as that not as complicated as games like tristan justice or anything like that very simple but the actual yeah the way that the players interact with each other i'm not sure if it paid off for me personally and i know that did rub off on all the other players i played with as well and this is going to require quite a niche group to get the most out of it and i'm not sure if i have that niche group and this is completely alien speak for me no these games are almost always a banker
for me to enjoy always my most anticipated game of the year and on this occasion i don't think that is the case sadly so i think this is quite clearly my least favorite game of the t-series i think this part of the game was lackluster didn't really enjoy it at all against some symbology very dodgy um this part as well i didn't feel too strongly about i thought the objectives were okay i thought these personal objectives on these on these cards that i didn't talk about these are too restrictive and don't really pay off um and yeah as a general consensus i felt like the game was just quite jarring very difficult to wrap your head around being obtuse sometimes for the sake of being obtuse and i think maybe the investment and that that again that things falling into place that initial learning curve aren't quite paid off in terms of the enjoyment and fun you get out of it there were some things i really liked about it like i like the i like the way that scoring works in the first place the the buildings multiply by the tracks that's really cool um i i like the simple dice drafted system that's perfectly cool um but other than that i thought everything else was just a bit too jarring a bit too convoluted and just so unintuitive so yeah that is my final thoughts on tabanusi so very strange not for me to be singing from the rooftops about one of these two games but i have to be honest and that is my honest thoughts thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i
am a woman operation i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time