Imperium: Legends Review
Transcript
hey everyone this is jack from the cardboard herald here for another review this time of imperium legends the new two-parter standalone simultaneously released series alongside imperium classics where this is focused on the more legendary and mythical civilizations of humanities lore as well as classics reflecting the more historical civilizations of humanity's past they are combinable essentially the exact same system just a different set of civilizations to draw their main inspiration from got your utopians who are looking for shangri-la you got your qing dynasty which i think is actually a historical dynasty but at the same time maybe this is the more legendary aspects of that you got all kinds of stuff in here so what is this game well it is a deck building game but it has a heavy contrast from just about every deck building game that you've ever played because unlike most in which you start with a set of cards that mirrors everyone else's set of cards and you develop based off of a shared pool in this one every civilization has their own unique asymmetric loadout as well as two sets of their own unique asymmetric cards to add to their deck that you will progressively gain more and more of throughout the game and then also a shared pool of cards in the center that people can pull from
that represent several different aspects of society that are in several different decks there's also a revolution mechanic that basically if you pull too many bad cards which sometimes you have to pull those as a result of actions or taking certain cards from the central pool if too many of those are pulled the game will end and the player with the least of them wins but otherwise the game goes until either the king of kings card is activated which is underneath the super plum stuff in the central pool of cards that is really going to be a huge source of points and some really nice abilities or some player gets all of their development cards in play there's an interesting pace to the game because you start out as a barbaric civilization you know the very beginnings of you ascending to power in which case you are only getting these cards that like progress your society forward and then eventually once you have all of those you flip to your empirical side you are an empire and then you can choose developments to add in front of you or in the case of other factions that may be interrupted you could be the atlanteans who already start out as an empire you could be the arthurians who instead of development so they're going on quests you know it's heavily thematic in that way there's a couple other contrasts to typical deck building games in that you have a pool of actions and
exhaustion tokens that you're going to end up spending in order to take your turn things can only be exhausted once you can only exhaust so many things on a turn exhausting is separate from an action you have only so many actions that you can take in your turn and loads of stuff of course manipulate all of those things as well as the two additional resources in the game and also the final real paradigm shift from typical deck building games is that you end up with loads of stuff in front of you your deck is going to end up collecting out in front of your play area as different permanents that are mainly the things that you're going to end up exhausting or paying actions for actions to put them into play exhaustion tokens in order to utilize their benefits these can have triggered abilities they can allow you to uh isolate cards from your deck underneath instead of just fully trashing cards it gives you a sense of this vast empire accumulating in front of you though those cards can end up cycling back into your deck for a myriad of reasons it is a lot to contend with on the table and conceptually from a strategic point of view which brings me to what makes this game cool because i'm going to give you a little bit of spoilers the back half of this review where we talk about what didn't work is going to last a little bit longer but i do have some things to say about things that i legitimately
really admire about this game first off the concept the the asymmetry not just from oh cool my power is a little bit different than your power perspective but from the the whole purpose and thrust of the game to have this asymmetric development as you progress your civilization to have it be very different than every other civilization is really cool and for the most part it works you have different flows different feels for the different civilizations and not just thematically but mechanically how they work some civilizations hunt for specific cards some civilizations just spread out vast quantities of cards in front of them some game points for different things being accrued into your deck they do feel diverse and different and there's a whole lot of them in the box and then on top of that i really adored the artwork the look the artwork is done by the mikko the maiko the mikko anyway this is really top-notch art by the miko some of the best that i've seen of them i mean you may have seen some more of their stuff in the raiders and paladins series as well as anything from preston jacobs videos on game of thrones theories to any number of other places really rising to prominence as a fan favorite artist in the board game realm and this is some of their best work to
date really diverse character styles representative of very different civilizations gives it a fantastic identity and there are a ton of artistic assets in this game so i really think it's visually spectacular but we have to talk about what didn't work and i got a bit of a laundry list here this game from setup from the very get-go and bear in mind i wanted to like this game i looked at it i read the rules and i was like oh this sounds cool this sounds interesting i mean i had to reread the rules several times because it was hard to kind of conceptualize how everything was going to be put together but ultimately i was going into this wanting and kind of just fully expecting to like it but then i got to set up it is painstaking to have certain numbers of cards and certain numbers of stacks even your personal setup is going to have cards oriented in different directions either face up face down sideways straight and then you're going to have different piles in front of you and then you're also weeding out cards for a certain number of players your sliding cards underneath other cards in the opening pool you're combining sets of cards and then on top of all this you have the maintenance of everything in front of you it's kind of overwhelming at a certain point to know like is my discard pile where is my draw pile what are these cards over here oh right those are the cards i'm going to end up
adding to my deck and then when everything gets combined together you finish up your game then take down is the opposite of it for what is ultimately a fairly fast playing game there is a huge amount of precision and maintenance to the point where it is painstaking in both setup and takedown and as for actually playing the flow never really clicked for me like i i wanted to jive with the overall system the acquisition of these cards being added to my deck but because of the the action system where i was spending these tokens i was exhausting certain things and i was having to maintain what is effectively several different types of resources from the cards that you have available in your hand to the cards that you can add to the actions that are at your disposal the action tokens you're using the exhaustion tokens that you're using and then two actual legitimate resources which boil down to the pink resource or the blue resource it never really had this smooth intuitive pristine flow that is kind of the hallmark of deck building games that's what makes them so attractive is to see this awesome engine get put together nothing about it ever felt smooth as far as the acquisition and streamlining of the cards that i had and then on top of that like i said the sprawling development of things in front of you the things that you need to take into consideration
just makes it feel so wide without ever really feeling too deep and don't get me wrong i love really big deep nuanced games this one just felt more complicated than it did complex and to seal the deal the components they aren't great i mean the cardboard tokens are kind of laughable at this point i was kind of surprised because other osprey games like the king is dead while feeling concise felt like they were really substantially produced this was kind of the opposite but maybe all the budget went into the art so overall my thoughts on this game i don't like it it's bad it's a bad game i'm sure someone out there is going to love it and if this is like your jam your jelly your peanut butter then let us know in the comments below tell me what it is that i'm not getting about this game because for the most part i like games i want new innovative things and while this is ambitious it still just kind of fell apart in flow and function and that's our review thank you so much for watching i've been jack for the cardboard herald if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our channel and website cardboardherald.com our content is audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard herald