Skip to main content
Loading video...

Board Of It's Board Gaming Pet Peeves

Transcript 36:48

hello everyone tally and farrell here and we are board of it and welcome to our board of its top 11 board game pet peeves video yep so we should say up front that this is just a bit of fun uh being british one of our national sports is complaining and i think it's good for everyone it allows you to de-stress you can make humor out of it so we thought we'd have a bit of fun and go through our i think we have 11 yeah board gaming pet peeves and i think it's also important because a lot of people who uh like you know comment on these kind of threads or whatever usually theirs are other people but we actually been quite lucky that our friends and gaming groups are like i don't know pretty good to game with so most of ours are kind of other things um but yeah please you know comment with your own and we'll have a good de-stress um but yeah so we're gonna work well backwards and then we will count down so we're going to start with number 11.

okay so first up is number 11 and that is arbitrary first player choices how do you describe it well yeah just conditions conditions arbitrary picking the first who goes first exactly and this was one i selected actually um i don't know if you find it as annoying as me maybe you don't because usually it's you who always gets to go first why because i've watched the martian first exactly no no the latest so that one's on recently on mars the player who's watched the martian and i'm like the only one on the table who's ever watched the martian so yeah hence that's why it annoys me i think it's quite they can be quite humorous and funny yeah in the first game when it's something like that but if you play a game multiple times and it's always going to be the same person who is always first and that's quite annoying there's another one um which is the youngest player gets to start i can't remember which game it is but again always going to be the same person if you grew a game with the same people yeah jaws game last person who was on a boat i believe maybe that was something else could be i like it because i like boats i am often on boats but if i'm on a boat usually you're there as well yeah so it's just uh never seems to benefit me so that's irritating yeah i care less about this one um but i mean it's a good point considering some games there might

be a first player advantage as well and if you have the same player doing it time and time again because like being the youngest for example yeah but yeah so that was number 11. let us know if you agree or disagree uh coming on to number 10 this is something that i put in and it's obviously because it's at the end of the list it's more of a minor thing but pay for money pay for money in games uh it just annoys me just use it's more because the paper that they make it with it's not like real money which is like easy to grasp and differentiate uh it's usually really hard and tedious to uh it's not tactile right to shift convert money into other money so you know it's games i don't know lord of vegas and some like 18xx games obviously paper money it just makes the game a hassle to play if you don't have iron clays or poke chips or something yeah and i just think it's always better to have cardboard punch out coins at worst because it's just sure maybe paper money like adds to the theme but it's not tactile yeah i was actually going to say i guess maybe some games where you need a lot of money to do it in paper it's like lighter for the boxers that's true that's got to be fair cardboard coins it's not that much heavier than that so yeah yeah so yeah number ten okay so number nine is

people who are really smug when they win and i'm looking directly at you i would like to actually say that i was thinking about this because i know you put it specifically because of me and actually what it is is that you get you show your emotions so much at the end of the game and you're mad that you've lost that it makes me laugh but then it's gonna make it worse so i try and hide it and then because i'm doing this weird like it makes me look really smug and it sets you up even more so no but sometimes it's not just your smug face which yes is very annoying uh sometimes you're like oh well who's won this game uh 10 times tally and that is incredibly annoying so that actually does come out verbally as well yeah that's because you're giving me credit very annoying and the thing is there's no reason for him to be smug because he's winning eighty percent of the game i should be the smug one that i do win maybe even you are smug i'm not i'm just proud of myself because i never win because you're like easy nice there's a fine line then i guess between being smug and being proud of yourself yeah and you hit the wrong side of the line uh yeah i mean i don't have a particular problem with this even when someone else is being smug think of a particular friend who maybe is quite smug sometimes who's that i won and it was the first time i've been oh yeah yeah but now it's like a joke now so

we know yeah we have a friend to he every if he wins a game it's the first time this play it doesn't matter if it's the first time we've all played it mostly first time first time playing like it's the first time we're all playing yeah yeah no i mean i've gotten used to it now i think it annoyed me more before but now it's just like become like almost a meme right now yeah there you go number nine smug winners okay number eight and this is one of my ones and that is family members who only want to play that one game you introduce to them obviously if you're an avid board gamer you generally have quite a big collection and you're always getting new games it's like the chase chase for the new uh thrill of the new and so obviously a lot of times when you do get family round or you're spending time with them you have something cool to introduce them and because they're not board gamers you know they always want to play that one game you showed them two years ago that they like rather than learn something new yeah they want to stick with something crazy that they know and you're like i've got and obviously some of those games as well it feels two years ago you probably played it like 50 times it's like for example code names i don't know like played it like i still play it obviously but we've played like 50 times and if we come there and we're like oh we've got this new word game and they're like yeah can't we just play code names like no we can't learn the new thing yeah and the thing is they had to have

learned that thing that they liked in the first place just like come on just learn this new one because you'll probably like it just as much as that one that you insist on playing and you know we had to teach that to you at some point so just open your mind a little bit and then be a bit more open to a new learning experience no this one's a bit more tongue-in-cheek obviously because but it's just stuff like and then you have the problem when you finally do introduce them to a new game then they just want to play that game yeah yeah it's like we introduced el dorado to like my mom's stuff and now el dorado is all she wants to play yeah so now it's like struggle to make a learn something else right exactly but uh but yeah so that's i mean i'm sure a lot of people do experience this if your family aren't bored gamers where you just like they just want to play that one like low-level game and they all really enjoy so yeah that was number eight number seven and this is games where the amount of components is disproportionate to like the level of play where and what i mean is where a box comes with like a thousand on one components but it only takes an hour to play you know i mean so i'm thinking of like orleans for example or imperial steam where it's an absolute nightmare to set up and you have all of these little tokens you have to sell out and there's like a hundred cardboard you know pop-out pieces but it's really kind of simple to play quick to play plays in an hour hour and a half and it's just that this proportionality does like mildly annoy me sometimes yeah for sure

even though some of those games are our favorite yeah 100 it's just it's like annoying right because then you feel like for orleans we've honestly talked about getting like a you know a component tray to make the setup quicker because we don't get it to the table as much because of all like the setup and the components and the finickiness because you can't just be there on a game night it's like getting a bit lame like okay we'll have one more game let's get our orleans because then it's going to take like 20 minutes to set up yeah which is a shame because like i said it's one of our favorites we'd like to introduce it to more people but yeah the the time and the it's the finickiness actually isn't it more than anything and they're like yeah i guess yeah it is just some games are it's a lot of like kind of old-style euro games are a bit like that aren't they where they just like really have a disproportionate amount of components and pieces compared to what the game is yeah on a related note maybe not to do the number of components but i hate it when a game has lots of like unique components where it has like uh like a round marker or something like that and it's like where do you put all of these single tokens that you have do you know what i mean so they can't just all go in a bag together and there's like a big chunk of the same component but they'll be like that one component goes over there and that one component goes there and it's like all these like small individual pieces that can be a little bit annoying yeah no i agree i think some prime examples of this would be um as you said imperial steam orleans i was just looking dinosaur island's a pretty bad one for that

because it's quite like a kind of lighter weight game and it has so many like cardboard pieces and they're like different player counts of different tokens so it's like uh what else we've got i think yeah some stuff like that but vindication a little bit because you have all those tiles and stuff that's not too bad to be fair but yeah so that would be number seven which is board games that have way too many components for their weight and length

okay and in at number six is weirdly shaped boxes and what we mean by that is boxes that don't seem to conform to a normal shape or size yeah i'm thinking of concordia actually right now i like that it's a very thin box thin boxes big thumbs up from me but it's then made like wider and longer than all of our other boxes and it just makes it a little bit tricky to know how to store them yeah it makes it look awkward when you have like a nice kind of storage setup of games and then you have these weird ones and also as the other part of this we're talking about not just weird shapes but ones where they just don't fill the space yeah that is so irritating it's like i think it is like one of that where the box is like pretty huge and it could be about one third of the size yeah because it's like so much empty space yeah exactly and it's just like i mean so many games do it well it's like you have root which is like an exceptionally well sized box you have brass birming which has a thinner than usual box um it's just yeah packed and uh makes the most of the space yeah it's just you know obviously as board game collectors we have a lot of games but not a lot of space so when companies are making these huge boxes that have a lot of wasted space i mean big boxes are fine if the space is

needed and warranted when it's a lot of wasted space it just feels a little bit irritating um because we are running out of space we live in a city apartment and you know if companies could alleviate that do better just do better do better it'll just really help us out and then we could buy more games because we'd have more space and we can give a great example here because the number one uh worth sinner in this category are those games or the publishers of those games that your family has that they get out at christmas so this might be just a british one but there's one called drum and park who do like they do articulate and the logo game yeah and all of those like like little family games that your family probably has had for like 15 years um and they do a normal sized game box and they just have a big crappy plastic insert in and usually it's like one deck of cards like a very small board that yeah like flips into basically a small triangle and then like you know a timer and a few like plastic pieces yeah and it's a full-sized box and you could literally get it into like the size of the cards against humanity box almost honestly yeah like with like with a little bit wider for the board and they're awful for that like we've actually you could honestly put about three or four of those games into one box which we have done we have done yeah

and yeah but like we said i think there are there are a lot of ones concordia is probably the winner for we're the shape innis could do with a lot less space uh it's like cosmic encounters one was pretty bad as well because like i have about six expansions in cosmic counterparts and there's still room for more stuff whereas like the inside it's hard to even get the original stuff back in make it make sense yeah it's just like just do look at route look at prospering and make bad boxes favorite culture is a good one as well yeah lovely sized books yeah kind of a weird shape to be fair but it is nice and compact and small i think it can be weird if it's compact yes yeah but yeah so misshapen boxes so we come on to number five and this is bad rule books and more specifically bad rule books when it's from uh an established publisher or it's a big money kickstarter or these games that have like you know sold crazy amounts of copies and yet the rule book looks like it hasn't been you know edited yeah well i had like a professional look at it um and i think it just stings a bit when you look at this kickstarter that's made you know millions and millions and none of it's gone towards a rule book and then people are struggling to know how to play the game i think

awakened realms or one company that i know kind of a bit no toys for this like i think other fields as famously the rulebook was pretty rough uh we had our own issues with like the nemesis mainly lockdown raw book because it actually somehow was of worse quality than the original nemesis despite the fact that they copied most of it yeah so i don't know how that works but yeah do you have any examples you would i would you i wouldn't know because i don't read the rule books no you've only ordered you've only done like what two teachers ever alice guy because i bought well read the rulebook and done the teams you've done teachers before what else it was i think out of sky is generally the onion i thought i have another one uh i really can't remember but yeah so it doesn't impact me so feel free on that one no but like bad raw books is definitely i just i i don't mind so much if it's a bad rule book and it's like a smaller game or you know what i mean like someone doing on their own i just can't stand yet because like a well-established company putting out of rule book and it just being absolutely trashed and like why what's the what's the excuse here yeah but yeah so that was bad rulebooks now we're on number four which is lying about the play account and this is where games you know they say i don't know for one to seven

players and if you're not playing at four you're not getting a real experience um because i mean there are a few reasons why sometimes uh you know it's cynical and it's just that they want to sell more games other times it might not be so cynical and the designers really believe that it's good at two players or you know whatever or that um they just wanted to be played by as many people as possible but it's tough right because if you spend your money on a game and you want it to be as good at all play accounts more or less and it's very disappointing when you spend your money and it's not and it's hard to know that which is why we do our what games are good at two-player series you know it's not specifically for two-player yeah exactly so we think uh root is a pretty good bad bad example no i think it's just common right it's very common example yeah so that has on the base game what two two four players but if you play it two the recommended uh factions that you play with are just the the cats and the eerie so you're not getting that full experience that you would have even just by adding that third player so that's obviously very disappointing if you've if you spent your hard-earned cash on a game and that is addressed with the clockwork expansion we do really enjoy playing it at two players but the fact that you have to add an expansion to make it worth playing when actually the base

game did say two players it's just a bit disappointing yeah i mean because it's not recommended that you play with the alliance or the vagabond so you like you buy it and then it's not recommended to play with half of the factions in the game right which would be disappointing yeah i think another example for us scythe is our favorite game if you're a view of the channel you know that we never play two players we just think it doesn't hold up particularly well even compared to three and say that it's a kind of game where two people could play it in two separate rooms and have the same game yeah um so you know that's another example i think it's fine as well when there might be like a third player variant or yeah who acts as a third player like june imperium for instance yeah or coffee traders for us we don't mind the third player sort of dummy variant yeah and it's you're getting in some games maybe a different experience than you would get with a real third player and that's fine as long as it's still the same amount of fun even if they're they're different exactly but it's when you're getting less fun by playing at two players that's a good point we're talking about it's when it's like a pale imitation of what it is yeah at another account right that's that's the problem and you know games where they say i don't know two to five but really you only ever want to play it three to five for example yeah so yeah that is our number four pet peeve which is

games that lie about their play accounts okay and in at number three is actually deciding what game to pick and play any given moment the hardest thing of being a board game yeah which is a really tough problem to have in life right too many games to play like picking a show on netflix yes exactly so yeah sometimes we just find that we spend tens of minutes just trying to pick a game to play because you know we do have some new games coming through so there's always the kind of push and drive to play them but also some older beloved things that maybe we played a lot when we first got them but maybe haven't got them out in a year that we just really want to play but actually you want to play the new game and then maybe you have friends around who also want to play other things as well so actually just picking a game to play can be quite hard because it can be just very dependent on your on your mood and the time that you have and all of these different factors right yeah we we tend to now a lot of times use randomizer where everyone will put in a game or two into the randomizer and we randomize it um but yeah like you say it's just like it's surprisingly tough when you have this big collection you're like oh we can play anything they're all good yeah but you know different people different levels of ability different you know everything really yeah does it get a bit spoiled by

choice 100 and i think like as a slightly less pet peeve it's tough sometimes it's really tough to play a game so you really want to play not for any particular reason but because maybe you know if you have a new game and you teach it to everyone and then they're kind of tall that game is new you still want to play it but maybe there's an older game that you play like two or three times that you really do want to get out again but you'd have to teach it to new people and you weigh up the two right so we've recently we've had this with pax vikings which we played it a couple of times when we got it like two or three we really enjoyed it but you do have to play it with more players like that's a good example from the previous one actually where it was all right too but it's such an interactive game that at two i think you very much be on separate ends of the board and like kind of win without the other player being able to do anything whereas when you have kind of four to six it's it really shines uh and we struggled we really wanted to play and we just struggled to get it to the table because the time was never right yeah and we recently did it and everyone enjoyed it so that was good fun yeah definitely but uh if anyone has a good system for this and making sure that like games are in rotation of an equal amount maybe uh maybe there's some kind of list system where okay you've got your new games you want to play but like ranking some of the older ones you haven't got out in a while so that if you're ever in a pickle about what to pick you can actually just consult the list maybe there's some kind of system like that let us know in the comments what you do to help you

pick your games so that was number three picking again okay so our number two is people who give up in a game because it's looking like they're gonna lose and uh self-explanatory really you're self-explanatory i might be a bit guilty of this myself oh you stopped playing what you stopped playing no actually i would never stop playing i never concede but i do get in a bit of a bad mood sometimes what's the point in carrying on usually when you've done something annoying to me in a game pro gamer move no just really annoying going on me what do you mean like last night yeah let's not talk about it because i'll get really mad dead reckoning to be fair at least that was like the last turn though you didn't have to play for much longer it's not like i made you play for another hour well that is true yeah um but yeah so obviously i think i'm the same like i'll fully admit that there's times where i've basically had like a hissy fit right but i do like in a game if i'm not gonna win but i do have a real innate drive to still do the best i can so i'll be absolutely miserable but i will still like play as best i can yeah uh i just can't like i've enjoyed playing board games too much i can't give up on myself no no i wouldn't give up fame the best example i

can think of is um that time we played barrage two player for the first time and i basically misinterpreted one of the tiles i bought and so it didn't do what i think and my whole strategy based around what i thought it did and so basically like that was game over and i was so mad at myself but i still like did everything i could right even though i was a bit pointless at that point and i had a good time in the end because i enjoy playing barrage but yeah yeah and as annoying as it is you have to carry on playing for the other players as well because it's not fair on them to just give up and not care like and not play a real game because they might be relying on you to do like real moves and like carry on exactly you're trying i think that's a another example we've had before where it's happened and like someone's given up and it was a game where what if they play properly it affects other players yeah because it triggers things for them and it when you stop playing it's like if there's five people in this game you begin to ruin it for the like everyone around you and because that can really affect like who can win and who can lose if you're not playing like a normal gamer yeah i think that that's yeah that's definitely um so yeah i mean like i said it's pretty self-explanatory to be honest uh i think i could understand the kind of mood yeah but you feel deflated right and then you just can't be bothered to carry on it's just kind of like if that's

the way you're going to be maybe it's best if you don't play do you know what i mean yeah yeah at the end of the day it's supposed to be fun supposed to be i mean a lot of time we've been playing a lot of games lately where we've got three it's got pretty stuff savager yeah ultimate railroads and dead reckoning my favorite but yeah so that was number two people who give up during a game so here we are number one board of its biggest pet peeve and it is people no not really it's um specifically people who kind of treat discussion around board games uh as though it's factual and not opinion based like people who don't respect that you have an opinion on the game and all people are different and people some people like some games some people don't like the same games and they slam them or criticize them for what they like basically because there's so much diversity in mechanisms types of games and just the amount of people who slam other people for liking something like pretty grim yeah it's actually wild to think that some people do think that everyone should just have the same opinion when there's so many games like obviously everyone likes different things and your experience with the game can be obviously influenced by a multitude of factors as well yeah so to be told like okay your opinion is wrong yeah is

you know it's pretty kind of special yeah and it's like uh you know and so there's two levels for us because we obviously do reviews and the first level is just generally like in the community people saying it to each other and the second level is us getting it like with our reviews and you know it's like so for the first level the example is spoke to someone once and they'd put they made a top 10 list for fun of their games of the year and this couple years ago and they put tapestry in it which you know kind of divisive um i don't think anyone has it in their kind of you know top 10 games of all time we like it but it's not the best game ever made and there was a lot of controversy around it as well um and they basically put it in and they kind of caveated it with i believe they've played it mostly solo and it's quite good solo and they hadn't played that many games that year and they told us they told us that they got people commenting being like your entire list is absolute garbage because you put tapster in like your opinion means nothing and it's like why why what's nice and it's like how grim is that for someone to say that to you like and then obviously the other level is that we're reviewers and it's opinion based yeah exactly and yeah i just think maybe the way we present our reviews you know we we just say what we think about the game and people take that as that we're saying maybe that everyone needs to think this

when really we're just describing and explaining our experience with a game which like i said could be influenced by a lot of things i think some people expect it to be um what's the word factual yeah and and objective when of course it's subjective because it's again like i said our experience with it maybe there are some of you who do make it more objective and maybe are stating facts about the game i don't know i think we're pretty like because we generally say that uh we're like look people aren't gonna like this we do or you know exactly yeah that's what i mean yeah that's what i mean so we're just saying how we think about it what others might like about it but again it's based on our experience of it not yeah i mean if you review in any medium it's always an opinion because it's shaped by what you like your experiences like your mood just your life in general it's all shaped as an opinion any review of anything is an opinion that's why you find the reviewers that have the same opinions as you and you watch them because then anything that they recommend you know that you'll like um i think you can find reviewers that don't align with you as well because again if it's opinion based you can just take the parts of it that resonate with you or don't resonate with you and maybe there's reviewers that you maybe don't align with on a lot of their opinion but that can also help to to inform if you think you are going to like that game because maybe that

person's critiques or negatives are positives for you and you just need to take what's relevant for you and you know take the parts that resonate and like let go of the other stuff that doesn't okay well that's their opinion i don't agree exactly and what's i think really interesting to us is we do this channel because it's like a creative outlet but also we want people to we want to expand the board game scene we want people to find games they really like we want people to enjoy themselves we want to recommend things that we like and that's why we're doing it and we we obviously thought that people watch because they want to know about a game but actually a lot of people which we didn't expect to watch our videos are people who have already played the game and they have the game they've played like 50 times since their favorite game and i guess we all do it it's like confirmation bias where you want other people to see the thing you like as you hear like you want someone to reinforce your beliefs and that's where we honestly get the most like hey when is people who have this game they've played and they love it and they come to our video and we like criticize part of it and they're like what are you talking about and they like kick off us and you know criticize us and it's like it's an opinion and the good the the funniest example and it's deleted so i think it's fine to say it was uh we did a review of beyond the sun

and we were kind of in the minority in that a lot of other people you know professional reviewers community at large they all loved it and we were really like eh we thought the mechanics were nice but we got bored of playing it after a couple of games and we didn't think the replayability was there in the same way other people did and we had usability issues as well so we were i wouldn't say we're negative but we're like yeah and we actually said in it we're like everyone else loves it so like watch other reviews see what other people say like because we aren't status quo i think that's quite fair and we got someone who commented and it was funny because they'd commented deleted it and rewritten it four times and i could see through the notifications like every iteration for some reason and it basically was like the first one was a completely fair comment it was just like oh i really like this game i like it because of this uh it's one of the best games i've played and like that was it and it's like of course it's their opinion they're completely right if they enjoy it they enjoy it right and then every iteration apparently that wasn't enough and they were like frothing at what we said i don't know if it's because they're watching more and more of the review or something but they basically got meaner and more personal every iteration till the comment was something like you saw it gone what i i was all deleted by the time yeah so it basically just said um it was like

how dare you beyond the sun is one of the best games i've ever played i play a brand new game at least once a week and out of all those games this is the best one um and it was like ah like obviously your channel's absolute crap and everything you do is worthless if this is what you think of beyond the sun and it was just like whoa okay and i think i just commented back and said something like first of all it's an opinion like this is our opinion of the game second of all uh i don't know why us disagreeing with you on one game out of 50 000 board games like kind of makes everything else yeah it makes everything we've ever done worthless to anyone right uh and yeah and then they just delete it and that was that yeah i guess that is the thing it's when people become like very personal about it when of course it's personal because it's about your experience but it's when yeah i think it's just when people get a bit disrespectful and comfort you personally rather than disagreeing maybe with your opinion on that game like we've said absolutely fine if you can sort of disagree and have a good discussion with someone in a respectful way then that's often where some of the best discussions come from but if you're just going to attack people personally for their opinions yeah then it's just not cool yeah i guess it's just interesting because obviously the thing is we we do a channel right so people can comment whatever they want and like that's just how it is like we do it we get that yeah can't complain about it but it's just

interesting that i think we expected more like i don't know negative comments about anything right like whatever but it's just always people that like really enjoy their games and then they watch our reviews and we criticize something they get mad at us and it's just quite interesting because it's just not something we expected no but yeah i mean so this is obviously in general i think not just we're saying this to reviewers but we see it all the time and yeah it's the thing i hate most i think about board gaming is just the fact that people are so like rude to each other about things they like yes it's just you know just in any space it's not cool yeah it's it's obviously an opinion like objectively there is nothing objectively basically yeah all right so that was our number one pet peeve and it was people who don't take the discussion around board games as an opinion but treat it like that another snappy title we're all about snappy tiles okay so that was our top 11 border bits board gaming pet peeves hope you enjoyed that video and just remember it was just for a little bit of fun and so that we can all have a little bit of a rant together and it's quite therapeutic to do that sometimes uh let us know in the comments if you agree with any of ours or disagree and just if you have any ones yeah i know you're gonna have different ones this is a safe space let us know but thanks very much for watching and if

you enjoyed this video we'd really appreciate it if you give us a thumbs up and subscribe to our channel if you're not already exactly and we'll be back as usual next time with our reviews yeah and we're going to be reviewing some very mean games so if you like mean games come back for that good times good times thanks for watching

Progress saved