Villagers Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everyone today i'm going to be talking about villagers which is a one to five player board game designed by harkengada and published by sinister fish games this one plays in about 30 to 60 minutes and accommodates one to five players so this game came out in 2019 and i think was kick-started in 2018 and had a relatively successful campaign and started getting some good uh good reviews and good feedback from its players it wouldn't when it did come out and that was quite surprising because harkengarda was i think this is his first game he brought out which is uh quite a quite a big praise to him that he's had his first design was very well received and i thought you know because of that good praise and um you know you know the good reviews and the actual concept of the game i was quite intrigued to play this one because this game you are building your own village as the as the name would suggest uh of all these different villagers with different skills making these kind of tech trees of all your different people trying to make as much money as you can in the two scoring phases so initially i was quite surprised by this one because i wasn't quite sure what to expect and the first play left me feeling a bit underwhelmed because i was expecting something a bit more involved and a bit more heavy um but when i got my head around that and started to understand what the game was all about you know it did start to click with me so essentially this is a a car drafting game and uh you are on a tableau building game as well as you obviously playing these cards down and you are going to well the the the way the game plays out is going to be
quite simple because you can have a a row of cards with all these different uh these different villagers with different skills from i think three different or even more than that different categories you've got your your all workers you've got your woodworkers and you've got your kind of forager kind of type as well as well as people who kind of work in their own right and the the way the game plays out is going to start with a basic ability to draw two of those cards from this row and put it into your hand and once everybody does does that taking turns you are going to be able to play to those cards um but playing those cards isn't always as easy as first expected because a lot of them have pre-requisites on them so for example if you had a say a carpenter you might need the lumberjack in order to actually play that carpet in the first place so you've got this real texture in a development of your of your abilities that you can actually use at any time in in a quite a logical and thematic way as well because as i said you know you couldn't have a carpenter unless somebody's actually going out there and getting the wood in the first place and that that in itself is a really cool idea for me i like the way that works you know it's easy to wrap your head around and i think it just it just flows nicely the there's also like a starting ability as well where you have your your founders of your villagers which again is another kind of starting point for you to build off and that's not going to be how the game plays out as you as you get more and more cars getting more and more advanced on these trees getting further and further uh down on them but another interesting thing about these these as well is that at least certain workers have have these tech
trees that need very particular things before them so you know they might have a chain of maybe only two different uh different cards or some might have a chain of four different cards and these ones with four different cards are naturally going to be very hard to actually um to play out not only because it's taking time to get them out but because you need particular cards in order to do so and but they're going to give you a lot more stronger rewards when it comes to those scoring phases because at certain points in the game where after a certain number of cards have been drafted then there's going to be a an initial phase where only your on your gold coins are scored from your cards and at the end of the game all your gold and silver coins are scored and knowing how to pace that is quite important as well because initially you might want to get loads of cards out as quickly as you can in order to score as many points in that first phase to get a leg up on your opponent or you can really focus through that end game scoring and try to tailor your strategy to get those loads of points that way so you know not only in these tech trees are important but also some cards have the um ability to kind of unlock other cards as well so using the carpet as an example again there can be i think maybe even more than 10 cards throughout the deck of the deck of the game that need the carpenter in order to unlock it and the cool thing about this game is that not only can if you if you have the carpenter you can actually take money for the bank if you have um if you have that card but other people other players can use that card that you've already bought so for example if they needed a carpenter in order to to unlock one of their cards they can
actually pay you in order to use your carpenter which you know obviously benefits them but at the same time it's going to give you points as well when it comes to scoring so you've got to bear that in mind as well so there are quite a few different routes you can go down you know really focusing on your woodwork focusing on your ore focusing on your on your other things as well or even the isolated workers score points in lots of different ways so some of them might work in fashions in ways such as you know for every all symbol you have you score x amount of points or you know if you have this card score this many points and so on so there are lots of different tech trees and things to go down but because not all the cars are used in every game and obviously they come out of different orders and things it's quite a tactical way of thinking and you're just reacting to what's out there and trying to or keep you keep your options open but at the same time if you want to go for those more ambitious tech trees maybe um you might be kind of pigeonholing yourself a bit in order to go that route so you've got to keep an open mind about things you want to do because you are always obviously reacting to the cards that are available anytime so i said in meaningful decision-wise it is decent there are there are different things to focus on um you know you you can try and stop your opponents from going for certain things if you know a particular card is what they're after and but at the same time i think majority in the majority of time you're going to be focusing on on your own little puzzle and your own little tableau rather than what your opponent's doing but still it's something to bear in mind and at the end of every round that cardboard is going to be um any unpurchased card's going to have a coin accumulated on them ready for the next round
um so you've got that extra incentive to take one of those cards but after that those cards are wiped uh ready for ready for a whole fresh batch of cards the two player variant is slightly different where if you want to keep a certain card in play that you haven't drafted this round then you can choose to put a coin on them to keep it in play but there are some other cool things you can go down as well so not only trying to focus on actual getting particular cards you want because you start with a base ability of being able to draw or draft two cards per round you can actually focus on getting these um these meal symbols or these these food symbols which means that if you have more of those on show then you can actually end up drawing more cards per turn and in the same vein you've got your building symbols as well which means that you can actually build more cars per round around and you are you know you start with a base level of two but you get capped at a maximum level of five but i think if you want to do well at this game you're going to have to at least pay some attention to doing that because if if your opponent is constantly bashing down five cards at a time and you are only playing two at a time then they're they're obviously going to do a bit better than you are but at the same time sometimes you might not want to take cards you can actually choose to trade in cards from your hand in order to take new fresh new fresh starting points in terms of your lumberjacks or your miners etc so you've got that constant idea of trying to you know trying to be as efficient as you can trying to bring out carton into your hand and into your tableau in order to get as many points as you can when it comes to scoring and that's going to be how the game's going to play out so very simply mechanically drafting cards and playing them and
before you know it there's that that deck of cards or the the card power's going to quickly deplete and the game is going to be over so it's a very quick game and considering the box says 30 to 60 minutes i think i think that 60 minutes is an absolute stretch really i think you can get this done more around that 30 minute mark so you know once i once i started to understand that this game is actually a relatively light game it's a i said it's a game where you're pretty much reacting to what you've got then i started to actually get quite comfortable with it and started to enjoy what it has to offer because actually does flow very nicely um i think it just works well for what it's trying to do the the balance of the game as well is while you are somewhat subject to the luck of the card the draw of the cards etc the backs of the cards aren't completely all the same so if you wanted to take a lucky dick in terms of getting a particular card you wanted at least you know the suit of the card you're drawing from rather than just um you know just top decking and hoping you get what you want so that's a bit of a bit of mitigation there and i you know alternatively i think all the different routes you can go down have uh have a good chance of offering you a chance of winning so that's nice except mechanically very smooth and simple easy to understand easy to digest and um and it works well time investment as i mentioned plays very quickly certainly doesn't drag on longer than it needs to and i think it flows well not much downtime and you know you're constantly thinking about what you're going to play next and what you're going to draft next you've got a good amount of turnouts there you know if you want a particular card and it's your opponent's go they're going to take the card you want them
naturally that's going to be a good a good kind of amount or an injection of player interaction and at the same time in terms of player interaction you've got that mechanism where if you have a certain card and you really need to use it you can end up paying your opponent in order to use that card to to play something yourself so that's another another nice um implementation of player interaction which isn't particularly you know obtrusive or in your face and it just works well there are some other kind of alternative cards as well you can use that that give you amount amount of uh play and manipulation on the board so you've got these kind of dummy cards which you can switch out for others etc to really tink with your tableau and try and be you know a bit more savvy about how you play things more efficiently and uh replayability as well there are some cool different tech trees you can go down and you know if you as i said if you want to go for something particularly ambitious you can try that um but you know ultimately it's going to play the same or very similarly but i think because it's so quick and snappy and pretty engaging then i think you know the replayability holds up quite well aesthetically is something i'm in two minds about uh villagers because while the the game has a very minimalist look they're very white with a very white cards with um you know bold text on them and that's nice in a way because you can clearly see all the information that you need to see at a glance so for example you can see all the tech trees that you need you know for example to play this card you need these prerequisites um and you know it will show what what
cards can build off of this card at you know at a moment's glance you can see if the cards need padlocks or have padlocks on them so you need another card to unlock them you know very simply and and so yeah so yeah in terms of holding the information and portraying that information i think the cards do a really good job because i think a lot of the games that do have a lot of card information on them can be a bit busy and that works against it but so in that respect i think the the artwork and design works well but what i don't like about the about the aesthetic of the game is the artwork itself so all the all the different villagers have quite a weird art style on them where they have these almost computerized cartoony graphics but with these weird googly large eyes that don't quite fit well and all the artwork looks pretty pretty weird and soulless it gives you a bit of a bit of a weird feeling but um you know i'm being a bit nitpicky there but i thought the artwork could have been a bit nicer a bit more um a bit warmer and a bit you know a bit a bit nicer to look at but as i said the the actual functionality of the pieces is very good the um the the theme of the game i think it works well you know for example having to have certain prerequisites which work thematically in order to play other ones that that makes things easier to explain and i think the theme does does fit quite well and set up and tear down time is pretty good as well just shuffling up different piles of cards and dishing out the initial starting hands so again um you know set up time is absolutely fine and something i should
have said as well about the component quality is that the the money resource in this game is absolutely shoddy it looks awful there's absolutely no graphic design or artwork on them what whatsoever literally just a a gold coin with a with a with a number written on it or a silver coin with a number written on it with pretty low quality pieces as well so that you know again another another thing that throws the components a bit off for me um progression of the game it works pretty well i mean for a quick quick game you can focus on your ability to constantly draw more cards or play more cards so you know by the end of the game you're playing a lot more cards than you were at the beginning of the game and obviously you're you're expanding your tech trees further and further so it has a nice progression of it and in terms of uh you're churning out your points as well as i said you can really focus on being a top heavy on the game by getting loads of points in that first phase and maybe getting uh you know the same amount of points in the second phase or you can really focus something you know for your end game scoring so the pacing of the game is something you can tailor to your own needs really so it does work absolutely fine and scalability as well works works absolutely fine at all player counts the slight uh the slight alteration of the rules works perfectly fine in a two-player game so you can get a you can get a two-player game with the whole feeling of the game without without sacrificing any of the gameplay so any player account works absolutely fine for me in uh in villages and comparisons while there are lots of tableau building games there are lots of uh lots of card drafting games the way this one builds uh merges the two together works nicely
there's certainly nothing in this game that doesn't need to be there i think it does what it's supposed to do well once you understand that it is a light game um and you aren't having these extremely advanced and sophisticated tech trees i think this is something you can you can really enjoy so yeah overall i think this is a really pleasant game and something that or or certainly a great first design by garda who said it was completely unknown before this game this is a great uh a great first first game to kind of give your or give the kind of games that you'd like to put out so light enough to be accessible but still has enough to enough interesting decisions throughout without being incredibly deep but still having enough going on in it to keep you interested i think i think this is a nice game that comes together well simple mechanism certainly doesn't do anything anything new or particularly innovative but i do like the the meshing of the theme and the simple mechanisms i think it all comes together in a nice package that's quick to play it's fun it's uh you know it's reactive but you can still focus on things and ultimately a game that i would happily play almost any time so um yeah i can understand why this one was as successful as it is i think it's a great almost gateway to next level game that you can introduce to people and it it's gonna hold up well i think because it doesn't have anything that doesn't need to be there and it flows nicely so that is villagers by harken garda certainly worth checking out if you like this style of game so i hope you've enjoyed this review if you
have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye