Scale is Overrated (Here's Why)
Transcript
In this video, I'll tell you about scales in wargaming miniatures, how they're measured, and why they're not nearly as important as you think. Wargaming is one of the few hobbies where you have to concern yourself about scale. I mean, well, there's probably also a lot of scale concern in model trains as well, right? Now that I think about it, like if a train is the wrong size, then it won't fit on the tiny little train tracks, I assume, right? Therefore, having all of your trains the exact same scale is pretty important. However, having all of your wargaming stuff on a single board doesn't mean that it all needs to be in the exact same scale. Believe it or not, there's some wiggle room. Really, do you understand scale in wargaming? It's okay if you don't. It's a little confusing.
Definitions of the word scale in general read from, you know, a graduated range of values forming a standard system for measuring or grading something to the relative size or extent of something. And while both of those are true and kind of have to do with how we use it in miniature wargaming, it's actually more specific with our miniatures. It all kind of starts with a person. Well, you know, more of a a model of a person. In wargaming, scale is usually measured thusly. A model is measured from the soles of the feet like where it's standing on the base to the level of the eyes, not the top of the head, right?
And and that measurement is done in millimeters because the metric system is better. So when you hear about miniatures being 28 mm scale, which is one of the most popular miniature scales in current wargaming, then that's what that means. 28 mm from the bottom of the feet to roughly where the eyes are on the model. Other popular scales are like six millimeter which is generally battlettech scale although the little mechs aren't 6 millimeters tall but if a person was outside the mech standing next to the mech they would be 6 mm tall so that's where that comes from and then of course 15 mm which is used in games like flames of war you know and and many others so scale is absolute right like specific measurements done in millimeters and everyone agrees right well no um you See, some people who make miniatures will sometimes work towards a little bit of a smaller scale, like 25 mm. Others start to head towards 30 mm or 32mm with their sculpts. If you look at games like Marvel Crisis Protocol and Star Wars Shatterpoint, they make their models at 40 mm. Now, some say that this is to make the models bigger and more heroic, you know, like the Marvel game is specifically about heroes, superheroes actually. Um, others say that it's to make you buy all new terrain.
But why would you need to buy new terrain? Well, because terrain also has a scale as well. It's based off of the size that figures are in relation to the terrain pieces, right? A 28 mm figure looks really out of place or perhaps monstrous next to terrain meant for a 15 mm scale game. A six millimeter scale battlettech mech looks really tiny next to 28 millimeter scale buildings. Honestly, the only really allpurpose piece of terrain at nearly every scale is the rocky outcropping. The good old rocky outcropping. It can work as basically terrain in nearly any scale for wargaming from 6 mm to way beyond.
So that's that. Make sure your models and terrain all match numbers scale-wise, right? But rocky outcroppings that they're always okay no matter what scale. So, you'll be fine and then everything will be great, right? Right. Maybe not. Um, like I said earlier, some companies follow different scale variations than others. If you stick directly to very specific scale numbers for your models in your games, then you'll probably be limiting the models that you have available to you for your games that you like to play. And limits aren't much fun, are they? Now, I'll admit, if you limit yourself to just the one game, then you probably won't have to worry. But again, what fun is that? Generally, if you buy all your models from a single company, you know, a single manufacturer for a single game, then you usually shouldn't need to worry about scale much. All Warhammer 40k models are generally the same scale. All War Machine models are pretty much the same scale. All Battletech miniatures are supposed to be the same scale, right? Etc. The issues can come when you start to like mix and match from different companies and then you 3D print some stuff or whatever and you kit bash like fun models for games whether they're miniature agnostic games or not.
That's when the scale numbers can get a little weird and some miniatures won't be the exact same size as others. But here is a bit of a controversial take. scale isn't so precious that you can't mix and match some of the different sizes together. If you have a smattering of models that you're trying to put together for a game, something miniature agnostic or maybe even something that's not technically miniature agnostic, but you still want to like proxy your own models anyway, then that's totally fine. Some people get real fussy about all of their models, let's say an entire group of humans, just to make it easier, being all exactly the same size. And that's not how it works.
I'm an entire foot taller than my wife. And yet, we are the same scale. Take a look at Dwayne the Rock Johnson and Kevin Hart. They've been in a bunch of movies together. They're also the same scale. Check out this behindthe-scenes photo from the set of 1984's Conan the Destroyer. That little guy in the middle is Arnold Schwarzenegger, who is 6'2, according to the internet, like I am. Yet, he and Wilt Chamberlain and Andre the Giant are all the same scale. Not everyone on your miniature wargaming table needs to be exactly the same height. There is some wiggle room. However, there are limits to the wiggle room. wiggle limits. In my mind, and I'm not saying that you have to think this way, but in my mind, there are bands of scale that I'm fine working within, right? Like the smallest band is the 6 mm area, mech games and such. Mostly, if you put Battletech miniatures next to Steel Rift miniatures from Death Ray Designs, they pretty much look the same scale. Now, some people might think from the way that they're sort of sculpted that the steel rift models look like they should be like a little bit smaller in scale or something like that or whatever, but it that's mainly just a difference in sculpting detail and style. I think the next band up is around the 15 mm scale. This can frequently include 20 mm scale as well,
at least in my mind. Most of these games seem to be kind of historical for the most part. uh Team Yankee, Flames of War, stuff like that. Except for 15mimeter sci-fi games. 15mm sci-fi is kind of its own genre to some degree. Stuff like Star Grunt 3, Tomorrow's War, Full Spectrum Dominance, which I keep seeing more and more of online. Uh Hammer Slammers, kind of old school stuff like that. Also, you can play a lot of 28 millimeter scale games with 15 millimeter scale miniatures if you want. You just either end up having the having the, you know, the the minute the the measurements in the game. So, if it says this guy's got a range of 6 in, now it's a range of 3 in or whatever. Or, uh, in many situations, you can just change the inches to centimeters. Then we head into popular territory, the 28 mm scale band.
This generally includes everything from like 25 mm up to about 32 mm models. Nearly all of the big well-known miniatures games and most of the indie ones too, right? You know, are are in this scale. This is the scale band I usually hear the most complaints from as well. I see comments about models being a few millimeters too tall or too short in comparison to what the commenter believes to be the proper size. But again, you know, think of that photo of Arnold Schwarzenegger and his friends. Not all people are the same size. Fun fact, when you see an indie game that's called something and then it ends with the number 28, that's referring to the scale, right?
Like frankly, I wish more games would do this because then you could pick out the scale on certain games just from the name, right? I think it started with Inquisition 28 or more commonly Inc. 28, the original Inquisition game from Games Workshop, which came out in the early 2000s, was designed to be played with 54 mm models. This is mainly why it failed, among, you know, some other reasons. However, the indie community decided that it'd be a better game if it was just played at normal 28 millimeter scale, and they were right. So, they kind of picked it up and ran with it. Nowadays, adding 28 to the end of your game's title lets people know that it's generally a narratively driven miniatures game, and it's also, you know, 28mm scale. There's even a free downloadable magazine for the 28 scene called 28 magazine. Strangely enough, it's spectacular and I highly suggest that you check it out. Link in the description. For me, the best thing about playing and kit bashing in the kind of 28 mm scale band from 25 to 32 is that there's so many models to choose from and the parts can generally be mixed and matched in kit bashing without too much problem. Then we head into the next band which is kind of between 38 and 40 millimeter mostly right you know games you'll find in this area are titles like conquest the last argument
of kings from parabellum at 38 mm and Marvel Crisis Protocol and Star Wars Shatterpoint from Atomic Mass Games at 40 mm. One reason that some folks like this bigger scale I is is because it can be a little bit more fun and or easier to paint details at this scale. You know, it depends on who you talk to. I can see that to a degree, but I'll be honest, I'm pretty much happy to stay in the 28mm scale band with most of my games, except maybe mech games. And recently there's been a bit of a return to the 54mm scale that frankly didn't work out very well for GW's Inquisitor game from the early as John Blanch and Thomas Pieran are working on a dueling game called Ong Guard which is going to be 54 mm I believe. I don't know that that's really a game for me if I'm honest right but I think it'll be interesting to some folks. I don't know if it's the type of game that needs like also 54 millimeter terrain as well or maybe it can just be a bunch of those very useful rocky outcroppings. We'll see more soon.
So, generally don't sweat scale too much as long as your models are near the proper scale bands, right? 6 millimeter, 15 millimeter, 28 millimeter, 40 millimeter, and maybe even 54 millimeter, then you'll be fine. Again, some people are short and some are tall. So, a 28 mm scale figure and a 32mm scale figure can play together in the same war band and it'll be okay. Don't worry about the specific scale and instead worry about whether you're happy with your paint job. What's your wiggle limit, you know, for scale in your wargaming? Are you very strict or maybe a little bit more wiggly? Let us all know down in the comments below. And if you like videos like this explaining ideas and talking about concepts and things like that, then a little bit of depressment of the like button would be very appreciated.
It helps to get the video out to more people, helps the channel, and uh it makes me smile. If you're also interested, I make videos like this every single Friday. And if you hit the subscribe button, which is also down there, then you're more likely to see them uh every single Friday. It's free. Thanks for watching.