The Gods Will Have Blood | Review
Transcript
hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from Beyond soliter and today I'm going to be reviewing the gods will have blood a boutique project about surviving the French Revolution from Dan Bullock all right so here is a setup of the Gods will have blood uh this is a game where you have sympathized with the French Revolution you are revolutionary uh but now you are responsible for a bunch of show trials and you have got to get through this by maintaining your life and your soul uh while basically your entire situation conspires against you keeping both of those things so you're going to preside over some show Trials of people that you mostly don't care about but your choices have consequences and then there are a few people in this deck that you do care about and you don't want to send them to the guillotine but by the time they appear you know maybe the momentum will be too great maybe you'll be in a position where you cannot help them you're just going to have to see so this is a game that you can lose in many ways you can only win it in one in order to win the game you need to do two things one you need your reputation to be up here at the top on this asterisk so you've got to move your reputation up the red reputation track and you've also got to to have at least one white Cube still in the bag that you use to judge people and we're going to talk about what the trials look like meanwhile if you're going to lose there there are a lot of opportunities for that um if the pawns on these trackers reach the bottom on either side so with your reputation or with the legitimacy of the Court uh you will be killed and
you will lose the game if your reputation is not Stellar at the end of the game even if you're only one off on the track well you still lose the game and if you have three white cubes here on removed white cubes meaning that you've essentially lost your soul during this process of judgment uh well then you lose the game and what's so fun about this one is that the way that it actually works turn to turn is extremely simple all you're going to do is read about somebody that you're supposed to judge you decide what you want to do with them uh and then you see what the rest of the judging panel thought so here on this card we have a woman who does not find herself here because of her dubious politics having made a mockery of marriage and family in her plays and pamphlets instead she's in trouble because she's authored a publication encouraging the reestablishment of the monarchy such seditious behavior is a capital offense so let's look at this woman and decide you know what this this lady's guilty we want to kill her goodbye so we want to say that she's guilty but we don't get to make that decision on our own we have a court to contend with so we decide our verdict which is guilty and then we're going to draw two cubes from this bag and if at least one of them is red then the Court will agree she is guilty and we will see what happens as a result so let's draw one cube a red uh and then we'll draw one other cube a white so basically no matter what we decided about her we would have gotten what we wanted basically red is a vote to condemn and a white is a is a vote to spare to acquit so because we decided we wanted her to be guilty and
at least one Cube from the bag matches our opinion on that well guess what this lady is done for straight to the guillotine chop chop with her her so these cubes are going to go back in the bag and we're going to flip her card over and find out what happens so this back of the card tells us if she is condemned so that's the picture of the guillotine then our reputation goes up one oh baby so much reputation for killing this lady this sedici just woman um and we have to add to momentum what that means is we're going to add a Red Cube to the bag if we had decided to spare her our reputation would go down which can absolutely get you killed very quickly early in the game and it says or do not reset momentum so basically we would be faced with a decision about whether we want to reset momentum which sometimes you really want to do or loose face in front of the court so resetting momentum is important because as you might have noticed if you need to occasionally pull an innocent verdict well there's only three white cubes in the whole game there's a bunch of red ones that can go in the back if you want to pull all that momentum all those red cubes that are going in from Death after death out of the bag then you need a way to reset your momentum and put those cubes back here so sometimes when you manage to stop a death to stop a killing you get to reset momentum and that means that you're able to kind of take a breather put the balance of the bag back in order there you know you start with four red cubes and three white in here but of course things get more and more unbalanced the longer you allow the
longer you allow momentum to build you can even run out of momentum and if you need to add momentum but cannot the legit Legacy the court starts to go down because You' become overly bloodthirsty but in this case we've resolved our case this lady will be among the discarded I prefer to put them face up so I can look at what I've done and that's how a turn in the game works but of course there are a few complexities so one we discussed as momentum momentum will build the more people you kill typically uh and you have to be very careful not to let things get too out of hand or else you won't be able to stop the killing you also need to be watching these tracks right here one thing that makes them very interesting is that as you'll notice they Share three spaces so let's say that we're here if my reputation was going to go up I actually couldn't move it up because this other Pawn is in the way you can't move up into another Pawn's space to share that space however if the quartz legitimacy were to go down uh it would actually skip over me and go down an additional space because you can always fall down faster but it's harder to climb up there's also a blue cube here that's kind of like a wild Cube so when the court is is very very legitimate the blue cube goes in to help you sway decisions in a way of your choosing the other thing I want to note by the way is that once you've run out of momentum for the first time and all the momentum cubes have gone into the bag the game fundamentally changes and the way that it changes is that you split the piles of the accused in two and you start to run two trials at a time and this will persist even if you manage to reset
momentum later and that means that instead of trying each person on their own by trying two people at a time you have to make the same decision for both people and you have to take the consequences for both cards good or bad and so it's a weirdly dehumanizing experience where you're no longer giving each card their individual attention you might have someone that you want to help and then someone that you think is definitely guilty and they're just going to be in the same trial and you're going to have to make a decision that applies to both which is exceptionally nasty the other thing we'll note is that there are some blue cards in here three of them in fact to match the three white cubes in the bag and they are your friends so one of your friends has been charged with conspiracy for associating with a prostitute but he's still your friend and if he dies you have to remove a not guilty token from the Judgment pool which you really don't want to do however if you spare him you lose reputation so you need your reputation to be good enough to lose a bit uh in order to win the game or maybe you're going to have to die trying to save your friends so that is how the gods will have blood plays so it's a relatively simple game but it's on a deep topic so let's have some final thoughts about that all right so now for some final thoughts what did I think of the Gods will have blood well first things first at the beginning of the video I mentioned this is a boutique project and I just want to make it really clear right now um there were only 200 copies of this game printed that were signed and numbered by Dean Bullock I don't know about the game's future availability and I didn't really make this review to sell the game because there isn't anything to sell uh this is
I wanted to document my experience with a very very interesting project so so first off this game is fascinating in the sense that it's not really a fully commercial project the idea is not to sell more copies of the game the idea is to kind of make a small project that's a cool game design that only a few people will buy but it's sort of like a cottage industry thing so I actually applaud Dan for that because he had a vision of how he wanted this game to turn out and he went for it and honestly I really wanted this game and I knew I would so I set an alarm my phone to go back this thing on game found and just like prayed that I wouldn't be the last in line so I was very relieved to get it um I don't know what the wider availability will look like but I'm assuming if there's demand maybe there will be a P&P or some sort of print on demand situation I have no idea that would be up to Dan that said so what do I think of it as a game um I think this game is really impressive in ways that not many games are so what I love about the gods will have blood is that it has an incredible Simplicity to it while also really evoking deep problems and and creating a gaming experience that is surprisingly intense for how simple the game is the game is not hard to play you look at a card you decide whether you think a person's innocent or guilty you draw some cubes and you deal with the consequences and you move the pawns around you know you have a really really really simple gameplay setup going however the decisions that you make end up becoming very painful because you need to get
your reputation up in order to survive to get your reputation up you have to kill people however there's people that you want to save if you don't save them you lose your soul uh the Court's legitimacy can very easily bump up or down uh depending on who it is that you killed but you can't always help that and so basically you're just constantly in a situation where you're sort of stressed out about what's going on both in terms of the court and your reputation and also in terms of watching the momentum cubes go into the bag and quietly panicking about whether you're going to be able to turn the tide because once enough of those cubes have gone in you start to feel really really tense every single time about whether you're actually going to be able to save somebody when it's time to stop the bleeding I also really loved the touch of you not really knowing if the person's innocent or guilty you just get a little bit of information about them and you have to read the card you have to make a decision about them that's just a random decision uh and also you'll get a little bit of card refresh because not all the same cards go into the into the deck every time you leave some out of the game each time so you'll have a different you know makeup of potential condemned but you just read a little bit of text and you have to decide if this person is guilty or not and then you just have to deal with it and it's really a messed up thing to do because you feel uncomfortable uh some of the descriptions of these people are sort of ambiguous so if you're really into the game and you're kind of letting yourself mentally be in that space um it becomes really tough to make these calls because you really don't know and in a lot of these cases it's quite ambiguous what's
even worse is that once once you accidentally let the momentum get out of control and you end up trying two people at a time not only are there double the consequences but also you are potentially hurting somebody who doesn't deserve it to get it somebody else or you're letting somebody who seems pretty awful Go free um in order to try to preserve a life and the sort of dehumanizing grossness of just trying two people at the same time to get it over with is so foul and I also really love it as a game mechanism because it's so gross you should feel kind of gross as you play it and so the the way that the different mechanisms in this game interlock is really wonderful and I'm super impressed with what Dan has managed to do here um I think that he took some really really limited materials and mechanisms and created something that feels a lot more expansive uh than what it is the game plays really quickly you just go through the deck it's over in a Flash um and then you feel really bad about what you did uh and it's actually pretty hard to win because you don't really know know in order things are going to come up in and there's some people you just have to save there's a whole mess involved with that as well but I will say I particularly love the mechanism of having to build momentum by executing people and then break that momentum by sparing other people because you could just go racing up the reputation track with kill kill kill kill but then you might end up in trouble dropping legitimacy of the court or accidentally killing somebody you didn't want to because everything got so bloodthirsty that it was like a stampede
and you couldn't make it stop this game is actually based on a novel called the gods will have blood which I haven't read yet but I did download it just because I was really really curious to know more about where Dan's head was at when he made this game uh I just think it's a really impressive piece of work and I am very curious about going a little further down the rabbit hole to kind of see what he saw when he was designing this that said it's not a perfect game um but my little quibbles with it are not really a huge deal so the first is that I actually had to watch his video tutorial in order to fully understand what he wanted what when I was playing the game so I more or less thought I understood the rules but there were parts of them that I didn't think were very clear so watching dance tutorial video on BGG it was very helpful U because I really otherwise might not have played it correctly on just a couple of accounts the other thing is that because this is just sort of a self-designed thing um there's not a graphic designer involved I do think that some of the fonts are unreadable so the cursive font that's used to give the names of the people who are accused and then some of the information about the consequences of their trial uh is like this it's just a really spidery cursive where the lines are also too thick and so I can't read it very easily so they're just a couple little user experience issues that make the game less legible and therefore sometimes annoying uh however I really think that's an extremely minor equival with something that is truly a brilliant game design I don't know that a game like this is for everyone because because I don't know that I would call
it fun it's not like you play this to have a ripering good time uh what this game does do for you is it offers you a really thoughtful experience about what you in your role of agency in the game are doing to people and the consequences of what your choices are and to me this game is important because it's pushing sort of the boundaries of what games can be about and what players can be asked to do and what they can be asked to experience within a game Space while also being a very sleek light game and so for me the gods will have blood is a deeply impressive piece of work I can't wait to see more from Dan he's one of my favorite designers who's active right now because he's always pushing that envelope and he's always looking for something interesting um maybe upsetting uh sometimes funny to do and so this is another example of how he is willing to take risks for his art and to really put the player in a place where they're uncomfortable but they're also really getting something out of their discomfort so that is the gods will have blood I honestly really love it I absolutely glad I spent the money on it it was worth setting the alarm I'll buy anything that Dan does and um you know definitely be on the look out for his next project because it will no doubt also be worthwhile so thank you so much for watching please like subscribe uh maybe help me out on patreon if you're feeling generous and most of all happy gaming