Beyond Solitaire Podcast 89: Dan Bullock on Controversial Game Topics
Transcript
it's at break time first i want to mention that i have a patreon so if you love this podcast i would deeply appreciate the extra support at patreon.com beyond solitaire second the beyond solitaire podcast is proudly sponsored by central michigan university's center for learning through games and simulations which continues to do amazing things in the world of academic board gaming their first kickstarter monumental consequence has now entered fulfillment and you can still order a copy through cmishpress.com link in show notes their next kickstarter rising waters will hopefully launch the end of october and if you were interested in a certificate in applied game design clgs is offering several courses throughout the year starting on october 10th eloy lasanta will bring back his art of game crafting course and starting on october 11th lamar smith will teach visual storytelling game art design and branding so sign up and get your learning on for now though let's get on with the show hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitaire and i'm a very special guest on the pod this week i'm here with dan bullock he's a designer of several different games uh but maybe you know him from no motherland without which is about north korea or from 1979 revolution in iran how are you doing dan great how are you oh i'm doing all right it's good to have you on here so um yeah i want to talk about your tendency to choose controversial game topics but let's just start
so i know that no motherland without that's your first published design is that correct yes that was that was the first like kind of um big design in general you know usually you try to start well i try to start with like a little project that i could actually see through all the way to the end proof of concept and everything um but yeah no motherly without kind of a odd topic i think for some people to pick is their first game they would want to do um but i was pretty inspired by some of these like defector memoirs that i was reading and then kind of dug into more books about that conflict on the peninsula from basically the end of the korean war to the present day which at the time was like 20 2017 and since then there's been like you know some interesting developments but yeah that was a subject matter was really drawn to make a first game out of that's awesome uh how long would you say that you spent researching the game so you started with some memoirs but then like where do you go after that i feel like north korea is a place we don't know that much about so how do you assemble good information about it's a basic game so good information is an interesting concept um i so i spent two years researching for the game i started with um some books like uh you know there's uh cilantro there's charles armstrong book called tyranny of the week or two i think it's tyranny of
the week and it was like basically an overview of kind of the ascension of the kim regime and then like three generations of it but it really starts off its story focusing on kind of post-war reconstruction of like north korea to kind of set the stage for how uh kilo sun like you know consolidates power behind him and everything but the book was actually like kind of plagiarized in portions from another author uh the last name zelante his first name i'm blanking on because i haven't read any of these books since 2018. um but uh so as i wrote like a book about it um about the same period and basically like this this very controversial book had like taken like excerpts from solante's work and then changed them and tweaked them big no-no but as a result of this terrible misdeed i became aware of a bunch of other sources kind of in the periphery that he had taken from and then i started reading these these other books i was reading zlatan's stuff andre lankov does like a lot of books on that topic as well i would say in general like there's a lot of really good sources about north korea that are chinese and russian that you can find translated there's a lot of observers on the peninsula obviously and are okay you're trying to triangulate what doesn't seem like this seems credible to paint a picture about what's going on in there
um i chatted with boko ronko about it because he was saying just like how do you get good information about this topic and you know we're kind of even seeing like in the age of open source intelligence and also with any kind of story sometimes you're researching a topic for a game and you're looking to hear the same story be repeated but like with little different you know different takes like slightly different advantages on what's occurring uh sort of like a in a crime film like when they're just interviewing witnesses to get an account of what happened like not who's telling the truth it's like well everyone's telling what they've witnessed but you have to kind of form this mosaic from the respective kind of testimony of these people and that's definitely how you kind of have to approach north korea there's going to be little gaps and holes but your research is really about just painting this picture and trying to make kind of a complete sense of it i mean it kind of sounds like a fun challenge but you mentioned a bunch of the sorts of chinese and russian i'm sure they're not all translated so i guess the other question is to what extent did language barriers make it harder for you to get the info you wanted um i think that the language barrier is probably less significant than all of the other barriers north korea i think they're the other barriers are pretty pretty severe for that um in part because uh a lot of the information you know like when we're talking about russian sources
or east german sources stuff like that like a lot of these authors have taken the time to translate this this work and and that's essentially what i'm reading and i think that with the south korean you know observers on the peninsula like there's just a lot of a lot of like sources for being able to find information i would say that you kind of have to weigh a lot of that information and see what seems credible to you what doesn't um and then definitely like i always have a emphasis on i i want things that are more recent i don't read a ton of you know sources like if i'm doing a story on you know or like a game on um you know north korea it's like i don't really need to read about something that's just basically it was published in 1960 like for the most part i'm really looking at more recent sources and kind of trying to see how it incorporates some of the other things that i've read and get a little bit of perspective on what everyday life is for north koreans on the peninsula but also just like kind of the history of our conflict nuclear arms and their presence on the peninsula and all that jazz so yeah it is difficult though for sure like there's a lot of barriers to that kind of a topic and i think that there's an element for people who make historical games they want a complete perfect picture and then i don't know that that exists for anything i think you just want to do enough of the homework to feel like you are able to offer something in the game like an insight
that isn't out there in the in the market in the wilderness of games so so for people who have not played your game uh could you describe sort of mechanically what the core conflict and goals are for no motherland without because i do have some questions about how you set up but we should cover the basics first sure so and no motherland without it's a two-player card-driven game uh has a very similar kind of event resolution to something like twilight struggle basically i can use my cards to do actions and activities um if it's my opponent's card something bad is gonna happen first and then after that i will try to repair the damage done or you know cause my own damage elsewhere um one player plays the dprk and really what they are is they're kind of playing the role of the kim regime right they're going to basically be trying to maintain their hold on power within the country they are trying to keep their prestige from kind of falling through the floor because with things like pressure of say sanction regime and like maximum pressure economic pressures there's things that would basically be leveraged against the regime to force them out of power through diplomatic means and things like that so they're basically trying to keep their prestige up and sometimes that means repression of certain political dissidents within the country sometimes that'll mean things like saber-rattling with launching
nuclear missile strikes and things like basically like ballistic missile tests and things like that to kind of try to relieve some of this sanction pressure and they're building up infrastructure around the country in part to rebuild after the korean war ends but they're also doing that in part to support their overall nuclear program and we have there's like also an element of there's a standard of living that needs to be maintained on the board and that's tied to the infrastructure as it exists on the map so these are like the incentives for the north korean player and the way they're going to win is basically by staying in power until the end of the game and having a certain level of infrastructure if they haven't launched enough successful nuclear missile tests where they are basically coming into power and for the west their victory is kind of contingent on either being able to force the regime out of power by turning up the heat and make maximizing that pressure curtailing the spread of infrastructure and the development there and also kind of minimizing their ballistic missile tests their ability to launch those tests and at the same time they're also trying to help with facilitating a pathway for defectors to get out of the country in political dissidence to become active within dprk so those are kind of like the competing incentives for that and the west is like a stand-in for really is rok and the us
but those things are fairly lockstep when we're talking about kind of the the early era of the game and then once kind of parallel to the kim jong-il era you know like basically when he succeeds his father um as kind of the head of the regime then we see kind of also a sea change in what the relationship is between that alliance between rok and the us and they diverge a little bit more they have a little bit conflicting approaches to how they want to handle the you know questions of reunification and the korean question and they are even more divided now than they were the day i finished that game like submitted so it's like uh definitely the uh strain of the the uh trump presidency certainly put a new spin on that particular alliance which probably makes the game feel like a little bit more like it has an end point like not really to present day but maybe it feels a little bit more like to 2015 or 2016 or something along those lines um but yeah so that's basically like the layout of what the game entails yeah it makes sense so i feel like it has a kind of point that's one thing that's weird about historical games that are recent right is that when they finish recently and you just publish it it feels like oh yes this is about yesterday but then time starts to pass inevitably you're like whoa what happened yeah it's like a magazine in a waiting room right like it's just like sometimes
like oh this is like two years old it's like yeah you want to read this interview with uh kobe bryant this magazine is kind of old like i'm very sorry like it's just things are not fresh yeah i mean um yeah i think that's tough but also knowing kind of the gestation period for a lot of historical games it sort of makes sense so yeah so i think it's really i want you to expand on talking about the west and how you meant to conceive it because i felt like when i played it it really seemed like the united states felt like a primary stand-in for the west and in my readings about north korea i don't know and this may be the way that we present it in the states uh but i always just sort of felt like north korea it's like quit hitting yourself quit hitting yourself and then they're just like an intensely self-destructive regime for reasons that don't entirely make sense to somebody in the states and that we don't have to interfere that much for just bad stuff to happen over there but um it's i got a different impression from playing your game yeah i have a very different impression of what's going on there i i think that was a a pretty big part of kind of like driving like inspiring like the game is it when you view certain powers as like irrational actors um and kind of take away some of like you know eliminate their incentives from your from your viewpoint of like what that conflict entails it sort of creates this illusion there's nothing that can be done to ease tensions there's nothing to be done to address
the conflict you've just got this one irrational actor on the peninsula and they're just gonna do that what they're gonna do i mean they're like kind of wild and i think that that's not entirely accurate i i was trying to portray that for dprk there's self-preservation of the regime is the motivating factor so they're not going to do things that are going to lead to their own annihilation and that um there's also a kind of a different view of like how we we view or represent like the korean war here in the states like kind of our view of it how it's viewed and in rok and then how it's viewed in the north and like so when it's a matter of trying to extend something like oh the un is offering like this kind of help or you know to come inspect these facilities you know for potential like negotiations over uranium origin or something like that it's like well we're technically still kind of at war with the u.n so we don't really want them looking around here and i don't think that's like a thing that like enters like most americans minds like they don't necessarily understand like what the terms of the armistice were kind of what the tensions are there but i did want to kind of have create at least a model where players could understand that there were incent like tangible incentives that were being satisfied by the regime trying to suppress like dissidents and it's a hold on to power where very few are exerting this control over every facet of life in north korea and i
think that that's what i want to portray and so that's part of probably why the americans seem like they're at the forefront of the west portrayal because it's sort of a game for i think it's really oriented around kind of trying to teach americans something about what's going on in north korea rather than presuming that i'm going to be teaching koreans something about that's going on in korea that's not really the idea there i think um and i just wanted to kind of paint a portrait of how some of these things are interlinked and like why that might be there but i think that for the rok and like west it's it's a little um you know when we see something like sunshine policy i know what how americans regard that type of approach to foreign policy and we just think oh they're just giving away stuff they're giving away stuff to the north koreans that's that's just bad that's bad policy that's bad policy it's like there's there's just like different approaches with successive you know like different um administrations and are okay have tried to approach korea in different ways sometimes it's a hard line sometimes it's an olive branch sometimes it's about hey can we form some sort of you know like corporate partnership and like you know ksong like industrial you know park and like have like some means of like trying to form um you know kind of shared ventures where we can actually have a positive influence on each other and i think in the us there's just a little bit more continuity across presidential
administrations and i think players would probably see over the game there's a lot of us like not wanting to deal directly with with north korea there's no engagement post six party talks because it feels like it's a political loss to whoever tries to do it because you got your hands dirty or you got your hands slapped away because we weren't able to get them to you know completely disarm like and abandon all their nuclear weapons it's like if that's your barometer for success like i don't know that you're you're really setting up uh good faith in any negotiations with anybody so um yeah i think that's probably why it seems like more western fronted i would think all right actually two questions coming from this but the first one i'm going to ask is what kind of feedback have you gotten about this game from players and especially from players who have different uh cultural and historical perspectives yeah i would say that um i've probably gotten better reception from players who have reached out to me from south korea than i would have expected on it and most of the very negative stuff that i've gotten was from americans who think that they knew that topic better is better because they were stationed and are okay or have you know followed like events on the peninsula even though even if they're not really observers of say what the statuses of various human
rights violations and like kind of the plight of north korean people um but more about like the portrayal of the us being i guess i don't know i would say that they're indifferent but basically like that they're somehow maximizing the damage of hardships famines things like that on the peninsula by withholding aid or you know i mean like with basically the sanctions that are in place there whether it's energy sanctions i mean or even just like humanitarian aid food what have you um but i think that over the course of 70 years there's definitely a record of those kinds of uh constraints causing some suffering like on the peninsula and probably making people's lives in general harder it's not that they don't do without reason but you kind of want to just show what has occurred and i think that that's caused some some people to feel wrangled and i think also if you make a game about iran or uh north korea or something like that um i think the topics are gonna be controversial to some folks there's also a little bit of you know just like why is this white guy making this game i was actually about to ask you that so why um yes so i mean the question is so you're interested in north korea and it is interesting what makes you the right person to tell the story like you commented that you're not trying to teach south koreans about this
but that you maybe felt like you were in a position to talk to people in the west about it so that's maybe part of your answer but why are you the one well i think that for me it's just always i don't really wait there's a lot of waiting as a player for certain games to come out covering the subject matter you want to see made into a game or something where you think that hey this would be really informative um you know for players to kind of engage with but there's definitely games that tell stories that aren't my story to tell and then there's going to be games where i'm like yeah but i'm going to try it like to hell with it and maybe sometimes you're going to try it with a co-designer or consultants that you're going to check sometimes you feel safe and engaging with the sources that you have and you hope that that's going to be enough for at least you're going to have a very well researched take and your advantage but my vantage point isn't going to be the same as someone who living on the peninsula and if someone was living in south korea it's not going to be the same as the north korean designers take on the same subject matter and i want to play the north koreans take on this subject better like i want to see the grounds eye view it's going to be wildly different and then i'll get to see everything that i got wrong as anyone who's watching what goes on in korea from the outside looking in it's gonna be like what part what parts are we not getting what aren't we seeing what we do but i think that to me it's a little bit more of a
i know and i'm going to tell you how it is and a little more of a diy aesthetic of i just don't want to wait for permission to make art and so to me it's like whether you're making a game out north korea french resistance you know you're gonna do your homework you're gonna do your research like a queer game but like whatever you're making it's like i think that you're already gonna have the barrier of trying to get a publisher to try to put forward some other story where maybe maybe the american viewpoint doesn't world view doesn't look so great it's not going to really come out totally unscuffed unmarked and unscathed on the other end of people engaging with your design um and i think that that's fine to want to want to see like you know quite a representation and in the hobby and like see the designer who comes from that particular background making those types of games but i don't i just don't view it as being like a necessity for making a compelling game that touches on a topic in part because i think also you're kind of opening the door for hopefully more games to talk about certain subject matter whether it's north korea specifically or human rights issues in general that don't directly affect things in our backyard i think it's just like really important to start considering the different types of
historical games we can make and how they'll touch on political things and in other forms of history that aren't always very military centric so so i guess why me is because it's a thing i want to see develop in in board game design that doesn't happen quite enough it's getting there it's slowly opening up but um i mean when i shopped no motherland around it was like crickets trying to find somebody who wanted to touch that subject matter and when i did find publishers who were interested they're all wargaming publishers and they're like could you make it a little more war gamey like instead of being about you know like having the generation map i had so many publishers who pointed it's like i don't like seeing faces or i don't like this element of it but that's where it connects with the humanity of the people impacted by both the kim regime and by the kind of sanctions regime the maximum pressure and like everything that's uh you know kind of being leveraged against the regime to force them out and i was not willing to take that out because it's like the thing that like players really connected and engaged with and that was like what a lot of people refer to as their favorite thing in the game but yeah i think if you're making a game and engages with the humanity of the people involved and you put them in the foreground of their own story you just need to like do show that you're doing the work you're being sensitive and you're doing the research and i think you're gonna be in an okay place to like put that game out
interesting so um let's talk about yet another controversial game then uh one that is so controversial that yet again people who live there can't actually buy a physical um so this would be iran 1979 so what inspired you to do this game uh is it a true follow-up like did you actually start designing earlier and you came back to it and you know what's it what's this one about jason matthews thinks i'm doing an axis of evil trilogy but i'm not not doing that that was not my plan um but but it's not um it's not totally disassociated for that i guess because there's some of it it's just like we're kind of taught in the united states there's these countries that are just like opposed to our way of life they hate democracy they you know are colluding with terrorist elements in a weird worldwide network or cabal of like just people who want to do harm in the united states and just like oh i want to investigate where where the beginning of that kind of you know like attitude sort of takes shape and starts um but really i was just always fascinated by the coup uh like operation ajax in iran and basically how it gets treated as this blueprint for um american like just like kind of overturning like flipping democracies and like trying to reshape other countries to basically align them behind you know kind of u.s policy at a given time and so you see how it gets used in like you know guatemala all throughout latin america and like other places um
but at the same time we're heading into like the 2020 election and i'm you know in my house during a uh pandemic and uh finishing up my stack of reading on a run and i was just like i'm gonna make a game about how fragile democracy is and like i just want to kind of show how influence could like kind of oscillate between you know various factions and how coalitions get formed and how they fall apart i thought that that'd be like really fascinating but that's not the part that seems to be what bothers people is that you're making it about iran and that you're making a game where it's like no one's playing the us or britain it's just groups of iranians trying to shape like control their fate of their own country and things like that so again also not a thing that publishers from the war gaming sphere were very psyched to like see a game about because it doesn't doesn't really you know there's like not like a thing like is there a market for that kind of a game i think the best you would again get would be like somebody would be like you should really take this to gmt they do these coin games you ever heard a coin it's just like oh that's a great idea i never thought of that thanks uh and then so yeah it's just like interesting like from the respect of just like i i already wanted to see like kind of american interference with with democracies and then how it played out over the course of decades kind of in this enclosed kind of scope of just iran and how those some of those
same elements and forces based on our initial you know putting our thumb on the scales coalesce into the islamic revolution but you're also motivating a player to try to uh remove the shah from power so kamini can fill in the vacuum which is not it's an it's an interesting player choice like people are not always going to be wild about like you know some of these victory conditions for for various powers but um i was very interested in like modeling that conflict mostly for trying to show like kind of how political influences fluid and then also just again you're kind of making this game for americans somewhat to teach them a little bit about the basics of this conflict i think there's something to be learned for a lot of people but um i don't yeah i didn't see anything like that in the market i've been waiting for an iran game for for a long time so so you lost patience and made it i mean yeah yeah i waited a good 10 years after 10 years still waiting for the game it's like i think you might just need to like start doing the reading yourself and like kind of putting your back into it and doing the work so that's kind of how i approached it so you have played this game however with iranians online yeah so what kind of feedback did you get from the people who the game is like about it's um
it's very interesting because it seemed as though and i won't say general because they come from different educational backgrounds you know everything from like the hobby gamer who just is an omni gamer who would probably you know they're like dana it's great but i'd rather be playing like blitzkrieger you're still like little like like some other game but they're like this is really heavy and like kind of different but it was interesting like i think like a lot of them and felt that they were learning something more about the operation ajax part of it like the early era around the most of the day about around mossadeg but very different viewpoints of like what was kind of some of them wanted more drill down of like specific issues that were the reason for opposition to the shah for example and white revolution policies and things like that and uh that to bore your listeners with like all the all the the weeds of iranian politics but basically it's just like that wasn't something i was as a non-iranian person and not a muslim was comfortable commenting on the specific grievances of obama in iran in 1970s like i really just wanted to like kind of keep like more more basically like a panoramic view of what the political landscape looked like and specifically like the alignment of certain groups in with their certain forces or in opposition to the shah or with the ayatollah i didn't really want to get
into like trying to state their cases because that's like i'm advocating for these various different views and that's it's just not my like i just don't have skin in the game really it's more like i just wanted to kind of paint this overall picture about the kind of historical record and if there's any place where i felt fine getting my hands dirty it was when we were talking about british and american involvement with it because then i i felt like well this like i can i can show this i mean like uh yeah i think i think that as much as folks might have um the iranians i played the game with which which isn't that many but it's so like a few and even like one of my colleagues here here in milwaukee it was just like even though it's like very few there was still like a sense of it wasn't so much nitpicking like so like their their stuff is like a little bit like you know kind of nitpicking like specific tiny details but the overall the crux of the game is like bookended by this coup and then the islamic revolution you get to see at the start how um a lot of the the coup is really being orchestrated from within like embassies in a network of assets around these embassies and then at the end of the game there's no question as to why you know 400 students climb the walls of the american embassy and take hostages it's like oh well this makes sense and i think in a weird way other games that i've seen kind of portray the iranian hostage crisis they just do that last part without really setting up how
how we might have gotten there or what the significance of that event particularly meant not just to the iranians but to the union like to the americans and the embassies and like what led to it but i might just like to stir up trouble i don't think that's what i'm doing but well i mean aren't you also doing a game about uh weapons contracts in afghanistan yes i am i'm sure that'll have a much easier time getting published right yeah that is that is the current project um that's my little corner of the u.s afghan war that i wanted to portray in a game uh it it has euro mechanics it's very much a euro game folks are going to build an engine that does a certain thing and hopefully get to see it hum press your luck trying to minimize the effects of impact of inspections on your work and avoid insurgent violence to try to make progress on projects but all in pursuit of obligations paid paid money from the us government for your contracts while getting awarded more contracts so you're basically taking the role of a small firm and trying to make it a very big firm with some influence in washington but that's the that's the game um yeah that is a project that i've been working on since january it's been moving like really fast and it's always frustrating when you're pitching something and people are just sort of like
like they really don't want to touch it and then you'll run like i was at wbc and i ran two demos of that game and it just killed it just did so well the groups loved it and then you're like trying to pitch it to someone and they're like i wouldn't touch this like like with a 10-foot pole like this game is just like there's no way like there's no way we're publishing it or you know uh one company even asked me if they could retheme it about something else and it's just like this could be about space or something you could do like something like no i'm pretty pretty married to the theme yeah i mean and they're like but why it's just like i just like making less money and making a point like it seems more interesting to me dan he makes no trouble at all yes yes oh so i mean i feel like this is a question you you probably get asked but i'm just gonna ask you like and i don't really i don't really know what your answer is nor am i really worried about it but i wanna know like you know we live in the united states we are americans it seems like you wanna make a lot of points about the us that are disgruntled um what are you working out for yourself through these games because i sort of feel like when we come back to topics again and again it's about something that's bothering us and that we need to explore so like what keeps calling you uh ignorance i think that's an excellent question by the way but it's definitely like there's just a blind spot a lot of
folks i know who design historical games they have like an expertise like if you ever talk to brian train it's like walking alongside high speed rail like he just knows all this stuff just raises right you're trained brian bulletrain it's just like his expertise and everything and then he'll be working on 10 concurrent projects and he knows everything about all of them all the time and she's like i'm like just don't talk to me i'm reading right like i just have to keep everything somewhat siloed until the project's done and for me i always start a project with um i don't i was never taught about that in school and like you know i i after a bachelor's degree i work in academia but i'm not an academic so for me it's just my education's unending i just i'm going to be researching projects you know until i stop doing projects so it's always like i don't start with a thing i know about or even have um a lot of prejudices or like kind of assumptions i just go in with questions and then just have to start cobbling together you know i mean what like basically finding out more about the conflict how would i model it who's okay who's accounts or what and like that's that's it it's just like a kind of like a journalist but showing up to a thing that a bunch of people already know about but i don't have the sense of i need this narrative to get here to tell my story and angle in this way and so it's really easy to pursue north korea from a point of ignorance because hopefully we all think we don't know that much about north korea that
would be kind of ideal and then you come out on the other side and even if the game doesn't quite um come together with as complete of a picture or all my questions don't get answered i still know more two years later than i knew going in there's a lot of elements of that rule book for no motherland without that i would like another shot at tweaking but the research done in the last 12 pages is not one of them that that's like well i'll die on that hill like that's totally fine you know and i think for iran it was the same thing it's just like i know what i was taught which is basically nothing so let's walk backwards from that and read like you know these iranian sources and like you know other sources about the nationalization movement the influence of you know bp aioc oil you know like basically in the country and then also like the shah relationship with the us and the region we're just like cobbling together this story and coming out of the afghan war it's a little different because like we were we've been present for the last 20 years we've been reading about it but then i like to find the one thing that i don't know hardly anything about and then she's like well i want to make a game about this little piece this tiny little corner because this is what i don't know about and then you spend two weeks reading through contracts and um special investigator audits and like what the outcome was of work that it was hiring just like now i know more about that subject matter and i feel confident enough to like
try to engage with a design but you always start out with a it's kind of i don't know like just it's a blind spot and that's why it might seem kind of cantankerous or like i don't know some people might pursue it like or perceive it as being anti-american which i don't think it is i think if you live in this country and you want the country to be a better country you're you're a freaking patriot that that's how this works if you live in the country and you want to see it turn to just a smoldering pile you're not a patriot you're just you just like you just want to be comfortable and it's all about facilitating your comfort or upending hierarchies that you don't think are very just and not advocating for people that you feel like are being wronged that's it it's pretty basic i want to be smart when i'm dumb i want to be better where i'm not you know i mean like it's just continued improvement so speaking about curiosity and wanting to know things we don't know um and maybe really being determined in your pursuit of that can we talk about the paganini game oh sure oh absolutely um yeah i'm very of all the history i'm probably passionate most about weird music history and so um uh will william heinrich ernst was a morovian violinist and composer a talented perj of paganinis or maybe he wanted to be a protege of paganinis but he he was platonic stalking paganini well he toured all over europe again if you if if any listeners don't
know was just like an incredible composer violinist he's he's like a showboat he's a total freaking showboat all fireworks all the time so he'd like come up with a new technique and the best way to show this technique off is to just like do it in the most ostentatious way possible and a piece that just highlights him doing these tricks so so our hero ernst would follow paganini from town to town and then he would rent a room in a boarding house adjacent to paganini's put his ear to the wall and listen in on paganini's practices and then try to learn how to play paganini pieces by ear through a wall and paganini was famous for not really liking the practice and he also practiced with the mute because he just like to surprise people you know you kind of go and you you would shed it right and then you come out and you just surprise everything oh it's like very impressive you know so um apparently at one point uh what during one of these tours they were performing in frankfurt and paganini and ernst ran into each other fancy that staying in the same boarding house and um again paganini paganini offered to uh have ernst perform with him but like just kind of do you want to open my set you want to play first and ernst you know delighted at the chance to play with his hero so he did he did perform a few pieces before paganini performed his concert and one of the pieces he performed was a song called moses fantasy which was an
unpublished work that paganini had been working on and he played it exactly and then paganini still had the gall to perform it anyway for his set because he felt peggy felt he did it better so he wanted that and then the audience couldn't really decide which one they liked better of these two dueling versions of moses fantasy so that is so messed up so just a historical question i have to know was that considered like a dick move oh that is practical i would be so mad yeah but like how did pagani how what do we know about what paganini said or like how he reacted like i need the t on this so so i don't really know in terms of the reaction i think we can kind of guess what the reaction is because this is taboo no matter what century you do it in like it's super rude to like steal people's unpublished work and then perform it like in front of them but then to do it in the venue where you could be seen doing it you can also see like the kind of to me it's like just such a weird such a turn in the punch bowl just yeah you can tell that ernst the gears turning in ernst's head are probably that he has done something very impressive and that he somehow won paganini's respect by doing this despite the fact that this is the same lack of like kind of social graces that would cause one to stalk their hero all over europe rent adjacent rooms to where they are staying listen in and eavesdrop on their practices cobble together an unpublished piece but then to perform it in front of them and their audience just like oh look what i
did like with beaming with pride it's just like you know paganini thought he was like the like alpha creep like just like the worst probably after that there's no way you'd be okay with that so in the game you're literally following paganini from town to town and there are these cards that represent the walls of your of your of your boarding house room and they have excerpts from the moses fantasy piece and then a qr code linked to a segment of the violin music that you would like hear through the wall if you hear anything and so you scan it with your phone if you want to hear the piece otherwise you just see what music is revealed and you're trying to complete the piece it's a set collection game like about just cobbling together this musical piece and you need to have it all together before you get to frankfurt because you you really want to show paganini what you put um and side room games had a 50 card like a 52 card design contest like a couple years ago and i was like thinking oh i think i'd like to do that i like you know like my key and black sonata in some of their games i was like i wonder what i would do for that contest and i went to lunch when i was at work and i thought up the entire game like i had the whole game just written out on a piece of paper and then to like came home basically just been like 48 hours and i told like one of my friends he's like fellow designer about it and um i was just telling him that i made this game he's you really felt you had to sprint to get that one down before
anyone else took it from you didn't but they might have heard you planting it through the wall yeah right something like that so just shot inspired via so i submitted that for the contest to probably a lot of furrowed brows or whatnot but those are the types of things that like just i i love the idea of like that story and it felt like it needed to be embodied in the game and one of the cool things about solitaire games in general is you can just do that for people you can really take people for this like kind of on this kind of weird adventure like now we liz we both know stalking's wrong right but in this one case i'm going to need you to stalk this guy for like a little bit because we're going to learn this violin piece you're like okay okay i i guess i could see that but hey okay if i recall correctly isn't it true that franz list was such like a hottie and a superstar that women used to follow him around and try to get his gloves and try to get like the leftovers of his coffee yes like you can have a follow-up set collection game trying to get like list of souvenirs oh i'm feeling this is not good no this is good like i feel like i'm making you know i've moved on i'm not now i'm just designing games for the new yorker like i'm just like making like a weird esoteric crap that no one else would want to play but yeah i i think i think it was also kind of uh when i was working on the turns game uh naomi clark had a game called consenticle that came out like a kickstarter and it was this brilliant piece of art about
like basically how we talk about consent like when when folks are approaching intimacy and the rob for the game is that it's like a two-player co-op but it's harder the less you communicate you're like yeah like that that's brilliant right and then i was like thinking like okay and then i love that i was so moved by that game it's like well now i'm gonna make a game about platonic stalking but what will my subject energy um so in a roundabout way this my game was i guess naomi clark's fault like i was inspired by my herpes i thought that was good inspired by a game about consent and mutual enjoyment to create a game about the opposite about the opposite well let's make the opposite yeah no that's that's very natural for me i'm going to do the opposite thing we'll go the other way that's slowly i got to play this paganini game at some point but um so i i've taken up a lot of your time i really appreciate you like coming on the show so i'll do some wine down what gifts have you been playing for fun recently uh games i've been playing for fun uh last last couple days i've been playing sniper elite because i just got that um crescent moon has been great it's getting a little bit of a bad rap right now on bgg i'm noticing but at five players i love the engagement and i think a lot of that game has is fueled by people's willingness to negotiate and talk at the table uh i never like where my situation is as a player so i'm always willing to chat
and try to improve it i think other people are very very like safe in their uh i think i've got a good strategy i think would bang out but uh so crescent moon's been excellent i like sniper elite a lot because normally in these kind of hidden movement games both sides don't have interesting choices sometimes one person gets to like your jack the ripper and you get the snicker for 15 seconds well then everyone moves for five minutes and deliberates about what you're doing and like sniper elite was very much like uh we both have interesting things um to do so those been the two big ones um recently and then tried like a handful of games at wbc uh tried nicaea for the first time and played that thing outpost eight player game which i was terrible at i'm just not good at lying to a group of people i think that is not my skill set if i was i guess i could be in office or something but i'm just not not well suited to it at the game table everyone knows me too well they see me changing colors and not talking for like 30 minutes it's just like the jig is up i'm not getting on this helicopter so i'm also a terrible liar if it's any comfort we just have so much integrity liz that kind of game is beneath us that's what it is but that must be it it can't possibly be that i'm socially awkward in that smooth ball no it's like no it's the game it's the game's fault for sure um clearly yeah clearly all right so people want to talk to you online ask questions about your games see what designs are coming up uh where
can they find you online um always respond to rule questions on uh bgg and uh i usually put up uh rule videos for my games so folks can consult those though uh joe buyer has a what will this piece what does this piece do series where he's been like kind of breaking down the history of games and like how to play them his video is way better than mine and it just went up this week so if you're having any issues trying to learn 1979 definitely check that video out and then i'm always on twitter like to the point where it bothers my wife so definitely get a hold of me uh you just follow me on twitter or dma um answered like design questions real questions there too so aaron sort of had a better life if there had been just twitter
indeed right uh for sure it's like an interesting place where uh you can start a really good conversation and then watch it fall into the absolute brass afterwards and i'm there for both i like both so if you want to find me online anywhere i'm all over the places be on solitaire i prefer to stay out of the morass but i guess we can have a ride sometime uh thank you so much for coming on yeah this has been a blast talking to you thanks for having me liz those of you out there please like comment subscribe and most of all happy gaming so
you