Skip to main content
Loading video...

Moonrakers - Board Game Review - We're Attempting Re-Entry

Transcript 28:48

my God what's Bon doing I think he's attempting re-entry sir hi there everyone you're watching the broken me for the show devoted to boarding card games I'm Luke heor and Good morning Vietnam this is the second of essentially three videos that I am doing for Ivy Studios the first one was on fractured Sky by all means go check out that review but these next two are going to be devoted to one of their older games called Moon rakers just like the moon not that moon raker now this one's a bit of a different story I was kind of been trayed by this a while ago but I never really thought I could stomach up the cash to pay for it up FR because it was quite an expensive Kickstarter and I was in two minds as to whether the concept could work even though I was intrigued this is a negotiation deck builder so not two things you tend to see go together well the idea is is that you are doing deck building as you would in any other deck builder but you can work with other players to complete the objectives that you're trying to do but of course everybody is out for their own agenda and there is only one winner that alone did make me go wo this could work but I wasn't prepared to sort of look into it at the time I was too busy now though got a bit of spare time and I've been getting into this along with the free expansion so you will no doubt get some reports on those expansions in the

next video where I do a beyond the base game on all three of them but for now we're just going to talk about moonbreakers in the base set alone without any of the other expansions in so is it worth picking up when it's just the base or are you going to need some of those expansions later we shall see so just as a quick note this is for the base game only and yes there are some expansion elements in these trays the trayes themselves are expansion things but this is how I store the game now so I can't exactly separate the whole lot for you but don't worry I'm only going to talk about base game elements so Moon rakers as I said a negotiation deck builder everybody has their own board where they can put ship parts and various upgrades during the game but the idea is is that you have a deck full of these various starter cards things like fruster shields uh the Miss dead card reactors and damage and they're pretty basic cards they do what they say on the 10 so plus two cards plus one Shield you plus one damage you know they're very simplistic but the idea is is that you will start off with a basic deck and you are trying to complete these various contracts these contracts essentially have different requirements that you must play during the turn and these will correspond to the different action cards that you've got so orange is damage right well let's say for this one I need five damage so I've got five orange here as well as two Shields two green and they will also come with some Hazard dice which you have to roll which essentially will nerf your points if you end up rolling them and you can't block them with shields they all also have rewards on them both in monetary credits which you use to buy

more ship parts and buy more uh cards but also the victory points of which the goal of the game is the first person to reach 10 but you can't do them all alone you'll be able to do some alone and certainly later on as you get more powerful you'll be able to but particularly early on in the game you're going to need help and that's where the other players around the table come in because as soon as you decide I'm going to announce to do a contract you can rope in any allies you want choose any players all of them none of them one of them whatever and and so you have a discussion among players and discuss how you're going to split the rewards you have to decide there and then what moneyy credits are going to get what victory points is going to who and if they give any other bonuses like say bonus cards or you know you know anything like that then you're going to have to split that as well and you can even split the hazard die to say that someone's going to take that hit rather than deal with them you know by some other means and so what will happen is once you've all agreed what you're going to do each player in turn order will basically play as many cards as they can to satisfy the requirements you have one action to play one card doesn't sound like a lot does it well luckily the reactors give you more actions so you need reactors for a kickoff but then as you play these cards you will essentially combo into more and try to play everything that the requirement has so for example you know my first action card could be the play the reactor gives me two more actions okay so I've got two left and then I've got a fruster which will give me two cards okay draw two cards in the deck and I didn't draw a reactor so all I can do is contribute a uh another fruster okay fine so for the

contract that I decided to do let's say this one for example I've contributed two of the four frers and one of the reactors not a particularly great start hopefully though other players will be able to chime in and fill in the gaps and that's essentially how doing a contract works if you fail you fail but if you win then split the rewards as necessary and turn order will move to the next player you will get rid of all your cards though so is a good way to get rid of a bad hand you could just simply say you know what I'm going to help you there's no binding negotiations or contracts or anything apart from the rewards so I might say I'll help you just to get rid of a bad hand he sneaky in bird culture this is considered a dick move alternatively you can stay back at the base to gain some credits and ditch your hand but on every turn you are allowed to buy more cards so you have ship parts that you can acquire and these things do all sorts of cool special abilities that are ongoing and they allow you to put more cards into your deck and they come in all the different colors to match the card so they've got like varous like things they tend to do like better at drawing cards or stuff like you know making things cost less Shields and you can have four of these on your board they cost money to you credits and they allow you to specialize and change your you know your strategy and your combos in any way shape or form and you also have objectives that you can complete during the game by staying at base and collecting them where basically meet the requirement cash them in and you get the points that's very much the simplistic nature of the game you carry on in this fashion constantly as you get more powerful until eventually one player gets to 10 points and is the winner of

course now these games are not cheap IV Studios does not do cheap they're pretty expensive retail or deluxe version this one is the deluxe version especially and yeah not cheap but you do get some very good quality stuff here I mean I like this minimalistic card artwork which is both kind of like you know sci-fi-esque as it should be but also very easy to distinguish colors on there I mean if you're color blind you'll have to rely on symbology there is symbology on these cards so you can follow oh that's a damag card that's a fruster card even if you can't see orange yellow or blue for example but if you're not color blind these things will stand out quite nicely and at a distance you can see the important information you may not necessarily be able to fanom the picture and bad lighting and certainly these boards with you know some of their kind of glossy embossed uh like covering on them can make them a little bit difficult to see at a distance I mean you know this board in particular you know you might actually struggle to notice that it has you know Parts on here that tell you how many cards need to be next to this display the text is very small and even on some of these uh you know these ship parts and that the text is not particularly big either and this is quite a small card so you're going to want to play this on a relatively small table space and hope that people can sort of lean in and see across the table to see other cards if necessary it's a bit of a nigle it does get in the way occasionally but not to the point where it's you know a major problem down in front on top of that you're getting cool little plastic ship pieces to represent the different players and if you've got the Deluxe Set

like I have you've got very cool metal coins I like these metal coins they're free and one they're clear to see they're clear to distinguish they feel good in the hand they're not like overly thick coins but they still feel really good quality I mean they've got like a kind of almost like a circuit board style etching on them so there's definitely like a multi-layer to this coin and they are pretty nice the whoop losing the ship already the cards are not bad they they've got kind of a linen finish and they are reasonably sturdy although I'd be hesitant to want to play this game unsleeved I mean I do have half the game sleeved certainly anything that's resulting in a deck building aspect is sleeved cuz that's just the nature of the Beast you really should sleeve deck building games but I have not sleeved the square cards because the square cards you don't need to pick them up too often they're not handled that often and also I'm not sure there is a sleeve that can actually fit these squares cuz I haven't found one sleeve Kings I don't think does one so if anybody does know what sleeves fit them let me know but honestly I can get away without it and for storage purposes you're probably better off not doing it anyway because storage wise you get a decent insert in the box and well why aren I why am I not using the insert well that will become clear when we talk about the expansions but the insert is pretty decent for the base game only it stores the dice it stores the coins you've got the pieces in here and then you can put all the cards in there and it will fit them sleeved it will be tight it will be very tight you know they'll be very snug if you sleeve everything particularly all the square cards as well but they will fit if you

don't sleeve your cards everything will fit in here very nicely but yes as you can tell there's a lot of plastic here that gets that seems to take up a lot of space for what is a big box so it's not the the best insert in the world but it will do the trick particularly if you're not a sleever at least for now we'll get on to that in the next video I expected this game to be pretty complicated or like a fair fiddly game but no it's actually pretty streamlined for what it is I was quite surprised the rule book does look fat but that's because they've gone for this weird styling where they kind of just waste a lot of page space I mean you open the first page and you get the components in the game overview okay fantastic and then you get this blank bit with the contents there separated into the three sections and then you get more wasted space with the section heading there and it's like okay I didn't quite need that much styling in your rule book I mean you could probably shave off a good 10 pages of this book if you just took out the blank stuff and condensed it down a bit making it bigger doesn't make it clearer but that being said it's pretty easy to follow the language is good it's fairly big text and there's a lot of picture representation here there's a lot of examples you will not have very much in this book that doesn't have some picture to look at to illustrate the point it's trying to make and there isn't that many rules in the game I mean a lot of these are examples so that whole page here is literally the example of playing a contract so it goes through in very fine detail how you would attempt a contract

but when you actually boil it down and see okay just how many rules are there there's not a lot I mean you essentially choose a contract you have discussions with the players it tells you exactly what you can split on the card the hazard dice are easy to do the cards are self-explanatory for pretty much the most part really the main part that you have to kind of learn and get used to is the ship parts because well there's a lot of them also the crew I didn't mention this in the overview but basically you can get crew cards that are sort of superp do powerful versions of normal cards that do special abilities and you know these ones are really great to have but again they're all unique abilities so therefore there's going to be a slight learning curve to there but they are good fun but yeah really when I've taught this game it has not been problematic to teach it you'll get the occasional FAQ moment that does arise but there is a glossery in the back there's a pretty good community on Board Game Geek for looking up particular questions you can easily contact IV Studios themselves they're very passionate about this game and if you really don't like reading Rule books go on Ivy studios's website or more more importantly their YouTube channel they have their own YouTube channel they have done instruction videos for how to play this as well as the expansions and they are really really good quality I mean they have you know good backdrops good you know explanations good visual like representation what's going on apart from the fact that their music background is a bit loud and I know the irony of that cuz some people tell me about my music but trust me my music's

fairly quiet theirs is quite overpowering but that little blemish aside they are very good tutorial videos and definitely worth checking out if you're not a fan of negotiation games you probably should stay away from Moon Breakers because it's that FR and fr I mean you are interacting with the players to a high degree later on when your deck's more powerful you can try and do some missions solo particularly easy ones but at the beginning there's not a lot you'll be able to do yourself you're going to need help you need to build up some credits get those ship parts get more crew get better cards you know and you know as the game will go on you will get a better deck and you can do more contracts but even some of those harder ones they go to level four level one to four in difficulty level four contracts are going to be n and impossible for you to do by yourself pretty much at any stage you're going to need help with those but it's a very easy process it's mostly about splitting the rewards and having some idea of what each person is going to contribute you know what I can take the hazard dice I've got a lot of shields you got the damage cool you want to do this I'll do the shields I'll take the hazard D I'm taking this many credits and victory points though for the risk you can help out though I'll give you more of the credits but I'm taking more of the points you know there's easy little bits like that but it keeps everybody engaged there's not a lot of downtime you you know you might not necessarily be in a deal or you might you know you might be get pushed out of a deal so the contract gets attempted without you but contracts do not take take very long to resolve barely like a couple of minutes of that per contract even with a lot of players and the advantage of that is is that you don't have a time when you're sitting

there going no you're not there is very little downtime you're trying to get into different deals you're trying to do a contract yourself you're thinking about what other stuff you can buy that's not to say that this is a particularly short game more on that later but you're going to be engaged for the majority of it the ship parts and the crew represent the best aspect of this now there's not that many in the base game so variety is a little bit of a problem but the expansions help on that you know more detail later but these ship parts and crew are really cool the fact that they're all unique and do lots of really cool abilities you know hiring a crew for your deck feels good it's just like getting a really powerful card for your deck in any other deck builder but then the ship parts are always really cool you've got space on your board for four of them so you can have four of them at any one time you're allowed to replace if necessary and you can build some really cool Comber rific stuff with these and they do a lot of neat stuff I mean for example yeah you might get easy ones like saying at the start of a contract you get a card if you have no frers in your hand okay great so you've got some card drawer if you full foul of no frers but in I like stuff like the jumpjets Allies receive plus one card at the start of a contract so I have an incentive to have people Ally with me because I'm saying look Ally with me we can do this hard contract here I'm giving you a boost to help me here and it also makes you know people want me on the team because then I'm giving extra cards out as well I mean that's just the tip of the iceberg for what these ship parts can do but I like having that variety and it allows people to feel

differentiated while you're playing cuz these basic cards aren't differentiated they are the basic cards but you could still have one player go pretty heavy into damage and one player go heavy into thrusters and still get a nice element of variety from that the game Mark is also pretty tense throughout you start off just getting a point here a point there and you know just being one or two points ahead can be a big deal but obviously it influences how people want to negotiate but even if you're fallen behind there have been times where those people have caught up and done pretty well because if you're at the back then people are more willing to give you victory points in exchange for other stuff or they're more willing to have you as an ally you know the weaker player will get more allies because the weaker player is far enough behind but by doing that to an extent that weaker player then starts catching up and is brought back into the running when you get to around the 8 n point mark it gets pretty tense I mean you it's kind of on Dune Imperium levels for those of you who like the game you know the that one has a race to 10 points as well and in that one every Point counts well in this it's kind of similar because you could get one two maybe even three points from a contract depending and you might have an objective that's hidden from players that could get you another point so when you get to that top bit it's kind of anybody's game as to who could win and there have been some very close tight finishes and some genuine surprises one negative of this game that does crop up and you have to kind of get used to it is the dice themselves the hazard dice one thing that does irk me with midweight and heavyweight games is when these RNG or random number

generator elements are thrown in on top of what is essentially a Euro game these Hazard dice are a bit on the swingy side you know when you're rolling for a contract for example I mean let's say I take a you know a scout Cruiser here right this has got three Hazard dice on it a hazard D can be zero one or two hazards and it's equal proportion two blank two one and two twos so there's an equal distribution of rolling really bad for each one of these you need a shield and if you don't put a shield down it negates a whole Victory Point pretty bad when you're trying to get victory points of a contract and then you end up having to take hazards without the shields on top of that if you're no more victory points on the contract it deducts from your actual score what people have four fallen behind as a result of these Dice and I'm not sure how I feel about them they I get that there's a little bit of tension there and obviously if you're negotiating you're going to take Hazard dice you should be demanding a bigger reward as a as as an idea and certainly you should be confident you're going to have the shields to block these but you know for example let's say you know I'm willing to do two Hazard Dice and you're willing to do one okay we roll the dice and you know let say for except purposes I rolled two blanks okay two blanks I roll two dice got no hazard oh that was cool that was really lucky person who only wanted to take one die gets two and suddenly it's like oh great so you had two dice and got no hazards I rolled one dice and I've got two hazards and I only found one Shield I just lost a victory

Point by dumb luck it's a luck element and it's a bit of a pain it's certainly a negative of the game and it has hurt on occasion but it is a midweight game and in it base form it's not the it's not too long although it's not too short either so this is walking a bit of a tight rope as to whether this mechanic is any good or not I don't think it breaks the game because you know it's coming you can negotiate it away and that's why you have Shield cards if you're running a deck that doesn't have any Shields well then you kind of are at the mercy of the dice and that's kind of your own fault but the ship parts allow you to mitigate Shields as well there's crew that can help you with that I mean I've got you know one crew here uh no that's an expansion one let's try this one uh yeah redacted play as a shield reroll any number of your hazard die oh great you know you take this particular crew and it's a really good defense against this sort of thing but yeah random elements could we have not found a more deterministic way to do this on the subject of the RNG Randomness the objectives can also have a little bit of that aspect as well each one of them is worth a single point none of them are worth two none of them are worth three but they vary in terms of their ease of being able to do them I mean some of them require you to have like after four Parts get a fifth part and replace one of the others for a single point that's not going to happen to a good chunk of the way into the game and so you know also ones like acquire three of the orange ship parts on your deck well that's great if the orange ones turn up but then you know on you know as a different example I mean fail a contract as an ally that's really easy you just

jump into a contract that you know you've got no chance of winning and fail as the Ally quick one point yeah that is so much easier to do than some of these collect a Million Parts or collect like six to eight credits and that and you know the problem with that is is that you know if you get a bunch of these really objectives it can Propel you into the lead quite quickly into the game now you might have a sudden burst of points from somebody who has a bunch of these late game objectives but that's assuming that they can get them out period and also whether they can get them out in time to catch up to other players it it's surprising that they didn't like put more Point values on some of these or maybe just make them a little bit easier so you didn't have to get very specific requirements on some of them and really easy requirements on others it varies from moment to moment the length for the game is also on the variable side it can take anywhere from between I would say 90 minutes to 2 hours easily the box says 60 Minutes to 120 I think an hour as if you're playing a solo frankly 60 Minutes is not happening with a three to four five player game it just will not be possible the game easily straddles the 19-minute mark easily can go to the two-hour Mark particularly with four or five players and that's not too bad not too bad I can deal with it at that length if it went if it goes any longer than 2 hours it's dragging its heels and we need to hurry up and end it but I've not had a situation where it's gone too far beyond two hours bearing in mind that's also including the teach so it's not too bad a length but you do have the dice to T

in with that but if you think you're going to play this as some Quicky like you know sci-fi version of dominion with a bit of negotiation it ain't going to be that okay it does take a little while for people to build up their turns I'm actually surprised they haven't put some kind of light speed variant to speed up the start already I mean maybe they could in the future do something like what space base did I think it would work quite well but you know definitely you might find that this is a bit longer than you were thinking but 2 hours is not too bad variety is a little bit of a weak spot in this game as well now you'll see there's quite a lot of stuff I've got here but that's because I've got expansions okay there's not a lot of the best element of this game which is the crew cards and the ship parts there are only 20 crew cards in this entire box and only 30 7 ship parts 37 ship parts is not too bad but 20 crew is a very small amount I would have liked there to have been a lot more because you run the risk of actually seeing a good amount of the crew in one game or certainly within about two to three games you will have seen most of them and you know for variety sake especially for the price point you're paying I would have liked there to have just been more not to say the expansions won't go some way to fixing this but we're talking about the base game alone and so when you play this multiple times GES you are going to see a bit of repetition in the sort of the different cards that you can get cuz even the ship parts I mean you've got six of them out on display there's only 37 of them you're going to see them come up pretty often there's only 20 crew cards and you're going to see three of them at a time there's going to be some repetition there just would have been an easy fix

to just put in more in the base bags especially when you are charging the price point that you are for this game spared no expense player scaling is also a little bit wonky with this it says one to five players don't pick up this game if I'm thinking of playing a solo or two player at least not in this base game form the the two-player and the solo game mode I don't think are that interesting you essentially have this little mercenary deck which is just made up of a bunch of basic cards that a bunch of them are revealed and you use those as your allies effectively but it Nerfs the value of the contract and that's pretty much it but come on you are playing a negotiation game okay it is negotiation negotiation implies interaction with other people why would I take a negotiation game and make it solo that doesn't make any goddamn sense okay why would you even think that was a good idea well you got me by all accounts it doesn't make sense this seemed like just an excuse to shove in a Solo mode for the sake of pleasing solo players and honestly I have said this a million times not every game needs to have a solo mode bolted into it but even the two-player mode doesn't work that well you play it pretty much like the base game but you've got that mercenary deck as well but would you really play a negotiation game with just two of you that's just not enough three four and five is where this game switches on and yeah actually this game does work with five players it's going to go on a bit long you're definitely going to hit that 2hour Mark without any like shadow of a doubt and certainly you might be waiting

a while before it gets back around to a direct turn for you so be wary of five but five still works three and four players though is a really good number for this cuz three you have two potential allies and I think that's a good sweet spot for length versus interaction but four is pretty damn good you know three people to Ally with the game will still take around the 2hour mark tops and it's enough of a good game like from a negotiation standpoint but it does mean you are kind of looking at this as mainly a three to four player game five every now and again and the whole one to two aspect is might as well be ignored now I know that there is something called lumor which is this like kind of like computer based game uh version of this where you use the physical components from this and you play kind of like a story mode type thing with one or two player co-op I have not tried that at some point when I get some time I would like to try it and I will report in a podcast episode or something about what it's like maybe even though I'll try and do like a screen share video of it I don't know but I will try and do something with the luminor game at some stage but ignoring that entirely the one to two player mode in this eh so room rakers is overall a pretty solid game but it does have some blemishes here and there I love the negotiation aspect in this it keeps you engaged and it's relatively smooth and pretty streamlined for what looked like a game that was going to be pretty fiddly and nasty the cards look cool with the minimalistic artwork and if you've got the deluxe edition these coins are really nice but it does pop on

the table even though it is a minimalistic idea the rule book pretty well written with a lot of good examples longer than it needs to be with some wasted Pages for Unnecessary styling but yeah that's a minor nigle in itself it's still a solid rule book and if you don't like rule books the tutorial videos are definitely going to elevate your ability to learn this and normally I don't give brownie points to a game for tutorial videos but these are official they're done by the publisher I don't get brownie points if some third party makes a a tutorial video for this but the publisher has done it themselves and they're very good I highly recommend using them if you don't like rule book reading and to be honest even in my case I use them in conjunction function and it just made learning this an absolute breeze it's definitely worth your while but I like the the idea of building up your deck with cool Cru cards and the ship parts that's really cool but the blemishes of variety are a bit of a pain cuz this is going to have a bit of a limited lifespan in its base game form you also have to put up with some random elements like the objectives being a bit swinny on how easy they are to do for a single point and particularly the hazard dice which can make or break a player in a particular contract and if you just happen to roll bad luck with these particularly in successive turns it can really hurt your chances to win and it's not like it was your fault it was just bad luck with the dice especially as you can roll equally bad and equally good with these things but the game itself still pretty salid it just maybe needs a little bit of extra content and you have to put up with those random elements but

the expansions might help with that we shall see but if I'm going to rate this as a base game only I'm going to say seven out of 10 good game this is definitely getting a seal of endorsement from me because it is a very enjoyable game but you know it's going to have a limited lifespan it is quite a pricey game regardless of which addition you buy and you have to put up with a couple of blemishes here and there but for a game that takes less than two hours fills a niche gives me like a negotiation and deck building which I like those two mechanics are really cool for me and manages to make it work really particularly well and pretty well streamlined is an achievement in itself but we'll get on to more detail in the expansion videos where I talk about how this game can potentially be elevated a little further but base game alone seven out of 10 so that's it for me on this episode of the broken B if you like what you see them please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on Board Game Geek when I put it live on the page don't forget to leave your comments below about what you think of the game in its base game form only don't talk about expansions here I want to just hear base game fors don't worry you'll have another video where you can talk about expansion fors but I want to hear what you have to say say do you enjoy it do you agree with some of the random elements do you think there's enough variety did it need more let me know down below until next time regardless of whether your short and fruster or not it's still only a game so take care bye for now

Progress saved