Skip to main content
Loading video...

Fadenfroh Review - Gettin' Stitchy With It

Transcript 19:08

Hello and welcome out to the Dice Tower. I'm Wendy Yee.

And I'm Chris Yee.

And today we're going to be reviewing Fadenfro.

This is from design team design duo. I've never seen these two work together. Jordy Adan and Alexander Pfister. Jordy Adan has done primarily known for Flip Towns, Cartographers, Stones of Architects, all great games.

Uh also Alexander Pfister, who I may or may not uh love and adore his games, most of them.

Yeah.

Also one of our most divisive games.

Sure, yeah. Well Alexander Pfister, a very renowned designer, done tons of big heavy things. Also done small card games. So I was interested to see what these two would come up together and they came up with Fadenfro which is German loosely meaning

Joyous threading?

Yeah, joyfully like like thread happy is maybe the the way to put it.

Yeah, embroidery.

Cuz the term nidiculture was too close too close.

It makes you think of knitting circles indeed.

Yeah. So anyway, there's a little card drafting of sorts kind of a game.

Yeah, with some interesting scoring that we have seen before from Alexander Pfister. Anyways, I will briefly show you how this is played and we'll come back and share our thoughts. The game Fadenfro takes place across five rounds. So in round one, there's no scoring, but then every subsequent round there's going to be a scoring of the cards that are adjacent to it. So for example, in round one, it's going to be A and B. Round I'm sorry, in round one, there's nothing. In round two, it's going to be A and B. In round three, B and C. Round four, C and D. And round five, A and D. And then also your choice of B or C. So what does a round look like? Well, during the round, there's going to be this setup over here of stuff that's going to be draftable. Um it's going to be based on the setup card based on player count. Um and so I have it set up for a three-player game over here. And we have a few different items. We have string, we have uh needles or yeah, the little in their like in between thread here. We have our thimble, and then we have different columns of cards. So on a player's turn, they can choose to draft one of the items, one of these little token items from the area. The color of the string doesn't matter. It's just pretty and colorful. And then at some point, after enough things have been drafted out, a player can choose to pass, and then they can choose to take one of the columns of cards. That means that they are foregoing collecting any more of these uh little strings or other token items. When they've collected that, play will continue until everyone

has chosen to pass, and finally the last person is going to go ahead and get everything that is left as well as that last set of cards. Then after that draft, anyone who has three threads is going to go ahead and trade them in, and that's going to allow them to look at a few cards and choose an extra one to pick. And so it's just a way to get extra bonus cards throughout the game. Then a player is going to look at their play player area, and I'm going to go ahead and set this up. This is going to be uh first player, and they're going to go ahead, and they're going to lay out the cards that they gained during the round. So let's go ahead and say that this was a player that gained cards. They traded in their string for whatever they needed to trade it in for, and kind of this is what they have left. They're then going to choose to lay down the cards um on their board. They can either overlap something that's already there, or they can use um these little string things here or the little needles here to kind of stitch some cards together.

Also in the future, they can lay over the top one of those stitchings on top of two cards if they want to. Uh that piece does stay there, um but it because it's on top, it's okay. You can never, however, slip underneath. You can't ever flip cards over. Like there's a bunch of rules of the things that you can't do. Um but basically you're going to be adding into and creating these three different rows of cards. And like I mentioned before, they're scoring at the ends of rounds two, three, four, and five, as well some end game scoring over here. So if we were on to round two, and we'd obviously have more cards than this, but if we were go ahead and score, we would look and see we're scoring A and B. And so what this would mean is that blueberries are worth two points each and strawberries are worth negative one. So right now I have four points from this card. We then go through and we'd look at flowers. This is for every two, three, or four different flowers in your uh little tableau area, and I have two.

So I would go ahead and get four points over there. That'd be the end of round two. We'd move on to round three, and then we would do that whole drafting process again with the same amount of cards, the same amount of stuff, and then we'd build our tableau again, and then we'd go ahead and score for round three, doing it all over again for round four and finally round five. Now throughout the game, these four scoring cards all have to deal with different things. So we have cards that have to deal with the strawberries and the blueberries. We have ones that have to deal with the flowers, ones that have to deal with the color of the cards themselves, so these little like half area colors, and then finally the cute little animals like so. There's also cards that are in the deck that are scoring cards. Uh there's these little feathers that score at the end of the round, and then there are also these cards over here um that have some sort of scoring. And so this is if this is showing in your tableau at the end of the game, you will also fill out those scoring. There you go. That's a brief overview of how you play Fodder and Furrow.

All right. So starting out, I want to talk about that scoring because the scoring is not a unique thing. We've seen Alexander Pfister do it before, and that is with Isle of Skye.

Yes.

How you feeling about it?

Well, here's the thing though is you said it's not a unique thing. It's in one other game that really use utilizes it well.

That's true.

And and so yeah, it's it's pretty darn old unique. And I know people hate it when we use pretty unique or fairly unique cuz people say unique is a binary. It is or it isn't. Well, guess what? It's pretty unique because one other game uses it.

One other. Yeah, so I um I have mixed feelings about Isle of Skye. I love the scoring. I love the tile placement, but I don't necessarily love the auctiony bidding part of the game. And so Fae and Fray takes all of that out and they're like he's like ha. We're just going to gain cards a different way and I think that that is absolutely awesome.

Yeah, I think that if you have a clever scoring mechanism like this, putting it in different context is a good thing. I think it fits very well with this. Now this has this kind of uh this little like it it's a strange drafting kind of thing where you go around the table. It's like an open draft.

of chicken.

Yes, because you're not taking like one card at a time like a lot of open draft card games do usually. Well, do you want to grab that you know grab grab a thread? It's it's very like little like chicken picking like little bitty like grab this thing and then so finally someone goes I'm taking cards.

I want them all.

Yeah, once you grab cards that you're out is is a good it's a good way to implement that game of chicken.

And you know what? I honestly think that it works out at two players because it has that very tense dynamic and I know these kind of games sometimes they can be or cannot be good at two players, but I think if you want an interactive game um it definitely has that element to it. I also really enjoy the sitting down and puzzling out your cards and I love that you're getting the cards all at once so you don't have to sit and puzzle after every single action.

That's true.

saves some time.

Yeah, you're not taking one card and then saying like okay I hope I get that other card that goes with No, you're you're grabbing those three or those two or those four together. Yeah, you're getting exactly that. Now there is that little thing as you collect the the thread disks. Very strange. I get thematically thread comes in different colors, but you have to explain almost every time. Doesn't matter what color disk you grab.

Doesn't matter.

This one's red, that one's yellow. Doesn't matter, right? It's just if you have a disk

the one you like. If the one you don't like isn't left, we can swap it out or you can just be a big kid and take what you want.

Right. But when you trade three that's that's a pretty fun moment, be able to draw three cards, choose which one to keep.

Well, and I love it because those threads are like card for card you don't get as much for the amount of actions and poles that it takes to get three threads as it does to just taking, you know, the big bunch of three cards, right? But, you get a better choice because you're drawing three and picking one and they're the scoring really matters in this game and setting up for that scoring and kind of figuring out how you're going to begin that scoring and what you're going to work on throughout the game really matters and so having that choice is such a big deal.

Yeah, and and well, you if there's good cards out there you could just grab them right off the bat and I have seen people do that and do pretty well in this game which just leaves the rest of those little bitty bitsy picks and stuff to all the other players and you're just saying, nah, I know exactly what I want and I'm just I'm just going for it.

take it and it's amazing. And then sometimes you're sitting there going, I don't care which one I get because they're either both good for me or they're both bad for me and so I'm going to make you pick so that I can just gain more other little paraphernalia stuff.

There is a little bit of a a hierarchy of those thread tokens like the little needle tokens I guess what they are. Those are obviously better

Yeah.

than grabbing a token that's worth 1/3 of a card draw of sorts, right?

Yes.

Uh and they allow you to spread out your display of things better and there's a pretty limited amount of them. And so And I wrestled it for a little bit like, well, those are just objectively better. If you're first player you're just going to grab one. But, also grabbing first player is one of the things that you can grab

Mhm.

and if the right set of cards are out there then when you are first player you're like, well, maybe I will forego the other stuff and just grab the cards that I need for scoring because everyone's doing the same scoring. So, if I take it I'm also restricting other people from getting the cats or the squirrels or the berries or whatever.

Yeah, I think that first player does feel very powerful because even if you go around one whole time and everyone's like, oh yeah, we'll we'll grab string this round, right? It still comes back to you and you're like, am I going to be the one now, now that I've got one little token or whatever?

Yeah.

Am I going to come back? So I think that yeah, that first player can be very powerful. Go ahead.

I have a few negatives that I'm going to say about this because I think that this section of the game, the interactive card drafting everything, superb, right? What these designers do very well with just a few little pieces out there creating a lot of tension and interest. I think the part where you puzzle together your display of cards and everything is still good, but you got to know that people are just going to be heads down. And if you're one of those sticklers for games where it's possible that someone could cheat even on accident where they lay out a few cards and go, I'm going to pick those back up and I'm going to do something different. It's possible someone picked up a card that they already had down from last round. There's like those little nitpicky kind of things and there's just a lot of of if you're done with your display really quick, you look around, oh everyone's still kind of faffing about.

Oh, someone has a lot of choices to make this round because they grabbed a bunch of cards and they traded in tokens and so now they draw extra cards and they have to choose which one to keep and they're not sure. You might have a a moment where you're sitting there watching someone take a turn for a while.

Yeah, that's interesting because the actual drafting part should be pretty quickly as long as people aren't overthinking everything. And the lane Well, and then the laying out is the part that is going to be slower. But yeah, I've I've played games where it's gone both ways. Like my earlier game when we are were all learning, you know, took a little bit longer and that laying out was a little bit more confusing. And then other times I feel like it's gone by really quickly. So I don't I don't know. I'm not too worried about that, but I think you have to be clear with the group at your table of just like, how are we going to approach this game? Are we coming to this to calculate every last point out of everything or are we all just going to be like, hey, we're going to do our best and we're just going to have a fun quick game?

Yeah, but

that's that's the thing about the way that the game is designed with that particular puzzle when everyone's simultaneously doing that. It There's a lot a lot of decisions to make. Some of the decisions are interesting, cost-benefit, like really cool decisions. Other ones are just kind of calculations, the word that you used is very accurate. They're just calculations of if I do this and then this, how many points that going to get me worth? Now if I do this then this instead, how many points is that going to be worth? How many points will that be worth this round and then how many points will that be worth next round? You know, so it's There are those moments where if you like I I have myself kind of frozen up and been like, oh, I'm not sure which way to go. The more players you have, the more likely someone is freezing up that particular round.

Yeah.

And so it is a pretty quick overall punchy game but for those kind of moments there.

Yeah. And so yeah, I think you're That's worth having a discussion at the beginning and I don't I don't know if that's a flaw or not and I think some people are going to definitely see that as a flaw.

That's why we bring it up here.

I think that that's important for you to go into this knowing that for sure.

And sometimes when we bring up these issues, people say, oh well, you know, Chris and whatever, your your you know, your complaints, blah blah blah, this that and the other. They're relevant complaints to somebody. That 's why we do reviews and why we bring them up. It doesn't drag the game down for me too much, but it is a note where I I do say, oh, there's a lot of sitting there doing calculations at some point of the game, especially later on.

Yeah. Now artwork-wise, we usually often talk about that at the beginning, but I think now's a good point. How do you feel about the actual like look and feel and vibe of this game? Do you feel like it's thread-happy?

It's okay. I've never considered what thread-happy would look like in my life.

You've never done embroidery, right?

No.

been your thing?

Oh, there is a Okay, really quick, small aside.

I cross-stitched a little bit.

There is a video game that makes me thread-happy and that's called It's like the the the deer the the red deer inn or something like that. It's a video game where all of the pixel art is basically cross stitch and crochet and stuff. It looks amazing. That makes me thread happy. This is this makes me thread neutral. think it's kind of how I feel about it.

I think the animals are really cute.

The animals are dang cute. Yes.

Everything else is is fine.

And it's okay that that's not my sub hobby. I look at it and go this is a good mechanical way to do some scoring.

It's a hobby that I in my mind think I would enjoy and then in actual reality it just gives me arthritis, you know.

Yeah. And then

hurts the hands and the eyes.

store fabric and thread places [snorts] places where we need to store games.

True that. All right. I think we've gotten off on a aside. So let's go ahead and start with our scores. I'm presuming yours is lower than mine. So I'm going to let you begin.

Sure. Bold assumption.

Ooh.

Like I said, I have a few hang ups with the game, but overall I really like it. I'm giving this one an eight. I think that the card draft is a delightful bit of interaction where players really are going to be coming together and having that little tense game of chicken. And I think that when someone makes a swipe, you know, the it's not like a a shocking moment, but there are times where people go whoa, I wasn't expecting that.

You know what my shocking moment was? Is that you gave it an eight.

Really?

Yeah. I just I assumed you would be lower than that.

Here's the thing. It does bother me how calculative the especially that like the last and the second to last laying out phase where you're putting everything out there, it can kind of bog down. None of the decisions are individually too hard, but they really layer on top of each other, especially when you're like, okay, now we need to set up for the future scoring and everything. So it is a little bit of a downer there. That being said, I think that the game is overall quick. It's very clever. I love that little scoring going around, making sure that two things activate each time. And at the end you have one little bit of choice. There's nice variety in the scoring. Some of them are explained very poorly and

Yeah.

if you don't remember that the term half means halves of card. Anyway,

of a card, yeah.

But I like the game. I I like the game a lot despite the complete neutrality towards the theme.

Okay. Well, I thought Chris was going to come in at like a 6 and 1/2 or something. So, I too am giving this an eight.

Oh.

Um and I thought that I loved this way more than you, but clearly uh you are a Fister fan all the way.

Mhm. And a Don.

And a Don, yeah.

a a Don boy. I

Adon Jordy Adon. You got this.

No, I was making up a term of like Fister fan and like Adon Adon Adorer.

Okay.

I'm Adon Adorer.

You're Adon Adorer, yes. Okay. Well, I'm coming in at an eight. I thoroughly enjoy the scoring. I think that that is such a fun puzzle. I love laying stuff down in a tableau in front of me. I do agree that it can get a little bit calculated at the end and there's definitely been moments where I've been like, okay, Wendy, just pick something, go. And I could have spent five more minutes and eked out two or three more points and it might have won me the game. Um but I've made that personal decision to just not let that bother me because the fun of the game and the fun of the puzzle, that matters more than the actual like winning and the squeaking out. Um but yeah, I think that the theme is fun. I like the artwork. I like the little embroidery animals. I think they're adorable. And uh so yeah, this one is it's it's a good one to me.

What are those freaky feathers that like big like ka-pow explosion of feathers?

don't bother me at all. That's a very like normal thing to put on stuff.

Yeah, it just looks a little weird. Looks like Randy Johnson just threw a 104 mph fastball and real thing.

That's the next embroidery thing is a fastball breaking through the embroidery cloth. It's going to be one of those like 3D like you know you're there moments.

There's a dove on the other side that's exploded out.

Yeah.

Amazing baseball moment. Amazingly sad. All right. Well, there you go. That's our thoughts on Faden Fro. Uh high score of an eight giving this one a seal of approval from us here at the Dice Tower.

All right. Thanks for

us. I'm Wendi Yee.

And I'm Chris Yee.

And go uh cross-stitch something. Or play this game.

Go stitch yourself.

Hey everybody, thanks for watching another video from The Dice Tower. Hey, you want to learn more about us, communicate with us, we have a Facebook group, we have a Discord channel, lots of different ways to get involved with The Dice Tower. You can find that in our Linktree link below. So just click that it will take you and you can communicate with us on Facebook, join our Facebook group. There's lots of cool things that you can find and become part of The Dice Tower. Thanks so much for watching. I'm Tom Vasel.

Nidaculture, get it? Like nidaculture? It's pretty good. It's pretty good.

Progress saved