Is Kill Team: Arena the New Shadespire?
Transcript
in this video I'm going to tell you about the new add-on for kill team Arena and whether it's the new shadespire or something else so as I've said many many times I'm not particularly a competitive player but I do uh enjoy the fact that there are competitive players out there that there are competitive tournaments big events things like that the type of games that I like to play with friends and people maybe at the shop don't generally bring bring three or four or 5,000 people together you know Gamers hobbyists tabletop whatever into big you know events like the Las Vegas open which I'm going to next week or adepticon or a Nova open in DC later on in the year or any of these other type of things that that that that crop up those generally don't crop up and get as big as they do without some sort of major tournaments now that being said I still don't play in those tournaments but a lot of people do and I think that there was some talk early on after kill team was first released back in uh July I think it was that um it was maybe not a great competitive game because well frankly for some of the same reasons that 40K is not a great competitive game there's a lot of gray area um the rules the tournament organizers very frequently have to have very specific rules that are different than the ones in the books to make it a more competitive and fair and balanced type
of game but you've still got a lot of models on the board and the board is designed in a way that there's no hexes or squares and there's a lot of three-dimensionality and well I think this guy can see that entire guy well no I think you can't see his foot so therefore he's obscured and all that kind of stuff which is is enjoyable and fun frankly for me in a normal tabletop fun game with a friend or somebody at the local shop but when you're playing a tournament and you're trying to get you know through games multiple games in a certain day and hopefully score well it can become kind of a problem one of the ways the Games Workshop went into uh trying to get into the tight and balanced rule set competitive field was with uh Warhammer underworlds I always want to say Ultima underworlds but that's a Warhammer underworlds which was originally first Shad spire and now you have night Vault those games are specifically designed to be competitive and you can tell because they're played on a hex board so there's never any judging about whether well I think you're about 3 mm off well no I think that you just nudge the board you're either in a Hax or you're not okay so there's that um you've got these decks of cards which kind of bring a lot of the magic players and those types of competitive folks to the yard and so that's kind of a fun thing but yet there's still revised lists um you know restricted lists and Reserve lists and things like that that you can't use these during tournaments and you can't use these during whatever and that kind kind of stuff so you've got that ability
and that kind of competitive level and you can easily also play by just playing with the unpainted you know color colored plastic models that come either in the starter boxes for shadespire or in any of the add-on boxes and I've still believe to this day that shadespire to some degree is a direct kind of um move against something like Star Wars X-Wing which turned into a very competitive game you saw a big competitive uh Circuit of play of you know championships all over the place and I think that Games Workshop was looking at what they were doing and saying we want to be able to do that and make it easier for the tournament organizers to not have to write their own rules and go through all their own stuff and do all of this we want to make a game that is kind of self-contained and streamlined and definite but still fun and can be competitive and I think that the original you know kill team that came out last summer wasn't necessarily fitting that particular flavor and if you were into more 40K and less into say age of Sigmar which is where you get to play Shades Spar and whatnot you were sort of stuck so Along Comes a new add-on Arena which this is make no bones about it this is not a required add-on there's no such thing as a required add-on at least in this system so far you had commanders you could use it or you can not uh you got Rogue Trader you could use it or you can not and the same with this again you can either decide to use use this or not but this is no bones about it designed for
competitive play to the point where it even has an entire section in the rules booklet about how to run tournaments either at your local shop or something bigger or whatever which I've never seen before really for the most part in Games Workshop games so why such a big box well I'll tell you why partially it's because it comes with terrain okay so this is two sprws heavyduty uh kind of a silvery Gray plastic most of these models I recognize but I've never seen them in this sprew configuration before and you have doors and barrels and you have crates um some kind of pipe things and then you also have some boards as well and there are two boards in here and each is double-sided so there are four possible I haven't taken out of the shrink yet but there are four possible boards that you can play with now when I first saw these boards they had uh squares on them and I thought to myself okay they've decided to make it a game of rather than I measure i instead now I go one square two square Three Square which is not true that was what I first thought when I saw the images and I thought okay that's why it's kind of heading towards maybe the shadespire thing because shadespire uses hex's and I was kind of bummed about the concept of taking kill team and trying to put it into this more of a I'm just moving my playing pieces along the squares like I'm playing Candyland but they didn't do that if anything it's because I think in the book when they show you you how to set up the missions they show you very specifically where to put all of these
pieces of terrain and you don't play by the rules in this book with other pieces of terrain you only play with this stuff and so I think that honestly the squares on the board there make it very simple for you to go okay I have to put these barrels one two 3 four four squares over right there on that line and it makes a lot easier to make sure that you can set up the board the way they say in the book because the thing about the way these boards are designed is they are absolute perfect mirrors of of of each side there's never a game where you set it up and go well if I pick this side of the board I've got the taller building so that kind of gives me a little bit of Higher Ground for my sniper or whatever along those lines this is designed to be set up so that the my side of the board is identical to your side of the board and every one of the four different kind of kill zones that come in these big thick boards are not identical to each other but each side of them is identical to the other side and again there's special rules in here that explain exactly where you put all this terrain and this is the way that these missions are done there's kind of no leeway I mean certainly if you and your friends want to do it and start you know changing things up that's fine but I know that if this rule set starts getting picked up by the big tournaments and they start playing Arena at a lot of the big tournaments you will be playing with exactly these boards with exactly this Terrain in exactly the way this book says so the book starts off by telling you about Ultra close confines one of the things you need to know about the arena boards there's really no three-dimensionality that
three-dimensionality though something that I love for normal guill team play doesn't really lend itself super well to competitive play having everything flat and you're basically walking through hallways almost a little bit like space Hulk makes the game a little bit um easier to figure out when you have cover when you don't have cover when you've got line of sight all that kind of stuff honestly going through these rules it reminds me a little bit of the old Star Wars miniatures game uh that Wizards of the Coast used to make where they would have the prepainted Star Wars guys this is back around oh it was like post the prequels you know clone wars and stuff like that and they made these little kind of rubbery sort of hero clicks type people but they were all Star Wars prep paints and it was a tabletop Skirmish board which you played on just a mat there was no actual you know three-dimensional terrain or anything like that and this has got some threedimensional terrain but it's really H honestly just there for a bit of a visual flare it's this could played frankly on just a board with no terrain at all the terrain could be built into the board and it would work the same way the only benefit to having these things is that if you print it onto the board you can't move the terrain and in this you can kind of move the terrain around depending on which Mission you're playing so again this is an add-on to kill team so you need the normal kill team book but then you have these extra special things talking about um walls and visibility and being obscured and it kind of tweaks and changes the normal kill team stuff and tells you all about that then it's got an entire section explaining the four different kill zones
you've got gen gen generator generator I guess it's where the Gen generators are catacombs that's easier to say um The Garrison Vault and I skipped one stockpile so the four boards each two boards double-sided and then the terrain that you're given that's how you make those four kill zones and that's pretty much the only way you do it they tell you exactly how to set up the terrain like how to put it together and when they say this that means three barrels with one on top or it means two crates with a thing and so there's no there's never any like yeah but his side has got the better terrain than mine because it's always again like I said in every one of these missions it's mirrored and then there's all the different missions and they're called competitive play missions so that kind of differentiates them from narrative missions from matched missions stuff like that um and they give you all the information that you need on how to set up each board and all the different things for deployment and scouting phase and all that other stuff and it's designed to be played so that each side has an absolutely kind of equal thing and again it's the type of game where um like a lot of people in Kill team don't play with the like I have a tendency just to build a 100 Point Army but what you're supposed to do is have a roster of models and then pick your 100 points after you figured out which Mission you're going to play they back that that up definitely in um Arena like that's a big point of it and I think think that you're going to see a lot of that in the competitive play at events and tournaments and things like that is that you're going to be bringing a bunch of models and depending on what
you know of your opponent and what you know of the mission you're going to then be able to pick your stuff because you have to have these cards and the data cards and all that jazz set up and they gives you a bunch of also all kinds of cards and and all kinds of extra stuff inside this box um even the mission cards it looks like where they have the big deck of missions um on these cards and instead of having to have them in the book and it kind of helps for maybe shuffling together and deciding which mission is going to happen at which time then they have something called Ultima missions which is basically team games where two of us versus two of you and what you have to do is have two sets of Arena because you're putting the boards together and they have to be perfectly mirrored and again all of it's explained in the different Ultima missions and it shows you all the different ways that they have to go together and where the terrain goes and where the deployment is and all that stuff and so they kind it's kind of cool that they're also not just giving you the one-on-one but the two on two because there's a lot of I mean adepticon one of the the biggest tournaments is the 40K team tournament and it's also I think one of the most fun to watch so being able to kind of take that into consideration over at Games Workshop and put that into the rules booklet I think is a pretty good sign and then lastly they've got an entire section on kill team tournaments and how to run them you've got tournament structure um scoring ranking Arena objectives tokens data cards tournament rules Miniatures all the stuff that you would have to kind of think about ahead of time before you decide to sit down and run a tournament and and again this is at least in my mind they've talked about you know organized play in the past in other
older like um you know main Rule books and stuff like that but to see this specific game go so kind of uh so skewed towards competitive play it's very interesting because again this isn't going to be for everybody this is going to be for the people that are interested in that kind of competitive play it's not even necessarily going to be a situation people are like well I'm just going to buy it for the terrain because as I've said this is all terrain you can get in other places they just never had it all in one sprew like this before I recognize these barrels I recognize these uh ammo crates and you know even the pipes and the doors this is all stuff they've had out for a while it's just now you've got it all together and you could like literally have a tournament just with this box as long as it was just a constant one-on-one tournament maybe you Swip people through you know switched people through as you were playing but that's up to you a store could get multiples of these get them all painted up put them out and have a good siiz you know kill team Arena tournament for not a lot of money so earlier in the video I said is this the new shadespire I wouldn't say so I I really think that it's moving in a direction that shadespire originally moved in but it's doing it in a different way shadespire was designed to be a competitive game and like I said I think it was designed to go head-to-head against uh Star Wars X-Wing and the tournament scene that was happening around that and we're seeing big uh you know Warhammer underworld tournaments at the big conventions uh so that you know mission accomplished there with kill team Arena this is them trying to take
the current kill team rules to make them even a little bit more stripped down and specific so that they will work best in tournament play the thing that always Goofs up tournament play is when the rules in normal play are left to be a little Loosey Goosey for lack of a better term when the rules are kind of like well you know you just measure and you shoot you whatever use your best judgment in a lot of games you'll see that whole thing well if you can't decide rollof you can't do that in a tournament so tournament rules have to be much more strict and specific and that's what they're doing with this kill team Arena and again I'm not a competitive player but it's really interesting to see them taking this Tack and knowing that though you know shadespire night Vault whatever is doing well for them over on the fantasy side they needed something I think that going to do just as well but in a different way over on the 40K side