Empires End - Board Game Review - "No Thanks" Did It Better
Transcript
it sank into the swamp so I built a second one that sank into the swamp so I built a third one that burned down fell over then sank into the swamp hi everyone I'm Lor from the broken me this is the show where I rant and Rave about board games but let's be honest I tend to rant more we'll get on with the show in just a minute but first I'd like my sponsor to have a quick word with you as Gamers we find it hard to deal with empty shelves some worse than others you therefore want the supplier that has what you need at affordable prices and delivers on time for me that supplier is Kender they offer a discount on bulk purchases as well as a point scheme for future Acquisitions down the line if there's a hot title you're after chances are kender's got it wingman mine Arc no mine Eclipse actually hate that game it's terrible but you might like it if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection A F of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it and thanks to the patreons who have suggested this review yes this is voted by them Empire's end John declair as a designer who you will know mostly from his probably his best work space base which I got down there but I also know him from a couple of other more obscure games including Edge of Darkness which I've got down there check out my long
review for that one this big Mammoth worker placement card crafting system and of course you've got Mystic Veil that's also on the Shelf you know generally he's my designer for card crafting when it comes to his like other spin-off games I haven't apart from space base I haven't really jailed with them as much but I was curious to see where this small one kind of landed for two reasons firstly it borrows the no thanks mechanism where you bid in order to not take a card because taking the card is bad for you this was done very well in no fangs I've probably still got it on a shelf somewhere as a tiny little micro game but to see it replicated in a game that's a little bit more involved it's like okay that's a bit different I'm up for you know a little bit of innovation in this respect but the other reason I was intrigued by this is because I barely see anybody talk about this and I don't see anybody play this at all it's only ranked two and a half thousand on Board Game Geek which let's face it is not the highest rating to ever give it not that I trust the rankings that much but then when I looked at the reviews that you see on there probably like some fairly well-known critics they tend to rate it pretty high for a game that most users don't rate that high it's the equivalent of looking up a movie on Rotten Tomatoes and seeing the critic score really high and then the user audience score really low so part of me is thinking okay is this actually you know a bit underappreciated by people but then I'm also thinking is this a little bit overhyped by critics that's for me to find out am I so out of touch
no it's the children who are wrong Empire end is played over a series of phases which are tracked as the game goes on most of these phases will resolve around disasters affecting your civilization so everybody will have the exact same setup of civilization tiles in front of them that represent various locations with different effects depending on the phase economy military industry and the idea with these is that what will happen is a card will be flipped off the deck which will have a disaster on it and it will affect a specific location which you'll Mark with a little fire piece let's say this one here I don't know blight for example actually well 10 all right fine let's be accurate it's that one and the idea is is that then players will bid the resources pictured on there in this case axes and hammers to not take the disaster so you might have a bunch of these behind your hidden screen so people can't see the resources and so I decide I don't want that disaster I'm putting a hammer on it somebody else next door after me says well I don't want it I'm putting an axe on it third person decides I don't want to hammer I want I don't want it I'm putting a hammer on it and you decide well you know what I like those resources I'm going to take the disaster which you might think why Earth would you want to because when you take a disaster you get two benefits as well as the bad the bad is it blows up your location meaning it doesn't count for victory points it loses all abilities and any like special things underneath it but you get all the resources that are on the disaster to use on future turns and the bottom of each disaster is an innovation kind of like an upgrade a ility which you can
slide underneath a healthy location and it gives you either some extra bonuses in economy some extra discounts in Industry maybe some little shenanigan abilities here and there or some endgame scoring abilities or even some economy phase scoring abilities they basically improve the rest of your Empire and that is kind of 75% of the whole game really these disasters will keep flipping sometimes one at a time sometimes two at once and you have to bid the specific resour resources which you know there are some grain ones in here here we go flood requires grain and so with your resources you're kind of trying to enter this Balancing Act of you know do I take the disaster with what's on it do I let it go around a few more times try and get other players to put stuff on it or do I you know try and keep out of my system for as long as possible because it will really hurt but as the game goes on you will obviously destroy some locations you're going to have to you're not going to keep everything squeaky clean but in doing so you'll be able to grab more of these grade abilities to make the rest of your Empire really good the economy phase is simply just gaining resources based on the green abilities in your Empire the industry phase has you build some of these out of your hand you'll have a hand of these any one time four cards and you might decide well you know what I'm going to sell this card for a gold and I'll B I'll build this one okay so this will cost me so many hammers you can also repair destroyed empir Bings by spending hammers as pictured on the tile and then finally there is the military phase where the military phase has you I didn't take the cards out of the box silly me you
essentially have a bunch of cards with a scaling s rating for military power and you have base power based on the number of sort cross swords on your Empire tiles but you'll be able to also then do a closed fist bidding phase where you put as many axes as you want in your hand out it goes everybody simultaneously reveals compare the military power you get victory points and resources based on how high you got but the winner gets a little bit of a bonus and the losers have to do some swappy nonsense with their tiles yes the tiles may start in the same location to begin with but there are various ways to swap the various things around so that you can have a different setup to other players the game carries on until all the phases are done on this track it gets to the very end and then you total up some endgame victory points as well as what you've earned during and the one with the most is of course the winner so to quickly talk about Aesthetics the Aesthetics of this are standard really there's nothing particularly amazing the artwork is fine on the tiles although I do quite like how the fire effect on the reverse is kind of done in this uh sort of shiny edged emboss look so whenever the light catches on the tile it really does glow like it looks like a glowing fire that I find is just quite a nice touch but the tiles are decent thickness the cards are they're very thin that's one thing I'm not a fan of I mean these are very flimsy like thin cards you know you thought like space base had thin cards I think these are thinner but I can't deny that one aspect this Aesthetics get right is the insert and just the storage
now it's not particularly suited for sleeving cards although I don't think you really desperately need to with this game it's pretty cheap enough but you know if you sleeve the cards you will a you'll barely be able to find ones that fit unless you grab the space Bas slice sized sleeves but even then the insert doesn't cater very well for sleeve cards but what the insert does do if you're willing to ignore sleeving is store everything really nicely I mean you know everything's already in there from a card perspective the screens sit on top of there the board would sit on top of here and then these trays of which you've got a resource token tray with lid you know lid perfect and then you've got a player tray for everyone so this contains all your location tiles as well as uh you know the markers for your civilization and some extra starting resources you just simply put all four of them like so I'm doing this kind of roughly cuz obviously I want to show you other stuff but they'll store really neatly in there r book on top lid done and it's you these aren't game trays these are just standard plastic trays for a fairly small publisher I mean brotherwise games are not that well known or that particularly large this is pretty good going I think it was a Kickstarter but you know if it was a Kickstarter it would have been a fairly small one but this is pretty decent for a storage solution you know they they dro the ball a little bit on the whole sleeving front but if you can get past that little blemish it's done pretty well it's just that the artwork is kind of me you know the tight the the cover
isn't really seen in it to you the title is fairly Bland and you know nothing on here is particularly amazing in terms of art but functionality does a pretty good job the rules to this aren't particularly complicated I mean the rule book is fairly small there's a good quick start guide on the back which is pretty useful and everything is referenced at the back of the book as well there is a decent amount of text though and certainly I did find myself having to do a bit of rule checking in the first couple of uh first couple of games particularly when you had to worry about double disaster phases and exactly what you're allowed to do in the industry phase and what some of these abilities do they're not particularly intuitive so there's a little bit of rule book checking here and there but I didn't have too much trouble with this after say the first couple of games it you know I got used to it after a point and the rules for most part are pretty straightforward especially if you have played no thanks the mechanic is pretty much no thanks you know down to a te so if you already have experience with that game well then teaching you this is absolutely like you know absolute ease but even if you have never played no thans in your life and you've never seen this bidding mechanic before doesn't take that much to explain now the actual mechanic itself is definitely the highlight of the game the idea that you've got a disaster card that has been flipped you look at the Innovation below and think hm that could be beneficial to Me Maybe it wouldn't be too bad if I took it but I on which location is it going to blow up oh God my 25 Victory Point Town I'm not sure I want to blow that up even for this uh you know what I think I'm going to try and not grab this
so uh grain no no oh go back to me again grain no no oh no do I take it because if I put any more Grain on it you're going to take it you're going to have all this grain but I don't want to blow up the town that's I don't like it and you get a lot of these angsty decisions every time a disaster flips up some of you may die but it's a sacrif iice I am willing to make now there are some issues with it as well we'll touch on those a bit later but I do like the T antin that it provides in terms of the Innovations themselves it's cool that you can slightly customize your play style as the game goes on you'll start off identical but as the game progresses you will swap some of these tiles around and you will be able to get all sorts of these different Innovations I mean every industry phase you can build two of these Macs out your hand and if you take several disasters then well you you'll have even more of them in your Empire and they do all sorts of things I mean they can add to your military phase I had one game where I had so many swords down the bottom that yes I kind of struggled a little bit for certain resources but when it came to the military phase it was just boom dominance like not a problem but then you got other ones that actually reward you if they blow up you've got endgame scoring for having resources or being next to certain tiles and you know we'll touch on this a little bit more later but there's even some ability straight out of space base where you can trigger them by putting a cube on them to say well well I don't need to put a resource on this or I can negate this so there's a decent amount of variety in the
abilities and this Choice over which ones do I build which ones do I am I willing to take a disaster for in order to get this Innovation is definitely where the highlight of this game is there are a few bad things to go over but none of which are particularly gamebreaking but there does seem to be quite a few of them firstly let's talk about probably the biggest one of the lot which is the duration of the game 45 to 60 Minutes is what's quoted on the box good fraking luck with that yeah 45 to 60 is a little bit optimistic you were really honestly looking at 60 to 90 you could possibly do this two players in 45 minutes if you know what you're doing but every game I've played of this with three or four players never takes lower than 75 minutes it's always taking longer than that and 90 minutes for a free player is not unreasonable h I have seen four players you know go to two hours it can go long if players take a while to sort out their industry phases the economy phases I mean yes they are supposed to be simultaneous but you're still only going as fast as your lowest common denominator and if you're playing the game with four or more players you have to do even more disasters because you have multiple of them you know in a particular round and if there's two disasters in a round then you've got more to consider as to what resources they have what they're going to blow up Etc so the game easily is longer than 45 to 60 minutes which is not to say that the game is stupidly long in general but let's consider some other negatives first the luck aspect there is a decent
amount of luck in this game and the longer you make a game without luck mitigation then the more problematic it becomes and this game does have a problem of outstaying its welcome once it gets past an hour because you are just basically rinse repeating throughout the whole game it's like disaster disaster quick industry phase disaster quick economy phase disaster disaster disaster quick industry phase disaster disaster disaster it's like and Military thrown in every now and again mostly near the end it's it's a little bit repetitive well that was point so let's talk more about this luck aspect every disaster that comes out is random every Innovation you draw from the deck is random and there is no luck mitigation for this bar one Innovation ability that might let you change the top design they get split that's the only way you can mitigate these aspects right so your civilization will start off identical to begin with but very quickly with some swapping Shenanigans and various things getting blown up it's going to be different for other players particularly where you put these Innovations you know I might stack you know I might put an innovation on a tile that you don't do it on yours and suddenly that tile is worth more for me than anybody else but let's say we know we flip a a flip of one 's sorry flipper card number seven here fire okay 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 it's this one so for me there it's an 8 Victory Point Farm not too big a deal for somebody else it might be their Free Victory Point Farm even less of a big deal for somebody else it could be their 32 point City and giving the 32 points
is like a fifth of your score on average that's a that unless you've got a good Hammer income that is not a tile you can afford to let blow up under any circumstances it is a massive blow because it takes like 12 hammers to fix and it's insanely hard to get that many hammers but the problem is is that this this is one card right so you know okay fine it there it blows up not a problem that's happened I then flip over another card and it also says seven and then it says seven again and then it says seven or eight you know it says you know one of the two that's already blown up this could happen and in one game it did we had one that just constantly kept repeating the same area of the board the problem is for one player that's not a big deal because there's small victory Point values I haven't put anything there whoopy do but for another player it's absolutely crippling because they can't afford to have their giant towns and their big city blow up but the deck is constantly bringing out disaster cards saying these are going to blow up these are going to blow up that person is fighting a much tougher game than anybody else and it's entirely down to luck of the draw without usually any means of mitigating it bar that one Innovation ability to flip was it to change the top card of a disaster deck which isn't on that many Innovation cards to be frank just give us a T you son and then you've got the idea of drawing Innovations in the first place so you have four in your hand you can choose whether to scrap um them at the end of around but let's say okay I draw four new ones let's see I've got endgame scoring for having Farms well they've
already blown up and I've got military boosts but I've already got a decent amount of military okay so these are mostly useless to me somebody else draws a few cards and suddenly gets like oh W that gets me a lot of grain for this and oh that's perfect for where I've got there so again they're in a really good situation and it doesn't seem like they you know were any more skillful it's just the cards just happen to come out in that way and it benefits them rather than you and this game does suffer a little bit on that as much as the no thanks mechanic is still fun and tense the idea of actually being able to plan anything in this game is pretty much non-existent you can't plan for anything you don't know what Innovations you're going to draw you know what disasters are going to come out of the deck it's entirely random so you're playing fully tactically which I don't usually mind games that are mostly tactical but this is tactical in the sense that bad stuff is happening to you which for some players it's going to irk them you know I don't mind it if the whole game is like that the whole game is meant to be about you know things bad happening to you although there are limitations as long as you can mitigate it to a reasonable perspective you know I don't like in the year of the dragon by Stephan felge and that's another game where that one just basically throws every like everything in the kitchen sink at you to make your life miserable well this one is doing that on a similar basis just it's a lighter game but you can find yourself in a position where the game just absolutely hates you and that's not going to be a fun game for you if that happens it's going to leave a bit of a sour note in your mouth it
also has a problem where you can kind of easily tell who's going to win by the time you get to about the three quarter Mark you know I get to a point it's like well I'm miles ahead on this point track because of militaries I've got some end game scoring here so of you I mean yeah I'm really much in the lead here and it just ends up staying that way so I've never had any surprise oh wow I didn't expect you to beat me on the scoring moments you know they have never happened another little negative I have is that the game ends up being kind of a memory game at some respects and I don't like memory games that much and a lot of people don't memory games is probably going to be one of the least liked genres out there but because your resources are behind the screen and you know these are they do take a little bit of folding to get stand up but you know these resources are here there 's no way I can remember whether somebody's got three axes five axes 100 axes who knows you know from round to round there's just too much going on to do that so when you're doing the bid for the disaster TI you don't really know whether somebody else is likely to carry on bidding or has no opportunity to bid because they don't have the pictured resources now if they were revealed resources so you knew exactly what everybody had you could make that decision you could think well hang on if I keep this going long enough they're definitely going to take this you know they're going to have to they haven't got a choice but then it could also still throw a spanner in the works where somebody you think well you've got enough resources there I reckon you're going to carry this on for a while and then they still take the tile and it's like oh okay I didn't expect that you know you could still get surprised a little bit but I do wonder if the game
would play better if you didn't have these hidden but while they're hidden you've got the randomness of the card drawer you've got the randomness of the innovations that you get and then you've got effectively a memory game for remembering what resources everybody had and I don't mind that too much you can make some educated guesses but I don't know it's just one of those other little irks that the game has that I think H maybe that could have been improved in some way aside from that there's also one kind of throwaway mechanic that I don't think really needed to be in this game I feel like this was John declair trying to throw in something that makes you go oh I know that's a John Clair game because this is in the game and it's these Cube abilities none a lot of these Innovations have these Cube abilities and you start off with two locations that actually say you can refresh neighboring ability cards but these two tiles you would pretty much blow up instantly if not for the fact that they are fairly High Victory Point values you know so you know these most of the time are useless because you could go the whole game never drawing a single Cube ability but it's the same thing from space base you know it's that thing where you go right I've got an ability here that lets me swap the top disaster card okay put a cube on it I've done it and now I've got to refresh it by taking the cube off it's finicity it's fiddly it's kind of one of the more sort of clunky Like rules of the game and it just feels like it was an afterthought like I need more stuff to put on these cars than just these abilities I'm kind of running out of ideas you know what I know let me just hijack this out of my space base game shove it on the cards and that will work
I mean you barely have any cubes in the slot I mean you got like about like 10 you know 10 12 cubes in there this is how rare they think it's is because they've barely given you like 12 cubes to deal with four players worth of cube abilities potentially it's like that's how like little it matters but is that it there's also not that much player interaction in this game you've got the the decision of oh you know it's going around the different players and there'll be the resource but because you can't see what their resources are there's not really much you can deduce from them so it's just another obstacle or another random effect as to whether it comes back round to you or not but on top of that the player scaling is a bit off this is two to four players and honestly the most optimal count is probably three and it really does kind of need to be fre cuz if you play this with two then there's not enough resources being passed around if you play with four then most certainly is enough resources but then you've got to play with all these extra disasters to deal with which a makes it more punishing potentially but also elongates the game but even though it's simultaneous you still got more to consider but the length of the game in general is extended with four players beyond what is already an optimistic time frame on the back so fre seems to be the right sweet spot but it's bewildering that this board does not scale with players I mean you get some scaling now you know I will uh here we go quickly sort of summarize here so this is the fre and four player section with two players you don't have as many disasters and phases to go through so
it's only as a much faster game but the problem is is that none of the tiles scale so you know this one costs seven hammers to repair regardless of whether you have you know two players three players or four players so if only two of you are passing resources around how many hammers do you think you're going to get suddenly anything that blows up is a massive deal but if you've got four of you if four of you are putting resources on those tiles and they're being passed around then there could be a ton of resources on the tow before you take it suddenly repairing a location isn't anywhere near as bad yes there's more disasters so that might make up for it to some extent but again random draw the disasters random draw the Innovations who knows it will do there's no easy way to you know to you know be certain about what effect it has so Empire's end is a fine game but not one that I'm going to go too mad over it's it does the job from that no thanks biding mechanic CU I do enjoy that you know having this tense decision of whether I let the tile pass on or whether I let it blow up something in my area and then watching my Empire get better in some respect and worse than others that bits fine but those problems do add up you've got a lot of Randomness in the game that you can't control that can easily hose a particular player if it's just unlucky for them the player scaling as I said is not particularly great two players does not really work three is optimal and four just goes on a bit long and has way too many disasters happening but then you've also got some of the issues that there's not a huge
amount of player interaction you've got that the you know some of these locations just aren't particularly worth it the whole Cube ability system just feels like a throwaway waste you there's you know some parts of the game that just reduce its Effectiveness from what it could have been I could have seen this actually being a solid endorsement wory game but for me I think it's a game that I would play if you put it on the table I would play it but you know I would definitely want to stick to three players which Aden AES two player counts out of the bag I would also probably not seek it out it's not one I'm going to keep and I would certainly rather play no thanks honestly because you're asking me to play effectively no thanks for three maybe four times you know the length of that game and that's just from the what's printed on the box let alone if it goes longer than that you know no thanks is a tiny little micro game that does the job for a reason you know this one is basically trying to say well do you like that mechanic let's just do this for another 90 minutes or so yes there's a few added bits here and there but do you want to play the no thanks mechanic for 90 minutes straight or would you rather just play the micro game so all in all I'm giving this one a five out of 10 it's average it's not bad it's not particularly great either I would play it but it's not what I'm going to keep I wouldn't seek it out I can see why it's ranked a bit lower I really don't get where these critics are saying 8 n out of 10 that I think you have to forgive so much in this game to
be willing to give it even an eight let alone a nine out of 10 nine out of 10 seriously an Excellence rating a distinction rating where are you coming from with that that doesn't make any sense so I'm definitely siding with the audience on this front you know when it comes to the whole Rotten Tomatoes analogy the critics have got it wrong the audience have got it right so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on board game gek when it goes live on the page don't forget to check out the other content I've done I just done a massive video on my top 10 tips for running a board game club by all means check out that lengthy discussion and let me know your thoughts and course let me know your thoughts on this one do you agree with the negatives do you agree with the positives do you side with the Critics on this one or do you side with the audience be interesting to know until next time regardless of whether you want your place overrun by famine blight plague revolts earthquakes you know you name it every disaster in the book it's still only a game so bye for now