Skip to main content
Loading video...

Alison Collins on Wiñay Kawsay | Zenobia Finalists 2021

Transcript 27:25

hey gamers this is liz davidson for beyond solitaire and i'm here with mitch reed from no dice no glory what's up liz i'm doing great because we are here today to introduce allison collins she's a finalist for the zenobia award and the designer of wenye kause how are you doing allison i'm really good thanks it's lovely to meet you both it's great to meet you too so why don't we just start with the the obvious tell us about your game okay so when you calculate is a two to four player euro style game all about um understanding interpretations of machu picchu so it's almost a history of the history making of of machu picchu rather than a history of the place itself so it's exploring the multiple different historical interpretations of the site and and what it was over time and also it's a look into the role of historians in shaping historical narrative and constructing history sometimes by um not so sound practice or not necessarily with the history at um at heart so what got you interested in this particular topic so it was a bit strange um i had a university assignment for a course all about the role of the city in history and immediately the the assignment said pick a city and explore an aspect of it and i'm like yeah i want to do machu picchu the lost city of the anchor for my assignment and i started researching it and i was very upset to find that um it probably wasn't a lost city and then

it really got me thinking oh wait but why does everyone know that machu picchu is the lost city of the inca what led to that being the case and i started to do some investigation into the historical opinion of what machu picchu was and found just a minefield of you know machu picchu was lost city of the inca machu picchu was a royal estate machu picchu was a religious side a citadel of some sort lots of different interpretations that over time historians had you know some had said this and some had said that and fighting each other and reinterpreting evidence and a whole train of malpractice and misinterpretation as well and then when i had another history assignment at university um they said you could make anything and i made a prototype for when you call say that the board game but um so yeah that was really what i um that's how i got interested in the topic and then the zenobia award came up and i uh i entered my very very different prototype in that um and it got completely sort of the original one got thrown out the window and um through the process of the last few months been making a game that's that's much better than that original one that i submitted for the history assignment so i guess you're a history major i i did a double degree a bit of a weird one i did history and then i did i t as well nice that's a that's a rare combination yeah it's it's surprisingly rare but um the the two actually go quite well together um yeah

what was the hardest thing about um doing research and building mechanics for this game um so the biggest the the research thankfully i done most of it for the assignment itself so i had this this great base of research before entering the the zenobia award to to build off and a lot of the cards in which the you know the evidence is sort of the basis of the cards of the game so this piece of evidence suggests that machu picchu was these particular interpretations so that was actually all done before the contest but the hardest part was understanding the history and then looking at that malpractice and the misinterpretation and converting that to game mechanics so i didn't want a game that the players were forced to sort of perform the the missteps and the malpractice and that and that was the original version of the game it was all about performing malpractice and the more i thought about that i thought oh this is pretty bad you don't want the players to be making those mistakes you want them to have the option to actually do things well and be historically rigorous rather than it just be a case study and failing um so balancing that that history of you know things done badly with the option for players to pick their own route to exploring the history being more interpretive than literally just following the uncovering as it happened um and then fitting that within a fun game mechanic that held together regardless of your approach so the game itself does still let you conduct male practice um but that had to be sort of competitively balanced with

following it doing it a more rigorous way and there were a lot of changes to the game around there used to be a conspiracy theory mechanic in the game where conspiracy theories could be published to discredit evidence which is something that's obviously done in the broader historical space and that does inform an interpretation of a lot of historical sites like conspiracy theories but um a lot of feedback i received was you know fostering conspiracy theories is such a strong mechanic of the game probably not a great approach to go with presenting that on equal footing with a genuine publication and so a lot of revising to still keep the fun and the interest in the intrigue there but but making it putting its best foot forwards ideally rather than the malpractice well you know conspiracy theories we have a bunch of them now so it's kind of a fitting in my opinion would be a real fitting mechanic but may not be great for a game so i have a mechanical question so in a game how do you reward doing the right thing historically and kind of disincentivize doing the wrong one or does this game do that i mean i i'm actually a historian myself and i wonder about that because sometimes it seems like it'd be so easy to just make something else yeah and i think the the interesting thing here is that the victory point currency of the game is influence and that was a very deliberate decision that influence the best way to gain influence in the game from from me playing it a few times

is to do the right thing you're more likely to rack up the points really easily if you're building those interpretations you're publishing you're advancing your academic tenure in the game so doing things the right way does help that however there are little opportunities you can engage in to to sabotage other people historical events come up and it's the cornerstone of that mechanic is that you can sabotage those events if you feel it's not in your best interest to help out the broader historical community um and also in terms of the options for you to develop yourself as a historian there's sort of two more academically sound routes you can pick and there's one pathway there the popularizer pathway which sort of is for the historian that maybe values themself and their own charisma more than necessarily what they're saying based off a key historical figure in the matchy picture case study and that's a risky route to go like you could win the game very convincingly if you play your cards right on that one but it's a risk to take it's definitely not the most straightforward pathway of the three in the game so i think it's balancing risk reward in terms of how how far a player is willing to go to to conduct that malpractice how committed are they and the fact that through the other players in the game that that really sabotaging the other players and almost having this historical community turn on the players who aren't as historically rigorous as the rest and having that social dynamic in the game but also making it more risky in a competitive sense nice so i have one more kind of history

in your question and i i think about this so my own research so i studied egyptian monasticism for my dissertation and i always think about you know like you know i'm a class this is not a land teacher so we think about things like you know britain having the elgin marbles and like a lot of historians uh study cultures that aren't necessarily theirs and then publish about it you are australian you got interested in machu picchu made a game about a historian studying machu picchu how um did you account for kind of the extra layer of cultural challenges of historians studying somebody else's culture and maybe doing that from a colonial perspective yeah and it's it's such a hard one and i think it's exemplified that a lot of historical games are presenting the history as a history as it was question marks um and and trying to represent that almost as a simulation of the history this one's doubly hard because it's the history of the history making process so it's understanding not only how that history was made but the flaws of the history process being made and then what is represented on top of that um to account for that as well this particular history is very interpretive and there's no like though there's a genuine perceived sort of um consensus broadly in what machu picchu was it's still being heavily debated and people still have different opinions coming coming in and interpreting different evidence so for me i think i just tried to make the game less of a simulation try and make it more explorative so here is the evidence that um has been found

of the site have a look at this evidence and what do you personally see in it um i think in terms of understanding the culture itself um that's something that beyond there's no reward in taking this game forward i definitely want to to do more and it's something that i've been trying my whole process along to sort of check myself check any sort of biases i have coming in re-go back to the research and then moving forward it's something i'd really like to do in terms of getting a cultural consulting on before the publication talking to some people making sure is my understanding correct have i missed anything i think that's something an emerging practice that very necessarily has to happen and something i really want to do to make sure i'm on the right track like i'm trusting my my historical background from university right that i i am doing this rigorously and i am doing this properly but you know getting a cultural advisor on would be you know it is the way to go with any of these historical games and it's something that um i think wasn't necessarily in the scope of the contest given how tight the time has been to develop the game but moving forward hopefully towards publication that's the number one priority for me there are a few key historians in particular that um you know have have completely uh informed the game and their research has been a cornerstone to understanding the artifacts i'd love to talk to them i'd love to talk to any particular cultural advisors in the space especially looking at the the religious history of the site that's where i'd love to to meet a few people and and talk to them um just the the contest was quite tight in

terms of its time spans and and that considering i had to rebuild the game from you know basically scratch in february um getting this base prototype that we've all had to submit for the finals has really been my my number one priority having something good enough that someone can come in and help me with it rather than just oh here's this thing i cobbled together please help me and that leads me to uh to uh like a two-part question here is this your first foray in game design and uh whether yes or no what do you think of the zenobia process so to the first question yes this is my first foray in game design i almost don't count that first prototype i submitted of this one game but i given that that was for a history assignment and i didn't really trust my professors would um you know understand complex mechanics and that was more about presenting the history rather than designing a game itself so um there was that and that was well trash if i'm being honest um so so starting that from scratch and rebuilding a game this is really the first game i've i've developed um and my experience with the zenobia award process um i can only speak for myself but i've just had the best time with this opportunity i got the most wonderful mentoring team in marie stuckling and dan burt to help me and and to advise me and you know i i'm at a stage now we've done so many meetings over the course of the last few months and chatted so much and um they've really

really helped me you know understand game design better and helped me improve the game and continue to iterate and iterate um i've met some really wonderful like i've met all the finalists and a few of the other contestants and they're so lovely and the games are incredible um and just meeting this broader network of incredible people like you know chatting to volco regularly and meeting some some really other wonderful people in the contest it's just been it's it's been incredible like for someone with no game design real background but wanting to learn and wanting to explore historical games more um to be able to really jump into this space meet people develop ideas and and and prove something that i'm now super passionate about it's just for me it's been the best i i can only speak for myself but this opportunity has been uh it's no hyperbole to say it's been life-changing for me um this this process so you have another you're gonna do it you're gonna do another game eventually right this is positive yeah i hope so um and then i've actually been able to i'm not i believe my work on when you cal say help this i've i've been wanting to move into game design more broadly i've been applying for jobs and very recently i actually got a job in in the games industry and i'm pretty sure that my experiences in the senobi award shaped me getting that job as a graduate game designer so what was the uh what do you think was the uh most difficult part of going from having an initial vision of your game

and then getting to the zenobia version of your game yeah so i i think i this was a really hard one because i i was weirdly proud back in february i was a completely different person turns out um and i was proud of that pro that trash product i had and then to sit down with my mentor in one of the first sessions and him very sort of very gently leading me towards this whole thing should be revised if you want to get you know if you want to use this opportunity to develop and grow as a designer and if you want to stand a chance in this competition needs to be started from scratch um that was quite a hard thing but i was i was pretty lucky and i've always been relatively good at coming up with ideas and it just so happened that i'd been given for christmas by my partner a model of machu picchu because i'm very interested and i love it and i just happen to be thinking how can i change the game how can i change the game i saw the model and it just weirdly clicked that sort of ah a model and this idea of you know having this physical side of machu picchu and then historians deconstructing it and rebuilding it with their own mental model and the mental model that's in the public it's just sort of weirdly like one of those real sort of shower thoughts i entered the shower with no idea i left the shower oh this is going to be the core of the game um can recommend showers showers for

game design so i i think that really thankfully that that pivot happened quite quickly and then from there it's thinking about well what are the other historical aspects that are key to this this model model historical model um of understanding this particular case study is it focusing on the malpractice is it focusing on this idea of reinterpretation is it focusing on this idea of history as an evolving understanding and it it was for me i wanted to hopefully touch on all three of these ideas um and trying to make particular systems work together to very um nicely hold all that together and that was like the whole zenobia process getting to a point where i felt that the all those different systems embodied that historical model and i think that's probably been the the overarching challenge for me especially with this model that is a little bit off the beaten track and a bit different to typical historical games when the historical model is sort of um much more meta in some ways of how do we understand history making those systems hold together make sense still be fun but fit within the history i'm trying to present that's been the challenge for me and it's really been something that at every point i've created a prototype and it's been like oh this is great i think i've got it now do a play test oh i very clearly don't have it yet uh iterate iterate iterate presented in front of the play test oh i

think this could be it it's not it's not and i think it's going to continue to i'm happy with where it's at right now but you know ask me in a few months time and i'll think oh you know you bring up an amazing point and i've even before zenobia i work with so many game designers um i never had box envy i never wanted my name on the box but i enjoy helping others and i always say check your ego at the door because if you trust the people that are helping you um listen to them as much as possible and it's so hard for games excuse me game designers to do that because it's it's their creative baby yeah and so good on you for listening and then my only real question now is was that model of machu picchu in lego i wish it was in lego you know there is actually a designer who's gone and made a little lego model of magic kitchen and originally when i was coming up with the block idea i thought lego would be so cool um sadly i i didn't reach out to that designer at all but um no the model i have is a beautiful one made out of um some sort of i think clay or um some sort of modeling process a hard modeling process i've completely forgotten the name of clay or some sort cement perhaps even i i'm a game designer i don't know anything about building materials so speaking of uh games more in general as we kind of get

to the softball part of this interview uh what what games do you like to play yourself and do you think that any have inspired you as a designer um so i guess this is a strange question for me i'm very very very new to the the war gaming and historical game space i don't i don't deny that i have not played many myself and learning about these games through the zenobia award and studying like the different judges and the the organizers games has been really amazing and excited for me i come at it from a much more casual perspective like a lot of the the board games i play are uh very sort of you know more more casual bent ones but um i think that's what's made i guess my game quite interesting because it is a more casual it's a competitive game but it's not it's not going to take you 10 hours to play and it's got knock on 100 different pieces and i think bringing some of those more simpler mechanics and mechanics that have a more social dynamic to them um so for example one game that i really love playing is mountains of madness which is a casual game but it it has a lot of different social dynamics that influence how um you complete different challenges and that inspired me in aspects as well of you know having different sabotage mechanics um i'm also more broadly interested in in video games and even sort of um social simulation game shows and reality tv like i'm a huge survivor fan and bringing in some of those ideas of being duplicitous and working and

almost riding other people's coattails um in their development and i saw a lot of parallels with the historical scenario of historians riding others hotels and working off what others have built off and kind of you know someone presenting a lot of evidence and others getting the glory for it so i've really drawn my inspiration for the game from from a lot of different avenues and i almost feel like not being so focused on on a particular genre of what i play and then drawing more broadly has created a game that i think is more sort of the mechanics fitting the historical model than necessarily fitting convention fantastic uh and would you recommend the well actually let me rephrase that so how would you recommend that other people like you who are maybe curious about trying game design hop in i think like first and foremost you've got nothing to lose if it's something you're passionate about if it's something you enjoy doing join give it a try like you know and never think you're not good enough never think that you don't have enough knowledge to start because you you have to start to gain knowledge right um and so i think in terms of building up that knowledge contests like the zenobia award are brilliant yes we have designers coming in who have published titles and yes we have designers who've made lots of different games and have you know strong bases in historical games or a history degree you don't need any of those to to join a contest like this and there are other contests as well like zenobia award is not the only game design and board game design

contest out there more broadly things like game jams like be that video game jams or board game jams are incredible opportunities to meet people and learn and to make a game in a very short space of time that lets you gain some confidence and gain some skills meet people and see if this is something you like doing and if it is do another one and if it is make a personal project like we're so lucky that we've got so many different tools available to us like tabletop simulator like vassal um that we can you know make games and prototype very quickly and it and it look very very good and play well with with people from all over the world um you know in that sense we do live in such a wonderful time of of knowledge building of being able to develop oneself without you know incredible getting a huge game design degree at a university or anything like that because there's so many resources available to us so i think just jump in like is my advice i i jumped into there's no reward not really knowing what to expect and i've gotten so much out of it so i can definitely recommend you survive the process i did survive the process and what a process it was so we know that you guys have been talking to one another and you've heard about um all the other games yes what games are you i it's a hard question because i know you guys are becoming friends um what games are you excited to play from

the other seven like i know it's a real cop-out to say all of them but that's what everybody's been saying i know but that's because they are also interesting and also different like all coming at it from a very different mechanical perspective you've got ones like winter rabbit that like is such a different take on history in it being more a folklore way of telling history and very like simple but elegant game mechanics compared with you know the vast scale of a game like like tyranny of blood which has a lot of different moving parts but all seem to work together really well molly house on top of that like a truly unique incredible theme where that like for me the moment that joseph explained that the currency of the game was joy and collective joy i'm like wow yeah that's genius that's so inspiring and clever like i'm personally really interested in in sort of period dramas and that that british style history so once like the season look incredible to play and that interesting dynamic between building up the skills of a young lady that she needs to marry versus the practical skills she actually needs in life um marcel's game um orange shall overcome like it looks stunning and evading you know getting caught looks looks brilliant um i've i've seen a bit of damon's game from a few months back and liberation haiti with the two different phases just looks so incredible and interesting and sharia's game as well like teaching indonesian school girls to um you know be more literate and that

process of actually getting them from the schoolyard into you know the broader community and enhancing like on a more national scale um they're they're all just so incredible like i i just i'm blown away by like so many of them even some of the the non-finalists like if anyone hasn't seen the the list of the games that got to proposal stage and then on top of that the two um highly commended they all look amazing so i i don't have enough hours in the day to play them all because they all look so damn great they really do so our clothes are saying yours looks amazing oh thank you and uh do you have a social media presence where people can contact you about your work i do not twitter is a scary scary space of anger and and um you know socially anxious people i think for me no no no no no so no i don't i'm looking at getting a board game geek um page for for windya kelsey um in terms of i think reaching out for me um at the moment i'm i'm unknown so in the future you might see me on there if i get convinced by someone but um yeah contact listen mitch if you if you have any questions about the game um i might even add a link to the prototype perhaps with this this podcast in the description if that's allowed

so you can you can hop on there and that's obviously in steam workshop you can contact me if you wish um and yeah otherwise contact liz and mitch and they'll pass something on to me and i'll i'll i'd love to talk to you i just social media is is a scary horrible place it brings your danger indeed indeed so if you want to contact me for me i'm everywhere online is beyond solitaire mitch can be found there's no dice no glory and we have been so happy to have allison collins designer of wigner cause happy gaming everybody thanks everyone bye

you

Progress saved