Skip to main content
Loading video...

Dinosaur Digs: A Zoo Tycoon Board Game Review

Transcript 15:30

Hi everyone, I'm Tally. This is Farrell and we are Board of It and welcome to our review of Zoo Tycoon: Dino Digs, which is a standalone expansion to Zoo Tycoon the board game and is for one to four players. This time, you're not just creating a zoo, you're creating a dinosaur zoo. Dino Digs very much has the feel of Zoo Tycoon, but with some elements changed or adapted with some elements being more streamlined and some being added due to the new theme.

Yes. So, because of that and because of its similarities to Zoo Tycoon, we will be kind of comparing and contrasting at times, as well as obviously talking about the new mechanisms. But, before we get into it, please know that what you're going to see is a prototype. Uh I believe that the gameplay is pretty much all there, but the components will probably improve for the better. I know the dinosaur meeples are going to look a bit better in the final product. So, yeah, just just know it's a prototype. With that, we will get to how to play.

Dino Digs is played over seven years with each year consisting of four seasons. Throughout, you'll be gaining popularity and science points and then at the end of year seven, the player's final score will be the lower score of each of the two types of points. These points are obtained from a variety of sources like adding dinosaurs to your zoo, from buildings and via end-game scoring. Worker placement is a key aspect as players will start with some private worker placement spaces and can also buy buildings that provide worker placement actions. In spring, players can use workers to draft items from the fieldwork board such as dinosaur cards, DNA, technologies, and sponsor cards. In summer, players will use workers to clone dinosaurs matching dinosaur cards that they own using the DNA they have collected. DNA will be male, female, or neutral with different dinosaurs having different DNA costs with the DNA used also determining the gender.

Dinosaurs created can either go into quarantine or straight into an enclosure if one is ready to hold them. In autumn, players will build. On their player boards, players will build enclosures to house the dinosaurs, landscape those enclosures, and also build buildings which provide storage, resources, or worker placement spaces. Each dinosaur species is represented by a card which shows several needs for the dinosaur. These include the experience level of your staff with the dinosaur, the size of the enclosure needed, the type of landscaping needed, and the number of dinosaurs needed along with the threat level of the dinosaur. These needs are color-coded with the end goal being to get them to the highest level of happiness as this will provide several benefits like lower threat levels or unlocking more workers.

Finally, in winter, you'll check your threat level which may result in some negative effects for your zoo if it's too high as well as deal with revenue and running costs which provide you with your income for the following year alongside doing any cleanup and preparing for the following year. Dino Digs is clearly an attempt to improve upon some of the issues that some people might have had with Zoo Tycoon with certain aspects clearly being streamlined and some other certain elements of randomness also being reduced. However, to us at least, it's not a clear-cut improvement. It's very much an experience of one step forward, one step back.

Yes. So, in Zoo Tycoon, it was undoubtedly fiddly. It had a lot of moving parts. It was a very complex game, but what all this did was it gave a lot of things that went on and it made it feel like a park management simulation board game. And more importantly than that, it made each animal feel unique because of all these intricate little systems. And you know, having an elephant in your zoo felt very different than having a parrot in your zoo. And that's part of the reason we enjoyed Zoo Tycoon so much.

Here, there has been a lot of streamlining. Now, it's off your own back what dinosaurs you want to create rather than relying on a random spawning of available animals. This type of dinosaur you want, there will be a way to get it. There's also no maximum dinosaurs per tile. What matters here is the total amount of tiles in your enclosure. So, all of this makes it easier to play and to keep track of what's going on. However, it does then have the effect of making the dinosaurs feel quite generic. Because they all need roughly the same amount of maximum space and the same mix of terrain types, there's not really much character from one dino to the next.

Similarly, the breeding system has been paired down to be more smooth and accessible. Now, and this is something I like, the major factor to whether you have babies is the animal's happiness as some of the randomness has been taken away of the system from Zoo Tycoon. However, again, here it means that the system loses some of the flavor that it had in Zoo Tycoon. Because whereas in that game, it could be quite crucial as a method to get animals that were difficult to get, here it doesn't really matter because of the DNA system and its flexibility. In fact, most of what it's there for is to get a couple of extra science points and potentially even, you know, a dinosaur here and there if you want it.

There actually isn't even that many dinosaurs that breed, so it's something you could easily miss in the game. And it it's just a shame because in Zoo Tycoon, it was such a core part of the system. It added uniqueness to the animals and flavor to the game. It was something that was very smart and crucial in a way to get their animals, but you also had to deal with the consequences because the animals were going to breed every round and it created a problem to solve because you couldn't just get rid of them. There are some things that have improved. So, the worker placement has been much expanded and is now a core part of the game. In fact, basically anything you do in this game is done through worker placement except for building your park. And to do this, the the number of buildings has been greatly expanded with many of them having worker placement spaces now.

And this is nice because it gives an arc to the game where you start with very few worker placement spaces and then as you buy buildings and put them in your park, you get more options and eventually you get more workers and the game gets more expensive. And all these buildings are pretty interesting. You do kind of want a bit of everything and it's a fun decision on which to spec into and what strategy you want to go through. And it also gives a nice spatial puzzle in terms that visitor buildings play on what's adjacent to them, either enclosures or other buildings. So, you're working on your puzzle where to build everything and it just all works really well. The one thing that's a little bit awkward is that some of these buildings can only be used in summer, some can only be used in autumn. And there's not really a good delineation of which. Uh and some buildings even have one space that occupies or can be occupied in autumn, one that can be occupied in summer. And there's just something a little bit fiddly about it that it would have been nice if there was just one worker placement phase.

This greater expansion of worker placement means that the drafting of cards, DNA, etc. in spring adds a nice touch as it adds more player interaction. Often some offers can be better than others, so it's really tough decisions as to which you take first versus which do you risk other players taking. The DNA in particular adds a really nice flexibility as it allows for the very simple creation of the dinosaurs, but due to the gender dynamics, still very much matters how you draft, so that keeps things nice and tense.

Keeping with the fieldwork board, uh we really like what they've done with the sponsor cards where these have now become goals that when a player has achieved them, they can, instead of taking dinosaur card or DNA, they can take one of the sponsor's cards and get the reward as well. There's also technologies you can now draft in the same phase where if you spend technology points, you can take one and then it gives you an upgraded version of a building in the game that only you have access to. However, uh these are both examples of the one step forward, one step back that we've talked about before in this game where I really like the idea of both of them, but I really don't like the execution. For example, the sponsor cards, their goals can vary wildly between something that is quite easy to do in the second round to almost impossible and maybe actively harmful if you're trying to win the game to pursue.

And what tends to happen is a lot of the difficult ones come out and then they just sit there for almost the entire game until someone can finally do them. So, it's like a mechanism that's there that you only interact with once in the game and it's a little bit at odds with the streamlining. I would have preferred if they were easier, more approachable, more quickly. And it's the same kind of complaint for the technology tiles. I really like what they're doing, but the only way you get technology points is by kind of being one of the players with the most science every round and maximum you might get one or two technology points per round if any at all. And all of these technology tiles cost between three and five technology points, which means it takes a number of rounds till you can even get one. And then it it the short version is that the costs are way too high for what they give you. You know, why should it take me three or four rounds to be able to buy an upgraded museum when all it lets me do is hold two fossils. It's just It would have been a much more fun game if these were more easily accessible considering they're all unique. Lastly, just two nitpicks that we wanted to share. So, one major change has been one of the end game scorings. In Zoo Tycoon, what you're trying to do is get a group of animals from the same location and then if you do that quicker than the other players, you can say, "I've done this."

And then you got some points at the end of the game. Now, it's been changed to where certain dinosaur cards will have tags, but not all cards have tags. And whoever has the most of the tags which are in play, they will end up getting some points at the end of the game. However, because not all cards have it and there's a bunch of tags and some of them might not be in play for the scoring, what happens is that somebody might get a card and that will be the only one of that tag for the entire game because you only have so many cards moving uh throughout the game and then they win and then they get seven points which is can be easily a game-deciding amount of points just for having one symbol and being first player at the right time. And it's not fun if you played a 3-hour game and lose because of that.

Similarly, you also have the threat system. And on one hand, we do like this because it adds a little bit more flavor to the dinosaurs and it's something else to manage. It has some interesting ways that it interacts with buildings and mechanics. But, you get punished if you have too high a threat. And the punishments don't really make sense in context. You're just drawing random tiles out of a bag which tell you lose something or uh you know, cover up something. And the problem with this is that some of the tiles will make you lose points and others will basically be like a nothing punishment. And again, it can be that you end up losing the game because you had to lose three or four precious science points while another player just had to cover up some terrain that they were never going to use anyway.

Uh there's something that doesn't feel good about it when you see someone else lose points or you lose points from it. And there's just no character to it. It's just there. I feel like the entire game as a whole has missed an opportunity to lean into the inherently zany premise of what this is. And it's kind of played it too straight-laced because it's keeping to Zoo Tycoon's uh core gameplay. And it is is sort of missed having an identity of its own. And I think it's a shame and it's a missed opportunity. Final thoughts. Dino Digs is attempting to, I think, correct some of the issues that people had with the Zoo Tycoon board game. You know, I think there was complaints that it was overly convoluted, there was too much going on, and there was clear elements of streamlining here.

Uh certain changes are arguably for the better, such as the introduction of DNA to make things more flexible, the fieldwork board and the drafting. I think it's something we appreciated, the expanse of worker placement and the way you can build your own strategy. I I think those are all elements we like. However, it has come at the cost of some of the character of the game. I think certain elements feel a bit uh kind of lesser. You know, there's no real character to the dinosaurs. The the breeding element, it doesn't have much impact on the game. And those are things that just us as people who really like Zoo Tycoon very much miss. And we miss the character of that game.

Yeah, I totally agree. Just to echo what you said, there's definitely some elements here that I did prefer, like the way that the marketplace works. That works to be more streamlined cuz then you're reducing the kind of randomness there. But yeah, exactly like you say, it's just missing that character of the individual animals. And that was the whole fun of the game was yes, it was fiddly, but the management of it was the fun.

Yeah.

So for us that's just missing here, but it would be interesting that if you've never obviously played Zoo Tycoon and come straight into this, I think you would enjoy it. If you like this type of game because you just don't have the previous one to compare to, maybe. So, you have a bit of a different perspective on that considering we played the other one. I just think maybe it's just personal preference as well, but the dinosaurs to me are just less interesting as a theme as well. And I just found it really difficult to even find the dinosaurs in the boxes because some of them look quite similar. Whereas with the Zoo Tycoon, okay, as ever as a zebra, we all know what that looks like. So, that added a lot of fiddliness at least for me where there wasn't that kind of element before kind of visually and yeah, how the components are, but that's a small thing, but it just added to the more like generic feeling, I think.

Yeah, I I agree. So, that's our coverage of Dinosaur Digs, a Zoo Tycoon board game. If you have any questions, please ask us. We appreciate you watching. Please consider subscribing if you aren't already, and we'll see you next time. Thanks for watching.

Bye.

Progress saved