Skip to main content
Loading video...

Islandopoly Board Game Review

Transcript 16:08

this episode of brains on games is about monopoly with boats welcome to brains on games i'm dr brian mcdonald in this episode we're going to talk about a game that's a version of monopoly of all things usually on the show i talk about new games that maybe you haven't heard of or seen before but i think everyone has played monopoly although this might be the first time i've actually read the rules to the game of monopoly this new version of monopoly is from a company that's out of vietnam and it's a company of artists who are creating artistic versions of classic games out of well they're handcrafted games so sort of like i think the only handcrafted game board i think i have here at the house would be my crocodile board but this is a similar sort of idea and one of their new games that's coming out is this version of monopoly called islandopoly it comes in this great big briefcase there's a handle on the top uh and i will tell you that this game arrived i'll put it down for a second this game arrived in the mail and the box was torn apart by customs it was in tatters held together by tape and the package inside the the pure later guy stuck around so that he could make sure everything was intact when i opened it but even the delivery guy was surprised

by how well uh insulated these games were there were multiple games in this box i'll talk about the other ones later but uh he was very surprised about how well packaged the games were themselves there was a little bit of damage to the islandopoly box i don't know if you'll be able to see it on the screen but it didn't quite survive its journey from vietnam to canada islandopoly is like monopoly it's a game for between two and six players you can play it with kids aged eight and up and games last from one to three hours if you can believe it let's take a deeper look at islandopoly now of course i'm not going to talk in too much detail about the rules of this game i'm going to talk more about the components that come in this version of the game but of course monopoly is a light game what you're trying to do is buy these properties and be the last one to have any money left so it's a player elimination game there's set collection of course you can build it's not hotels and houses on your property like it is in the regular game of monopoly instead you're building hostels and resorts on your property and you're you're going around this round board this three-dimensional board and you're traveling in these little boats to different islands let me hold up these components so they everything's sort of a gradient of two colors in this game some of the the colors on the board might be a little bit hard to distinguish between

each other but um you know there's different shades of cream and yellow and purple uh with the oranges maybe a little bit brighter once you get used to the pieces and their locations it shouldn't be too hard to figure out what's what but of course monopoly is a roll and move game it's a set collection game where you're trying to get all of the properties of a particular color so that you can build your hostels and your resorts on them in order to charge more and more rent and drive the other players out of business now i can't remember the last time i finished a game of monopoly monopoly is not my favorite game i do like these components but monopoly isn't a game that really i i enjoy playing i i find it long and it's not very strategic and like i said i i haven't even ever in my life read the rules of monopoly until i was getting ready for this video and what i learned and maybe you don't know this maybe you've played monopoly before everybody has these crazy house rules for monopoly but the official rules for monopoly are that if you land on a space and you decide not to buy that property it goes to auction and the other players will will bid on it which does speed things up a little bit and could also add at least some strategic element to this game that's mostly based on these die roles i think one of the reasons why i haven't finished a game of monopoly is that everyone i play it with is so serious about it and you cannot trade properties

with these people because they don't want to give anyone an advantage so maybe that's the reason why i never make it to the end i guess i run out of patience and then i donate my money to whichever player is in the last place and then i go do something else for a while while they finish the game so you saw that this is a game that comes in that giant briefcase that i showed you it's a three-dimensional board and you've got this this ocean whoops this ocean in the middle that's sort of recessed and you've got a volcano that's can be separated from the board to make it easy to slide the board back into that briefcase at the end the cards in the game are plastic so they might be a bit reflective on the camera but they are certainly good sturdy cards uh and islandopoly money is is pretty similar to uh the regular monopoly money it's a little bit more like magazine paper i would say than just crinkly plain paper and the ships are made of plastic as well so it's it's a game i mean it is basically monopoly like i said maybe with the added well it's not added but certainly if i were to play this again i would definitely any version of monopoly i would definitely make sure that auction rule was included so that's not really added they've changed the names of the locations and one of the things that i like about this the rule book for this game is that it includes some historical facts or geographical facts about these different places like sydney harbor that you you'll visit in your boats through through the play of the

game you don't just go to any jail in islandopoly you go to alcatraz which is sort of a fun fact you can visit easter island and it's meant to be a relaxing game but i've never played like i said a game of monopoly that was relaxing it was always tense and combative but your mileage may vary on that one so this is a game and i would say this about all of the mastermind mastermind games these handcrafted games that are put together by artists it's a game that's meant to be a decoration in your house these are of course they are handcrafted games and that means they're not ex they're not inexpensive by any means but you can see this giant boar this this great big thick i don't know if you can tell very well it's this great big thick board and like i said you've got the three-dimensional recessed pieces in it it is a board that i could you know if i had a sun room that was sort of bright and decorated in white this is a game i would want to have on an end table or like i said to use as decor and one of the reasons why i thought it might be fun to share this game even though it's monopoly and everybody's seen monopoly before the reason why i started this channel is because i i i think it's great for parents and kids to play together and and that we get so busy kids with their extracurricular activities and their school activities and parents with work

and all the other things that we have to do we get so busy that play does sometimes get lost in the shuffle and the idea of having a game a beautiful game that sort of appeals to the senses uh and it's a tactile experience and you're doing that in person rather than playing video games like kids are often doing instead of playing board games uh you you want to have a space that invites that play to happen it's you're more likely to be able to drag your kid into a game or or for your child to bring their friends in to play a game if you have it set up in a way that it invites that kind of play and if you can use a game as a decoration in your room as a feature of your room now this isn't one that i would that i would be displaying in my game room i like the idea of having it in a sun room instead in some bright area where you're thinking about you know at the cottage or something like that because my game room is much more you know wood and leather and it's it's in my basement and so it's darker and you can see all the game stacked up back here so this library of games is kind of an invitation but i do keep my crocodile board out on the table and set up and it's always ready for a game there's always a box of iron clays nearby in case the kids want to get together and play a game of cards so whenever my kids have friends over they do come down to the basement that's where our television is and it's a sort of a living room area where they can hang out but but that's where the game table is too and so i will often come

down and see them playing games with their friends and sometimes they invite me to join in in fact that's our weekend plans this weekend is that kids are coming over and we're going to play together a prototype that i was sent in order to test it out for a video on the channel so i think games like this are important this is a classic game that everybody knows nobody hasn't played monopoly before but games like this are important in creating a space that invites kids in to play with their parents and it just puts that play in the front of your mind that's my question really for this episode are there games that you would want to leave set up on a table so that people walking by would think hey let's play a game what are the games that you would put on the table like that are there classic games that you wish were reworked with fancy parts and beautiful pieces that you you would like to leave out uh i think most of my games my wife would would go crazy if i i left them set up on the on one of the tables upstairs instead of at the basement game table but some of these mastermind games ones are are more amenable to that because they're meant to be artistic pieces that you would have out on a table somewhere so my question is exactly that what board games would you like to leave out as a decoration in order to invite your kids or roommates or friends to play them now what skills are you developing by playing a game like islandopoly well of

course you're counting change and counting money and you're doing a lot there's lots of math involved in this game and in fact there was a study a few years ago if i can find it again i'll put a link to the article in the show notes there was a study a few years ago that found that kids who play role and move games show up at school with better numero numeracy skills than those who didn't play those kinds of games now the ones that kind of follow a path with numbers on them do tend to work better than the round circle like this but roll-up move games and numeracy do kind of go together but you're also making change and counting money and it's it's large amounts possibly that you hopefully that you'll be working with when you play through the game there's some negotiation as well because you are going to be trying to trade properties and negotiation and compromise is something that you're going to try to do yeah you may want to set up well of course when you're playing a game you want to set up not a win-win proposition but you have to be giving the other person enough to make them tempted to give you something that's going to give you an advantage as well uh and that was always the hiccup and the headache whenever i played monopoly is nobody wanted to share their properties or make deals and that's a big part of the game so there's a little bit of negotiation uh and there's the the counting money and and counting spaces on the board and these roll and move kinds of games final thoughts about islandopoly well i mean it is probably

the prettiest version of monopoly that i've played uh my other favorite would be bob's burgers monopoly but that's much more like a typical uh traditional monopoly board this one uh is much more appealing in terms of a game that you might like i said leave out as a decoration in your room i like that the rule book includes those facts about the different areas that you might be visiting and one thing i didn't even show you speaking of components that i like of course the ships are pretty and the volcanoes are nice that 3d board is great and you've got this little bag now what do you think is in this little bag of course this is the hostels and the resorts and they look like candy look at these things here what table presents this game will have once you start putting resorts on the board check this out and they're embossed on one side and let me see if i can find the little hostel uh which is you know it's got a good contrast in terms of its color and it's much smaller so you can definitely fit four of those on your space on the board so it's just another you know pretty element you don't want to leave this out with young kids because they'll probably think that these things are candy because they're i mean they're just this appealing kind of color and they're translucent the downsides of course about islandopoly is that it's monopoly now lots of people like monopoly there wouldn't be so many different versions of this game with these mechanics if people didn't like it but if you don't

like monopoly you're probably not going to enjoy playing through a game of islandopoly you know when i would play it it would be because my kids would want to play it or i wanted to or my niece wanted to play it it would be somebody else who would be inviting me in and i'd be sort of saying hey i want to do something with uh with these kids with my family something that they want to do and you know i can put up with it just to be in the company of someone who i care about uh it's not i mean it's so much based in chance there's not a lot of strategy here which is maybe why it works with the younger kids uh but the biggest issue i think that i have with any version of this game is that it is a player elimination game and it's a long game so if you get eliminated early on there might be another 45 minutes or an hour when you're waiting to do whatever the next activity is you're just sitting around so there's no way really there's no mechanism because it's sort of an old-fashioned classic game there's no mechanism for players who fall behind to catch up and there's there's no you know you can mortgage your properties and things like that but at some point you're going to be eliminated because it's the last person who has money is going to be the winner so those might be and and are i would say deal breakers for a lot of board game players but if you like monopoly this is probably the prettiest version of monopoly that i've ever played and i have to thank mastermind games for kind of exposing me

to a new version of monopoly and for giving me a chance to try out this game i will put information about masterminds website in the show notes of the video if you have any questions or comments if you want to answer my question about games that you would like to leave sitting out on a table to invite people to play them with you you can leave them in the comment section below or you can email me at brian at brainsongames.ca brainsongames.ca is the website that's where future episodes will go and the previous ones are up there already brains on games is the twitter handle and the facebook page and the instagram feed so we're all over the place and if you enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future ones you can head on over to youtube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully i'll see you next time

Progress saved