Skip to main content
Loading video...

A Very Civil Whist: My Favorite Mechanism

Transcript 5:06

Hey, I'm Jamie from Stonemaier Games, and today I'm going to talk about my favorite mechanism in the two-player I'll say trick-taking tug-of-war game, A Very Civil Wisp, which looks like this. This game I was completely off my radar, and I'm delighted that I played it though because it it offers a really neat dueling puzzle um in this head-to-head game. Uh and it came down to the wire for us. We have only played it once so far. Henry and I played it, and it it was an incredibly close game at the end. I think I won based on a tiebreaker at the very end of the game. Uh basically the game we're the the overarching scope of the game is that you are playing little tricks of cards. So, I'm playing a card, my opponent is playing a card, and uh based on the if I am the one playing the card, if I win based on the suit of that card, I move um in my direction on that track. So, if I played a heart, and I'm playing as the red player over here, I and I I was the person who started the trick, I would move in the direction on this tug-of-war track based on the suit of that card that I led.

Um or if I as the player leading the trick, if I lost, I would uh perhaps suffer the loss of one of my leaders. I have two leaders that offer an asymmetric special ability um on that specific tug-of-war track. You're trying to win the game by doing two things. One, you're trying to be in your color on two different tracks. So, like if I'm if if this token, this tug-of-war token, is here or here on the track for hearts, and for example, here and here on the track for spades, and my uh my token on this side of the board, there's these other tracks, are within the red spaces, then um that's a that's a threshold I have to cross. I then win the game.

Quick overview of the game just in case you haven't heard of it. Um I love a couple things about that. One of the things that I've already talked about, I love the idea that there are there's a tug of war track for each of the suits. So, we have the hearts, we have the spades, we have the diamonds, and then the clubs are on the special track over here for foreign support. I really like that. I like that while you're playing, there's different types of progression, either one-time bonuses or um some ongoing bonuses. For example, you know, once I get to this point on the parliament track, I gain a a car a 10 card in the suit of of hearts. Uh so, there are different ways different places along these tracks where you gain a new card that you then have for the rest of the game. And 10s are the highest card that you can play. So, they're great. Um also, on the foreign support track over here, this is the track that determines whoever sets the trump suit for that round and whoever leads as well. So, this is two pretty powerful things in this game.

Uh so, I really like all that. Uh also, I think perhaps my favorite part of the game, my favorite mechanism, is that before you do everything that I just described, before the main trick-taking portion of the game, there's actually a separate lower-stakes planning stage of the game where two cards are randomly drawn from the deck, two playing cards are randomly drawn from the deck and placed on the table. And we are competing over gaining one of those two cards in a trick. So, I'll I'll play I'll play a card and and you have to try to follow and whoever has the highest higher number wins that trick and gets to gets to pick one of those two cards that are on the table. I think that is particularly clever in this game becau- for a couple different reasons. One, the card that you play is then out of your hand for the tug of war trick-taking portion of the game. So, if I have if I really want to win, say a nine of hearts, say nine of hearts is at stake, I really want to get that nine of hearts. I have to decide what card am I giving up to gain that nine of hearts.

Um, I'm also potentially trying to shortsuit my opponent or shortsuit myself by pulling out some of their better cards out of their hand so that they don't have them to play during the trick-taking during the the tug-of-war portion of the game. So, there's a lot of kind of kind of like mind games that are happening as you are crafting your hand of cards during the planning phase that you can use during the tug-of-war phase. It's somewhat the equivalent in a trick-taking game of passing cards at the beginning of a hand, but you have I would say more agency here and there's more of a puzzle happening than simply giving up a card and getting another random card because you're deciding which card do I play, what card am I trying to pull out of my opponent's hand, and which card do I want to win, or do I not care about winning either of these cards. I think that's a really really cool this planning phase in a very Civil War list.

So, yeah, that those are my thoughts my favorite mechanisms in this head-to-head dueling trick-taking tug-of-war game A Very Civil War list. I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments if you played this or if you have other games that echo any of these mechanisms. I'd love it love to hear about them in the comments as well. Thanks.

Progress saved