Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 Board Games – Better Gateway Games Than Catan!?

Transcript 18:29

katan is a great game the first time you play it there's something spellbinding about it that compels you to play it again and again so many people call it a gateway game and it's true many of my friends and myself included catan first and then i played dominion in puerto rico and agricola and seven wonders and well i'm getting ahead of myself the point is katan is only the beginning and in this video i'm going to talk about the attributes of katan that make it so interesting and games that share some of those characteristics but may even be better so before we jump into the top 10 games that are better than katan i want to talk a little bit about the attributes of katan that make it so interesting i usually rate games on five attributes theme mechanics luck strategy and complexity kittan has the following profile it has in my opinion a three for theme an eight for mechanics an eight or nine for luck a four for strategy and a three for complexity so what's interesting about that profile is the high mechanics and luck score i give it a high mechanic score because the game is rather ingenious in the way it keeps everybody engaged throughout the entire game this was the first game that i ever

played where i didn't have to wait for my turn before i could do something every single round people are rolling dice you have to pay attention in order to claim the goods that you produce and then you even have the opportunity to trade with the active player plus added to that is that element of luck which means that it's at any given point anybody's game and while it may be frustrating that sometimes you can just lose because of bad die rolls you also have the opportunity to think about probabilities and strategize how you're going to build your route in order to maximize your income every single round plus there's a high degree of interaction as players try to team up against each other as somebody comes into the lead and overall it makes a really fun experience even if it's not very complex or strategic or even if the cards are a little bit meaningless and abstract with sheep and wheat and why does it take two things to make or whatever it doesn't really matter what else is happening the game is all about mechanics and luck if you're interested in this how games are rated based on their attributes be sure to check out my website theperfectboardgame.com where not only you can check out games like this but you can also buy this t-shirt which is actually a hand-drawn shirt by none other than me i spent hours drawing over a hundred game components to make

this shirt so if that sounds cool to you check that out on the website or look at the link in the description of this video uh the shirt is on sale as of right now actually this is my first video since i received this um my version of my shirt so before we get started let's talk about the criteria for this list because it can't just be top 10 games if it was i would call it top 10 games it's top 10 games that are better than catan so that means they have to share some characteristic they have to be comparable to katan in some way so all of these games have lower complexity they're all very easy to teach they have a higher degree of luck than most games that i would recommend but that's because i think luck is an essential attribute that makes katan so attractive in the first place and then all of them have fantastic mechanics some of them have better strategy scores which is probably why i think they're better and some of them have better theme scores but that's what we're looking for in this list so with that being said let's begin at number 10 is mountain goats mountain goats is a short little game for two to four players in which players take turns rolling dice to move their goats up to the top of the mountain once they reach the top of the mountain they can continue to earn points until one of the opponent goats dethrones them and knocks them back down to the bottom throughout the entire game players are competing

both to get their own points while dethroning one another when another mountain goats sits on high for too long it's easy to learn easy to play and has an excellent luck element as you pair dice together in order to decide which mountain to move up on number nine is a very underrated card game in my opinion the game is innovation in innovation players are playing cards that represent new technologies and as they play more cards they gain more and more abilities which they can either share with competing civilizations that have similar technology or they can use to dominate one another on every turn a player must decide whether they want to use the technology of their existing cards or draw more cards in order to invest in newer and possibly better technologies number eight is a classic game that really draws on that element of player to player sabotage the game is pompeii in pompeii players play cards in order to place their civilians into the city of pompeii they do this for the whole first phase of the game until mount vesuvius erupts during which they take turns evacuating their civilians as quickly as possible the really fun thing about pompeii though is that as you place lava tiles when you place those lava tiles on top of an opponent or even yourself for that matter you get to take

all of those civilians and throw them into the volcano which is actually hilarious and uh if you like moving the thief around i think you would really enjoy a game like pompeii number seven is a game that depends heavily on effective luck mitigation and also involves dice the game is railroad inc in railroad inc four dice are rolled and all players use the face-up side of each of the die to plan out a route of highways and train tracks there are certain placement rules for highways that have to be connected to other highways and train tracks being connected to train tracks but the objective is to connect as many exits as possible while avoiding errors errors being any route that hits a dead end without connecting to a station in order to do this effectively you really have to draw your routes in such a way to leave possibilities available in case you hit some bad luck later on the next game like katan has a modular board where the pieces are laid out differently possibly for every single game and has very careful route planning which is interrupted by player to player interference the game is istanbul in istanbul you move around a city completing different actions in different locations the catch is the only way to perform an

action is to either drop off an assistant or pick up an assistant this means the game requires very careful planning as if you are ever left without an assistant you essentially lose a turn if you can't reach another assistant to pick up that gets even harder when if an opponent is in a space that you wish to go you have to pay them money to land at that space so what other players do is very important i also put this game on this list because i love the element of luck how you draw cards and the cards can give you certain abilities that you can play at just the right moment much like many of the cards in katan whether it's the night card or some of the building cards and then there's die rolls that are used in the tea house or in the black market and so there is quite a bit of luck involved and the game ultimately terminates when one player reaches a certain number of victory points which in this game are measured by the number of gems that they collect over the course of the game it can be really exciting when somebody pulls off a really effective move using a combination of cards and careful planning and is able to surprise everyone by ending the game earlier than they anticipated so an element of katan that hasn't really been addressed in any of the games i've discussed so far is the alliances that are formed between

players especially as one player takes the lead everyone can trade with each other until somebody rises up above the rest and then suddenly it's all don't trade with that guy right so in that same vein is game five on this list the game has been around for a really long time it's canon it's also one of the first games that i played after playing catan that is and the game is cosmic encounter in cosmic encounter players are alien races and they are competing for building the most foreign colonies they do this by flipping over cards from the destiny deck it's the destiny deck that tells you who you are going to attack and then once an encounter is plotted both the attacker and the defender are given the opportunity to invite alliances now as you can imagine in the beginning why wouldn't you ally with one person or another person everyone's got zero points it's all good but as the game goes on and as somebody shoots out above the rest the alliance phase of cosmic encounter can become a really big deal and very very exciting as well as not to mention the alien powers that allow each

player to modify the rules of the game in a very unique way it really is a classic cosmic encounter number four exercises the same very successfully implemented mechanic from catan that of simultaneous dice rolling the game is dice forge and the big difference between katan and dice forge aside from there not being a map is that while in catan all players are affected by two dice in dice forge every individual player has their own two dice on a player's turn every player rolls their two dice and picks up the resources on the face of the dice and then the active player gets to perform an action one action is to perform heroic feats and to use their resources to get victory points or the more exciting action and what gives the game its name is the ability to buy dice faces and forge them to your dice therefore modifying your probability for the rest of the game not only is dice forge brilliant in mechanics and luck like katan but it also has some of the finest component quality of any game i've ever bought for the cost which is only about 40 bucks incredibly so i highly recommend it especially if you like the tactile experience of rolling dice the game is dice forge number three is like katan in two ways one is it's a simple game with an economy where the

resources vary in value during the course of the game and the second thing is it has excellent replay value and can feel like every single game is very very different depending on how players interact with each other so the game is raccoon tycoon in raccoon tycoon there are so many objectives to the game on one hand you can buy buildings which will give you certain victory points for satisfying various conditions you can also build railroads which will give you more points as you collect more railroads of the same type or you can build towns but while all of this is happening there's an ever shifting economy of resources to gain resources you must play a card and every card you play alters the price of other resources and that means the game is all about timing on your turn is it best to sell very valuable resources or is it best to start an auction for uh another train line the important thing shifts based on how your opponents and you play together um that makes it very interesting for me to play multiple times and i also think that um without having to get into a heavier game like brass or something like that this game has a really fun economy that doesn't have a high learning curve to get into and that game is raccoon tycoon number two is a

brand new game it came out this year i just got my copy from europe i'm very excited about it because it's so fun it is the kind of game that is undeniably full of luck and yet so much fun to play over and over again it has just the right amount of luck and analysis trying to optimize your turn the game is explorers it's a little hard to find so if you're searching for it you can specify the designer phil walker harding or you can check out the link in this description now to explain explorers i would like to say that it's a game that's a lot like kingdom builder but fixes all of the flaws now if you've never played kingdom builder i'll just describe how you play the game all players have an identical map it's a grid of squares and they all start in the same location and they must explore the map by crossing off two or three squares using a dry erase marker the squares they can cross off are determined by the terrain type again like kingdom builder but it's determined by a card flip that affects everybody points are earned by putting x's on different areas of the land but in order to do this effectively you have to really carefully plan how you're going to make your way across different regions i really like the game because it's so easy to learn and play and the element of luck provides just enough challenge

to really make you think without taking the game too seriously and while giving everybody a really even chance of possibly winning it's not just some pure strategy game where always the best player is the most experienced player not to mention there are goodness gracious hundreds of ways to change the gameplay by using different objectives for scoring so again brand new excellent designer the game explorers and finally number one my favorite entry-level board game that shares characteristics with katan the game is via nebula and the designer is martin wallace who also designed brass which i had mentioned earlier it's a more complex game but this game is brilliant in via nebula players take turns taking actions that will help them collect resources to build buildings in order to earn victory points and win the game much like katan the only difference is that whereas in catan you're rolling dice in via nebula there are no dice at all in fact via nebula has a lower luck rating than any other game in this entire list but what makes it incredible and what i think it embodies that is also my very favorite thing about katan is that in catan right in the beginning of the game when all the little tokens are on the board you sit there and you do your probability analysis and you think about okay well you know there's a five and an eight and there's a higher probability of those spaces but how am i

going to get some brick and there's over here and i can trade you're doing this whole analysis of the board before you place your first town and your first rows that element of reading the the board is very well exhibited it explores by the way that i just mentioned but in via nebula is incredible because there are no dice instead of analyzing probabilities what you're analyzing is other player behavior see in via nebula players can share the same routes and the routes are built not with roads but by making clearings in the clouds and any player is allowed to move through any other players clearings and in this way the best player is often the player who does the best job of piggybacking on other players work i love the element of thinking about where other people are going and what they're trying to do so that you can sort of join them and get in on the action with while having to do less work um the game is brilliant i hope it is just as big a hit at your table but those are my top 10 board games that are possibly better than katan let me know what you think and if you have another recommendation go ahead and write one in the comments i will leave some links to my other recommendation and list videos and if you want to check out this incredible shirt

go ahead and take a look um thank you so much for watching and i hope you will stick around for more content from me take care bye

Progress saved