The Hungry Gamer Reviews The Witches of Willowspur
Transcript
Oo, that looks tasty. Welcome folks. J the Hungry Gamer is back with another game review and today we are talking about The Witches of Willowspur from Devious Weasel Games designed by Jenna Felly with art by Allison McKenzie, Naomi Robinson, and Rowan Mayo. And thank you to Devious Weasel for sending me this game so I can make this video. Now, this is a game that is not quite on the market yet. This is going to be a Gen Con release. And if you are watching this before Gen Con, there will be a limited number of copies at Gen Con if you are interested in trying to pick them up and it'll have a wider release later in the year. Now, with that being said, this is a cooperative game set in the world of Murray the [ __ ] Frog. That's a weird statement, right? But that is what this is. And we actually get a little backstory on Murray. And we find out that Murray was a human and he was bewitched by the mothers of all of the witches that you might be playing in the game, the aonomous witches. And you all have decided you were going to save Murray. And to do that, basically, you kind of have to power yourselves up as a witch and disrupt the ritual enough so Murray will turn back from a frog into a person. And I assume if you are able to do that, Murray will not be an [ __ ] anymore. or he will be lovely and kind and generous. Not quite sure if that's how it works cuz I haven't won the game
yet, but that is what I assume is going to happen. Now, this is a fully cooperative game of push your luck, recipe fulfillment, and dice chucking. Now, if you are not interested in how this game is played and want to jump to my final thoughts, then you want to go to the timestamp on the screen right now. For those of us still here, let's talk about how this game is played. So, what I have here is I placed one of the witches out, but I will point out that there are a lot of other witches that you are able to play. And I'll just kind of keep flipping through these here so you can just kind of see all of the art on all of them because quite frankly, I think the art is pretty darn good. A little spoiler for later. Look, I am still flipping through here. There we go. Now, we're back to the beginning.
I will also point out that on the back of each playerboard, there is a reference sheet which you will need for sure and there are enough different characters that are go far beyond the number of players that you can actually have. And so we have our characters and they are all exactly the same with the exception of each one has their own special power. Zara here is able to do some rerolls though she gains some suspicion if she does so. Kind of set this back ready for the beginning of a game there. Over here we have the Strega ritual. Strega being witches plural. And this is the ritual that is being done by the mothers to trap Murray as a frog. And we have the spirit ward here. I'll talk about that a little bit later. I'll talk about this board here a little bit later. And that I will briefly mention later. Then we have here in the middle we have the wild different places where we can forage for ingredients. And then finally down here I have the ingredient deck. You can't quite see the whole thing. It's just a deck of cards and three ingredients next to it. This is the apothecary shop that you can go to.
Now, what's going to happen is on your turn, you're going to go through several phases. First thing is you are going to meet at the clubhouse. And when you are playing cooperative, it's a chance for everybody to kind of discuss and you're able to trade things. Now, it's very important that it is trade, not give. So, for example, let's say I was playing with someone else and I had this potion here and someone had this potion. We could swap potions. We could trade water. We could trade ingredients, but it is trade, trade, trade. Now, I haven't talked about this, but there's two things that you cannot trade. You cannot trade spells, and you cannot trade elixir recipes. Now, each player is going to have an elixir recipe. That is going to be the main way that you are going to score points in this game. and I'll talk about that in just a bit. And you will probably likely also have some spells and you will likely have a potion.
You'll actually start the game with all of those. And additionally, you will have some gems. Now, things to talk about. The main thing that you're going to be doing is you're going to be going out to the wild to try to get the ingredients that you need. So, in this case, a clover and a fern, which you'll have to mix with some water to prepare and drink these elixirs. What these elixirs are going to do are allow you to boost your stats. And there are three levels you can go through, white, yellow, and red. Red being the most powerful. And you'll notice you have three stats there. I'll talk about memory, moxy, and magic in a bit. And so, that's mostly your goal. That's how you're going to get most of your points. You're also going to get points by brewing potions. And potions are very simple. You have a big old chart here. And it's going to tell you what ingredient, which when combined with water will give you a potion, and then you'll get your potion, and you're always allowed to drink it whenever you want in the preparation phase.
Now, what's going to happen is when you drink a potion or cast a spell, you'll notice these symbols right here. they go with this spirit ward board over here. And so what's going to happen is let's say I were to drink this potion here. And don't worry about what it does, but say I drink that potion. Then this would go here because that spirit is what powered that potion. Then let's say I were to cast this spell. Now what matters here is when you cast a spell, you're going to flip it over. If you try to cast a spell and fail, and I'll talk about how you do that in a minute, you simply turn it like this because the spell went sideways. Get it? But it just means it didn't work and you can't cast it again till later. And if it's flipped upside down, same thing. You can't cast it again. But that would have moved it over to the snake. Now, what matters is you can't drink a potion or cast a spell that is from a blocked spirit. So, just something to keep in mind. Now, I'm going to move on past that. So after you've done the clubhouse phase where you are trading stuff back and forth and making your plans, everyone will decide where they are going to go. And you can go into the wild, you can go into town, or you can stay home. And each place has different actions that you can do. Let's start with the wild. When you go to the wild, you can do two things when you are there. You can forage for ingredients or make an elixir. If you're making an elixir, you have to have, as I said, have your water and your ingredients.
You'll go, you'll spin them and you will upgrade one of your cubes like so. And then you will get a new elixir recipe like so. And now you're chasing that. I'll point out that to upgrade from yellow to red, there's actually extra things that you need. I'm not going to go into detail about that. Now, foraging is where we're going to talk about the dice. And most of what you're doing this game is going to be rolling dice and hoping you do well. So, the way it's going to work is I'm just going to So, the way it works is let's pretend that I came out here to the wilds to forage because I'm trying to get a shell and and a mushroom. So, what I'm going to do is you're going to roll one dice plus one per witch because one thing that you can do is you can cooperate in this game. So, if there was a second player, we could both say we're doing the same action and it'll turn into one die roll. So one dye plus one per witch, in this case one plus whatever your memory stat is. Right now my memory is white. So that is a plus zero. If let's just say we were here it would be plus one. So I would roll three dice. Then I will take my dice and I will roll my dice and I rolled that one star and two blanks. And so what that means is in this case I would get one pull from the wilds per witch. So in this case one plus one per star. So I get two draws.
Had I rolled this I would get three draws. It is also possible to roll these eyes. These eyes are suspicion. I'll talk about suspicion later. But for everyone you roll your suspicion will go up. But for the sake of the argument oh let's just say I did the most amazing thing ever cuz I never do. and I rolled three successes. So, I've getting four draws. So, what I'm going to decide to do is where do I want to pull from? And you'll see it tells you what ingredients are not found in those decks. Otherwise, there's pretty much one of each ingredient. The next thing to note is are you in a waxing or a waning phase of the moon? This represents your turn. So, right now I'm in the waxing, which means I can only get the white ingredients out of these decks. So, if I pull one of the black ingredients that's only available in the waning of the moon, I cannot take it. But four draws.
So, I'm going to pull here. Look at that. I got a shell. Good for me. So, I would just So, I would just take that and leave it to the side. Now, I choose my next one. I'm going to do the I'm going to keep doing the ponds all the way through. and I gained a water and my third pull a black fern and my fourth pull is the ward. So, first thing that would happen is this is now a blighted area and until the entire next round, no one can go searching there again. Also, that raises suspicion and is going to get me a talking to by mom. Now, as I said, since we're in the waxing phase, I can't get the fern. It's not available. I can get the water, which as I said is one of the ways you make potions and elixirs. So, I got that and I can get a shell.
So, I would take my shell and my water. Then, I will take these other cards and I'll put them on the bottom of the deck like so. Now, there's other places you could go. As I said, I could have pulled from here or maybe I had one more pull coming. I can't go there. So maybe I decide to go to the well in the middle and get some more water. Whatever it is you'd like to do, that's how you do it. Now, if we had multiple witches here, we're all working together. The person who rolled, which is usually person who has the best memory stat, gets to divide the stuff up, but they must take one thing. And so it all gets divided up. And remember that matters because everyone has their own recipe here and everyone is trading at the beginning of the round. Now, other things that you can do if you choose to go into town, you can brew a potion in town. And brewing a potion is very, very similar except you just have to have a water and a single ingredient like I mentioned.
Then you will roll your two plus your magic stat. In this case, I have no plus, so I'd roll two dice. And since I got no stars, I did not brew the potion. I don't lose anything, but I didn't brew the potion. Had I gotten one star, I would go through the potion deck and find that specific potion. I can deconstruct a potion. And deconstructing a potion has two options. One, you can just say it's gone and you can get the ingredient on the bottom. Or you can roll the dice, and if you get enough successes, you will also get a water to go with the ingredient. I forgot to mention, anytime you brew a potion, you get crafting points, which is based on your Moxy stat, and that's going to be points at the end of the game. Next thing you can do in town is you can go learn a new spell, which like everything else, you're going to roll the dice, and you're going to roll two dice plus your memory stat. And then you will get one spell plus one more per success.
And so you'll draw the spells, you'll take any spells that you already have, you'll go through them, and depending on your memory stat, it'll tell you how many spells you can keep, and you'll keep new spells. The other thing is important is that will actually rery any spells that you already have. So that's a way to kind of keep using your spells over and over again. You can do a trade, which means you go to the apothecary, and at the apothecary, you can trade an ingredient. Like, I don't want the shell, which would be silly for something else. And you can also trade two gems for an ingredient as well. You can take the action bewitch the towns folk in which case you are going to roll one dice plus one per witch plus your moxy stats. We'll roll that. I got one success and you will get one gem per witch plus one more per success. I haven't told you what gems do yet for the most part, but I will in just a moment. Then the last place you can be is you can stay home. As you're playing through the game, you roll eyes, you'll get wards, your suspicion will go up the suspicions that your mother has, and you can do an allay suspicion, which means you go down to the top of the previous suspicion level. And at home, you can also brew potions or deconstruct potions. Now, that's kind of the core of what you're going to be doing. There are other things that are going on and you're building up your stats trying to get points, but there's a few things that are going to happen as you go through. Depending on what happens during the day, if you pull a ward or your suspicion level's too high, your mother will confront you. And if your mother confronts you, maybe nothing
happens if you're down here. If you're up here, she'll send a crow to watch after you. And after that, anytime she confronts you again when there's a crow, you're going to get an extra suspicion. And sometimes the crows will fly off to the forest, which is going to give them these unbound ingredients, which is points for the bad guys at the end. Or if you get high enough on the suspicion track, you can wind up being grounded, which means you're stuck at home. You can only do a few things until you have dropped that suspicion back down far enough. And it's also possible to get an even more restrictive penalty as you're going through. Now, when we get halfway through the game, your mothers are going to send out their crows, and that's what these three are. This is also kind of tracking the endame as we play, because what'll happen is you'll flip one over, and you'll draw three ingredient cards, and then go ahead and reshuffle them.
And so, we had a flower, then a shell, then a feather. So what's going to happen is I come to this track over here and I will start out and I have a flower which is here and then I go down this list here and in this case I'll just put a black symbol just like that on the top. Then we have a shell which is over here and normally you would just put a shell like that. However, if we look it says if there's any black tokens in the row replace the leftmost one with a red. So now I will do that and then I have a feather which would mean I do that there. And now that's going to happen three times throughout the game and also going to put something out here so I can explain in game in just a moment.
Then you'll be restocking the apothecary and a few other things. Then we go through the then we go through the waning phase which is when you can get these dark ingredients from out here. At the end of the round, your mother's going to confront you again and you will then reset all of the wild. So, the wards will come off. You'll reshuffle everything and so on. When we get to the end game, that's when stuff gets kind of crazy because in the endame it is math. And I'm not going to go through the exact formula other than I'll say which are going to get points for their different colored cubes that they have collectively and whatever crafting points they have. While the straga, your mothers are going to get points for all of the different red symbols they have out here. They'll get less points for the black and white ones, and they'll get points for these down here. And they're going to get points for how suspicious they are of you. The more suspicious they are of you at the end, the more points they're going to get. And when I say it's math, look at the screen. You can see it is math to do these things. Now, it's not as complicated as it looks. I put the complicated one up there for funsies, but it is some math that you have to do.
And whoever has the most point and if you have more points than your mother's, you win. If you don't, then you lose. And there's a little chart that tells you what happens to Murray and everybody else as you go through. But that's how this game works. So, with that said, what do I like about this game? The first thing is what a fun, unique theme. And I really appreciate this shocking to me. Truly to me was shocking this connection to Murray the [ __ ] Frog because I like Murray the [ __ ] Frog a lot and that game really shows you that he is horrible. Now this one, maybe he's kind of showing you why he's horrible because he's been turned into a frog. I'd be pissed, too. And this trying to save him is kind of a fun little tiein. and it allows for a very cool magnet that you can get, especially if you're a Genkot. But so I I like the theme and I also appreciate that both thematically and mechanically, I haven't played something like it. At the core, it's a lot of kind of push your luck, dice chunking, and recipe fulfillment. But the way it all works out and the way that you are restricted from doing different things, and the way that you're cooperating is just not an experience that I've had in this way. And so, I really appreciate that. And this is one that if you have this, you're not going to have anything else on your shelf like it. And that is always a cool thing. Next thing I'll say
is the cooperation is so important in this game because what's going to happen is I don't know if you caught it, but the more witches you have in a location, the more dice you're going to get. And those dice I think have two stars on the eight sides and one set of eyes and the rest are blank. Which means only each die only gives you a 25% chance of getting a star. And for some of the things that you're doing, if you don't get a star, you don't do the thing. And figuring out how to work together, how to cooperate, how to use your gems, because gems just give you an extra die. When to use your potions that might make eyes also count as a star, or it might allow you to roll extra dice or whatever, or maybe your spells let you do a roll, or all kinds of stuff that's happening. But figuring out how best to choose when to use those things, when to decide to use something in the preparation, how to figure out together at the beginning of the round, what are we going to do? Okay, well, you're going to do this thing. Okay, we're going to send you with her and then because you're going to go out and try to get us all these ingredients that we need.
Well, in that case here, trade me a clover for my potion. And now you're going to be able to use the potion to get to allow you to use gems. are going to give you plus two dice if you drink this potion instead of just one which means okay let me give you all my gems too you better give me something back all the cooperation and discussion that has to happen is really intense and I say that in the best way next thing I'll say is there's lots of restrictions as I just mentioned and as you play through the game there's a lot of things where you're like I can't do what I need to do because I got grounded which is just funny and so I got to work that out well that's going to mess up everybody else okay what are we going to do how are we going to make this work and At the end of the day, every restriction in the game is thematic and it makes sense. So, that's pretty darn cool. Next thing I'll say is the witch art is awesome. I love the player boards. I love the look of the witches.
They just look great. I love the variety of them. I love that they all have different powers and those powers are great. And depending on who you're playing, each one is going to feel like that is the best power in its moment. So, I really really like that. Next thing I'll say is it's actually really easy to play the game. Not to win, really easy to play the game once you get it. Now, I'm going to talk a little more about that later, but once you get it, it flows pretty darn quick. Next thing I'll say is it's a really tight economy in this game. You are chasing down those ingredients. you are forging them, getting them to the right people, and you only have 24 turns to do it. But keep in mind, you're going to wind up getting grounded at some point, which means you're losing some of your turns as you're going through. Also, keep in mind what I said about the dice, which means there's going to be turns where you're going to do stuff and you're going to get almost nothing or maybe nothing at all. So all these things are happening with a tight economy and you are feeling fraught the entire time though feeling fraught I think in the best kind of way and because of that the timing is so important working together to figure out the timing of anything is key to this game and it's really fun when a as Hannibal says don't you love it when a plan comes together and man do you feel that way when you play this game it comes together you're like yes that was awesome Next thing I'll say is again thematic in these restrictions, but in particular
the waxing and the waning as you're kind of going through in the during this phase of the moon that's going to give the magic that you need to these different ingredients. So when you find them there and then when it's waning it's the other way. And it's just a clever restriction, but it's very cool. It's very neat and I really really like the way that works. And the last thing I'll say is for a decently small box that's it. I mean, it's just a lid. There's a lot of stuff in the box. It's It's really heavy. It is a shockingly heavy box. So, there's a lot of stuff in there that's really cool. Now, with that said, what are my quibbles with the game? First one is it's not easy to learn. Now, as I said, once you get it, it's easy to play. I had a hard time learning it. I actually spent a while reading and rereading the rule book, and I was just having a hard time kind of grasping it. And my first play was rough. And rough one, like any game, you're going back to the rule book a lot. But I was going back to the rule book a ton and I got obliterated the first game. Now, that is not a commentary on is the game good or not.
In my opinion, lots of games the first time you play, you're making mistakes, you're figuring it out, and you don't have the flow, and you don't do well, but really didn't do well. like might turn you off from the game when you get obliterated the first time you play. Now, the very next time I played, it was all much smoother. I still was making mistakes here and there. I was still going back into the rule book a fair amount, but so much easier to get through. Then by the third game that I played, went to the rule book maybe once, and that was just to confirm that I knew what I thought I knew. So, point being, it's a harder one to learn and to grasp from the jump. Next thing I'll say is those dice are brutal. Just brutal. It's all about having a bucket of dice to toss because there's not a lot of successes on there. And that will mean there will definitely be times when you roll a bunch of dice and get nothing. I have had multiple times where I've gotten all the way up to eight dice, all the dice, chucked them all, and all blanks.
devastating, but that's going to happen in this game. This is a game that will kick you in the teeth, and it will happen over and over again, and you got to get back up, put your teeth back in, and go back out there. Next thing I'm going to say is it's very luck driven when you're foraging. Now, you do know what's not going to be there, and if you're kind of counting cards and paying attention, you know what's come up, and you know there's only one of each thing in there. So, you know, oh, I found the shell in the stream. Well, I'm not going to find another one that would go somewhere else. But it's possible. Like with the dice again, you're foraging. You don't know what you're going to find. Like with that, there's going to be times when you're just not going to get anything or you're just literally going to pull only things that are from the waning moon and you're in the waxing phase, so you can't pick them up. So, that is going to happen. And again, like with the dice, this is not again necessarily a criticism of the game, but it is what is your play style? Are you the type that wants to feel like you are succeeding every single round and getting closer and closer and there's lots of games like that or are you okay with again getting kicked in the teeth cuz it's going to happen sometimes. The next thing I'll just point out is the ritual board. That's going to happen no matter what. You don't have any control over that. So you are just trying to power yourself up faster than the moms are going to power themselves up. So, it's a integral part to the game and I actually find it kind of interesting and cool. I like the way the board works and the way things change, but that is purely luck driven. So, just kind of
understand that. And the last thing I'll say is it's really hard. It's designed as a very hard co-op game. And in my opinion, I think the loudest group of people that like co-op games say that they want to lose far more than they win. I don't know that that is most people, but if you are in that camp, you're going to be thrilled with the difficulty here. If you are more like Mrs. Hungry Gamer, who would rather win 80% of the time, let's be fair, she'd rather win 100% of the time we do a co-op game, this is not going to be one for you. Now, there are levers you can pull to make the game easier or harder. I cannot imagine making the game harder, but you can definitely make it easier. you get more gems and that actually really can make the game easier at the beginning because it gives you a boost. So, there's ways to change it, but just understand it is very, very hard. But there you have it, folks. That is the Witches of Willow Spur. And this is one that I enjoyed. I am forever impressed at how unique the games that Jennifi creates are. Now, I've only played three of them. I have Cosmic Frog, which I love. I think you can see it right behind me, maybe. Uh, yep. Yeah, yeah, right here. Oh, nope.
Can't quite see it. Cosmic Frog, which I think is just fantastic. Murray the [ __ ] Frog was my honorable mention the year it came out. Very cool game. And now this one. All of them are so crazy unique and I really, really appreciate that. I think it is a huge challenge and it surprised me because after that first play I wasn't turned off to the game because it was a first play but I went into my second and third and fourth play thinking you know what this just might not be for me. I might not like this game. But each game as I got it and understood and you start to see the different ways things combo together really cool. So this is one that I think if you are a fan of a hard co-op and you don't have a problem with all the teeth kicking that are going to come with this. This is going to be a unique co-op game on your shelf. I can't think of anything like it. Also, I love supporting smaller publishers like this. So, there you have it, folks. That is The Witches of Willispur. As always, if I made any mistakes in the rules overview, please let me know in the comments with the time stamp so I can get that in the click on subtitles. If you found this video useful, please like, subscribe, share, maybe become a channel member. As always, thank you so much for watching.
Have a wonderful, wonderful day.