5 Things I HATE About Monopoly - with Tom Vasel
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Tom Vassel and I'm the head reviewer here at the Dice Tower. We talk about thousands and thousands of different board games. One of the board games when it you talk to people about board games, the number one board game in the world for the past 100 plus years is certainly Monopoly. And in this video, I want to talk about five thing reasons I I kind of hate Monopoly. Now, Monopoly invented in 1935 uh by Elizabeth Maji. Um and there's a whole storyline in there. She made it was originally called the landlord's game, showing you the problems with monopolies. And then Charles Darrow took it to Barker Brothers and became a millionaire on a game about the problems of Monopoly. Um, this it has sold somewhere just shy of 300 million copies. It is everywhere and I dislike it. Now, it's cool to hate things these days. And this is often the reaction to a video like this where I say, "I don't like Monopoly." And people go, "Oh, it's so easy to dislike Monopoly. You just like you just dislike it because it's popular." Well, partially yes, actually.
But I don't I think it's okay for me to point out the problem with Monopoly because I think Monopoly is actively bad for the board gaming hobby. It's like saying I hate McDonald's. It's sort of an easy target, but I think it's bad for a hobby and actively makes our hobby of board gaming worse. Popularity doesn't mean something's good. It can be very popular, but that doesn't mean I have to say it is good. But I have five reasons that I want to bring out as to why I think Monopoly is a bad game. First of all is the rules. Nowadays when I teach a board game, I will often teach a board game with maybe one or two pages of rules and I'll see people's eyes glaze over because of how complicated the game can be for them. And I'll think, you haven't seen complicated. There's games with 30 pages of rules. Well, in fact, Monopoly is a fairly complicated game for what it is. And yet so many people know the rules because they've learned it basically by osmosis by passing it down. You've been taught the game. The problem with that is is that house rules have entered the game to a large level.
Uh there are so many rules that people think are part of it because that's the way they always played. For example, the most common one is when you land on free parking, you get all the money in the middle. You seed money to the middle. Different ways you put money in the middle. When you land on free parking, you get that money. that's never been in the game or there's just extra cash in the game. You get double money when you land on go. Um people also don't realize that when you land on a spot and you don't want to buy that spot, well then there's a mandatory auction and it's auctioned off so it will go to somebody. And when you talk to people about Monopoly, they'll say, "Hey, if you play by the proper rules, it is a better game." I do not agree with that. The biggest problem that these house rules do bring in though is that there is a large influx of cash causing the game to go on forever. That's one of the complaints about monopoly is that it goes on a really long time and much of it is due to these house rules. But the rules themselves are not particularly easy. They often involve a lot of math with mortgaging and they're fairly complex which causes these house rules to come into existence. My number two problem I just mentioned is the length.
what when included with the luck the length and luck of the game. A Monopoly box says it's 60 to 90 minutes and we all know if you've ever played Monopoly that that is likely not true. Now part of that is due to house rules but it doesn't matter even if the game only lasts 2 to three hours. The game seems long and the fact is it has a random setup which doesn't really help. You could get thrown into jail on your first turn if you just start rolling a bunch of doubles, which makes you miss buying properties unless you pay to get out. Or you can just land on different spots where you don't buy properties. Auctions can take too long. A player can just have a long turn. But at the beginning of the game, there isn't much going on. You roll the dice. This is straight up luck. You see where you land. That is the property that you buy. And until players start getting sets of properties, it really doesn't the game doesn't get going. So, this beginning part feels interminably long. And then at the end of the game, sometimes with the money passing back and forth, that also feels long. And there's no real planning to the game. You just deal with what you've got. And the luck of rolling the dice, the luck of landing on the property, there's certainly some excitement to the luck. I won't deny that. When you're sitting there going, I don't want to roll a seven because I will land on boardwalk. I get that. But that luck that's thrown into the game doesn't particularly make it good when combined with just how long this game can be. My third problem is player elimination. Now, I'm not actually talking about the rules of the game where when someone runs out of money and has to mortgage everything, they're out
of the game because that is player elimination. But this game also has essential player elimination, which I mean essentially someone's eliminated when they're down in their luck. They've had to mortgage everything, but they're still in the game, and they just have to keep rolling dice and dragging along until they're eliminated. And it it that the game just has this sort of drag out period and somebody can figure out very early on to the game that they cannot win. When you talk to people who are fans of Monopoly, they'll often talk about trading being essential in the game. You need to trade properties. But the fact is, if you don't have any trades or you have properties that aren't worth a lot, then it's hard for people to you can't force someone to include you in it. So you excluded so you feel like you're on the outs and then for the next two hours you are sitting there and watching everyone else play. If you rule poorly, there's no real chance to catch up. And the goal of this game, the goal of Monopoly is to put other people down. Now, often when this is mentioned, people go, "That was the point that Elizabeth had back when she designed this game in the past. She was showing how bad capitalism is or how bad monopolies are." Whatever it might be. Fine, that might be a point, but that doesn't make the game fun.
This is sold as a game of fun for families, and I don't believe so. I win Monopoly by making you lose, and not just lose, but soul crushingly lose. The game also rewards collusion with other people. There's even cheating. Oh, quick roll the dice before the other person notices that you've landed on there and more. So, I don't like it because of that. My fourth reason for not liking the game is the intellectual property and the number of Monopolies out there. If you go to boardamegeeek.com, a website that has a listing of all the board games in the world, you'll find 1300 plus versions of Monopoly. Monopoly FedEx, Monopoly Bass Fishing, Monopoly Betty Boop. There's a Monopoly and Scrabble crossover. You build Monopoly. Monopoly, Stranger Things, The Big Bang Theory, Costco, Monopoly, Sun Made Raisins, Monopoly, Monopoly for Millennials, Miz Monopoly, there's a monopoly for every city. There's a monopoly for every state, for every country, for every sports team, for stores, TV shows, movies. There's even a game called Monopoly Cash Grab, which has a gun that you shoot out. And that gun actually was co-opted by the the TV show Nailed It. But that was one of the most uh well that was kind of the it's self-aware monopoly cash grab. But the fact is because there are so many of these different monopolies, none of them make any sense with the theme. They really don't. I'm walk around and I bought Fuzzy Bear or I landed here and bought what? None of it makes sense.
They have some similarities in all of I believe jail or go to jail and free parking is in all the different monopolies, but there's so many differences between them and it's turned the game into a joke. To go out and buy a game, there's there's statistics out there that show that 60% plus of Monopoly games that are bought for people are never even opened. I know you like this sports team, so I bought you that version of Monopoly. I know you like that TV show, so I bought it for you. and you're like, he he he and we put it and then it doesn't get played and then it actively makes the game worse to have all these out there. Thousands of copies flooding the market with just utter trash. And then finally, my fifth reason is the whole reason I'm making this video is I think Monopoly is detrimental to the hobby as a whole. Now, Monopoly has brought into us phrases, you know, go directly to jail, get out of jail free, do not pass go. We know what Boardwalk and Park Place is. McDonald's helped us with that. We know what Mr. Monopoly looks like. We know the dog, the thimble, the race car. But Monopoly has caused so many bad experiences. When I talk to people, when I tell people about board games, they remember some of these bad experiences with Monopoly. The length of the game, the luck, the bad times, the arguments, and it's pushed by Hasbro to be everywhere. It's looked at as really the only strategy game that's out there because otherwise you play Uno and Candyland and there's a couple strategy games. You either play chess,
you know, or Monopoly or Scrabble and that's it. And that's really not the case. There are thousands of thousands of wonderful games that are out there, but Monopoly pushes to the front and it watches all them. It's like if you turn on your favorite streaming service and every time up pops play Monopoly, play Monopoly and it's everywhere. The math in the game is nonsensical. You if you play Monopoly, you know, you draw the card and you get second place in a beauty prize contest and you get what 20 bucks. You have to pay 10% of your fees over here. the playing boardwalk on on Park Place and getting them, you know, landing on boardwalk or Park Place will cost you thousands of dollars as opposed to the math over here and roll over here. And it's math that most of us would never want to do and yet it's shoved into this game. And I'm glad many people have good experiences.
But when you know Monopoly and you know all this stuff, then to go and you play this and this is what board gaming is to you, to go to other board gaming feels foreign and strange. And I have that problem because so many people I want to introduce some really cool board games to, but they've had such a miserable time with Monopoly that that turns them away. Now, it's possible you're watching this and you love Monopoly. That's wonderful. I am not here to convince you otherwise. Go enjoy it. Ignore everything I said. Go. If you're having fun with something, who am I to spoil with it? But for those of you who have turned down the wonderful world of amazing board games because of a bad experience Monopoly, I have good news for you. It's the outlayer. It's It's a relic. It's the past. Board games are amazing. Now, that is what the channel here, the Dice Hour channel, is all about. We're here to tell you all the time. Now, don't get me wrong, there's lots of bad games that come out, but there are thousands and thousands of good games out there. What do you do? Hey, go play a good game. I can tell you off the top bet. There's Katana, Ticket to Ride, Pandemic, Cascadia, but there are hundreds of others. Go out there. There are games where players are not eliminated. There are games where we all can work together. If you don't like the competitive nature of Monopoly, there are games where we work together and win as a group against the game. There are games where we are simply racing to see who gets to a certain amount of points first. There are even a few hard to find versions of Monopoly that aren't nearly as bad as the rest of them, but there are so many games out there. So, go
check them out. Jump into this wonderful world. I don't like Monopoly. I think it's bad. These are my reasons. I'm Tom Vassel. We'll see you next time. Hey folks, I'm Tom Vassel. Thanks for watching this video. Check out our channel. We have a lot of videos on our channel. We have live videos that go up each week from live Q&As's to videos where we take a look at the newest stuff on Kickstarter crowd surfing to top 10 lists and more. There's lots of stuff on this channel. We encourage you to explore it. You can find out more at our website dicetowwer.com. I'm Tom Bassel. Thanks for watching another video on the Dice Tower.