Are These Games Still Good 7 Years On?
Transcript
i've been making videos about board games now for seven years when i first started out my role was played by this small child but when i first started making videos i'd only been playing games properly for three years now i've been playing them for 10. so my tastes have completely changed the way i see games is so different so i thought it'd be really interesting to go back to the first videos i made to look at what i said about those games and decide would i still recommend them are they still in my collection we're going to review the reviews if you want to check out the original reviews i've put links in the description below and i've put links if you want to buy any of the games if you use them a small cut will go towards this channel and help me keep making videos thanks this is my first ever review it's of a party game called fun employed some board games give us a taste of life at its most brutal whether it's fighting on the front lines of world war ii and memoir 44. this is this is such a long drawn-out joke and just my face whilst i'm saying it i'm i it's just like i'm so disinterested but really i was just so nervous each round one player will take on the role of the interviewer turning over a job card say psychic and every other player will then take it in turns to pitch for the job using their unique hand of qualification cards it's then up to the interviewer to decide who gave the best reasons who had the best pitch and that person wins around that's a pretty good description of the game that's the great thing about
fun employed is that it acts like the setup to a joke with the player providing the punchline so the idea of using a lisp as a reason to get a job as a proctologist that's a funny idea in itself but it's your execution of that idea that brings the joke home yeah i think that's a really good point you get given the setup but you get to deliver that punchline and that's what makes games like this really good and crucially it's still you making your friends laugh it's not the cards doing the work for you like happens in cards against humanity fun employed is fun because it's you being funny you get to be creative the game helps you along as far as you need so it's not hard to be funny but you you don't get the kind of agency taken away from you liking cards against humanity there was a a real common vibe in the community that cardigan against humanity was like this big success story but didn't deserve it because it was bad for all these reasons it was definitely a whipping boy for people that loved board games passionately and i was leaning into that because fun employed is kind of a great alternative to it and ultimately then i play i made another video that was alternatives to cards against humanity to really hammer it home the style of humor is created by the group not by the game and so it's not a game forcing a sense of humor on you yeah exactly the game is fun for your friends because your friends get to determine the level and
you bring your sense of humor to it if you're very wholesome and you don't like swearing and being rude then you can play it that way and if you are the opposite of that you can play it that way the artwork is great the card quality is great the artwork is great the card quality is great who cares fun employee won't work for everyone um if you've got any friends that particularly shy or they don't like to talk in front of groups of people then they might not go for this game so this is the crucial point of the review and i would emphasize this much more now than i did back then fun employed is a great game for a very small group of people so would i still recommend the game yes with a big asterix i still own fun employed but i hardly ever get to play it because it needs the perfect group it needs people that are all into it that are willing to improvise and try and be funny and i found a lot of people find it embarrassing they are very nervous in the game they don't enjoy it because of that it's a tricky game for me to bring out i don't like to make people feel uncomfortable or have a bad time so i'm never going to bring it out in front of people that i think wouldn't vibe with it and that's most people that i know if you're in the market for a party game it doesn't get much better than this this is it if you're in the market for a party game it doesn't get much better than this
and that's it the same music i've somehow i just found some music through youtube to end a video with and it's been the same every single video for seven years and i really would love to change it but i just never there's never a good time to spend time on that job so you're always better making a video as a youtuber than fixing things like that so we've got the same music we've got the same ident music for seven years my second ever review was of deception murder in hong kong which is a social deduction hidden traitor game and i'd actually got the original version of this cs files from hong kong it's one of the few games where i paid extra to order it from another country and it was worth it the game was actually good looks like somebody hasn't been feeling too stare well so this is my first attempt at a sketch this was filmed in the stairwell of the block of flats we used to live in and the dead body is played by my friend phil i think this might be the only video that he's in and you can see that his legs like up the stairs to fit in the shot he got really uncomfortable in that position because i was doing so many takes they tell me you're the best damn forensic scientist in the city you can see here that we covered a table with kitchen foil to make it look like a metal slab that they would have in a forensics lab and this is one of the only times where i've tried to have me in the same shot and you can see there's
a line where the lighting is different it's just way too hard to try and do stuff like this especially on your own so i gave up this idea after doing this video one of the detectives is the murderer who's trying to stay hidden throughout the game the good guys win by correctly identifying the right piece of evidence and murder weapon one player knows that information the forensic scientist but he can't talk to the other good guys he must communicate the information he knows to the detectives by placing pawns on the six tiles in the center of the table the forensic scientists will have to give a location where the murder happened or a noise that's in the background or something that was found at the crime scene but they have to pick from six options so they can't just say whatever they want they have to pick something that is closest to the murder weapon um that they think is gonna give people a hint in that direction so they're having to use quite blunt instruments to communicate something and the other players are really having to do a lot of deduction with the information they've been giving because it's so vague and weird and that is what creates a load of discussion and what makes the game so fun because you're really trying to interpret those clues and it gives you that room for the traitor who's trying to stay hidden and not get caught it gives them room to go well no that is not pointing towards my card it's clearly pointing towards your card how can you say it as me i don't even own a scarf
oh god my french accent in this video is so bad you can see in the background how messy my kitchen is i obviously didn't decide to wash up before making this video in games like the resistance new players can find it hard to get involved in the discussion but here new players are straight in anyone can have a discussion as to why a scarf makes more sense for suffocation than packing tape yeah i think deception is probably the most entry-level hidden traitor game and not because the rules are any simpler but because i think it's just got a wider appeal it's more approachable it's less demanding on the players in terms of bluffing and deduction one of the great things about deception murder in hong kong is there's no meta gaming to it it is really just arguing over do you think this means scarf or does it mean packing tape what are you talking about packing tape you suffocate people this guy everybody knows that there's a pause here where i just clearly can't remember the next line you could probably go back to my videos and spot where i'm like you can see the cogs wearing where i'm trying to remember the next line and there's this pause and then oh okay that's what i meant to say and it gives the traitor something to work with no more are they just protesting their innocence it isn't me i didn't do it now they have an argument to make it's not a scarf it's the poisonous gas yeah that's a great point about this game you're not just saying i'm not the spy believe me
you can come up with a reason why people should look elsewhere you can try and find some logic that links the clues elsewhere now sometimes the clues are so good or they just hit the nail on the head that you actually get trapped and you you can't really think of a good reason for people to vote elsewhere but most of the time there is some blurriness that you can play with and that's why it's fun being a traitor it's different enough from the resistance that you can still enjoy both i think it scratches completely different itches for me at least and if you don't like the resistance you still should check this out because it may fix the table talk problem that some people suffer with yeah this is the crucial point of the review and i absolutely agree with it all deception feels so different to the resistance or werewolf or secret hitler which are different from each other but all kind of feel the same on some level and deception offers something quite different which is why i still have it in my collection and yes i would absolutely still recommend this game i mean i wish the box was smaller this is actually the expansion box um but that's the only thing that i can fault it on it offers something very different and you might hate those other social deduction games and still like deception yeah i played this as recently as a few months ago had an absolute blast with a couple of games it got really heated there were some really big moments and it's just great for that kind of experience so my third video was my top
10 couples games video and this was my most successful video for the last seven years until i made my top 10 mistakes video a few months ago so this is the most watched video or the second most watched video on my channel today i'm going to talk about my top 10 games for couples this guy's face unbelievable so i'll say about this video was that i love playing games with serena we played a lot of two-player games but i didn't have 10 really good ones to talk about i probably had like seven or eight and i was really trying to get together 10 because i wanted to do a top 10 because everyone does top 10s and so i was really scrabbling around and the ones at the end of the list are ones that i added quite last minute or i had only recently played a little bit so it's just a little insight into what it's like to be a youtuber early on and you're you're pretending you know more than you do whereas nowadays i could recommend sort of 30 or more games for couples and find it really hard to pick a top ten back then yeah i only had six or seven and number ten is agricola all creatures big and small designed by uber rosenberg if you like worker placement games then this is a great short one to play with your partner and if you've never played worker placement games before then this could be a great introduction to the genre yeah i don't actually really describe why i like the game or what makes it interesting and i think that sort of gives away that
i wasn't that in love with agricultural creatures great and small and i wouldn't still recommend the game today i got rid of it a long time ago it felt quite samey and it just lacked a certain amount of excitement that i really want from a couple's game a number nine is the game which is a cooperative card game you each have a hand of six or seven cards and there are four piles in front of you two going down from 100 and two going up from one and on your turn you have to place at least two of your cards into one of those four piles the twist is you can't tell the other players what cards you have there are better co-op games out there but the reason i included the game on this list is that i think every couple's collection should have a simple co-op card game every couple should have every couple's collection it should have a simple co-op card game uh i'm not sure that's a hundred percent true yeah i don't think i'd played the game enough at this point to really decide that it was in my collection long term i got rid of it actually quite recently but that's partly because it's such a small box that it wasn't really taking up a lot of space on the shelf so i allowed it to stay longer than it perhaps deserved it's all right you play it a few times there's not really enough depth you've kind of seen all the game has to offer you appreciate that a lot a lot of it's down to luck it just feels like you're making obvious decisions and that there isn't even though you can't communicate with the other
player there isn't that much of the kind of mind reading that you would want from a game like that and number eight is carcassonne designed by klaus jurgen vrader but it's also as competitive as you want it to be some people see it as a cutthroat game whereas other people complain that it's too relaxed but that's the great thing is you can choose whether to just focus on your own thing i'm just gonna build my monastery here by my castle and let the nice man farm the land so he can feed his family or to go out of your way to sabotage your opponent and i'm gonna put my road here so you'll never be able to finish your castle and your man will never be able to leave i think this captures a good aspect of carcassonne that some people can miss how cutthroat it can be or some people play it in a much more like relaxed way but i don't think it really gets to the heart of what makes carcassonne interesting it's a tricky one for a board game reviewer to get across and it doesn't help that it's sort of ugly and looks old but there is ultimately a reason why it's so popular and hopefully i did a better job of describing it in my latest uh games for people that hate rules video so yeah i would absolutely still recommend carcassonne i think everyone needs to play it once to see if it's for them and yeah i still have a copy of it in fact there's a newer version and i also have carcassonne hunters and gatherers which is a version that i slightly prefer because it's a
bit more mean and there's a bit more excitement to it i talk about it in one of my top 50 videos and number seven is battle line designed by reina kinicia easy to learn hard to master is a running theme of this list and this is a great example of it yeah easy to learn hard to master that's basically rhinoceros epitaph there are nine flags lined up on the table and you're playing cards on your side to try and win that flag you either need to win three adjacent flags or five in total you only have seven cards in your hand so you have to gamble on the cards that you hope to get in the future and you have to decide do you want to focus on the flags that you want to win or try and stop your opponent from getting the flags that they want yeah i wish i'd emphasized that more but it's the crux of the game is what do you commit to now you you can't get all the cards that you need to to build something out you can't wait for cards to come in because you're always having to play something out so where do you commit and where do you make those sacrifices or compromises your battle line is a game of making compromises and occasionally you'll hold out for a card and really hope for something good and sometimes it will come off but a lot of the time you do need to be tactically changing tack pivoting to somewhere else because you can't just always be clinging on for the card you need this is a great game for couples because it's quick it's easy to learn and you're going head-to-head with your
opponent but there's no aggression there's no hurt feelings you can't sabotage the other player you're just doing what you need to to win yeah i think this is a simple way to describe why battle line is so popular and also lost cities another game from rhino committee because you are competing with each other but you're never directly attacking them or taking away from them you're building up on your side they're building up on their side and so it's competitive but there is no take that and it and you you can't sort of be upset by what the other player is doing would i still recommend battleline absolutely i think it is one of the best two-player games one of the best couples games it's a game that me and serena have been playing for years i now own the shot and tottenham version just because it's smaller and i slightly prefer the artwork but battle line is just as good they're basically the same game so pick the one that you like and number six is cv designed by philip milinski cv is a game about telling a life and it uses a yahtzee dice mechanism to try and win cards to get jobs and different things throughout your life so you sort of tell a story of a life and that's a theme that's always really appealed to me but what cliched analogy works better for life than throwing the dice and seeing what you get like you might want that job as a ceo really badly but luck isn't going your way damn it i needed knowledge you could gamble on it waste a re-roll but the odds would be
stacked against you or you could put your efforts into something more attainable i guess i'll just take up marathon running instead yeah this is really reminding me what i like about cv that such simple mechanisms get across much bigger thematic ideas it's really an acute way it's not like you're immersed in this world but it just all clicks and works in a really satisfying way would i still recommend cv maybe it does depend what you're looking for i still have it in my collection so that tells you something but i haven't played it in a long time and i am put off by how long i remember it taking it can bog down a bit but the the way it delivers on its theme there's a big part of that is is my fondness for it it maybe doesn't hold up with the kind of tight speediness that i would want from a game of this level if it was released today but the theme kind of carries it into my collection and has made it stick around so it depends what you're looking for and of course if you like the theme there is also a pursuit of happiness is another option and number five is patchwork by uber rosenberg who would have thought a game about sewing a patchwork quilt would be any good well i didn't and then i tried it and here we are at number five in the list yeah patchwork is amazing and i think it's one of the games from
this list that has really stood the test of time that people are still talking about and playing and if i was to make a top 10 now patchwork would still be in it i feel like at the time it was hard to excite people about a game about quilting with like a brown cover over time the word has really spread and and now the pedigree of patchwork is much much higher that people really appreciate how good of a game it is and now of course it's on board game arena and it's probably the game on there that i've played the most because it's just so easy to enjoy and it's always the decisions are always tough and that satisfaction of trying to complete your puzzle and get everything and and sort of trying to reach the nirvana of having it all complete that still exists every single game that you play so yeah i love this one absolutely would still recommend patchwork it's been in my collection ever since i can't imagine this one ever leaving one of the best couples games around number four is paperback designed by tim flowers paperback is a deck building word game where you're using letter cards to build words to get points to buy more letters so that in the future you can build bigger and better words before modern ball games came along and saved us all there was one couple's board game scrabble but scrabble had two problems with it that the longest words weren't always the best they didn't get
the most points fluctuation that's 19 points vent v-e-n-t double letter on the v triple word score 33 points yeah i think this captures something that frustrated me and more so serena about scrabble scrabble was one of those games that we were playing probably when we first started going out and i would win more often because i would game it more and focus on the double and triple letter scores and of course that is the game but it's frustrating when you come up with really good words and you use your letters perfectly you've got an amazing vocabulary but because of the placement it's not worth anything and that is frustrating as far as i'm concerned paperback is a scrabble killer yeah i mean i don't think paperback is a scrabble killer in the sense that they operate in different realms you can't kill scrabble with a game that's as complicated as paperback would i still recommend paperback yes absolutely i still own paperback it's not a game that i play very often i think i'm turned off a bit by the setup of it sort of true of any deck building game when i'm playing a simple two-player game with serena i want something that we can just get straight into i've also played it a lot on the app which is great fun and so that sort of satisfies my paperback desires
so it means i'm less likely to play it in real life but i absolutely think it's the best modern word game around number three is arboretum a card game that takes some inspiration from lost cities which i hadn't played at this point and would now be in my top 10 couples game and it's one that i was probably talking about a bit before arboretum was like really big or at least that's what i like to tell myself um and now of course i think it's really understood how good of a game it is before i played arboretum i read the term hand management describing games and i never really got it i just thought it just meant organizing cards in your hand i didn't really see that there was much management required arboretum is more than just hand management it's hand obsession hand desperation and regret i can't discard that i can't discard that i can't discard that well i can't discard that can't just got that can't discard that and i can't discard that okay let's try again well i definitely can't discard that i definitely can't discard that i definitely can't discard that i definitely can't discard that yeah i think this is probably the best bit of this video because it really gets to the heart of the feeling of arboretum hand obsession hand desperation and then the scene afterwards that's exactly what it feels like to play this game in a nutshell and it's fiercely competitive without ever being
aggressive yeah it's another one it's competitive but not mean and again that sits in that perfect spot for couples games yes i absolutely still own arboretum i switched to this version i'm not sure if that was the right decision i would absolutely recommend it to anyone looking for a two-player card game it's also good at three and four but i tend to play it too the decisions are so tense it's stressful it's really thinky i i honestly think yeah it's just one of the best couples games and i think most people would agree with me number two is pandemic designed by matt leacock pandemic is a cooperative game where players are working together to defeat a global pandemic not only is it a great game but this is an experience that will bring you closer as a couple and then it creates a unique bond between you and your partner it's science if you go through a traumatic experience together you remember that i think you know i'm overstating it i don't really get across quite how cooperative and the the importance of discussion in a game of pandemic that unlike some co-op games there is a real puzzle to solve together and everyone's input is really important and that's why i love it as a couple's game because i might think to take things one way serena might think to take things another way and it's about compromising and cooperating
with each other and finding the best solution to save the world together i'd also recommend flashpoint fire rescue or other co-op games yeah i wouldn't recommend flashpoint fire rescue would i still recommend pandemic absolutely of course i still own it it's one of the first games i do own it's one of my favorite games of all time i also really love pandemic iberia pandemic full of rome even the dice version is great and then their expansions it's just such a great system to me the best cooperative game ever made and i'm yet to see one that does anything better than it number one is sherlock holmes consulting detective designed by raymond edmonds suzanne goldberg and gary grady sherlock holmes consulting detectives the original storytelling detective case-solving game from the 80s i remember it took me ages to try and get a copy of this game because it was just out of print for so long um i was so happy to get it you've got the directory where you can look up names of people involved and go and visit them and you've got a map of london i think we need to talk to the victim's wife no she won't know anything let's go to his workplace it's an easy game to try and describe and get across because it is so interactive with talking with each other and i think that what's so great about sherlock holmes is that it doesn't hand it all to you on a plate it doesn't tell you these are your options of places to go you can
kind of get around it it you know there's a little bit of fabrication to that they're they're making you believe that you have full autonomy you don't really but you you know you they might mention a ring and then you have to in think oh we should go visit the jewelers it doesn't tell you which jeweler to go to it doesn't even tell you to go to the jewellers and that's what i think makes the game more exciting sometimes than its other detective counterparts i recommend you play this game cooperatively you're reading out the encounters together anyway and it's so much more fun trying to decipher it together yeah i mean i'd forgotten that it's even a competitive game or at least it was maybe they've changed it with a new version i've only ever played this game cooperative and i don't worry about the point system i don't try and beat sherlock i just want to solve the case in a way that to me that feels satisfying no other game out there like it although i wish there was there's no other game out there like it though i wish there was well now there are loads so my wish came true would i recommend it yes absolutely i still this is the new version of sherlock holmes consulting detective and i've got the three other boxes uh it's a game that i love i love playing it with serena i think it's a great couples game we pretty much just only play it together i love the crime solving genre in general i i think this is probably my favorite but i also really enjoy chronicles of crime and detective a modern crime game
this is probably the best place to start and yeah i everyone should try one of them at least once well that was me reviewing my old reviews if you like this video please let me know in the comments because i could absolutely make more of them and if you want to see the old videos there are links in the description below as well as links to where you can buy the games that were mentioned if you use those links a small cut will go towards the channel please subscribe to the channel and if you want to support the channel you can become a patron of patreon.com forward slash actual for which you'll get the actual monthly newsletter i'm john perkis thanks for watching
you