Coimbra Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to chairman of the board today I'm taking a look at Cumbre which is a euro style dice drafting game by Virginia G Lee and Flamini Rossini now this sir designed you actually designed one of my people after my favorite game at the time of this recording lorenzo el magnífico now this game does have some similarities but also some quite distinct differences as well because this one has the mechanic or the mechanism of dice drafting in it it's a euro style game that uses dice which I naturally really like so again my expectations were very very high 2 to 4 players takes around 90 to 120 minutes to play I think the box has a little bit shorter than that but from my experiences that is the kind of time frame it takes so as I said fundamentally it's a dice drafting it's a kind of engine building game and you're using these dice to draft different cards to climb these different tracks give you kind of instant powers and I said as to build an engine as well but the the dice drafting is what really makes this game kind of unique and it's the way it uses dice drafting as well is very very intuitive very very kind of innovative because not only do the dice kind of pips on them of so you got your standard D sixes from one to six but also the color of the dice is also very very important so fundamentally you're going to basically take tiles drafting these dice and placing them on these different kind of rows so one of those
rows gives you kind of these bonuses and that goes for color from the lowest number although it to the highest number in order of priority whereas the other three columns you're going to use to buy cards and those cars are going to kind of make you climb these four different tracks I'm all relating to a different kind of currency you've got one track which can you match it stack which makes you kind of gain income or or gold one of them that you gain military points one of them lets you move your kind of merchants around the board collecting these different bonuses and the other one gains you purely victory points and I said all those different tracks are linked to a different kind of dye color so you've got are your oranges your Gray's your green your purples I believe so as I said these cards not only give you ways to climb those tracks and they vary in strength as well so some like that you just climb a track once or some do it three times some give you enough abilities some give you game end abilities some give you engine ability such as like gaining cards for cheaper or every time you draft a certain type of color of a card you'll get like a bonus and the like so you've got lots to think about there but the cool thing is not only of those higher pips going to give you priority in drafting the cards that you want it also means you're going to have to pay the relative cost as well so if you're drafting purely six is eat all the time you better hope that you have the money to pay for those sixes because I said it's going to be very very expensive to
do so so you're going to really have to weigh up those decisions on you know can I pay for it how badly do I need those cards but also what track do I need to gain the benefit of due to the color I'm drafting very very very clever I think it's actually a mechanism I haven't seen before and I don't even know if another game uses it whatsoever so I'm really really impressed by the kind of innovativeness of it and it is so so important as well because the game does kind of its breaking down into four rounds each of those four rounds you just draft three die so or three dice so the the important nosov gaining the right dice is very very kind of paramount into you into winning or not because you can't just spend a whole your time getting gold when you know you need the other resources as well and all those different kind of routes as well they're very very very balanced and obviously as you're climbing these tracks when you come to cashing in or come to gain the reward of the colors of the dice the higher that track the more rewards you're going to get to sales right at the top of the of the kind of victory point stack and I just the green dye I'm gonna get a very very big reward in terms of victory points as compared to somebody who's right at the bottom of that track so as I said that Jewel conflicting interest is very very interesting and really where the game you know flourishes I've also it's very very satisfying when you do get your
engine going because you can really get a lot of kind of combinations and you know your engine really really getting powerful and it's very very satisfying when you do kind of play to your strengths and you can really kind of pull away if you do play that way really really like it the the choices of getting those cars is very very important as well as I said if you're not getting into this top spot someone's going to take the ones you want you're going to have to readjust your plan and you know deciding on whether you want to you know take those one-off benefits whether you want to you know contribute to your engine whether you want to really focus on those endgame points is equally as important because you know all those different strategies seem very very well balanced and you know as with all Euro games you want to play to maximum efficiency in terms of strategies and bouts of that I think it's really really good I mean I've got no complaints whatsoever from what I've paid I've not played this game a whole lot a whole bunch but I played it a few times now and you know all your strategies seem very very well balanced the different tracks seem really good what I should have mentioned as well is the higher up these tracks you get you're going to get points depending on who is at the top of those tracks who's at the kind of a middle and who's at the bottom so you know it is just equally as important or maybe not equal is a lot but it is important to try and stay at the top of those tracks because there is a bunch of endgame victory points you can get if you do focus on that so not only that is the the variability is that
of the game is very very cool as well because I'm the so basically the cars are going to be pretty much you know well they are actually divided into four round is that because you're going to see the same cards every every game you play this but the tracks kind of have the tiles where you score the points is there variable so basically every game the different tracks are going to be worth different points depending on how high up how you are up them so that's going to kind of change the little focus the focus of the game a bit I'm also on the map where you're traveling around to get these benefits such as I end gabe bonuses or you get these rosettes which kind of contribute to set collection endgame bonuses or you know maybe they might just give you a bunch of coins or a bunch of military strength that they're very very variable and not all of them go out on the on the board straight away so you've got a bit of variability there and you've got different kind of routes you want to go to and prioritize in different ways and also the game comes with these different kind of voyages as well which kind of I think that's like five or six of them that come out on the board and they're quite expensive but they contribute very very strongly to endgame scoring and you only kind of get one opportunity each round to invest in one of those voyages and there are other ways to do more of them but the the fact that only six of them come out but there's absolutely a ton of them in the box really does spice up the game and again add that kind of modular variability which just increases the replayability and longevity of the game immensely so very very impressed with that and the game flows very very
smoothly from one face the next I love the kind of importance of player order or initiative because you've basically you can collect these crowns which will basically the personal the most crowns will be the first player in the next round but the game kind of naturally builds in the kind of function where whoever goes last in the previous round automatically gets a couple of crowns to contribute to their complete value so they've got a better chance of coming earlier in the turn order next round so really really like that player initiative kind of mechanism the game definitely doesn't out States welcome or anything despite being you know on the on the 90 to 120 minutes timeframe I think it fits that really really nicely it it doesn't lose your interest it definitely feels like you're constantly engaged you really get stuck into the game and especially as you get things going so yeah no complaints are at all again with with player player uptime as well as no issue whatsoever because you're doing a very small chunk of the game each time I mean you're not sitting around waiting for other players to take their long turns um maybe a slight little bit prone to AP or encourages that but no real issues whatsoever I'm really nitpicking there I said repair replayability excellent pay interaction is an interesting one in this one and obviously you've got the kind of quite passive interaction in terms of people snatching the dice you won in front of you really have to make you adjustments of that but in terms of
getting to places quickest or investing in these voyages there's really no kind of interaction there at all because basically there's no punishment to getting that quicker or after I had to play like a lot of these juror games you kind of if someone gets to something first they get it for cheaper that if someone goes there second whereas this one everybody plays the same thing there's no kind of real competition or um you know aggressiveness or that race in this one at all so you can really kind of do things at your own pace and not have to worry about beating other players there too to those spots which personally I really like I don't mind either way to be honest but I think it's nice sometimes when you do have that and you didn't have that constant or that other kind of pressure to get in other places quicker I love the look of the game I mean for a pretty seamless almost dry euro game the game looks really really pretty very bright the kind of character illustrations are really nice the symbology is good yeah no complaints or at all very very kind of bore that really pops and it looks really really nice to dice a really good quality no complaints about the production whatsoever comes with these very very nice little dice holders wait this when you're drafting your dice you put them in your colored dice holder and it kind of represents which dice you've drafted so really really functional no complaints whatsoever and I really like the look of the game as I said in terms of the theme I don't really understand what the theme is it's very very abstracted and but again it's a euro game I don't care so a set up and tear down time again no real issues there I mean he just gonna be shuffling the
decks and placing the cards out I mean it has to be done every round but no real problem there setting up the different tiles on the board takes a little bit time but nothing really too strenuous so I'm again no complaints whatsoever and but yeah overall this is another spectacular game it's a really really amazing game by these Italian designers they just keep hitting one after another for me they just really do hit that sweet spot for me I love all their games this is a pretty medium-weight game is not to too much in terms of complexity it's not too complex but the decision space is really they're really enjoyable some really tight you know tense decisions you have to make or whether you're going to kind of risk coming second and not get you the cards you want but you know balance that with the money you're spending balance like with the dice you're the colored dye you're drafting really really cool and you can get some really satisfying engine builders going which I really really enjoying board games I said if you tried anything against before such as Lorenzo or you know grand Austria hotel those kind of games you're really gonna like this one really recommend you check it out I know a lot of people kind of say this is very similar to rent it but for me it has a very different feel to where definitely you know space on the Shelf of both of these and I wouldn't just say that I mean I I don't like having games that are too similar and these two feel very different to me and yeah no quip is whatsoever on about keeping both of them this is definitely staying my shot I think it is a really
amazing game and one that I highly recommend if you like your medium weight euros if you like games that use dice if you like dice drafting if you like engine building this is one definitely to check out a real real success of 2018 this game coimbra a fantastic amazing game so I hope you've enjoyed this guy quick review of Coimbra and if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for over now so I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye