Shadowdark RPG Review: THROW THEM IN THE HOLE!
Transcript
Hi everyone, I'm Tally. This is Farrell and we're bored of it. And we're back with another RPG review. And this time we're talking Shadow Dark. This is a system with a lot of buzz. And it builds itself on being fast, familiar, intuitive, and deadly. Shadow Dark is a modern redesign or take on old school RPGs like Dn D with a focus on streamlining and ease of play.
So, we're going to jump straight into what we think. how to play and all that, but just know that while we did buy everything Shadow Dark ourselves, we did get a discount on the core book and Cursed Scroll Zen one. So, please keep that in mind. So, the one thing Shadow Dark is great at is providing a lot of options on how to play, but without it being overwhelming to new players. For example, you can create a level one character right off the bat, and it tells you everything that you need to do. There's even options for randomization to speed up the process, but it does suggest that you first run a gauntlet with level zero characters, which was by far our preferred way to start. Gauntlets are, in short, death traps. There are dungeons that are full of monsters, traps, and puzzles, which can also be traps if you do them wrong.
Each player will create four or more randomized level zero characters and stick them in the dungeon and see what happens. Level zeros have no class, minimal health, and minimal equipment.
Combined, these provide Shadow Dark with an ease of entry, and also an instant engagement to players. So point one on this score is the fact that when you play a gauntlet with level zero characters, it kind of strips away a lot of the extra rules that come with classes and and certain weapons and abilities. It means that players can get to grips with the kind of core system of Shadow Dark uh without a lot of extra FAF kind of weighing them down and crippling them with indecision. It also provides a a lot of fun in terms of exploration and pushing the boundaries because these level zero characters are almost destined to die. So, it allows players to experiment a bit more that they might not, you know, take chances they might not with their actual characters that they've developed and got to know over time.
Third, this all combines to create a lot of laughter, silliness, and and fun and engagement because you basically have village people and peasants running around getting mured left, right, and center. And it's just silly and it's fun and it just provides a lot of laughter and and some real memorable sessions. So, whoever then survives the gauntlet will get to progress to being a level one character and getting their class and the players can then kind of ramp up a little bit with those extra rules now that they have got to grips with the system. Well, we already touched upon how it is an excellent way to ramp up the complexity and the decision space in the game. It's also an excellent way to allow players to ramp up gradually the role- playinging elements because when you have a level zero character, they might be faceless. You might kill them off instantly through your actions. So, you don't develop too much attachment to them. But once you get the level one, then you you start getting more into that character and developing a personality. you begin to get spells and weapons and magic items and and it allows you to have a wider range of options to problem solve. And this kind of in a very nice bit-by-bit way allows characters or sorry players to become more creative in their problem solving and thus kind of develop their characters more. And this is what I've seen with my players and I think it works really well. Now, I think if you
have very inexperienced players with this type of system, going straight to level one could cause a bit of kind of incapacity to make decisions if there's too much at once where you have kind of uh your race abilities and class abilities and spells and it can get a bit much. But of course, if you have any experience with Dungeons and Dragons or any type of system like this, you very much are not going to have a problem going straight to a level one character and getting your adventure started.
Now, Shadow Dark has many classic elements. Classes are what you'd expect, perhaps by a different name, and the stats you roll for are the same as Dn D. When you want to attempt an action, you roll a d20 and then add or subtract any relevant modifiers for that stat and then see if you equal or beat the difficulty class for that action or the armor class of an enemy. It comes into its own through a focus on dungeon crawling and light management. XP is tied to the quality of loot that you gain whilst crawling, but dungeons are dark. Players will need to manage their light sources, usually torches, which are set against a real world timer, which is managed by the DM. Being in the dark creates a bad situation, so it puts a natural importance on the system. It's a really cool mechanism because it pushes for a more high octane form of play because you're always working against the clock. That's not to say you can only dungeon crawl in Shadow Dark, but it has been our group's preferred way to play. The core book provides a lot of tips on how to create pretty much anything you'd expect to explore in this type of game. Entire biomes, towns, dungeons, and taverns. There's also well over a dozen randomized encounter tables for inspiration or for use during the game for pretty much any location your party would be in. There's also a wealth of support in creating your own adventures and making them unique. But it should be noted there are no pre-made
adventures in the core book.
For that you'll want to look at the cursed scroll zenes and this is something that we have used. So these are additional little booklets filled with all kinds of extensions of the game. So new classes, new weapons, items and everything else, but also adventures and dungeons. Ourselves. We've used the gauntlet from Curse Scroll 3 and a dungeon from number one and we've enjoyed both of them. And I'd also suggest looking at the community at large as well if you want your own scenarios because there are plenty that people have designed. And I think that we'd also like to give a shout out to the trial of the slime lord, a free gauntlet that we definitely enjoyed.
Overall, Shadow Dark is a brilliant system. It's a perfect entry for people who maybe have heard of D and D, are interested in trying Dungeons and Dragons, interested in getting into this world of role playing, but have always been a little scared on how to approach it, especially when you have so many decades and so much content available for D&D. Now, just in our group that we've been playing Shadow Dark with, one of them joined because him and his other own gaming group had bought a starter set for Dungeons and Dragons that was hundreds of pages long. And they felt so intimidated they actually never got around to playing it. But now that he has played this, he feels much more confident and ready to turn and tackle that starter set and hopefully create his own sessions, which is just something that ShadowDoc can do for you.
The system is indeed fast, familiar, and intuitive. And I can say that even though myself and my players have no real love or connection to the classic fantasy setting, this has probably been the most successful RPG I've run in terms of fun and player engagement. And that is because of the strength of ShadowDoc's systems. And one thing in particular that I really credit with that is the core book because it has probably been the best core book in my experience. with DMing in terms of helping uh DMs create their own scenarios and situations. It's full to the brim with ro to discover tables uh for everything, NPCs, taverns, cities, events, all different biomes, and there's just such a wealth. And because the prompts are a little bit tongue andcheek, often it it allows you to very much extrapolate and expand a very simple prompt into something much bigger. And this means that players have great fun sessions with a lot of silliness and and drama and excitement.
And never before has it been such little work on my side to to run that compared to the amount of output the players get. Probably the only negative I would have for the core book is that sometimes I found the organization a little frustrating. Now, I will say it's a very good book and it has a very good table of contents, very easy to reference, but it's just that some things appear in multiple sections, split across multiple pages, and there's a lack of cohesion. And sometimes these are important elements, like for example, leveling up. I think that's split across four different kind of subsections. And sometimes it can seem contradictory because it's spread out so far across the book. And this isn't the only uh kind of example of this. So it it has been a little frustrating at times, but like I said, the the excellent table of contents has gone some way towards alleviating this problem. Final thoughts, I would say for our group, Shadow Dark has been a surprising smash hit, but maybe let's hear from a player.
Yeah. No, I've definitely been enjoying it and I've enjoyed it more the more we've played as well. I think maybe in the beginning I felt like I wasn't as connected to the characters as other RPGs that we've played and we're quite into kind of doing the whole roleplay doing a voice and all of this and in the beginning I struggled to maybe connect with uh my my characters but over time
and you know playing with them and like getting to know them it becomes a bit easier. So yeah, my enjoyment of it is definitely going up the more we play.
And it is really fun to do the kind of dungeon crawling puzzle style as well. I really like that. So you've designed some which is like an escape room type of thing and yeah, we've really enjoyed the the puzzle element of that.
So yeah, if you're interested then I can definitely recommend it maybe as a first parade into RPGs especially.
Yeah, especially if you're you want your RPG to be this kind of classic fantasy setting. Yeah,
I think uh I would definitely recommend it. So, that will do it for our review of Shadow Dark. I really appreciate you watching and please consider subscribing if you find it helpful.