Are Game Reviews Just Opinions?
Transcript
we as consumers love reviews whether it's buying a new car going to see a movie or even buying a board game with thousands of board games coming out every year people want to know where to spend their hard earned money and are looking for an honest objective review but here's the thing no matter who does the review in the end it's just their opinion liking a game or not comes down to a personal preference even though we may sit and play the exact same game you may like it and i may not or vice versa our previous game and life experiences will help shape our opinions on whether we like a gamer not and since we all have different experiences we may all come to a different conclusion thus in the end board game reviews are primarily subjective reviews here's the thing notice i said board game reviews because reviews can have different varying degrees of objectivity for example recently i went out and bought a new mobile phone and when i was looking at reviews for phones a lot of them were very fact based what is the size of the screen what is the resolution of the screen how much ram is there how much rom is there what kind of cameras does i have how many cameras does i have how good is the camera with again take a picture and look at the histogram of the picture to determine if it's good color or not all that is a hundred percent measurable quantities which makes it very objective in the end there was very little subjectivity when
i was reading these reviews unless it was maybe like a personal preference of maybe where the fingerprint reader was or where a button was on the phone but everything else was pretty much objective contrast that with say a movie review sometimes before we go see a movie we want to know whether we'll like it or not so you can go to places like rotten tomatoes metacritic etc and read their reviews well beyond the name of the movie who's in the movie the run time everything else after that's going to be a subjective opinion because when you're sitting in the theater and you're watching the story play out and the cinematography and the characters they may strike you in different ways the person sitting beside you is seeing the exact same thing and may not have a very good experience while you may be totally enjoying it so movie reviews tend to be more on the subjective side there's just not that many quantitative things you can say about a movie that's 100 fact based and you know what boy game reviews tend to be more like movie reviews let's look at the things that are fact based in a board game you can the name of the game when it was published how many people it plays the people involved in the game artists designers etc the rules of the game how it plays etc that's going to be the same from person to person but beyond that well then you start losing sub objectivity at that point shoot even the playing time you may see on the box this game plays 45 to 60 minutes how many of us have ever played a game that didn't match that maybe it was
quicker maybe it was longer depending on the group that you play with and then once you start playing the game well then it comes down to personal preferences this game is too hard this game is too easy i don't like the theme of this game i don't like the colors of these meeples i don't like the art of the game etc etc or somebody else may like every single one of those and if both of you sat down and wrote a review you may have totally different opinions about that game now why am i even bringing this up this is probably pretty much common sense right there's probably nobody out there thinking well yeah a board game review is just a person's opinion of a game you're not really telling me anything here there's two reasons i wanted to bring this up and the first one is a little bit of a squirrel but regardless of who you are what the format or the review is or whether you're just talking among friends your opinion is 100 valid if board game reviews are just opinions then your opinion can't be wrong now i will put a little caveat there the only way your opinion could be wrong is if it's based on something that's not true for example let's go back to the phone review say for example a person wrote a review and said you know i don't recommend this phone because it only has 32 gig of storage space and you probably need 64. well if in fact that phone had 64 then he based his opinion a conclusion on something that was not true now in a board game it could be something where a rule is played incorrectly you make a judgment based upon an incorrect rule and we we've seen that
happen before in fact i've even done it before shock but let's assume for the sake of this discussion that that's not happening so everybody's opinions are valid but there are some reviewers whose opinions may have more value than others so let me explain what i mean there for example on our show when we review a game sometimes we'll have a segment called five minute initiative where we discuss a game within five minutes tell about the game give our thoughts and we're done now say for example somebody else takes that exact same game and spends 30 minutes talking about the game they break down all the rules and everything and when it comes to their conclusion what they do is they give you a step-by-step analysis of how they came to that conclusion i like this because of this i don't like this because of this so there's a lot of value in that because you know exactly how they got to their conclusion whereas somebody else who just said hey i played the game i really liked it you should try it out you don't really know the reasons why they liked it so while all reviews are valid some do have more value than others so the second point if board game reviews are opinions and everybody's opinions are valid then there is really no reason to get upset when somebody has a different opinion about a board game than you i mean how many times have you seen on social media or forums etc well somebody will say man i really love this game and then
somebody jumps in and says how can you like that game that game's horrible ugh why would you even play that let's let's flip that because i've seen it too somebody may come in and say nah this game just really wasn't for me somebody else jumps in and goes how can you not like that game that is the best game ever and then it starts this back and forth thing now if it's one of those things where it leads to a discussion of maybe you know why didn't you like it oh okay well here's why i didn't like it but lots of times it just doesn't come off like that and then people get defensive right if somebody says i like something somebody says i don't then it's almost like it's an attack on that person how dare you not like that are you attacking me personally no it's just what you think about a board game and it could come down to so many different things again play style how difficult the game is themes some people like these things some people like these things that's why i have so many different themes but here's the thing if a person has an opposite opinion of a game than what i do it doesn't affect me at all nor should it affect my enjoyment or unenjoyment or disenjoyment and i enjoyment of the game it's one of those things if i let somebody's opinion of a game get to me that's not their problem it's my problem i could control how somebody else's opinion affects me when it comes to something like a board game
then well whatever but it is easy to get called up in the how can you not like this how can you like this sort of deal and some people are just very argumentative and and like being like that but i do think it's important to remember that if somebody has a differing opinion it's not an attack on you or me especially when it's just something as trivial as a board game so yes in the end board games are just personal opinions of the person reviewing the game it's a valid opinion and they're not wrong in their opinion and if people can learn to respect the right for somebody else to have a different opinion about a board game then maybe just maybe we can learn to respect the right of people to have differing opinions on other topics but that's just my opinion i want to hear your opinion go down in the comments let me know what you think about this topic are some reviews more objective than others where do board games fall on that spectrum of objectivity to subjectivity and whether you leave a comment or not if you're not subscribed to the channel please do so give a thumbs up i would very much appreciate it thanks y'all you