TDG: Arkham Horror: The Card Game (2026)
Transcript
Hello, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, I did one of my kids workouts the other day and now I'm really sore. In my head, shoulders, knees, and toes. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Arkham Horror: The Card Game, the new core set from Fantasy Flight Games.
In Arkham Horror: The Card Game from Fantasy Flight Games, one to four players take on the roles of investigators as they attempt to go through the town of Arkham to discover all sorts of weird occult monsters and all sorts of icky things and defeat them. All right, ladies and gentlemen, I have previously reviewed Arkham Horror: The Card Game. I'm not going to get into the weeds of rules or anything here. I'm just going to talk about the basics of gameplay and then I'm going to talk about this new edition. All right, ladies and gentlemen, so in this game you have a starter decks and you actually have these kind of pre-made starter decks in this edition. You go ahead, you get these starter decks, and you're going to essentially use them to, as I say, investigate these horrors that are going on in Arkham and hopefully overcome them. Now, you pick a character. Uh you can also uh use the little tokens that you're going to place on cards that are the various locations to show where you are at a certain time. You can use little mini cards as well, but these tokens are pretty handy. Now, at the start of the game, you're going to be set up with a starting location.
Uh you're going to have kind of the scenario cards that are placed out that give you the kind of basic information for the scenario. And then you've got tokens on your starting location. This this box comes with these like investigator tokens that you can use in different colors. Uh or you can you know, use the investigator cards if you want, but you can use the tokens. Now, critically here, you have several different options uh on your turn, different things you can do. You can have essentially you have three actions, all be all things being equal, and you can play these different actions. You can play a card. Now, you've got a lot of assets in your card, you can go ahead and you can you can play them. Uh or, you know, there's an event you can play. But most cards you play will have a cost associated with them. Now, you have a number of resources in the game, you can pay those resources in order to activate those cards. Some of these cards you actually kind of put out in front of you, some of them are, you know, items that you can wear. Uh some of them are things that you hold in your hand and they can give you various advantages over the course of the game. Now, one of the big things is skill checks. So, you can attempt to investigate. Now, you have a number of kind of investigate icons on your cards and you can actually just just play those, just discard those to get the um investigate icons and bring your number up. You have the stats and you can use those to improve your investigation stats. And so, you're trying to get that number as high as you can because you're going to reach into a bag and at the beginning of the game, depending on the scenario, you're going to put in various numbers, most of them negative, zero, some positive. Um and then some other kooky things. We're going to reach into the bag and you're going to pull out a number that will modify that number that you have. If you can beat the investigation number on the card, you can claim a clue token. These clue
tokens are important because you're going to need those in order to advance in the game. You could choose to draw a card or to move to an an adjacent location. The cards will be connected by these uh connectors. You can move to those different locations. If there's an enemy in your spot, you can attempt to fight them. Essentially, you do your fight uh skill check and same thing, you're playing cards uh discarding cards to get your fight number up and then you reach into the bag and you pull out one of these numbers that will, you know, modify that. And then if you can hit them, you deal them damage. If you have a weapon, you can potentially deal more damage. If you don't want to fight them, you can choose to uh evade, in which case you're trying to use your agility stat and do the same thing, just to get past them. So, that's something else you can do. But these monsters like to glom on, like to engage with the various hunters and they're hard to get rid of. You can draw a card, you can gain a resource. There's there's a few other different things you can do in the game. But over the course of the game, you're trying to, you know, meet the criteria of that specific mission. So, you're going around to the different locations, you're fighting these monsters, you are trying to gain clues, and you're doing all sorts of other things, activities that you're doing in the course of the game. You you can activate locations, you can play cards with special actions on them. So, there's all sorts of things you're doing. And then you're trying to get toward the end of that scenario.
Now, depending on how far you get in the scenario, you can resign, that's an option, but how far you get in the scenario, that's going to kind of determine how you're going to advance in this campaign. If you can make it all the way through to the end, then you win. Arkham Horror: The Card Game. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel, that is Cody Carlson, PhD, where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my uh lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel. And now, back to the review. All right, ladies and gentlemen, so as I said, I've actually I reviewed this a few years ago, the a previous um starter edition of this game. And so, the game is is fairly familiar in in in the basic ideas here. This new core set doesn't do a lot of changing up of the rules. There's some streamlining, but but basically there's not a lot there. What you do see here is a lot of kind of component and cosmetic and and and quality of life changes. Like I say, you've got those little tokens instead of the cards that you can put out for your location. You've got the pre-made decks that that that come with the game, starter decks. And as the game progresses, you'll have access to better, more powerful cards in the game, which is, you know, can can can really beef you up, right? So so, the game itself, uh like I say, brings a lot of quality of life changes and the scenarios, of course, here are new. Now, what is cool here is this is entirely backwards compatible with if you have a lot of the other stuff from Arkham Horror: The Card Game, uh it it'll function with this set. So, that's that's really really
cool as well. Um now, this is a game that I historically, when I played it, played it solo and I preferred to play it solo. Uh I played through this though the other night, um Ray and I played through uh scenarios the other night. I don't like it as much as a two-player. I like it much better as a solo player. But um here's the thing. I'll I'll just say this right now. Uh this game, component-wise, is awesome. I think it's a beautiful-looking game. I think uh well, first of all, too, Fantasy Flight did not just send me the game, they sent me a lot of swag with it. They sent me upgraded the the bag with the the really cool tokens in it. It's got [clears throat] a flat bag and so, it stands and then you can reach in and grab these really nice tokens.
That's really cool. They sent me the um connectors, which are the um not just cardboard, they're kind of little acrylic connectors that you can place on there. They look great, fun to play with. They sent me the game mats that you're seeing here in this. Um They sent me some of the deck holders and just just a lot of really cool stuff to upgrade the game. So, make it really really sweet. The game looks amazing. It just looks so good. Now, I'll tell you this, too. The game is fun. It's scary. It's it's typical kind of, you know, these these these Cthulhu games where you're battling H.P. Lovecraft monsters. You got investigators, you got skill checks. All that's kind of fairly common to the genre there. And the game is fun. And really, to me, what you're playing a game like this for is the story. You're you're you you as fun as the game is, you like to see that story evolve. You never know where it's going to go and how it's going to end up and who's going to die.
It it's really fun. And like I said, there there there there's a lot going on. I didn't get into the rules. You've got you've got an enemy phase where they're going to attack you. You've got upkeep phase, you know. Um I have to tell you, there are times when, as a reviewer, I get this kind of weird moment where I I like a game and I recognize it is a good, if not great, game. And I also realize maybe it's not for me. Now, as I say, I I reviewed this game before and I liked this game before, but I ultimately got rid of my my um earlier version of it because I'm not a fan of this kind of living card game model. Um I don't like having to to go out and get new sets whenever they come out and there's all these different sets and you I'm kind of a completist, so it's kind of a money drain. And then you feel guilty when you don't play through all of them. And and I'll tell you right now, this this this core set is very very fun.
But it's only got like the three scenarios in it, right? And you're going to run out of content pretty quickly. Um you're going to want to get more and, you know, that's that's the hook, right? You're going to want to go out and buy these things. And I just I I don't have really the the money, the time, or the interest to dedicate to one game like this. So, like I say, I gave that that early one away. I liked it, but I gave it away. And I like this one. It's fun and I really do enjoy it. But a couple of things really came came to me as I was playing it. And the first one is, yeah, I I'm still not going to get into the LCG model. I'm just I'm not going to do it. And the second thing that occurred to me now is as I was playing it is, you know, as much as I do enjoy this, as much as I like it, I would rather play Eldritch Horror or Cthulhu: Death May Die or Mansions of Madness. Um there's other kind of Cthulhu Lovecraft games that I enjoy more than this one.
I like this game a lot, but I don't I I but I feel like if I was going to play one of these games, I'd rather go to one of those games. Now, I understand some people Ray had said, "Well, yeah, but I like this one better for solo." I see that, but honestly, I think I'd still rather play one of those games solo. So, there is that aspect to it. Well, as I say, this is a great game. The it's a great game. But it's not for me. I'm actually going to give this once I finish with my review, I'm going to give this one to Ray. Ray really was excited about it. So, I'm going to give him and all the great swag, I'm going to give that to Ray. I think he will appreciate it. And again, if ever I do want to play it, I can go ahead and just head over to his place and we can we can play the game there. Whenever I give him a game, he always says, "Well, it's still yours. I'm just baby sitting it for you." It's like, "Okay. Okay."
One final thing I do want to note, and that is the insert that comes in this box is not great. It's I don't know, it's just weird. The boxes the shapes are just a little weird. I don't know. I know I haven't sleeved the cards yet, but I'm kind of wondering if the sleeves will really fit in there well. I was just I wasn't terribly impressed with it. Ray actually mentioned that he thought that Fantasy Flight Games has always had a problem with inserts. That's kind of their one weakness. Great games, great productions, but their weaknesses. So, fair enough. I wasn't terribly impressed with that. But but all told, again, I think it is a great game. And based on its own merits, I'm going to go ahead I'm going to give it an eight on the Cody scale. Eight out of 10. I think it I think it deserves that. I think it merits that. But again, I just don't see myself devoting the time and the money to this game that I think it really need to to appreciate it.
Thank you once again for joining us today on the Discriminating Gamer. As always, we'd ask you to please leave a comment for us here on YouTube, on BoardGameGeek, on Facebook, on X. We'd love to hear from you. Please like this video and subscribe to our YouTube channel. If you've already subscribed, check it just to make sure you're still subscribed. Sometimes there's some phantom unsubscribing unsubscribings out there. Ladies and gentlemen, we would ask you also, if you like what you see here, please check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson, PhD. We talk about military history, books on history, fun things like that. I even post some of my lectures up there. It'd mean the world to me if you'd subscribe to that channel as well. And if you do really like what you see here, I would ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. Say, do you know what was a more useful invention than the first telephone? The second telephone.
[screaming]
Oh, I know. Sheesh. So dumb.