Co-design, Collaboration & Kompromat
Transcript
okay so this video is the second video i've made talking about co-design and collaboration uh and my co-designer rob fisher will be chipping in diving into this video and talking about how we developed the game compromat which came out in uh in the sort of autumn of of 2020. uh so compromise is just becoming available at this point um and in this video i'm going to show you how the game works what it's all about i'm going to show you some footage of the game on table topia where you can play the game for free and i'm going to have a detailed conversation with rob about how we put the game together what we were aiming for what our processes were how we collaborate uh how we ended up pitching it to helvetique the publisher who ended up making it and how it eventually came to market in this particular form so let's start off by looking at how the game works compromat is a game for exactly two players who take on the roles of rival spies competing by taking on daring missions in pursuit of victory points the gameplay will be familiar to players of blackjack or 21 or pontoon as players attempt to outscore each other over several hands but never going over 21.
each player has an identical deck of cards with number values and each round four missions are revealed on a player's turn they reveal a card from the top of their deck and then they assign it face up to the mission of their choice they may then add as many cards as they wish one at a time from their deck looking at the cards but playing them face down so the other players don't know which cards they have in play if the total exceeds 21 then the player must stop adding cards but they don't have to reveal this to the other player and when a player stops either through choice or because they're over 21 then the other player takes their turn and so that sequence continues until each player has placed cards on all four of the missions now the cards for each mission are revealed and if a player has scored more than 21 they're bust they take one notoriety token and they discard their cards if a player scores exactly 21 they may lose one notoriety token and then the highest scorer who has not gone bust wins the mission card most mission cards are worth a set number of victory points but some give players one-off abilities that can be used at any time allowing players to look at cards in their deck or check the opponent's already played cards or adjust their own mission total by plus or minus one point some mission cards will be accompanied by counter intelligence and when these missions are won the spy is witnessed they take the number of notoriety tokens shown on the counter intelligence card and at the end of the game after six rounds of play the players total their victory points
from the mission cards they've collected and add one victory point per notoriety token but if a player has nine notoriety tokens at any point in the game they lose the game immediately hence the game features two layers of push or luck attempting to score higher than the other player on each mission while staying under 21 and amassing notoriety while staying under nine tokens okay so now you've seen how the game works i'm going to introduce you to my co-designer rob fisher and we'll have a little look at the process of developing this game let me introduce you to rob fisher my co-designer for compromats and rob was also my co-designer for the game quezon which i've also probably already posted a video about at this point because we've just talked about question or maybe i'll post about it afterwards but one way or the other there's gonna be another video about quasal that you can watch but today we're talking about compromise um now uh what what what should we tell me about compromise rob what is it compliment is uh published by helvetique it's a two-player game part of their after-dinner line of games um and it's based around blackjack um one way of thinking about it is that you're playing four hands of blackjack simultaneously essentially um we have a strong theme on the game of spies who are
trying to get secret information or suppress secret information um let's go back to the beginning of the design of the of the design because i think there's a couple of points there that that reminds me of really so it so it came about originally because i had been playing a lot of lost cities and hannah makoji and battleline and tramban which is a lookout game and these all were two player only games which had a sort of row of sort of cards that you would compete over with your your opponent um and i quite fancy having a go at designing a game along those lines and uh where battle line basically takes poker and and and you you sort of play poker but spread your you know your poker hands across you know you split your poker hands and spread them across these different missions i wanted to do that with um blackjack uh i i like pushing luck games i like games like quacks of quentinburg and incan gold or diamond and captain carcass or dead man's draw those sort of games so anyway i wanted to create something like that so i created a game that was all about pirates uh competing over different uh locations um and it was fantastic and so i took it to the game design group and i showed it to rob and a few
others and rob didn't think it was very good i i really liked the idea i i'm a huge fan of battle line um and i thought what you were doing trying to find us a game with a similar feel but with a another classic card game at its heart was a brilliant idea but i do have to admit i didn't like that original implementation um and it it sort of bugged me because i i found i couldn't stop thinking about it despite not enjoying the experience um and as far as i'm concerned the next part of the story is is where i was sat in a waiting room for an hour waiting for a doctor um and i i had nothing with me so i sort of started thinking about this game and i tried to i remember asking myself what specifically is it that i don't like about this design and i came up with i think four things i said fine so if i can just fix those four things and present it back to adam um see if he likes it maybe we can move the design on um yeah and achieve your your original goals yeah so you so rob then i think you came to my house and you had a deck of playing cards and uh and then we sort of set it up and you said right these are these are children and they are
in rowing boats and they're trying to get to central islands and so we had this sort of little theme but essentially the core gameplay was very similar to the final compromise game um and then you kind of left it with me to mull over and so i played a bit with it and i also thought a lot about the theme and i came back to you and suggested maybe we were burglars trying to climb up to get into windows um and you said you'd had similar ideas and we talked about having a bunch of tools that you would use in a burglary um yeah trying to work out what the cards represented that the cards that you're playing were they were they going to be people i think we talked about anthropomorphic animals at one point that you had this little you talked about uh them being some sort of like demon in a nightmare trying to steal children's dreams at some point they seemed to recall i did but um yes that that falls into the category of when uh racking your brain for ideas it's better just to say it to get it out of your your mind i'm not sure that dream stealing games are big sellers generally i remember showing my wife uh the sort of these images that i had put together for the for the burglary version with all the burglary tools and stuff and and i showed it to her and said you know would you play this game and she said no it looks like a game of serial killers why would i play that so um so then we then i sort of moved on
to this idea of uh of spies um which which seemed to seem to fit really well yeah and uh yeah we just i think we play tested a lot with the to kind of get the distribution of the cards right so that you were you know incentivized to try and risk getting to 21. um yeah we were trying to maximize the sort of push your luck aspect of the game we wanted you to constantly be on a knife edge and to try and find as many different ways of putting the player on that knife edge as possible so things like the notoriety system that came into the game um and how can we incentivize the player to try and get that 21 as often as possible yeah yeah yeah um and it came together pretty quickly really and there was a bit of back and forth trying to work out the special powers and things that would be on the different pieces of of equipment um that was quite fun working on those different bits and pieces i i think that came together when you rightly pointed out that we needed to keep it simple and that all the special items and should work in the same way that they would be single-use items because before that i i dreamt of all sorts of wonderful things but some of them were like passive effects and some of them were things you could use repeatedly some of them you'd use on your turn some of them
you could use on your opponent's tent some of them would go into your deck and oh yeah some cards in your deck and things like that and they were nice ideas but they were far too complicated um each one had to be explained exactly what it did and exactly when you could play it and you are absolutely right to streamline that to all the tools all the effects cards work in exactly the same way i always have my eye on a publisher as well and i'm with a game like this i was very tempted to try and keep it language independent and not have any text on it and i know the eventual version does have text on it um but it probably could have managed without just icon based because there aren't that many powers and the powers are pretty simple and so i i always think uh you know just just being able to say to a publisher this game could be language independent is is quite a nice sort of selling point really so that's another part of the reason i wanted to keep those things really simple um and we we toyed with the idea of more than two players but i think when we tried that it was very unwieldy there were cards everywhere all over the table lots of down time it wasn't really any fun was it no it was uh as soon as we tried it multiplayer it just absolutely confirmed that this is a great two-player game essentially which was nice uh because it meant we didn't then have to go off uh rebalancing the decks how's it gonna
handle three players four players and so on it just absolutely was what it was so i took it off to uh to essen spiel and showed it to a few publishers not many uh but i showed it to helvetique to haddie barcat i hadn't met haddie before i hadn't shown anything to helvetique although i really like their their games i like the graphic design and the boxes and the way they're packaged the way they're sold i think they're you know they stand out as something a bit different um and some and there's something quite clever and um canny about the way that they market their games and um you know it just feels like a company that knows what it's doing so anyway when i met with haddie uh had he absolutely loved it um we played it he you know i i could just tell that he he got it he understood what the game was he enjoyed it for what it was um and i remember coming away from that meeting and saying to rob you know we i actually had a lot of a lot of interest in the game throughout that sm but coming away and saying to rob you know what i want to i want to go with helvetique if they if they offer i don't want to wait for the others i want to i want to go with helvetique and uh you were happy with i think you trusted me on it yeah definitely it was a case of um trusting your co-designer um i think i've known you long enough that uh yeah there's this level of understanding between us i know what your your values are and i think we both appreciate um enthusiasm
uh enormously and when i got that first text from you describing hadi's reaction to seeing the game just it's one of the feelings i love a sort of childish delight that you've found something that you know is fun and you just can't wait to play it and that seems to be the way he he'd reacted to the game so yeah a great choice of a publisher to go with and then the eventual um i mean it's a bold design isn't it it's a bold design choice this orange and blue with the stripes and i mean what would you call that design it's almost something a bit retro about it something a bit psychedelic about it yeah um i just i i love it i love the confidence of the design i love the fact that everything from the outside of the box to the design of the individual cards doesn't look like any other game it's even the inside of the box it goes yeah it's friends yeah um i'm sure there are some people who won't like it and some people might not like it in a in a strong way but um they're wrong i think they're wrong as well if they don't i'm sure that i'm sure that's not the case i'm sure the vast vast majority of people are going to love this design but it the most important thing is it's it looks like nothing else on the market it's it really stands alone and and i think it's just extremely striking uh i think there was something very sort of russian about the the the font
and everything it all just i don't know to me it just feels right for a spy type game it looks classy i think and sort of classic um and they're putting this in their after dinner line and we all like to think that our dinners are terribly sophisticated and just the way had he described it push pushing the plates back and then yeah maybe the dark glasses go on and the game comes out and uh this fierce competition begins i i love it i totally buy into that uh vadi was very um i think it was felix actually wasn't it the graphic designer felix um who sort of said he wanted to know the story you know it wasn't enough to just say these are two spies competing over some missions they want to know what's going on and that's where this compromat idea came from you know that these are these aren't just two spies competing they're specifically competing to control information and so that informed then the sort of pictures that he put in for the missions uh you know the the waitress the the you know all these different locations and and and the the the items the drones and the um you know the usb sticks and all this sort of stuff um you know he i think he was he he was very much driven by having you know it's not a deeply thematic game as you've already gathered from the fact we tried out various different themes but but it was important to him as the designer that he that that theme carried all the way through and you see that in the other games actually i think uh the other games in
the um after dinner range captain bluff and omerta both have um stories you know within the game even though the games are relatively simple and um you know and and based on sort of classic uh classic games uh classic sort of public domain games um but developed into these bigger things but they've got a story running through them i thought that was nice yeah i really like another sort of bold decision on the part of helvetique was although they were going for this retro classy stylish graphic design um they're not setting it in the past we're not in the 50s or 60s we've got the latest cutting-edge gadgets we are we are flying drones over each other's territory and we are uh sabotaging computers and so on and i just love that um clash i don't know what you'd call it is it it needs a composite name like cyberpunk or something like this it's it's like um noir tech or something like that maybe i don't know yeah okay great well thanks rob um yeah that's great my pleasure thanks all right okay bye cheers so if you're interested in uh compromise as i said earlier you can play it on tabletopia for free i'm gonna just flag up there's a little bug in that game so if you if you go onto tabletopia and you play it uh tabletopia will sometimes delete your deck of cards in the middle of the game so if that happens to you you don't have
to stop you don't have to stop playing what you have to do is select the area around your deck where the cards have disappeared so drag around that with your mouse and then press the flip button and it'll flip all your cards face up then you can flip them face down again and they'll be back on the table just a little tip because i know some people have hit that bug that's that's a tabletopia bug but you can play the game for free try it out and then the game is available through the helvetique web store it's available in german in french and in english at the moment and it'll be going out to various different distributors and starting to become available in retail stores over the next few months so i hope you found this video interesting i hope you learned a little bit about co-design or maybe you're just interested in the game which is great too but if you enjoyed the video please subscribe to my channel adam's board game wales watch some of my other videos i've got loads of videos about game design and games that i enjoy just chatting about games in general or follow me on twitter boardgamewales or on boardgamegeek i'm adam78 thank you very much for watching all the best