Duel Of Meloch Review: Scythe Vs. Expeditions
Transcript
Hi everyone, I'm Tally. This is Farrell and we're Board of It. And today we're going to be reviewing Jewel of Melo, a head-to-head standalone two-player game in which one player is playing Scythe and the other one is playing Expeditions. Both of these are previously published games by Stonem Games.
Yes. And because this is such a weird little offering, uh it has so many unique elements that we're actually going to set out this review a bit different than our usual ones. and we're gonna break it down into titled sections where we answer questions that we think will be interesting for you to know like who is this game for and what do we think and stuff like that. So, we're going to get into that and before that we're going to say a brief bit about how you play it. But just know that this was a review copy provided by the publisher.
What we're going to do in this section is only cover what's unique to Jewel of Melo. Otherwise, we'd have to explain the rules of two different games as well as this game because one player really is playing Expeditions and the other is playing Scythe. We have a review of Expeditions and a buyer guide for Scythe which explains the how to play for those games. So, we recommend checking those out. Links will be below if you're not sure how to play one or both of those games. So, in Jewel of Melo, you get a new Scythe faction and a new expedition's mech, character, and companion. The board is a hexagonal neoprene map, double-sided so that you get two maps, each with their own different challenges. The hex's will have different terrain types relevant for the scythe player and gather icons relevant for the expeditions player.
Some of the hex's have map markers which act the same for each faction according to their respective games and corruption for the expeditions player. You essentially set up each faction as you normally would for their respective games and one player plays scythe and the other plays expeditions. The twist is is that whilst both sides are trying to achieve stars like normal, you win the game by being the first to claim four stars. On top of that, once a category of achievement has been claimed by a player, it's then blocked off from the other player. So, it limits the options as the game goes on. For example, the expeditions player is tasked with getting three quests, whilst the scythe player would need 10 popularity in order to achieve the same goal.
The goals which you need to complete to get starts are for the most part things you know and love from scythe and expeditions just tone down. So, for example, here you might only need to get three buildings out instead of four in the original Scythe or meld three cards instead of four like in the original expeditions. And the goal board is double-sided so that you can have some variety in your goals. And there are also some new ones here which didn't exist in either of the base games.
In terms of rule changes from the two base games, there is very little. Melo has its own combat cards which have a power value printed on them as well as a when played ability that can be triggered and can also be discarded on your turn to provide a bonus like money. Since combat doesn't exist in expeditions, there's also some new rules about how that goes, mainly around movement and sharing spaces, as well as how the expedition's player can actually trigger combat, which is through vanquishing. Lastly, there are also melo cards, which act as a catchup mechanism, and a player can gain bonuses based on the orientation of these cards each time the other player gains a star.
Primarily, this is going to be a game for fans of expeditions and or scythe. You know, particularly those who maybe struggle to get three plus players to the table or those who would like to see the the time it takes to play brought down it being easier to get to the table to play these games. And in noticeable part is going to be for them because it comes with a new faction for expeditions and a new faction for scythe that can be used in the normal base games of each of those games which I'm sure is exciting for a lot of people like us. And that's not to say that it it isn't for people who have never experienced expeditions or scythe before. And in fact, this might be a good proposition for them too in the sense that maybe you held off because of player count issues and here you can only need two people to play or maybe it might just be more attractive because of the price point which will assumably be a bit cheaper than either of the base games. The difficulty there, if you've never played either of those games, is that this game to play it, it is essentially asking you to learn 2.5 rule books because you need to know pretty much how to play all of Expeditions, all of Scythe, and the rules included in this game. And the thing is, this game only comes with rules for this game. And there's a double-sided help sheet for the expeditions player, for the scythe player that kind of has your your turn to turn, but it's hard because we've come into this game knowing how to play both of them. So, it's hard to say how
well it's going to help someone who's, you know, to learn those games who's never played that game before. Uh, and essentially the rule book just directs you to the Stonem website to videos or the full rule book. So, that's something to consider and might be a barrier for some people having to learn all these rule sets just to play this. Now, who it's not for is for people who didn't like Scythe and or Expeditions. You know, this isn't going to change your opinion unless the only problem you had was that you thought they were too long. Because essentially what you're doing is just playing Scythe and Expeditions, but with a few tweaks.
Jewel of Melo is quite a weird experience. Don't get us wrong. It's a real masterclass of design to allow these two different games to be played simultaneously on the same map, but it does just feel a little bit strange. It's a very tense affair and very interactive with the small map and you've constantly got an eye on what your opponent is doing. It also has a really nice arc as the expeditions player begins the game with full access to the map and is able to zip around very easily. But once the scythe player gets going, they take up more and more space, making the movement far more difficult for the expeditions player and the scythe player would typically have advantage in combat as well.
Now, we did struggle a bit being experienced players of both core games with one particular element and that is the fact that now the winning condition and the only thing you really focus on is the stars. Because the way this works is that the kind of starboard is double-sided and each side will have eight objectives uh for both players. And not all of the classic goals are on one side. They're kind of split in between the two. For example, in Scythe, you would famously get stars for kind of getting all of one thing off your playerboard, upgrades, enlists, [snorts] uh mechs, and buildings. But here that's split into half. So one side of the board you'll get stars for uh enlisting and upgrades. The other half of the board you'll or the other side of the board you'll get stars for deploying mechs and building buildings.
So what that tends to do and this will also happen when a player takes a star that you're going for and kind of makes that element of the game no longer viable to go into because you can't get a star from it. is that you just ignore that part of the game. You're like, if I can't get a star from listing, I'm not going to waste time in listing. Uh, and yeah, same if someone takes that star away from you. And then it feels very weird because you aren't interacting with a core part of the game. And part of the great element of both these games is the way that everything's so masterfully interwoven and you kind of go back and forth and dip in and out of different things and get this rhythm going. Uh, yeah. So, it's just something that we it's a bit strong to say didn't like, but it rubbed us off of the wrong way a little bit that that you do tend to ignore these things. And that's not to say that, you know, you should ignore them or you'll always ignore them. Of course, you might want to enlist anyway because that gets you money or because it gets you a combat card or some popularity or whatever, right? Um, so it's not the case, but it just tends to be that you do fully ignore elements a lot more than you would in either base game. Uh, and that's a little bit of a shame, I would say. Following on from this, we also both really miss the point salad scoring that both of the original games had because what tends to happen here is mid to late game money and resources tend to pile up and uh once that stars out of the way, there's not really any use for them anymore. Uh, and
it's a bit of a shame that that you can't do something clever with them in a sense because once you've got so many, it doesn't really matter if you need to spend one here or there. Now, all of those complaints aside, what the important thing is is that that is the price of admission and we fully accept that without these uh, you know, edges sanded off, this game could not exist in the way it does. It cannot be as tense as it is and it cannot be as interactive and head-to-head as it is because you need to only have eight goals and you need to have them go once someone has claimed them and you need to have this first to four race because it's what makes this a cauldron of tension. It's what makes the game work and you know without it being that way this game could not exist in the way it does. So, it kind of has to be accepted, but you know what you get out of it is this this kind of 30 to 40minute experience. You get to play both games very quickly. You get a lot of the same flavor. So, can't fault it too much. I think it's a bit of a personal opinion just because what we loved about both these games more scythe but it is the fact that with this point solid scoring yes somebody will end a game by getting x number of stars but it doesn't mean that they're the ones who are going to win because there are other ways to score and we always really enjoyed that element and obviously that's not here anymore. It was one of
our favorite parts. So of course we're going to say that we missed that. uh and it's something we preferred. On the other hand, we have to accept that I'm sure there are going to be a lot of people who much prefer the cleanness of this scoring system that first to four stars, then you're done. And you know, that's going to take out a lot of the mess that you have in the base games of all these different elements of scoring and knowing who's winning and knowing what direction is best to go in. Here, you can clearly see and you know where to go and that will definitely be a benefit for a lot of people. Aside from the quibbles that we just mentioned, actually this game does a really great job of giving the feel of both of these base games. And I would argue that Scythe comes out a bit better because it really does feel like onetoone playing original Scythe. But expeditions comes out a little worse because what happens here is that you only have a card marketplace of two cards. So, the options are very limited, the turnover is very low, and because of this lightning quick race to get the stars, you're often not building up card combos. More often than not, you're getting a card and immediately socketing it into your playerboard because you need to score it uh and get stars for it. And one thing that was great in Expeditions, the base game, is is card comboing and having fun with it. and this this really nice decision of when do I stop using this card for its power and when do I socket it into my board so
I can score it and that's not really here anymore which is a bit of a shame in summary Jewel of Milo is a great way to experience both of these games particularly if you want a shorter more interactive experience something is lost in translation from the original games a little bit but that's the price of making this experiment work at all and on the whole it's an acceptable price to pay for what you get. Few games are as tense and as engaging as Julok, and I really look forward to messing around with all the system can do. We'd also really like to actually praise a variety contained in this box with a whole slew of interesting cards for both sides, two maps, both of which are terrific, and two sets of goals to mix things up game to game. So, even if you only own this game, you're going to get a lot of play out of it and a lot of different situations and games.
One of the big selling points of jewel of Melo is that it can be used with all existing content. The new factions can be used in a normal game of scythe or expeditions and the old factions can be used in a game of jewel of Melo. That creates a ridiculous amount of possible combinations if you own everything expeditions and scythe like we do. One thing to note though is that if you do play with the older factions in jewel of Melo, you're likely to encounter some imbalance because of course those older factions were not designed to be played with this game.
For expeditions, we don't think there'll be any problem at all. The characters and the mechs are very neutral. So I think they're always going to fit well into dual melo scythe. there's a little bit more of an issue in the sense that in particular certain mech abilities are going to be totally useless when translated to these maps and on the other hand it can be very I would say in in a game all about efficiency very advantageous or disadvantageous based on the player mat combo with the faction and the kind of starting position I think those are things that you're going to want to consider when when picking the scythe faction to play here. One thing I will say is that I have no doubt because Stonemire is very good at tracking player data that they're going to look at all of the player data and they'll eventually put out some sort of list or post about the best matchups, you know, the most balanced matchups or great matchups and the problem will go away on its own in time. When it comes to components, aside from the factions themselves, everything is mixable and matchable except for the brand new combat cards. Now, this means that the new cards you get like factory cards and counter cards, they can be used in the base games or those respective cards from the base games can be used here, including, you know, the expedition cards. The only thing you need to be aware of is that certain cards just aren't going to work in the context of these maps or vice versa. So,
you just need to kind of discard and redraw when that happens. You know, something in particular to be wary of is uh expedition cards which have numbers for quests which don't exist on this map because it's much smaller, things like that. But otherwise, it it gives you a whole expansive new content to include, you know, backwards compatibility essentially, which is pretty great. Finally, Jewel of Melo contains variants, which will allow you to play Scythe versus Scythe or Expeditions versus Expeditions, and it works exactly like you'd expect, just that you're now all going for kind of the same goals, which are relevant for whichever game you're playing in a sense. And we're delighted to report that both work really well. Um, we had a really great game of Cipher Scythe, very tense, very close. And similarly, Expeditions also works really well, which is not a surprise because Expeditions was great at two players anyway. So, the big benefit of playing Expeditions versus Expeditions here is just that it's much quicker. you obviously, as already said, lose a little bit of that that kind of card comboing. Um, but it's kind of worth it in a sense for how quickly the game plays. And it's also interesting because now combat's involved, uh, which wasn't the case in Expeditions. So, it's also a little bit more spicy, I would argue, as well. So, that was a really great way to play. We're both very impressed with both variants of the
game. Final thoughts, I really enjoyed Julok. I think it's a very strange game for all the reasons we've described, but I also think it's a great game. Uh it allows you to do a lot with the kind of base of it and if you have both original games, you know, there's so much variety that can go into this, it makes these games easier to play. Now, we do think some elements are shaved off that experience, but that's kind of the price of admission. Uh and the other thing is that some of the things that we don't like, people might like more. Yeah.
So, it just depends what you're looking for. But definitely recommend it if you're interested, if you like both these games or you do think.
Yeah, I agree with you. I enjoyed playing it. I was just finding myself every other minute like this is so strange.
Yeah.
And there were things I didn't particularly like about it sometimes like sometimes one player would really go ahead because of circumstances. That's what I kind of felt like a little bit. But then at the same time, it's just not that deep. It's just a quick little jewel game that you can play
in half the time or less of a normal game of one of these. So,
it doesn't bother me that much. I just found myself noticing it and sometimes getting a bit of frustration about the way that it works with kind of the way that you claim the goals and it maybe seems sometimes easier for one player versus the other.
But I also really enjoyed playing it. So,
yeah, I think
is what it is. Not that deep. It's a good point that you bring up because we haven't talked about that there is sometimes a negative element to this where with the originals and you have this point solid scoring it can be anyone's game whereas here
sometimes people will steam ahead
and then it is this semi- negative experience when it's only about the stars of you being quite far back
and then you can be like well what's the point of playing anymore like I might as well concede
and that's something we haven't mentioned I think sometimes you know there's There's one game where I think you got two stars and then I went from like zero to four before you'd got any more. So, it does swing. But then on the other hand, there's a game we had where I was the expedition's character and I just steamrolled it in 20 minutes like through a bit of Yeah. luck and
kind of very quick tactical acumen and all this stuff, right? Uh and then obviously that's not a great experience for you to just like not even get a star out.
Yeah, exactly. And I think yeah cuz I was a size player obviously with size sometimes it is about building the engine and getting things going and then sometimes it can feel a bit pointless in a way because you've kind of gone ahead before I even got a chance to get going in a way
and obviously typically with scythe things are still uh useful but here because of the limited goals that you have and things not multiplying at the end some stuff just becomes not useful or kind of pointless in the end.
Yeah. But that said, I enjoyed every game that we played.
Yeah. And I think we've had some great games as well. I think particularly when we did the variants of, you know, Scythe versus Scythe or whatever. I think those both came out really well as well. So, it's a great way to play these games two player. Um, that particularly in the way of scythe you couldn't already.
So, this was our review of Jula Melo Expeditions for Scythe. We hope you enjoyed it. We hope it was helpful. If you have any questions, please ask us. And thanks for watching.