Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 15:14

thank you hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson for Beyond Solitaire and today I'm going to be reviewing endurance designed by Annabelle Holland alright so here's a basic setup for endurance this is a solitaire game from Holland Spiel that is about the Shackleton Expedition this is an expedition that attempted to reach Antarctica it did not go well the ship ends up stuck the men end up stuck for months and months and months until they actually managed to send out a Lifeboat that gets them help but really the fact that all these men survived this extremely long months and months long experience and did not die is a miracle and this game is really supposed to evoke that not by letting you achieve what the Shackleton Expedition achieved but by being so brutal that it illustrates how difficult that must have been and so this is a game that is basically about having limited resources that degrade over time and having morale that also starts to degrade over time and then you know essentially you're going to lose a bunch of people most likely one thing that's kind of interesting about this game is it does not have a win condition does not have a lost condition you just do how you do and you see how your Expedition turns out frankly every time you lose someone you're going to feel like you've lost something but there is no official win-loss condition for this game which I think is quite interesting but this game is going to go through several phases that mirror the progress of the Shackleton Expedition so you're going to start out with the endurance which was

their ship and therefore the title of the game um set up with some supplies on it but it's stuck in the ice the ship is eventually gonna sink and there's an event card in your deck that is going to bring that event about but for a while you have the ability to go and get supplies from here you've also got these groups of men some of them are doing okay on their blue side some of them are demoralized on their red side they can go from demoralized to sick and from sick to dead depending on the progress of the game your Camp is also going to change in kind of a mirror of what happens on the actual Expedition so you get your guys in their starting State you get your supplies there's a space for an active event and there are a combination of different card types that are in your decks so this is my draw deck this is just a discard pile that has some events in it by the way and then you've got an event deck and these events are wild so you're going to have things like malnutrition sea leopard attack true words said ingest but basically you make jokes that make you upset uh broken ice surgery you know there's some really serious stuff that goes on in these events and those aren't even the worst ones we'll talk about that in a moment so basically you're going through your deck and just trying to keep going through the progress of the game so on your first turns and things get worse

later by the way you draw two cards and you choose one card for its action and then one card for its test so actions involve hunting so that's why you've got these little penguins there wasn't much else to hunt but you could go hunt Penguins you could sled which means that you take your dogs over to the endurance and try to get supplies off of it but your dogs aren't going to last we're going to talk about that or you can entertain and so there are some supplies in here like a deck of cards a book a phonograph that bring entertainment and joy to the men and let you flip them from their demoralized to their better blue side and that's going to matter partially because you can lose by being demoralized and partially because these die rolls on here determine the dye values you're going to need in order to successfully test during these actions so when you take an action you don't automatically succeed you have to roll dice against these values and count up your successes and see how many of them you have and therefore how well you did on your mission if you succeed you get a reward maybe it's food you know it's to flip somebody back over from their demoralized side it's to get supplies from the endurance in some quantity so if you roll enough successes you succeed if you fail it's going to cause problems partially because you need the stuff and partially because it's just a bummer you also have tests so you do one card for its action you do another for the test so tests include food tests so you have to be able to feed yourself tests can include a morale test where you see how

well everybody is doing emotionally you have heat tests where you better have some blubber to keep yourself warm and you also have medical tests where somebody has gotten sick and you're going to have to see what supplies you have to help them out and these tests can be passed with just flipping men over to the demoralized side but you really don't want to do that what you prefer to have is supplies so these are the supplies that you can use and of course you can supplement from the endurance at first anyway but every time you use these supplies you have to roll to see if those supplies degrade and then if the supply is degrade you're going to have to see if they get discarded on future rolls so your supplies are also not going to last you and you don't really know how long they're going to last because you're going to need some die rolls to help you with that and then if you fail your test you have to take the penalty which is to bring down the morale of the men who are on the card so if we failed a morale test we would have to resolve penalties for number 24 and number 26 and the numbers correspond to chits up here so that's just the first round of the game um eventually you're gonna have to draw three cards instead of two and then in addition to the penalty for failing a test you're gonna have to resolve one penalty from one of the cards so you just keep getting punished and punished and punished as you go there's also eventually going to be a phase if you make it that far where you're meditating lifeboats to a new location and essentially gonna have to bring out these lifeboats cards that have different die roll combos that you're going to have to get and pass basically

the test on these cards in order to get the lifeboats across so even if you've made it pretty far into the game the odds that you're going to lose at least one Lifeboat are pretty big so that's tough and then on top of that this game asks you to make some hard choices including literally an event card called the hard choice so this one makes you remove all of your dogs and Mrs Chippy the cat who actually is a boy but was named Mrs chippy before everybody knew that um so you gain meat but you have to demoralize a bunch of people because you killed all the animals so this is something the actual Shackleton Expedition did everybody had to do this including chippy who was Mrs chippy's owner who never ever got over it and frankly neither would I but basically when you've gotten all everything from the endurance that you're gonna get and the dogs are no longer useful the question is do you eat your dogs and do you kill the cat and intelligently speaking in terms of survival the answer is yes but emotionally the choice is horrible and instead of just make it happen automatically the way that Shackleton ordered on his expedition Emma Bill Holland lets you make that choice as part of this game so endurance is essentially a game that is a huge bummer all the way through because you are constantly failing tests worrying about your supplies having to kill your dogs having deal with people who are demoralized having bad things happen like malnutrition this game is rough and all the rough stuff that's in

the game is in fact based on real historical events so all the cards that Annabelle has included in this game all the chits all the resources all of it are tied to actual accounts of the Shackleton Expedition so as you're sitting here worried about how you're going to do you have to sit there and think about the fact that some people actually lived through this and survived which is part of what makes the game interesting so now you have a basic overview of what's in here and of play why don't we go ahead and have some final thoughts about that because yes this game is a bit of a bummer especially if things don't go well but I don't think that that means that you shouldn't play it so let's have a conversation about that all right so now for some final thoughts I mentioned this game is a bummer but I also said that doesn't mean I think you shouldn't play it so what do I mean by that I mean that endurance is one of those games that is an art piece I think so what endurance is trying to do is create an experience to really evoke something and I think that all of the game's decisions are directed towards that and a lot of the more gamey elements like winning and losing are removed and that doesn't mean that this doesn't play like a game endurance in fact does play well enough as a game to be enjoyable that way while you play it so thinking about how to allocate resources thinking about which test to pass trying to get your stuff from the endurance trying to figure out how to portion out the dice when you're doing your um your Lifeboat run all those things absolutely work together exactly the way the traditional

board game does so endurance is not so far off the path that a normal person who plays games could not play and enjoy it that said the game mechanisms that it uses are employed for something that you don't see in a lot of games which is pure evocation of experience as opposed to winning and losing which of course are not even present in this game NFL Holland decided to design this without a win condition without a lost condition and that means that this is a game fully as experience as opposed to game as game if you believe that it's only a game if you can win or lose and so I think that maybe this isn't something that you're gonna play a whole lot because it's not like you can exactly have a high score and you know once you've seen all the cards and experience that spare enough times I think maybe this isn't a game that you play a lot it's not going to be your favorite game that you played 100 times in a row it might be a game that you can't bring yourself to get rid of a game that you pull out every few years a game that makes you go read a book about the topic of the game that's the kind of game that this is and so if that's what you're looking for then you're gonna love endurance but if what you want is just a traditional game straight up then this may not be for you if you're open to an experience or you're curious I actually think endurance is very much worth a try that's it I really love the way that everything this game is inspired by and threaded with history the flavor text in this one is actually great and I really enjoyed reading the event

cards even though they did terrible things to me because they kind of explain why things are done the way they're done uh I loved looking through the rule book and getting little details about who Mrs chippy was and you know which crew members were mutinous and how people felt about the photographer but they were also wanting to listen to his lectures to keep them entertained how you know the depression that people who went hunting felt when they had to kill Penguins affected their morale because penguins are apparently super sweet and don't know to be afraid of humans and it was really emotionally awful to hunt them those things all come into this game and as you learn about the Shackleton Expedition through Annabelle's eyes as she teaches it to you through her rule book through her events through her flavor text I really feel like it creates an experience where you really understand why shackleton's Expedition is so remarkable and you know you really get to feel for the little chits on the board because you know you can't help but become attached once you've seen enough pictures of these people you know the cards use real pictures from the photographer on the Expedition um from learning little stories about them and what they like to do what kind of jokes they like to tell you know it really makes the game emotionally gutting in a way that not all games are actually able to achieve achieve and so for that this game deserves huge and I think that Emma Bell's decisions about this come out the most strongly uh when you play the event card the hard choice

and that's the one where you have to decide if you're going to kill the animals so it's interesting you know Annabelle herself emotionally has to process what's happening in this game and you can tell because she allows you to try to keep your dogs to put them on a Lifeboat even though by the time the actual Lifeboat sequence would have happened historically the dogs had long been dead had long been eaten there was no room for these dogs on these lifeboats but she admits her sense of mentality and allows you to try to keep the dogs because that's a lot I think that's a lot about her as a person I think our desire to do that says a lot about us as people who are able to feel empathy into you know get attached to animals even if it's just like a little piece of cardboard and I also just love her allowing her sentimentality to come out in this particular way and especially because I often do make the hard Choice when I play it I feel crappy every time I do and I also think that this game is touching because it's about playing against really really hard odds and how miraculous it is that the Shackleton Expedition made it and Emma ball herself does describe it as a miracle so I'll quote from her rule book so she says the crew of the endurance suffered through disaster piled atop disaster any single one of which might have perhaps should have resulted in their deaths their survival was indeed a miracle an impossible unbelievable thing this game reflects that it positions the historical result as a fluke it evokes

the miracle not through Recreation but absence and so that is what I really love about Annabelle's games in general and endurance in particular it's not a game that you play to try to beat your high score the game that you play in order to experience and to learn and to have an emotional response it is game as art it is game as statement about both history and life and if that is the kind of game that you're into which if you watch this channel you know I absolutely am then endurance is a game for you and if it's not that is fine don't buy it though uh and if you're curious then I actually recommend giving this one a try I found it tremendously evocative that is endurance from Emma Bell Holland thank you so much for watching this review uh please like subscribe comment ask questions uh keep on patreon if you're feeling generous and most of all

Progress saved