Algeria in Flames | Designer Interview
Transcript
hey gamers this is liz davidson from beyond solitaire and i'm super excited to be here with you uh and with callie mcfaul he's a professor at newman university and he is the designer of a game called algeria in flames so how you doing on fire today i'm great i had a great play test this morning i'm excited about all the ideas i heard at the game development conference and i'm looking forward to talking absolutely i played this game so i will be able to comment on my experience soon but why don't you give everybody the rundown of your game and what it was like what's that sure so the game is about the conflict in algeria over whether algeria should be independent or part of france and it um it starts in 1958 after the um a session of charles de gaulle to power and it plays out over the next two or three years uh with the algerian movement for independence and the french government and citizens in both france and algeria trying to figure out how best to make their case and how best to lay claim on what they believe is their their right to the land so i know a few things about this but what kind of range of options for actions did players have in this game what was the array of of mechanisms that you wanted so players so so this is a turn-based game and in every turn they they select from a menu of possible options uh some of those options are diplomatic which can range everything from uh formally declaring independence to lobbying the united nations some of them are military so military offensives some of them are less traditional so they can
use extraordinary measures to try and get information from insurgents or use terrorism as a way of influencing public opinion so there's a broader range of choices yes and terrorism was in fact an option for me i played a very conservative man named joey ortiz who wanted to keep algeria french at by any means necessary mostly fortunately for me this consisted of a propaganda campaign where i made a bunch of memes they were very rude uh but i was probably about 20 minutes of gameplay away from becoming a terrorist and this was a very uncomfortable position for me um you know obviously i'm not gonna be like yeah colonialism this is great and it was also clearly uncomfortable for other people in the room to kind of dance that line so how do you help your students participate in these games in a way that's meaningful and true to form without being kind of gross yeah so this game is is maybe a more extreme example of the challenge that many of these games face right by asking you to by by putting students in a situation in which they are uncomfortable ethically or intellectually you're asking them to step outside of themselves right and so there's no perfect answer to that um but there are things set of things i think you can do as a game designer to help alleviate that one of them is distinctive to reacting which is which is creating a kind of community of trust within the students well before you ever start the game right you're trying to create
an atmosphere in which people feel safe inhabiting a different self and in saying things they would never say themselves and i think that's hard but necessary i know not all of the uh viewers or listeners are teachers but many of you might be my suspicion is especially if you're a high school a college instructor you were never really taught to do this this is not something you learn in a phd program but it is a key part of being a good teacher and it's a key part of making these games work right so you establish a safe space you establish ground rules there are things that we will not say and there are kinds of behaviors we will not practice recognizing that they existed in real life but we are simply going to say they are too dangerous for the classroom and we all agree collectively that we will not do them um while we did not do this this morning in the background for people who are are watching is that this conference is a place to push boundaries so you can figure out where the boundaries should be in a classroom in a classroom i would have established a set of safe signs or safe words right so a common one and i stole this from a colleague michelle ferguson who probably got it from somewhere else is whenever you are saying making a claim or using words that you personally would be uncomfortable you just hold your fingers like this so everybody knows that's your character saying he's not your role and you create this kind of space
the challenge i i would say one more thing which is to give students and i don't know that you saw this but in many roles i specifically say this is a hard role if you feel that you cannot ethically participate in the game in this way please tell the instructor and we will find a way right to accommodate that with another role or another responsibility the last thing i'll say quickly is all of these can go wrong right and so it is incumbent on the instructor to be alert yeah and to be connected and to understand from the expressions on people's faces or the way they withdraw suddenly that something is wrong and be ready to step in and give people a space to recover right so i think you know this was really fun for us but you're really in the hot seat during these playtests so so for all of y'all out there we basically played his game for several hours and then he had to sit there quietly while we told him everything that we thought about his game good and bad so what did you learn from this play test that was useful for you and what might have been hard to hear and like what what are some challenges that are ahead for you um so so there's so let me step back and say as one of the hardest things as a designer for me is to recognize that i tried my best and somebody else had a better idea and that's just a matter of
structuring feedback and for me just a reminder that i'm not talking i'm not defending my ideas that's not going to benefit me my job here is to listen not that i automatically integrate everything somebody said but that at least i recognize that there are other people with good ideas and collaboration is a good thing from this particular play test i got a number of very specific suggestions that are specific to the game but the most challenging kind of feedback had to do with concerns about the structure of the game so what you don't know is that this game is uh structured in a way that each side of the game are in separate spaces and they don't interact and that is both the virtue of the game it challenges students in a unique kind of way but it also is a problem because it's very difficult for students to this is a classroom game to really understand the other side when they were not part of that discussion and the challenge going forward is in fact to figure out a way that we can preserve the advantages of that separation while ensuring that they they come to an understanding of both sides in the debate right so is this your how many reacting games have you designed to date and what other topics have you chosen to represent yeah so so this is my fifth uh i've written one myself uh called the needs of others on the un decision about whether to intervene in what in the game is perceived as violence in rwanda and
whether to decide whether it's genocide along with abby perkis i've written a game called changing the game which is about title ix set in a composite fictional u.s university in the 1990s where people try and wrestle with the fact that women are underrepresented in sports uh with abby and then becca livingston i've written a game on the debate about the vietnam veterans memorial and then went with becca again about the treaty of versailles this one actually has the most similarities with the rwanda game they're both about fundamental questions about what role in what ways and times are violence an acceptable kind of strategy in human affairs are there ways in which you are required to care for your neighbor yeah and when are you not and when are the expectations that you you care for your neighbor override other kind of norms about when violence is acceptable man that's a rough topic i have i at my university and when i talk to prospective students i they ask me what i do and i say well i study mass violence and i say compare i teach comparative genocide and they just look kind of puzzled and i just let it rest a beat and they say it's not a lab class don't worry so what makes reacting to the past a particularly worthwhile vehicle for exploring these
issues in the classroom because it seems like it'd be really easy to just kind of sterilize it or like present the information what makes reacting a cut above for this even though it's hard so so let me first acknowledge that there are a lot of ways you can use games and games based learning to engage students what reacting is especially good at is challenging students to deeply immerse themselves in the material to wrestle with really difficult ideas and to learn how to empathize right in my mind that's the greatest advantage of reacting is that by putting yourself into somebody else's shoes you are developing a skill that will help you as in my case as a historian but more broadly as a student but also you're practicing a skill that's going to be necessary in the rest of your life right you will use the skill of empathy in business in your family at your wherever you might be um and that's something reacting does very well so i have a frivolous question for you so you revealed an important personal detail which is that in high school oh you were a war gamer i am and i'm you're in great company on this channel yes we are proud of wargaming here on beyond solitaire what was your favorite game of that time so i was in high school in the 80s so i was an avalon hill child and so squad leader was the one i played often i was in a small town where there was not many people who to play with so i did a lot of i guess i would say solitaire gaming and i the biggest challenge to my gaming life at that time was when i would get
up to get a a water or a pop or something and the cat would stroll by and all of a sudden my nice tidy battlefield would be strewn across the room an internal problem yes indeed so do you feel that your interest in wargaming um has a relationship with your pedagogical choices for reacting or those connected parts of your life and your your mind that's a really good question i think so yes in the sense that i draw on design elements and mechanics and aesthetics that i have encountered in other places and so here we say wargaming but there's lots of ways all kinds of gaming does that um and here i am a child of the 80s when in my sense wargaming's often glorified conflict in a way that i'm not really in that community right now but my senses it probably does not as much and that i have tried to recognize move past while acknowledging like i said i want to integrate i want to learn from it but i want to embed it in a kind of ethics that's appropriate for the 2020s not the 1980s that makes a lot of sense and so and this is a short interview we can probably go on about this oh i'm sure but if people wanted to find you ask questions see what you're up to where can you be found online well i can be
googled of course but i teach at newman university and i'm happy to answer emails um sadly i do not do twitter i know it's a sad world we're in um and so email is probably the best but i will say i i have my own podcast new books and genocide studies and that's part of a family of podcasts that looks at academic books and tries to to help ordinary people have access to the learning and the knowledge and the research academics do without necessarily reading 700 pages of academic prose okay that's fair uh but i will put a link to this podcast in the show notes excellent absolutely and for those of you who are watching this channel hopefully you know i can be found anywhere as beyond solitaire but thank you so much for kelly for giving some of your time thanks for having me it was fun so like comment subscribe ask questions most of all everybody happy gaming
you