Skip to main content
Loading video...

Brindlewood Bay RPG Review: The Murder She Wrote RPG

Transcript 19:12

hello everyone I'm am tally this is farell and we are Bor of it and Welcome to our very first tabletop RPG review and we're going to be talking about the absolute Delight that is brindlewood Bay where you play as elderly ladies in their Golden Years solving a bunch of gruesome murders as they should as they should now we are genuinely excited to talk about this because of how much fun and laughs we've had with it along the way and longer term viewers of the channel may remember this sneaking into my top 10 games of 2022 so this is an RPG review and as such we're going to try and format it a little differently than our usual board game reviews because we want to frame it in terms of questions that you should have answered when you're looking at getting an RPG so what is brindle Wood Bay how does it play mechanically how complex is it to run as a games master how complex is it for the players to play play and of course how does it feel to play What's good about it so we're going to go into all of that but first please note that we initially backed the brindlewood bay Kickstarter uh for PDFs of both of these books way back when it was on Kickstarter and we've been playing it for about two years and all of our thoughts and opinions were formed during that time but we did recently collaborate with the publisher Who provided us these books

just to show off and so we can take some nice b-roll of them so just be aware of that starting with the what Brenda W is a fairly simple RPG as they go with a very striking theme you roleplay as the murder mavens a book club of elderly women who roam around the small New England town of brindlewood bay solving one- shot murders Al Jane Marple Rosemary and time or Murder She Wrote however there's a Sinister undercurrent of eldrich horror in brindlewood Bay which soon bleeds into the Cozy and warming atmosphere that the town initially provides each session is a self-contained mystery with an Ecentric cast of characters and memorable locations where the mavens will have to put their skills to the

test each session of brinda woodbay is a more or less selfcontained mystery with a Snappy title all hallow screen dad overboard and of course Jingle Bell shock players are going to begin the session by narrating the intro to this episode they'll describe a little Vig yet of what their character is up to what they're doing and then this will lead into the scenario proper where the mavens will either be having a nice relaxing time and are approached by law enforcement to help solve a crime or they will be be out and about at a social engagement and of course murder occurs as just so always happens around these ladies then they will be called into action brindlewood Bay uses the powered by the apocalypse system a fairly straightforward rule set that is based off rolling to D6 Dice and summing the numbers then you'll add or subtract any modifiers from your character and your skills giving you a final result now this result is in Brack Ed into a number of different levels so six or below is a fail uh of whatever you're trying to do 7 to9 is a success but there'll be a complication 10 to 11 is straightforward success you do what you aiming to do a 12 or more that is a special success if you will and you'll get an added bonus or something extra will happen the goal

of a session is to of course solve the mystery which the mavens will do by using this system to investigate by talking to suspects and unearthing information as well as searching the locals they're in for Clues hidden around the environment now this is much more of a conversational and collaborative experience between the keeper who is the GM and the mavens themselves than many other RPGs because there is no set mystery the keep doesn't design one solution rather they just throw out Clues from a pre-selected list or of course create their own based on the situation at hand and it is the players and the mavens who decide what do these clues mean they talk about it they theorize and they make it fit together when the players are ready to solve the mystery they will do a theorized action here they will have a free willing discussion with both themselves and the keeper trying to explain all of the clues they've discovered and how will fit together in the mystery and how it points to one suspect or solution then when everyone is happy that they've manage to explain everything they can they will roll and from this role the complexity of the mystery will be subtracted but the number of Clues they have discovered and incorporated into their explanation will be added back on then if it's a success the

keeper will provide them with a way to confront capture arrest the suspect that they believe did it and if they fail then something dramatic will happen maybe that suspect will turn up dead who they just accuse but the mavens will always have another opportunity to basically come up with another solution and do another theorize

role well when it comes to running brindlewood Bay as the keeper which is what the GM has known as I'm delighted to say that brindlewood bay is a perfect starter RPG for people looking to run RPGs the powered by the apocalypse system is wonderfully simple and straightforward and the skills that the mavens are using are very broad so it's very easy to understand when they should be used and you and the players don't have to get bogged down in all the different micro skill sets that come with some RPGs brinder Wood Bay is wonderful in the tips and tools it provides to the keeper making running the game an absolute breeze hopefully there are multiple sections of tips for the keeper and they're divided into basic and Advance which means that you can decide how deep you want to go into that and how much you want to take on board before running a scenario and what really makes this easy for Keepers is the Mysteries themselves which are fully fleshed out with lots of interesting sharp ideas that they kind of jump off the page with really minimal effort from the keeper and this is thanks to all the wonderful descriptions which are kept simple but vibrant enough that with a few little bits of information they kind of jump into you and the players minds and let them really see what the scenario or the mystery is you've got colorful suspects

you've got interesting locations gripping Mysteries there are a lot of prompts for the keeper to ask the maven moments to sprinkle within your scenario and a whole host of other things all contained within a few pages the key element of brindle woodbay which alleviates stress and preparation time from The Keeper is the fact that the Mysteries do not have a single solution because the mavens decide what the clues mean amongst themselves the pressure is off the keeper because you don't have to design design a mystery with a single right solution and hope that the clues you have sprinkled around will direct the mavens in that way instead the whole thing can be freewheeling and adaptive and when mavens discover a clue you can just look down the long list provided and give them a clue that's perfect for that moment and that situation it means there's no frustration there's not a lot of time spent preparation and this is all great stuff for the keeper brindlewood Bay was actually the first RPG I played which had a GM and also the first RPG that I GMD and I have to say it was extremely painless to run and it actually was very simple with this system to make it look like I knew what I was doing and something I really appreciate in brindlewood Bay is the fact that they have a section of the book for scenario one where it kind of takes you through everything to do in terms of laying out the mystery the

characters the preparation what you do with the players what you tell them when you tell them it was really great in facilitating that first session they also have a similar section for how to continue the campaign and what to do during each future session which highly highly appreciated to keep things on track one final thing I really appreciated as a keeper is all the guidance provided on the dark conspiracy the eldrich undertone and kind of campaign centerpiece which links the Mysteries together and gives you an overarching enemy throughout the campaign it's a lot of information in the book but it's all provided in a very clear and understandable way and what's particularly great about the way this uh impacts in your campaign is it's gradually you start out with very small elements of it until you're having an epic final showdown and that kind of allows it to not overwhelm the players or the

keeper similar to running brindle with Bay playing it is also a dudle even more so because you don't have to plan anything creating your character is straightforward and simple as the character sheets have pre-filled suggestions on name style and hobby which you can use and still end up with some pretty unique characters or of course you can go off on your own Road and create your own from scratch with a few simple inputs it's really easy to grasp the core attributes of your character and jump right into role playing them it also helps that the afor mentioned powered by the apocalypse system is straightforward making it really easy for players to understand what their roles mean and their chances of success the reference sheets are also clear and instructive the moves are Broad and logical again making it very easy for players to understand when they can and should be used now there are a number of different options that players can use throughout the game and some different elements to keep track of for example each Maven has a unique power which can be used once per mystery and is based on a pop culture character it could be that they need to keep track of negative conditions some items that they have in their cozy Place remembering to use crown moves which is where a player has to tell the group more about their character in order to improve their role or deciding as a group to use the Gold Crown mystery move which gets a top tier success progression in the game is tied

to completing certain tasks in the session and you have to remember to actively do these which can sometimes get a bit lost in the excitement and drama of the mystery in short there is a fair amount for the mavens to consider which is really great from a gameplay perspective because it will allow for some really cool situations and scenarios but if you have less experienced players it might take them a few sessions to internalize it all and figure out how to best use all of those abilities if you have experienced RPG players then we don't think you'll have any issues here as most RPGs have more for the players to consider than this one generally though momentto moment gameplay is simple search for Clues and speak to people so I that really helps facilitate a session is the fact that almost everybody has some kind of knowledge of the TV shows or movies this RPG creates and the characters within them so people seem to inherently know how to bring their characters to life and go about solving a murder mystery with minimal support or research players can instantly jump into character know who they are know how to act which creates great fun for everyone around the table

despite being about murder and eldrich horror brinda Wood Bay is surprisingly light-hearted the characters the mavens meet along the way are eccentric cliches and bombastic caricatures providing an undercurrent a of humor this is further supported by the fact that the players themselves are role-playing elderly book club members a rather cozy starting point sessions tend to have a great Arc starting off light and Breezy and ramping up in tension and Drug drama with every new suspect you speak to and clue by clue until you reach the crescendo of confronting the murderer and depending on the theorized role can turn into an action-packed finale the game has a lot of aha moments as you discover new clues or the mavens get a shock as a suspect they were closing in on is found murdered brindlewood Bay is also reasonably low stakes at least in the first few sessions because of the tools at the disposal of the keeper and the player that can be used to negate danger such as the Golden Crown move or using a crown it's a really smooth design move to link negating a bad role with discovering more about the person that you're playing as it's also really nice that the mavens have a unique Maven move which adds some asymmetry and allows the mavens to create some cool moments it's a nice straightforward RPG because players are familiar with the concept of a murder mystery so have inherent knowledge about how to proceed

and how to act because there are so few skills and rules that need to be remembered the main focus really becomes the conversation and the collective creativity of the players and the keeper that said there's nothing quite like dropping your first void clue on your players some sort of horrific unexplained event and watching them go WTF because they have no idea what's going on the dark conspiracy is a really nice way to build the campaign whilst keeping the core rule set because it slowly encroaches but whilst it is a core part of the game if you did want to ignore it completely and instead run a series of loosely connected one shots then you totally could the one big negative of brindle with Bain is going to come down to your taste and what you're looking for and it's which means it's only a negative for particular people and that is it's in some ways a very vanilla RPG you know it's very rules like it's ational it's not going to be exciting rounds of combat there's not unique World building there's not unique skills and classes and locals it's very real and down toe except for the elich elements and as a keeper a lot of people might Ru the lack of control they have over a scenario and the players might not like the fact that all they're doing is kind of wandering around talking to people and investigating and obviously the lack of skills at their dispos all but that is going to be for you to decide what you

want out of an RPG before we get on to our final thoughts just wanted to touch upon nephews and Peril the uh supplemental book to the core of brindlewood bay this is almost a necessity if you're looking to run the full campaign as the core book contains six Mysteries but a campaign is recommended Ed to be about 12 Mysteries or 12 sessions so unless you are much more creative than I am this will be your best friend in creating that as it is almost entirely full of mysteries written by a number of different authors of different kind of Vibes and varieties and they nicely mix between ones that you can put earlier in your campaign and ones which could or should lean into the dark conspiracy and the eldrich horror there are also a number of mysteries which are sweep sweep Mysteries and these are recommended to be played as maybe a ones shot or post campaign or even as a side session when you're getting towards the end of your campaign and they lean a bit more into the weird and paranormal in different ways than the general eldrich horror of brender Wood Bay finally there are a few little bits for the keeper there's some information on fleshing out the town of brendwood bay with characters and locations there's tips on how to run different elements of the campaign and

different game mechanisms so all in all it's really recommended if you think you're going to go all the way and have a big campaign in Brenda Wood Bay final thoughts brinda Wood Bay is something we fully recommend if you've liked what we've said if you're looking for a uh to get into the RPG world and you want something that's simple to run and simple to play but provides a lot of great experiences I mean there's nothing that I played that I'd recommend more than this for those criteria and particularly if you just love the theme of a good murder mystery and elderly lady solving crimes yeah exactly I think we said at the top of the review this made it into my top 10 of 2022 and that's a big kind of recommendation that still stands and it really is is such great from from the moment that you start creating your character as a player and then developing them and letting them kind of shine through in the different situations the game really facilitates just all around good time for everyone I think so yeah we really really have enjoyed it and we'll do so more in the future yes looking forward to playing it some more and with that that was our review of brindlewood bit if you have any questions please ask us and we just appreciate you watching we hope it was helpful and we will see you next time and we'll definitely have some more RPG

reviews coming in the future so watch out for that thanks a lot bye see you

Progress saved