Bruxelles 1897 Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at brussels 1897 which is a small box card game designed by etienne esperaman and published by geek attitude games this one accommodates two to four players and takes 45 to 19 minutes to play now despite the small box here this game is actually surprisingly more involved than you might think at first glance um and it's actually kind of a a card game version of a game with the same name called brussels 1893 which at the time of this recording is actually out of print so um i've not been able to play this once that one so this game is going to be or this review is going to be purely based on this card game with no comparisons to the original so the board is going to look like this or the table's going to look like this because as i said this is a card based game so everything is pretty much um based on cards here and the setup is going to look like this it's going to vary slightly depending on that player count so you've got the kind of communal board here which is just a round tracker your score points marker and you've got these three tracks here so you've got this architecture track you've got this crown track and you've also got the shield track and i'll obviously explain the relevance of those tracks a bit later you've got four different decks of cards here which correspond to the setup for each round and this is done semi-randomly so i think you're going to draw three cards of each type you're going to give them a shuffle and you're going to make this little tableau of cards um so in a three-player game which i've got set up here you're going to have three rows of four these cards at the top here are always going to be available to use um so those don't change and you've also got these
four colored cards at the bottom here which is important in terms of area majorities or area control and which will give you a kind of fallout bonus if you happen to have the most of your color in any of these particular columns and there's also going to be a stack of money cards which are double-sided so one side you've got ones the other side you've got threes and that's basically just in kind of proxy of coins and each play is going to start with one of these um george brookman cards which can be used to get money and i suppose the actual workers are using this game because i would say this is semi-a a worker placement game are going to be in the form of cards and everyone's going to have an identical set to start with and again these are double-sided so you've got three on one side and so on you know these are all different depending on what you want to spend because once you use those cards you're going to have to spend that amount of money but let's explain how the game actually plays so of course the objective of the game is to get as many points as you can and you're going to do that by placing your cards out on this um tableau of cards and replacing ones with your own so you've got different types of cards here you've got these nobles you've got these kind of art artifacts here you've got buildings and you also have this xm exhibition card which will it might or might not come out during the round you've got these resource cards um and i think that's pretty much it so let's talk about how the game actually works so first off you're gonna or in player order you're gonna take one of your cards and you're going to replace it with one of the existing ones here you're going to you're going to swap that card over so let's just say i really wanted these materials
i will take that card leave it leave my own one there and then add that to my kind of tableau in front of me are ready to be spent later i'm hoping whenever i place those i'm going to have to instantly spend that equal amount of coin so again this yellow player is going to have to pay this one back to the bank and because they've spent that one um and also they could have used the other side and spent that three and you might think why don't you always spend the lower value and that's because not only are you trying to collect the cards themselves you're also trying to have the majority in these columns and in terms of the coin value so let's just say this yellow player had this one let's say the blue player had had this one here like so and let's see the red player really wanted that majority so they spent the four on this particular card here um so as you can see here the majority here is the red because they've got four to these two players um ones and they're going to get this bonus at the end of the round which would be to go up the corresponding track so they'll go up the crown track because they've got the majority in that particular column this one would go up the architecture track this one would go up the shield track and this one here would actually free a card from prison because at the start of the game you're going to start with some cards in prison and you can actually lose further cards and throughout the game um if you take a particular path and you'll get those back in your hand to give you more options in the future round so that's a really good way to give you more um give you more actions during your actual turn but let's talk about what the actual cards do so you've got the resource cards which i picked up earlier like these ones and
there are three different types of resources you've got wood you've got metal and you've also got this stone i suppose and when you collect those you're basically going to be using them to build these buildings so you can see here they've got building cards and you cannot take building cards unless you have the materials to build them so the first building you build is going to cost you one resource the second building is going to cost you two resources a third three resources and so on and it doesn't really matter what these resources are however the number of different resources you use to build that building is going to give you a point so say my first building let's say i built my third building and i had this card here and you know let's say i just have this card here because i've got one two three different types of resources then that particular player would get three victory points the artifacts here can be picked up um without any restrictions whatsoever and then in future rounds you can use just trade them in for money cards um which again should have been shuffled into the um card the deck and they could have been uh available on the on the display and you can trade these artifacts in to get more money additionally if you have the exhibition card um you could start an exhibition and then every player who's got artifacts can choose to play them um in a kind of a round robin turn um and not duplicating colors so let's say the player one has this colored card and the player two has a green one player three has a red one you can keep playing them until until you can't play anymore um of duplicate colors and then you get i think it's two points for each card you play so it's another way to get points
and money and that's why those art pieces are really good you can additionally pick up these noble cards and these will give you two options either to use it straight away for its ability so in this case um this charles bull's card would let me move up the shield track and but also you could choose to keep hold of that card to use in future rounds you know i'd put it with my other my other noble cards and that means that i could keep using them by going to another action up here which i'll have a look at in a little bit and um but you have to bear in mind that if you keep hold of those cards throughout the whole game you're gonna have to spend two coins for each of those at the end of the game or risk losing three victory points so you've got this one here which is going to be how you use your noble cards and the first time somebody uses this option they're gonna have to spend one card like so and then they can use as many nobles as as you are high up on the noble track so you know the higher you up you go you get to get kind of get more bang for your buck and get to take more actions quicker and it's a good strategy to take if you really focus on those nobles um but the second time somebody goes there they're going to have to spend two cards like so and then again they could use the same option however you have to bear in mind that um the values on the cards are not relevant in this case it's purely the quantity of the cards you play there so you're not so focused on money additionally whoever spent the most um cards on these top three cards is going to pick one of their cards they've used and put it in jail so that's going to be how you're
going to add more cards to the to the prison this one here as you can imagine just gives you five um five coins and this one here lets you take a basically a lucky dip on all the different um card types apart from um i think it's apart from the buildings you can't take a building from doing so so once each round is over the board state is going to look something like this you've got cards in that top area you've got cards replaced all the um or a lot of the ones in the middle as well and as you can see as more and more of these cards are being placed the shields are starting to form like so and that's going to be another kind of element of area control and a way to score victory points so not only are you going to calculate the columns i said to go up these tracks into release cards from prison but also you're going to have a look who's got the majority of each completed shield so as you can see here this shield here is evenly split between red and blue so therefore they'd both get the victory points and that's where you'd have a look at their position on the shield track and get that many victory points so in this case the red uh sorry the red and the blue player would get a victory point um and you're going to apply that to all the other ones as well so you see we've got more completed shields here again red's got the majority in this one so and more victory points and you can see here that blue's got the majority of this one because they complete two out of the four um spaces on that shield and that's going to be why the shield option is going to be a good strategy to take because the further you get up the more points you're going to get for completing those shields
the building action here or the building track is going to be how many points that those buildings are going to be worth each at the end of the game so of course you want to get higher up if you've gone for a really high building strategy so you can get a massive five points for each building rather than the standard one and that's going to be how basically how the game's going to play you're going to play four rounds of that in the final round um it's going to work a little bit differently because you're going to have some bonus scoring um where the majority is going to account for another factor um because each column is going to score you these bonus points so this will give you two points for each noble you have this one will give you two points for each piece of artwork you have that isn't a duplicate this one here will give you um two points for each building you have and of course this one here will give you um three points for each two spare coins you have at the end of the game okay so let's share my thoughts about brussels 1897. i will say straight up there are some mechanisms here that i really love and some that i dislike quite a bit and so first off the standard worker placement thing works really well particularly because these workers or your the card you're playing all have a money value corresponding to them and money in this game is pretty tight to keep going so you want to make sure that you are you know exploiting the spot here and getting more money in and of course using your noble cards to keep that money ticking along but bearing in mind that if you keep going there you're going to end up losing cars to jail so it really is a bit of a plate spinning exercise to keep money incoming as well as of course claiming cards because
that's going to be how you do anything in the game i also love the additional wrinkles where not only are you looking for particular cards and but also you want the majorities in those columns um to get the fallout bonuses here to climb those tracks and of course get cards back from the jail now i think this is a massively under explored mechanism in the board gaming space mixing worker placement with area control so i'd love to see a more kind of grand game using that system where not only our door and the spot but it's also going to contribute towards something else i think that's really cool this game does it pretty damn well considering this game is just made up of cards on top of that you know additional area control within the arrow control in terms of the shield majorities just to get those extra points and they all correspond to a kind of a different strategy in the game you know are you going to focus on shields and get points that way um are you going to focus on completely you know dominating buildings and building as many as you can and get points that way and hopefully you can climb that track and get the big bucks at the end or of course you can focus on exploiting those nobles and using them again and again and bearing in mind you have to pay them at the end of the round so i do like that and i will say that some of the mechanisms aren't quite as exciting as the others like for example i don't think noble track is quite as enticing as the other ones and i think the i don't know it just didn't quite land as well as i would have liked it i never really felt massively sucked in to go for those nobles and keep using them because again money is so tight and you do have to pay them at the end of the game and doing so it can be quite crippling if you don't have that spare cash in your pocket now i mentioned earlier that there are
some mechanisms i do like and some i don't like um so those are things i really do like the things that i really don't like is the way that you build the buildings in the first place i think that feels really rushed and quite tacked on um because as i said you know for the first building you spend one resource the second one spent two resources it doesn't matter what those resources are but you do get more points if they're different and for me that just felt i felt rushed it felt um very unsatisfying and just didn't feel very well ironed out so i will say i did find that a little bit lackluster and it didn't fight quite connect with me um the balance of the game as well i think is actually pretty quite you know it's pretty good actually so the different routes to victory are pretty well balanced and i will say you know even if you really focus on that building strategy um by getting as many buildings down as you can by tricking trading resources and getting the buildings and the chances are depending on the randomness of the uh the bottom row here um that that might not actually work out in terms of scoring the actual um the track climbing bonus as well so you know doing all is quite difficult so generally if you're building a lot of buildings you probably won't be high on the track or maybe if you're not building that many buildings you might have the freedom to climb the track and kind of compensate for that so i think that works quite well um and of course if you want to do it all then you're going to have to be pretty flush with cash and being flush with cash is not easy so i think the game does a good job of restricting you so that you can't do everything so as the box advertises this game does take 45 to 60 minutes to play which i think for a game of this scope is pretty
damn good so i think the ratio to the gameplay and the time um the time you know the time stamp is really good and i can't really complain at all just four quick rounds and with a lot of decision space under that blanket so yeah no issues at all with how long the game takes and it certainly doesn't outstay as welcome the replayability is something that i'm i'm questioning um there's not really a lot of options to try here because as i said everything does kind of tie back to these three tracks and three different strategies isn't really that exciting particularly when you will dabble in all of them um yes you are reacting to the game state you know you do want to be completing those shields you do want to be reacting to the cards available and the columns they correspond to but i said there's not a ton of options that come out each time you're always going to be collecting resources always going to be building buildings and so on so there's not really a ton of things to explore here and it is more of a of a tactical game but with some sprinkles of strategy of course depending on your position on these tracks but yeah i think the replayability of this game is somewhat hamstrung and i don't think you're going to get those you know double digit figures out of plays out of this one i think the player interaction in brussels 1897 is pretty damn fantastic and to be honest and because of course you've always got that scarcity of the um of the cards you want in the first place you know if there's only one building out there because it is as said randomized and therefore um you know maybe there will only be one building that comes out each round or in a particular round and everybody wants it so therefore you want to be the first to grab it and you might even want to really spend those big
bucks in order to get the majorities as well so you are competing with the other players on a a number of different fronts which i'm adds a lot of excitement the production of the game is generally good of course this is mainly built up of cards um the cardstock is decent i always don't like games that have blackboard cards but that's you know a nitpick um so good card quality um and generally the iconography and symbology of the game is pretty straightforward you can tell everything not much room for confusion there the little full box a little fold up board here fits nicely in this small box so i do like the fact that this doesn't um this box isn't just made up of air as a lot of these um games are so yeah i do like the way that it's kept small and um is nice and compact so final thoughts for brussels 1897 straight up i will say you know full props to making a game of this magnitude and this scope in such a small box and in such a tight time frame so i love that it really does bridge a nice gap between being a filler and more of a main event game um and i also like so much things about about this game around it's particularly this um all these different majorities you know the shields and the columns that is such a cool mechanism and something that could be explored so much further adds so much more wrinkles to the game so much more kind of depth of the game because you know i really want this card but that majority is not really something i'm interested in so maybe i'll go here and prioritize this and so on and that really does pull you in different directions and the tenseness to get to those spots is also really strong and of course considering how much money you have as well because you might want to get these big cards down
so you get those majorities but you have to be able to pay for that therefore you might have to go here and therefore you might have to lose cars to prison so there is layers here there is definitely things to explore however i think that once you've explored those things and experienced them for one or two times you're pretty much going to have seen everything this game has to offer i would have loved to have seen a bigger scope of this one and maybe that's what the um what the original game offers um but as a little taster for that main experience this one really does tick a lot of boxes for me um this one probably is an example of great mechanisms um okay game because again that hook to come back to the game isn't really there it's not that strong i'm really not a fan of that building mechanism as i mentioned earlier i don't want to keep banging on about that um but yeah it's it's one of those games that i'm really glad i played i've had an experience but i can't wholeheartedly recommend buying it i would say try it again if it's a really nice niche between being a filler plus game but yeah it just doesn't have that extra something to keep you coming back to it but a really nice pleasant experience a very near miss for me um and you know if you pick this one up at maybe a decent price and check it out and it does appeal to you and it looks like it's going to be good for your group then give this one a look i'm certainly not going to um disparage you from trying it or buying it because it's a good design it just isn't that extra something special about it so unfortunately a very near miss for brussels 1897.
something i'll probably play one or two more times and then part with it myself