Skip to main content
Loading video...

Horizons of Spirit Island: Discussion

Transcript 16:24

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games onl and today I'm doing a discussion over Horizons of spirit Island which was a game that I was going to completely ignore because I have everything for Spirit Island and I was like well I don't really need it um mainly and the biggest reason was because I knew that the spirits came with these flimsy uh cardboard pieces and I was like well I don't want to have just different Spirits with a different piece of paper uh but then a Gen Con this year I saw that they had this upgrade pack for the spirits that basically gives them thicker cardboard and I was like awesome they had the wherewithal to recognize that there are other people who have Spirit Island so now I can just get the spirits and not have to buy the whole game well not really that's just an upgrade for the spirits their cards and stuff are not uh in here so I basically could have returned that or just buy Horizons so I bought Horizons and here I am now but my initial thoughts of Horizons of spirit Island was that it was going to be kind of a Jaws of the lion experience in that it would ease you into the game so that you understand how Spirit Island works and either maybe because I've played Spirit Island so much or because the game is what it is I

don't think it quite does that there are certain sections of your player board that will be in parenthesis that kind of has a rule reminder like um the devouring teeth lurk underfoot it says one damage for his innate power death approaches from beneath the surface one damage in the parenthesis it says plus one damage for your territorial aggression Special Rule so there are some reminders throughout here and there is a quick start guide that does kind of tell you hey here's how you set up the board uh and then but this is mainly for these three Spirits uh weirdly enough this game only plays one to three which is odd but I mean honestly I think Spirit island is best at lower player counts anyway so three is not the worst number but it is odd that they decided to cap it at three but they tell you which three to use and The Invader cards and then kind of just tell you how a first round should go um this is as good as you're going to get for this kind of game now I love Spirit Island I think it's one of the best if not my favorite Cooperative game in terms of just Standalone co-ops like clearly I have Campaign games that are all Cooperative that I have higher than Spirit Island but if I just want to sit down crunchy fully Cooperative game Spirit Island really has no other competitor um but kind of where I was at was I

don't need this because I'm all in on Spirit Island so the question you have to ask yourself is which if you own all Spirit Island should you get Horizons or if you don't own anything of spirit Island should you just get the base game or should you get this and for the for those who do have Spirit Island um I'm actually going to try and answer both these questions for those of you that do have Spirit Island and you're kind of a completionist I actually do recommend picking this up for a couple reasons one it is a more succinct condensed version it's not going to be overwhelming for people when you just pull out a crate of and hand them 40 Spirits uh granted you just hand them someone cuz they they do have difficulty levels but this does have um kind of a more simplistic approach cuz the board is a static board it's not going to be randomized of the different board pieces the fear levels are or yeah the fear pool is on the board the blight pool is on the board The Invader track is on the board the fear car everything is just kind of all centralized into one location um so you are I think going to be able to go to new players and this feels a little bit more manageable I mean I actually think that the cardboard pieces of the cities and towns and and Invaders I actually find it to be a little bit cumbersome funny enough because the Miniatures for Spirit Island

are actually not that great but because the board isn't all that big you can't really stand them up or anything so whenever you're putting more into one spot it kind of does get a little bit cluttered you kind of have to just stack them which is f fine like this spot here has three Invaders on it and they're all different sizes so you do know who is what but I actually found that the the plastic is a little bit better um but they also include these power progressions which I believe other Spirits have but in this game it actually is kind of helpful because whenever you're picking Power Cards and stuff it just tells you which one to get but nothing made me more aware of kind of how complex Spirit island is than playing this game and thinking it was supposed to be a simpler version and then realizing it's really not it is Spirit Island um then yeah then playing this game so uh again for those who own Spirit Island and you're like well what about the spirits the five Spirits they're amazing they are no different than all the others in the um in all the other expansions and by no different I mean these aren't like simpler versions it's not like they're they're losing an innate power or they don't have uh as high of a presence or anything they look and play just like spirits and they are

extremely uh different from the ones that are being played like they I mean these are probably going to feel a bit more like other Spirits though but because again it's its own Standalone game but I think you could integrate these into your other game just to have more Spirit options and that will you're not going to sit there and be like that's from the horizons version like okay here you go like baby like I guess see if you can handle it like looking at it it's like okay I clearly see what sunbrite Whirlwind is about um like in fact I like this one specifically stood out the most in terms of being different because it was so much about control like the entire back is like slight offense but super high control and nothing really else like this was all about giving Spirits uh increased range giving them a bunch of energy uh one of their PowerUp cards uh was called Power storm that was like Hey this turn a spirit can pay uh energy to do a card again and if you have a certain number of elements they can do two other powers again that's insanely power powerful and I once we got this card I was like oh I see now why you hand out energy as much as you do because they have to they have to pay the energy for those cards a second time but that's incredibly powerful um to do your cards again and turning certain like gather or push

effects making slow cards fast this one is the one that stood out the most in terms of different differentiating from the others but there's also uh five Spirits total the eyes watch from the trees and fathomless mud of the swamp uh that are both well fathomless mud is basically even like Balan across the board and the eyes watch from the trees have really high it's funny it's almost like a like a signal booster from a phone High defense then a little bit lower fear a little bit lower control and a little bit lower offense but then you go to the devouring teeth lurk underfoot insanely High offense and then Rising heel of stone and sand also insanely High offense um and yeah the spirits just feel unique and they're incredibly powerful and they feel good in any combination of Horizons so yes if you own Spirit Island I'd say go out and get that but then probably look for the update pack so it fits with the rest of your stuff the only thing that sucks is you still aren't going to have certain things like you're not not going to use these tokens I maybe you will maybe you'll maybe you like the tokens a little bit more than the than the Miniatures so then you might use those instead the minor Powers major Powers all that can just easily get integrated into your game so yeah this really just gives you more stuff and I like that they made it backwards compatible with

stuff that already existed for people who also buy this first and then they can go by Spirit Island and they already have some stuff to as I'm kind of a mini expansion now if you're not in the spirit Island and you're like well which one should I get should I get base game or should I get Horizons well it kind of comes down to a financial situation because Spirit island has so many expansions I think it's like a little bit over 200 bucks to get all the expansions but base game to this um if money's not an option I would say just go get the base game because it's this is pretty much that uh with a quick start guide and like the rules aren't any simpler there's still icons and nuances to the game that you have to learn that the rule book pretty much is kind of a rule book of of the base game almost so it uh it just allows you to kind of Branch off into more stuff than having to kind of have some stuff that you're not going to use if you go and get the other stuff but if money is you know a concern or a budget or whatever it might be then definitely pick this up like pick this one up first you can get this Mass Market I think that's kind of what they were aiming for is I believe this is sold at Target so you could go get this at Target and then just be like okay now I get to play Spirit Island and

it's a lower footprint and if you don't end up liking the game you didn't lose as much money but if you do like the game at least you can be like oh hey no we actually really like Spirit Island let's go get the the base game and kind of go from there because I absolutely love this game it it's so so I mean so Horizon's is a fantastic experience it's still so good it's still just as crunchy um like it's not like again I'm kind of Blown Away at how much they were able to uh keep pure to Spirit Island without making it like without watering it down almost um yeah I mean and this was actually playing this is the first time I've ever two-handed Spirits cuz normally I play two-player if I don't like I don't play this solo ever it's always two players or more uh but I played this at two players recently and I was like oh okay well let's just see what it's like for this this version at three so I I two-handed uh two Spirits um yeah it's a little bit of a lot honestly like cuz there's so much Nuance to Spirit Island there's so much understanding what you can do what your uh what your uh uh uh what the other players companions can do and trying to

figure out the fast and slow movement when things are going to trigger how can we set up for different turns can we move Invaders around can we position them in such a way that like one of us can do a mass wipe or whatever it might be and trying to do that while also managing two Spirits for yourself is is a little much honestly at least it was for me but eventually we got it I mean funny enough the last game we played um I was just kind of ignor ignoring one one Spirit like I definitely focused on one more than the other uh so all the benefits of the sunbrite Whirlwind kind of went to one spirit that I was able to focus on a little bit more so kind of turned it into a two-player game and then the third one was just kind of like yeah if those Invaders come over to my area oh boy are they going to get it so so yeah again this is a really great Standalone game that kind of does everything you want it to uh except I guess that I mean they probably never even came out and said hey this is a tutorial for Spirit Island it's not it is its own game um but now I kind of have to and I knew this whenever I bought it it was like okay well going to not keep any of this I'm just going to kind of piece some of this out I don't need I don't need the flimsy boards um for any of that I have the the

cardboard for them so that's nice so here's here's these that I can add to my spirit Island stuff and then I just grab all the cards put them with the rest of my stuff and kind of toss the other the other like the board and the the tokens but at least I'm using most of the game um yeah so on a scale of 1 to 10 Horizons of spirit island is going to get it's going to get a nine for me like there's no reason why this should get anything less because that means I would have to kind of rate Spirit Island less and I think this is a very solid entry because it's I guess it's theoretically also backwards compatible there's nothing stopping me from playing this version with the other spirits but because I have everything else like I can just toss this into that um and it's also not something being thrown in that kind of makes something obsolete like my other stuff isn't obsolete cuz this exists uh that you can just kind like I look at this more of uh of as an expansion to the game than kind of a standalone but that's just me but again you can just go out and buy this for 30 bucks or whatever it might be instead of the 200 that I mentioned with all the expansions and still have a fantastic time and have a pretty crunchy still crunchy Co-op um and I think they have a Invaders

actually like an Invader rule uh for it because they have the Invader cards that have the little little symbol on it if you want a more difficult experience with this also but that is my thoughts on Horizons of spirit Island let me know what you think of it in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time upd is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved