Skip to main content
Loading video...

How to craft the perfect player experience | Jonny Pac

Transcript 1:08:29

ultimately it comes down to the question of does this make sense if you have a game where it's it's an agricultural game right where you're growing fruit trees it makes sense that at the end you know of the Harvest ground harvest season that you might get five apples or you might get four apples however if you get to the end of the season and your Apple Tree randomly makes oranges it's like well hold on that didn't make sense yeah

so Johnny you are a designer best known for Merchant's Cove but then you've also got these really cool western themed games like Coloma Fistful of meeples Sierra West like you've got some amazingly thematic games and I love how you have found a way to kind of marry up theme with the mechanics so it actually kind of feels like I'm doing this thing or I am actually kind of in this world even though it's you know expressed through these more abstractive abstracted mechanisms and I reached out to you recently you're a contributor to my find the fun book and really appreciate you contributing to that and you you said something interesting a while back that I wanted to to dive into with this podcast you said I lean more into unsolvable behavioral economic dilemmas versus creating complicated but solvable mental puzzles so what does that mean exactly so thanks yeah it's a lot to unpack which which I'm happy to attempt to do so so I think um kind of the the negative how we could look at this would be that games share a lot of things with puzzles especially I think even even more so in some of the Contemporary games we could look at um what we might think is like player board Centric games or the rolling right Revolution that kind of thing where there's a lot of um putting putting things together in abstract way Crossing Lines off and all that sort of thing where uh it's less of a medium of interaction sometimes than than say some previous games of the past or you know party games guessing games or even kind of the

first wave of Euro games that kind of thing and so um my introduction to um tabletop gaming was really through kind of that first wave of katan-esque Euro games and so a lot of those games by today's standard is considered actually like air quotes mean because of the player interaction you can not trade with somebody you can block somebody you can do a lot of indirect negative player interaction stuff and then some direct negative player interaction stuff and so kind of in this where I think things have drifted a little bit is into kind of a puzzle-centric uh what Jeff Warner would almost call like a baroque version of game design versus like a Bauhaus Style game design where there's a lot of levers to pull on your personal player board that creates a sensation of working with all these things without actually super needing to know what other players are even doing through majority of the game yeah that's interesting and I like the idea of breaking it down is your game more gamey or more puzzly right because I feel like sometimes as designers we don't think enough about that and then you end up potentially with a game that is solvable right where a player just has to crack the code okay I play this card in this round I played that card in the next round and this and that and the other and then I'm probably going to win which I mean it's kind of cool that moment you realize that and you crack code and you beat all your friends but at the same time it's like well why would I really want to play it again if I know the the you know like the parameters like I know step one step two step three now the

game almost plays itself that's not particularly fun so talk to me as far as your thoughts between like what is a puzzle what is a game not necessarily like specific definitions but just in your mind when you're designing uh yeah and obviously like we end up way at the weeds answering what exactly a puzzle is and what exactly a game is and so that might be somebody more call if I can answer those questions or write a book about it Keith Bergen has a really good book a couple books one of them is game design Theory and the other one is Clockwork game design and he actually defines like interactive systems to puzzles to games to competitions and how they kind of hybridize into these things that we've effectively called you know in his case video games and board games how they're actually our games um so to kind of sidestep those those definitions and maybe look uh kind of maybe on the spectrum of what is puzzling what is um more of a game would be something where we could look at and like a social deduction game is very much about the the politics and the figuring out of the people's behaviors on that side and then we could look at something like a uh maybe some of these rolling rights where say dice are rolled by some player and everybody records some number onto their crib sheet and kind of cross-references a bunch of things and kind of almost like doing like Sudoku and together like um maybe the game on tour would be a good example of a effectively zero interaction game where you take the numbers from the dice you kind of draw

on your map and at the end of the game you're really just comparing your your sheets with each other you don't really get bits or talk or leverage any sort of social pressure to do anything like that there's with uh there's obviously uncertainty so we have uncertainty as far as how the dice are showing up but barring that there's really nothing that's uh gonna really make you do something different you know I'm not going to try to negotiate with you how to record your dice differently in a game like that where there's no incentives uh across the table from each other so uh kind of looking at the this spectrum like that a lot of times like there's my work is a um let's say game developer and a game designer sometimes I will encounter a really cool early prototype from a designer that they're pitching or I'm working on with the publisher and a lot of times it feels to Me Like Somebody stumbled across a really cool puzzle and said wouldn't that make a cool game and they've kind of gamified a puzzle to a degree and there's really nothing wrong with that because some of those situations can turn into cool stuff like here's a question I would I would ask which I don't have the answer to is like the popular game of Zuul has very puzzly elements as far as how you're going to configure the layout of your pieces on your player board but the other half of azul which I think is less talked about is how Cutthroat and interesting the draft mechanism is in there it's very social it's very much

looking at other players boards and there's a clean heuristic of if I leave if I push all this stuff into the middle you'll have to take it there's too much are you going to be able to you know Slough off those negative points by taking the positive of what you actually need and what kind of sacrificial plate that I have to make in order to do such a thing the draft is fantastic and so I think it's brilliant and then the back end like what you're doing as far as administrating you know how you accept your tiles and score those tiles is more puzzly and I think I'm not sure uh if the chicken or egg how kiesling came up with oh here's a cool uh tile placement system it scores in an interesting way or was he like wait a second here's this cool drafting system that really pushes people into each other we just need a place to put these tiles once they take them uh I'm not sure which way that came out but that that would be kind of the process I would look at when I encounter a game like that is seeing does it feel like that scale is balanced between the puzzle and the the kind of behavioral economic drafting system that's happening in that and likewise with prototypes or anything else like that and you're kind of looking at like wood throwing a puzzle into an otherwise um social driven sort of game uh help that or would it actually just increase the cognitive load of the game so it's kind of like um here's here's a task you have to do and you go okay that's that's easy enough but then somebody says but also you know Pat your belly and rub your head and you know stand on one leg and spin a couple plates and all of a sudden that simple

task doesn't seem so simple anymore and it's almost like there's this it seems I think there's kind of a uh there's a word for it very well economics can't remember it's misattribution uh happens where they actually think the task they're doing is more complex because they're doing a bunch of other tasks on the side but none of those things are actually um say intrinsically rewarding or interesting it's just a matter of you kind of crowd somebody up with this burden and all of a sudden they feel like well I'm fighting through it he gave me they've had themselves in the back without really examining whether or not each of those subsystems is compelling truly yeah that's super interesting and to be clear we're not saying that one way is better or worse or good or bad like we're just saying these are different ways of designing games and and the ways different ways that games can play out like if I think about puzzle games that lean more towards the puzzle a lot of Cooperative games are very puzzly it's almost like the puzzle has been scrambled up in different ways and a lot of times randomly like pandemic you're never sure where all the cubes are gonna go in the initial setup and how the cards are going to kind of be stacked and all that but it's really just like throwing out pieces all over the table and now it's a matter of over the course of the game trying to put them all back in the right spot and there are some times where the game has scrambled itself to a point where you literally can't win you don't know that from the beginning necessarily but if you could examine you know play for play you're like oh we we couldn't have won this game it was not possible because the puzzle was scrambled up too much based on you know how much time we're gonna have and things like that so I think

that's one interesting thing to think about especially if you're designing solo games or cooperative games is you might lean a little more towards the puzzle just based on the way the game is going to play out versus competitive games where if it's solvable because like pandemic has to be in some way solvable like you have to be able to figure out a b c and d because ultimately we have to end up with a very specific game state to win versus we're playing against each other and the end game state it doesn't matter as much as do I have more points than you did I cross the finish line first whatever it is so talk to me a little bit about that you designed a lot of games that are competitive right and some of them are asymmetrical like each player has a very different role we're doing very different things at the same time um you want to you want to feel like everything is balanced and that experience is still fair so how do you do that from a player experience standpoint making things fairer to everybody and and making sure that there isn't just like oh here's the one way to win yeah it is a a few answers to your questionnaires so um one of them is is addressing the fact that there's there is an uncertain element so let's say pandemic or a lot of these other games where even a die roll or something like this that there's there's a medium that the game is presenting and then the players react to that and kind of you you have a certain I don't know like event horizon or whatever that you'd kind of come up to and it's like you can make a bunch of decisions under uncertainty which is great behavioral economic sort of stuff and then something will happen the card is played

or this and that and then you have to respond to that and you can kind of calculate your uh risks or you can you know YOLO it and just try something that sounds crazy and hope it lands for a bigger return that sort of thing and so you're playing against the the game systems um outputs which which is interesting but then we have to look at some other sort of games where uh games of perfect information that maybe let's say are zero-sum two player games we could say like chess and go or games that are similar with perfect information um that have no hidden cards no card draws no dice or rolled or anything like this all the information is effectively out there but it's the complexity and what the players actually do with those decisions that becomes the uncertain element so we could look at a popular game maybe Terra mystica it's kind of Herald is having no really random elements right and so it's also asymmetrical so it's you know they've done a lot of work to balance and rebounce it over the years and so on and still a lot of arguments around that but there's the game isn't suddenly going to throw something at you where there's a volcano suddenly erupts in the middle of Terror mystica and everybody has to run away and like event card is just not the style of game that that is where some games kind of have like a dialogue with the players between the kind of stuff that the designers baked in to create these experiences as they roll out so if we looked at something like that as players of games of perfect information versus games

where there's hidden information either that players gain cars that they don't know or there's an event deck or just anything that happens that the players can't ultimately know and they just have to respond to then that does kind of create the difference between whether or not something again like air quotes is truly solvable um so even even you know that some of the best computers like alphago is finally like you know beating the best go players out there and that's very very complex but you think about how simple in certain sense uh not in the true sense that go is compared to like all the weird levers that you'd have to pull in like a Terra mystica it's like you know the goal is very clear what you're trying to do versus aggregate a bunch of victory points from a whole bunch of different sources from a whole bunch of different asymmetrical abilities that are kind of like rubbing shoulders with each other and kind of these different ways um in a game like that uh so kind of fast forward to your other half your question there is how to look at something um like Merchants Cove is actually a really good example of a really difficult task to kind of look at it's like it's a victory point game it's a competitive game it's a game where you're trying to uh you know basically become the richest Merchant which is equivalent to just summing up the most victory points over set number of rounds okay but then we have these vastly different player boards that's going on that game so people aren't really familiar with it it's kind of like each player's got their own player board with their own character and their merchant in this town like you might be the blacksmith

you might be The Alchemist and their entire player board um has kind of one mechanism that is pretty much Universal for all of them is that there's kind of a work replacement thing where you move your Merchant to a work replacement spot and it will do something but the stuff that you do as those Merchants are vastly different like the blacksmith is kind of rolling dice is a sort of maybe like role players or Sagrada you're kind of like putting dice together in certain ways and then we've got something that's a little bit like a potion explosion sort of thing or Candy Crush where these marbles are coming down this little shoot that you're drafting for The Alchemist and the captain is spinning a spinner and then you send little boats out into the sea to explore Islands I have treasure on them and bring the those goods back and other ones like a rondelle where it's thematically kind of slipping through time and bringing back artifacts effects from the past one's a rolling right one's kind of Mancala like there's a lot of these different mechanisms and so trying to look at like a efficiency race like how do you balance these apples to oranges and say like oh if the blacksmith rolls a die how is that equivalent to The Alchemist pulling marbles out of this decanter and if we sat there and thought about it like that it's really really hard to do that and maybe we'd lose all the wrinkles of the game even if we tried too hard to do that so the sort of sneaky thing there's two things that uh made that game work at all and you know still people might argue if

something's balanced or not but one of them is we found kind of a universal uh sauce to make the whole thing work which is spending quote time so it's a Time tracking so if I take an action and I spend you know three hours to do this action a worth of stuff on my player board and somebody else does three hours worth of stuff on their player board we kind of looked at the average amount of time that every round has and the average amount of output of goods at your manufacturing uh that could come out of using those hours and Corruption and efficiency boosts and all these things over the course of a round of the game and one of some of the interesting things is like the blacksmiths can use let's just say an eight hour work day to produce a number of goods but their Arc is kind of different they have to kind of turn them out quickly like here's one here's another one here's another one they make small leaps and The Alchemist kind of Aggregates Aggregates Aggregates and makes big batches of stuff and so you look at the behavioral economic side which would be like what what are they what's the advantage and disadvantage of doing that so from a Alchemist standpoint um it's interesting is you can watch the market which I'll talk about a little bit um which way things the values are growing in all this and try to respond to it in the zero hour kind of wait wait wait and then respond um where the blacksmith is actually more has to make this those decisions at sooner intervals it can't just hold out and then make everything at the last minute but instead of doing it also

influences what those goods are value-wise because they have to make these deposits more frequently and therefore they can kind of shape the market with a little bit more ease than say the outcome is good and so you look at the the difference between those two players going like all right you're going to curate the market but maybe I'll capitalize on the market once you curate it and I'll spend my time just watching what you're doing piggyback on you or I'll work against you or and so on and so um that boils down to the last thing is how much are these Goods actually worth because if we said okay the blacksmith has a you know Gauntlet that's worth five victory points or five you know gold and then the uh Alchemist has a potion let's say I don't know it's worth six gold it's like how would you how would you do the math to look at these the difference between the should this be a six should this be a four these small numbers sorts of math that in some Euro games and things like that would be all the difference like you know a point to point um so the other kind of method that we went with is to have effectively like a a market that changes the value of these different things over the course of play which is player driven so it wasn't just like oh you pull a card out and yellow goods are worth more um what you end up doing is you pull a meeple out of a bag which is going to mean yellow this potentially could be more but we gave agency to the players to decide which boat that the meeples are going to go in and then they're going to uh come to shore to the the cove and then they're going to buy things from the merchants based on those things so it's a simple coil areas like if if

you're manufacturing large yellow Goods like say a big you know yellow sword or a big yellow potion whatever else and then the yellow adventurers come to the the dock then those things are going to have a higher selling price and it's simply multiplicative so the base price might be okay it's a five let's say dollar gauntlet if there's more demand for it it would go up to a 10 and then a 15 and 20 it just goes up with each increment like that and so small numbers got kind of blown out by this method which is which was intentional to not say oh this good is worth five this is where it's six this is should be worth five and a half should be six it's kind of like you know what this could go from zero if there's no market for it could go to Five if it just sells a kind of a slab which isn't necessarily good or 10 or 15 20 and so on we kind of look at what the ceilings are with these things and where the floor is so they can go from being worth nothing to potentially a lot like you know you can sell one good for 48 coins in that game and that's enough to be maybe 25 of your score if you do it right so there's these kind of like what columns like a Black Swan or a tail event that is so disproportionately big in its effect that it kind of washes out a lot of small numbers sort of math stuff or if it was truly a point solid game you say okay I went to uh wash my dishes and I get a victory point and then I uh you know move this over here I get two victory points in addition to whatever I'm doing the game doesn't really dish

out small victory points like that kind of lumps them into these goods and you really try to sell them with these multiplicative numbers so between the time track and then the actual evaluation and scoring of those things we don't actually have like the same sort of Baseline numbers that we would if we were trying to calculate all these apples and orange oranges so even when I say BGG so he says oh I lost by you know 48 points I'm like did you have any Goods left over is like and then they always like oh yeah well last minute so and so parked the boat on the other Island which I wanted to and it would have swung the other way they would have lost 36 I would have been up 48 and I would have won and so it looks like going from fourth place to first place was in fact a turn away not so much a matter of trying to calculate I would have had to you know aggregate points points points from all these different things in order to reach them oh it's impossible throw my hands up it was really just a matter of and events that changed and again it was a player driven event more specifically so long-winded answer but that's kind of a method behind it that sort of thing but I think that's really the heart of it though it's not that you drew a card and now the game dictated that that boat went to that island or that many meeples were added to that boat and I didn't really have a say in it and I've got all these yellow things but now there's no yellow things because the game said so it's it's player driven right you get that interesting um oh I want to do this but that's going to help you and now I have to figure out is going to help you more than it helps me and so maybe I do something different but that's interesting choices and at the end of the game like you said it's

always great when players can go back and figure out exactly why they won or exactly why they lost and if the game can come down to oh man I had a decision I went left I should have gone right and that's why I lost next time we play I'll think a little harder and I'll now I understand the game a little bit better and I can do things differently or I won because of the same thing like hey you went left I went right I made the better choice therefore I won the game versus you know unfortunately a lot of times point salad games you look at them and you're like I have no idea there was probably like 74 decisions that I made that would you know that kind of messed me up or got me the Victory and so being able to kind of pinpoint winning or losing is is super helpful another thing I want to touch on you're talking about whenever computers figured out how to beat humans right at chess and It Go I read an oracle article while back and it might be different now especially with the advances in AI it seems like every every minute you know computers are getting smarter than us but at one point the players had figured out how to beat the computers again kind of like to take the championship back by playing randomly they would play normally and then they would do something completely out of nowhere unnecessary makes no sense and do like a random move and the computer would like kind of freak out for saying it's like wait wait what it would like have to recalculate all these things and then the computer would make a weird play and then the player would go back into their normal strategy and so the players figured out how to win against machines with Randomness right and so I thought that was super interesting and how you know this this game that had been solved basically the computer had figured out two plus two is

four that's how I beat you but then the players were like okay well let's throw a little 0.25 in there let's see what happens with the math just messing with stuff and so anyway let's jump back to your process you were talking about figuring out okay is this gonna be a four is this gonna be a six and all that when you're designing for player experience really trying to bring out what was it unsolvable unsolvable behavioral economic dilemmas what is that what does that look like from your design process are you starting with this massive you know hunk of granite at the beginning and you're just trying to sculpt it down you know Chip Away Chip Away chip away are you more of an artist that you have an idea and then you build upon that from from nothing how does it work when you're creating one of these games uh I think it's probably more of the artist's side but but I think if somebody else saw that they would see it maybe it's the sculptor because you know what I think comes away is just the nucleus of something might be what I've had some other friends who make like very small smaller games and they go wow your your game is like five of my games you know because it's just the scope of kind of what their goals are which uh is an admiral like I I'd have a lot of difficulty making like a 18 card um game that's any good that sort of thing and I have some friends that have made those they're fantastic so uh so I do kind of go and find um a handful of mechanisms I think are interesting and then they support each other in ways that this mechanism leads into that one and the cool way has a cool feedback loop and maybe they kind

of make some gears turn in some new ways because I think in this day and age it's a little bit um hard to think I'm going to come up with an absolutely new mechanism from scratch like let's say the deck building arguably that kind of thing um but now we're seeing things like um doing Imperium arnac endless winter where it's deck building and worker placement so at one point both of those mechanisms were um relatively fresh feeling new right now they're hybridized into these ways like this and we're seeing a lot of games where there's a bunch of mechanisms that gamers are getting used to they're being perfected more so than their rough forms and then they're being kind of married together in new ways that creates even richer experiences so once let's say I have a handful of mechanisms I think are kind of gelling well together then I tend to stop and I won't go forward until I find a theme that I want to work with and that might be something I want to work with or maybe I know that the publisher I'm working with might have like a wish list where they really really want to gain about such and so I'm always kind of checking these mechanisms against that and from there it's what I call systematically informed design where you let the theme kind of point away for the the rest of the mechanisms and it can still be a very um mechanistically drawn games let's look at like one I've been working on for a while here it's his unconscious minds coming out next year it's had a lot of

uh you know Scott Rondell movement it's got you know kind of contract fulfillment things like speaking in the mechanical sense it has a lot of resource management just the kind of things you see in Euro games and is this point solid game and As We examined it uh we found that okay you're blocking people on the worker placement board that's one of the primary means of information uh there uh where interaction we're also looking at some tracks like being first up a track is being better than being last on track that sort of thing so some comparative stuff um and we're just going like all right this doesn't have a lot a huge amount of interaction points in this as in the sense like dudes on a map game might or something like that right and so um as we're kind of coming to completion it's going like well this game probably has enough room for maybe one more subsystem and then some sort of interaction so I was thinking about the theme a little bit and just kind of ruminating going like what could it be what could it be to make people do something and you know some games like oh add a follow mechanism or whenever one player does this you can bet whether or not it's going to come out that way and some of these other things are should there be a trading phase or should they bid to take their actions uh it's like no no no no so something came back from when I was a kid playing rummikube which uh is kind of a classic you know family game which I really enjoyed and there's this mechanism in there where people have melded all these straights and Pairs and things like out there on the the table they're kind of just out there and

you're trying to clear your board in that game uh one of the cool things about that game is you can kind of go out and mess up everything as long as everything when you're done messing it up is been reformed back into a legal spot so just maybe to play this one tile and I see you've got a straight over here but you didn't actually need the four because it's legal to have just the one two three so then I've look at that but I need to cover from up there you can kind of break all these things apart put them all back together and then find a legal place where that tile would fit into like the requirements there and I thought that was really cool because it's in a sense very interactive that you're you're effectively taking other people's what would normally be their Tableau or something and working it to your own needs and then putting it back out there into the world um so what's unconscious mind what kind of came up with was this idea that you are uh citing papers from each other and writing books and treatises and so as you kind of meld cards into your area you're able to put these book overlays on there and you get points and you get you know goat tracks that sort of thing it's good for you to write these books and then there's a little authorship token on there so what happens later on is if I were to write a book and you had already written one I could actually cite some of the cards that have been tucked into your book and referenced those and put them into my book to help me to complete mine easier however you get Kickback points for having done that to begin with and so it becomes this whole thing where okay do I put the books out there early to seed it out here so I know other people are going to

cite for me and I'll get a lot of these instant Rewards or do I sandbag and kind of wait until everybody else has done a bunch of books then it'll be that much easier for me and I'll try to come in there and swoop the last of the books that have been done this way so you see this kind of thing where the rummy cube-esque sharing of the knowledge the books the cards that have been played I'll kind of work into this ecosystem and so that was kind of the last little feathers of like we needed another piece of interaction we need something thematically that made sense that wasn't you know really oh my professor is going to go and you know knock over your your clientele Booth or something like this right it's it didn't make sense to do mean things um or sabotage each other in a game like this um so it I wanted to find effectively a positive indirect player interaction which was this back scratching sighting sort of thing and the brinkmanship of bringing something on early versus late and that sort of thing and uh yeah no I think you did that that makes such good thematic sense right that I am putting something out first and now other you know doctors or whatever are citing me as their source and I would get some reputation and I would get some points in the context of the game that makes sense thematically and so talk to me a little bit about that when you're when you're trying to figure out the marriage of theme and mechanism right especially you've made a lot of western themed games right and so there's there's certain there's a certain feeling like I want to feel like I'm out west I want to feel like a cowboy I want to feel like I'm in that very specific moment of human or American history how do you do that

right how do you how do you is it just a lot of trial and error and just going all right let's try this how does that feel no it didn't work all right I shot that oh that feels pretty good is it just a lot of trial and error or do you kind of have ideas in your mind going in with with ways that you're going to kind of intersection these things cross into them and go oh yeah that's that's definitely going to feel like I'm in a gunfight or that's definitely gonna feel like I'm writing a scientific journal or something like that what are your what are your thoughts on that so uh yeah I mean a little gut type mechanism is and say fistful and equals is a good example I was play testing expansion for it because Coloma is finally coming back in the branch in fiscible meeples is also as well and they both have expansions they're just some game found and did pretty well which is exciting because it's uh it's been a minute since I've been yeah the uh is play testing the game and my friend designer says I love how you just put in you know rolling off for the the gun fights if you get a bigger result you win it's just rolling two D6 why not against the other gunfighter against mine and it's like I can't believe you would do that you know it just seemed like not that it's a roll and move mechanism but it wasn't really super sophisticated like you know um eurogamy kind of the thing to do and otherwise you know work replacement Resource Management keep Pusher kind of thing and I think that you know my answer is really quick it's like it's it's a gun fight I mean you can't know what's gonna happen because if we took it from a few different possible ways to treat that it would be okay if there's a class of character let's say the deputy is a better shot than the rocker or vice versa whatever it may be what we decide and if they go into the

gunfight they just simply win all right the better shooter always wins over it's deterministic and then you're going to end up with um people playing chicken and stuff like that where it's like you know if you put a strong gunfighter out there I'm not gonna put anything weaker than out there because I know I'm gonna lose you know that I know that therefore you want to keep it out there to begin with because you won't lose efficiency and all of a sudden there's no gunfights in the western game and the whole thing just comes to a halt um so it needed to be something where once in a while the cow poke can beat you know the bad guy you know that kind of thing where these things happen a Man Who Shot Liberty Valance like whatever Shenanigans happens uh should be able to happen so the simple mechanism there is that if you have a higher ranked unit let's say the robber is better than the uh Builder that uh if if in the event that they roll lower they get one re-roll so they basically get to take effectively like you know two shots for everyone that is lower than them so if the deputy who's the best shot the good guys come out there and take that they get this extra roll on that but it's very likely that you could you end up shooting the deputy with with those you know you roll a six and then they roll a four and they go okay well if I roll a six then the better shot will win the tie but the likelihood is still that uh if if a lower ranking unit rolls well that they're gonna have a good shot at it and so I looked at that and I had to look at the concept sequences of that action too is this going to completely kneecap somebody if they said I put the deputy

out there and it didn't pay off the whole game is lost because of this so I had to look at are the consequences that dire is it going to completely derail you is it going completely hand the game over to the other player and in that little sandboxy game it's it's good to win those little parts of it but it's not the way to win the game there's not actually a strategy where it's just based on doing that repeatedly in order to do that the game rewards things they're more proactive like uh say building or money for gold and doing the things actually gets you more stable points it's going to raise you up and these little shoot-offs are kind of like little incidental moments that kind of help you nudge you along the way and it's also one of the end game timers so you might try to encourage those to happen to end the game while you're ahead as a tactical play but it's not actually a means to aggregating say the most victory points by just being the best you know shooter out there in that sandbox so as I kind of look at what I'm trying to tell as far as the little mini story of the game and the experience of that part and then looking at the overall ecosystem of how do you actually pursue your goals in the game how does that fit into the picture and I felt like a little dice roll off like that was just kind of the it's just the right choice hopefully and it seems like a lot of people enjoy that uh section of it versus something that say was more need more maintenance and more important strategic planning yeah I think ultimately it comes down to the question of does this make sense if you have a game where it's it's an agricultural game right where you're growing fruit trees uh it makes sense

that at the end you know of the Harvest ground harvest season that you might get five apples or you might get four apples from your Apple Tree okay because that's that makes sense like in the real world you're not entirely sure how many apples a tree is going to make but it's going to be you know within some kind of range however if you get to the end of the season and your Apple Tree randomly makes oranges it's like well hold on that didn't make sense right but if you have a game that has combat like a gunfight or you know I make games that are sports sports themed there's a lot of Randomness that happens in combat a lot of Randomness that happens throughout you know a sports match sports game and so to have dice in there and to roll things and also have some mitigation have things where if you're a more skilled gunfighter then you could add some you know a plus two to your role or something like that that makes sense but there's still a chance that your gun backfires your gun doesn't fire at all you you trip and fall because you didn't see that rock as you were running like there's a million things that can happen randomly in these moments and so to have that Randomness in the game State makes a lot of sense you know I've been working on a football themed game forever and the thing about that one is you're you're recruiting players that give you different special abilities and different Dice and the actual like games the football games during play uh are really just a roll-off kind of like you're a gunfight just roll the dice see what happens and I've got offensive Dice and defensive Dice and the better my players are the better dice I'm going to roll but every die still has blank sides so like even the best player in the game still has some blanks because even the Heisman Trophy winner has a bad game like they have an off day right and so you might roll much better dice but kind of randomly end up with some low rolls

whereas your opponent has kind of a sorry team they don't have very they don't have good as good players but they roll really really well and there's some other ways to mitigate things but another thing I kind of balanced everything out where every score at the end of that game so you know I'm rolling my offensive value switch either give me sevens or threes or blanks right so I'm football points and then the defensive Dives give me stops or maybe a pick six or a safety or something like that but the scores at the end of each game are like 14 to 10. 28 21 like it all comes down to very very believable football scores like you don't end up with you know right 68 so 22 like like what is this basketball what are we doing and so I think that's another thing is if you have these moments um of rolling dice that are random to balance the game and kind of put the game in such a a box you might say that it still makes sense at the end right that I didn't I didn't shoot you 47 times it's like well hey I need to hit you once yeah yeah exactly or something like that right yeah those numbers are interesting I like how you actually curated your um your numbers your score to be analogous to what you'd expect in the game and sometimes I feel like um like money in games a lot of times has to be it's it's a little it's a little bit weird sometimes when they just talk like oh here's a five but it's really a 500 or it's really a 5000 to try to to try to put it within the scale of what it would actually cost to do something I'm going to build this castle with two wood and a rock and it's kind of like you can't even build a campfire or two wooden Rock buddy like you know let alone a castle but you have to kind of represent that you know this this one unit of wood is you know an entire

Forest worth of wood or whatever it is it's it's been reduced to a certain point but other things uh somatically are hard to do that with like oh I you know I shot this you know guy 47 times with a six shooter well that's not going to make sense in the wild west sort of thing but if you had a fleet of um starfighters and they're all introverging on some big old base or something like that those numbers would make sense to have you know the numbers add up and have fractions that are different so um yeah I think you know we're kind of looking at what they call the dirty word uh Ludo narrative dissonance or consonants is when those things uh actually make sense and I think if you get enough of those head scratcher mechanisms or something like this and all of a sudden uh it doesn't work for the game and people start to ask questions and then I start asking other questions like you know why am I even rolling Dice and who made this game and they kind of go they break the the bubble and they start to look at it like they're outside the Matrix all of a sudden they want to know why everything happens why is why is it game a game and then we have to come back here and be like it's a game you you have to release a certain amount of simulation uh requirements and just know that against the game yeah and this is something I talked to writers and game designers anyone that deals with creating that bubble like you're saying right and it's this concept of very similitude and very similitude doesn't mean this is realistic necessarily it

just it basically means that you're you're drawing someone in to where they go this feels real even if they're watching a high fantasy you know show or playing a high Fantasy game with dragons and magical spells or you're playing a science fiction game with all sorts of crazy stuff going on it's not that you believe this is true but you you believe the world like you're in the moment and you you accept it as it is right but as soon as you introduce something that doesn't fit that immediately it pulls a person out of that kind of magical space and they go oh I'm watching a show now oh this was scripted someone wrote that dialogue right it does like we all know that they wrote the dialogue but if you've written the dialogue in such a way that it doesn't make sense or like the characters are saying things like well that doesn't fit with who I know this character to be or that doesn't fit the theme of this like what is this random mechanism that now I have to do oh this was the game designer had to figure out a way to balance something and they couldn't come up with a good way to do it so they just kind of tacked this on and now I'm kind of outside I've lost that versatility right and so thinking through how to best bring out the theme of A game through the mechanism through the player experience it it's worth taking your time right it's where it's you know sometimes you have a deadline and you just got to throw something in there because it makes it work and this needs to be this just because we got to get it out the door I get that but if you can take the time to really make it feel good uh one example I always go back to is the game villainous where there's the the Captain Hook character and it's I think it's the crocodile card like if something happens it causes you to discard your hand well that's about as brilliant of a mechanism

as I can think of right of marrying the the gameplay with the theme right it's like what a wonderful way and the more you can do that the more you can go you can go you can get players to go oh that's clever oh that makes sense oh that's really good the more they're gonna remember your game the more they're going to want to come back to it and the easier it is to learn the rules so tell me about that a little bit when you're designing one of these games it makes sense to roll a D6 when I'm shooting a six shooter gun duh you know and so what are some of the things you're thinking about as far as like making the game just easier to comprehend from this player experience from this very similar to kind of idea yeah um you know we spoke a while back and a lot of the when people think about themes sometimes they really think oh uh you know bear trash game or big simulation gamer there's just all this stuff in there maybe maybe it's loaded with a lot of um lore or maybe it's a loaded a lot of historic stuff to really create this whole systematic setting and um you know a little biased towards the Euro games and things like this I kind of look back at some of the simpler things where a theme or setting just assists uh what's going on so like the simple one is if you have a little unit that looks like a sailboat and you have a body of water on your board most likely people aren't going to go driving the sailboat across the desert part of the board to get to the next ocean right you can say well you know they carried it um it's one of those things where you know the metaphor is strong enough that people usually think the right units go

into their spots and there's there's a lot of ways to um Implement that and so I kind of look at rules overhead gets reduced when a lot of things just make sense thematically why they're doing what they're doing and uh as far as just simple ux stuff even if something doesn't really have a strong theme sometimes things will just um fit in a certain way where sometimes something is shows a lock on it and something else shows a key on it and maybe it's not a game about Dungeons and locks and keys and locksmiths or anything like that but the metaphor of the key and a lock these things go together in order to you know open something up is strong enough that you can use that iconography to communicate something now if the game also makes sense to have a actual like old school looking key on the chain and an actual lock over the top of say Treasure Chest something like that well that totally makes sense and it's like Yay where if I don't know if it was except in the far future maybe that lock looks more like you know some sort of weird box with glowy bits on it you have to insert some you know retinal scan or a microchip or something to unlock it and if we just showed like weird ambiguous box with like retinal scan icon you're going like I don't know like oh those open you'd have to have a rule that tells you this is a this is a locked case and this is the key where the metaphor is so strong with some of the simpler things and I think working in certain themes uh allows us to have that those tool kits available for

something like that if we we're building something in a space game I don't know if a hammer is just the same sort of workman's tool as it would be in like the game you know stone age or something where you know Hammer is just the thing and at some point you know we look at the the shape system these icons like the very infrequently do we have you know a telephone that actually has the earpiece and kind of looks like that but we still think um at least currently that that's the phone shape it's not the you know the earpiece in front of the mouth and holding the other to your ear it's kind of like the the one the one shape thing that we think about but a lot of times the phones are flat and this other sorts of things so it's like how do we communicate through icons the function of something and then is there a way within that game to still make it work so long story short I'm gonna look at really nuanced thing so there is a type of card in the game endless winter which is set in the paleo-american uh times and it's effectively like what we would think in a bulletin board or something like this that it's sticky you play this card and it stays in play and it doesn't go away when the rest of the cards in the game continually go away it would make perfect sense is the little thumb tack for a sticky Post in the Forum or anything like that it's like putting a thumbtack in this paleo-american just didn't make sense and so I talked to the artist graphic designers like well what if we take like a Tusk and it's been jabbed into something and the note is actually a

little piece of like hide that looks like a hide's been pinned up there so effectively that metaphor people are used to like something as sticky has been pinned to something has now been executed with materials that uh fit the theme of the game and didn't break that immersion because if I was like playing a Stone Age game all of a sudden I'm saying thumb tacks and jet packs and all kinds of things that don't make sense I go oh this makes sense for the ux but it doesn't make sense for my experience here and can you find a way to repurpose that almost like Flintstones these sort of thing to make it work in its uh gamery context as well as the Thematic setting and so that way it's it it worse you're just kind of like kind of stickering that oh it's it's funny that they did this thing you know the Flintstone cars you know there's no actual motor they're using their feet to do it but it effectively looks this way and sure they didn't do that but they could have and it's funny um at least you kind of get in there where it becomes funny instead of just like what you're talking about you break that immersion you step out you start questioning everything you start wondering what other Band-Aids are in this game due to mechanistic problems or ux hiccups that they couldn't get around or did they just phone the thing in yeah that's a good point and yeah I love that idea of first of all being being conscious as a game designer about ways to do this through graphic design through the art like it's not just the mechanism in like how the game is designed it's all these things working together and to really think about that and then realize sometimes you're just you're just not going to be able to figure it out either and sometimes you just kind of have to go this is this is okay I ran into a situation where I was

designing a game set in the 80s and I had this energy chart basically to say okay these are the dice that are available these are the dice that been spent and to represent that we had a full battery and an empty battery as the icons well after the game came out I had somebody send me a message and they're like hey you know this type of battery wasn't invented until like 1997 and it's like it for that one person it totally screwed up the immersion because like this game's not set in the 80s because they have an icon of the wrong kind of battery and I'm like my bad dude like I don't know like something sometimes you just kind of it's okay like just gotta let it go but um but it is something to definitely be aware of and to think about and to lean into as much as you can one thing one thing I want to go back and Circle back around to is this idea of fuzzy logic I think I think you mentioned this like even before we started recording of introducing these moments where it's kind of fuzzy and so tell me like what do you mean by fuzzy logic and how does that apply to your your game design for the player experience yeah so in mathematics is kind of a more you know fancy version of what fuzzy logic actually means in Wikipedia and people debate that but for let's just say for our purposes um we could kind of juxtapose that or compare it to maybe crunching something or with the you know oh this game is puzzling this game is crunchy and often what that times means is that there's a lot of figuring out of things you're just you're just going to go through this process and you will arrive at a sum and that sum is comparative to some other sum so you can actually say if I do this chain of actions and say a

dry run it and then I come out and say this is going to net me now five points if I've done this other chain of actions where I maybe maybe I set the set collect in uniform and that's giving me five points or a set collect in diverse sets oh that's going to net me six points and so you kind of look and go oh do the thing that gives me six points so there's really no contingency on whether which thing to do there's just whoever does the math slightly better cares about the small numbers and then adding up is going to be a better player at a game like that if we looked at introducing like a fuzzy scene in there it's kind of like what if I had a sure bet to get five points and a potential to maybe get four points but the potential to get six by doing this other thing that's kind of like swings a little bit there's still a floor but it swings a little bit or a lot like would I take five points now for sure or would I take zero or ten points later and so comparing those two things creates that sort of thing is that kind of fuzz comes in there where it's you're playing with a spectrum of what might actually work out and you look at trials what do I get one shot at this thing or do I get multiple tries to try to say let's say I have to find the other half of a treasure map in a deck of cards and I find the first half early in the game and I could think I have the entire rest of the game with many draws to try to find the second half of the treasure map and go okay that's a relatively safe bet versus doing something that's just you know finding a Doubloon a Doubloon one

at a time and just taking a sure bet uh because you're kind of gauging the overall length of the game and how many trials you're gonna have to find that thing and that's a very fuzzy sort of stuff and you could look at the psychology of what you might think it's like what if I found the first half of the treasure map on my last turn well you don't have another turn to do that so you know it's effectively worthless right and so then you roll it back one term before that you go like what's the odds if I find a relatively rare thing in a distribution on my penultimate turn and then the other half pays off on this should I take a safer bet at that point just opt for the yeah you know what I'm just gonna take the one to Bloon because I just don't think it's possible that I'm going to find the other half the treasure map with one more card draw it's that sort of thing so um one of my favorite answers when people say hey is this better and or is this better when they're asking a designer at the table or advice on something and you can just say well it depends and then you know they go well you know is there a hint you go yeah well this is the safer bed this one's a little riskier bet but there's a lot of stuff in between that where we look at the difference between uh utilities you know the capital u if we want to call it that way which just means um you know if if you're already Filthy Rich the utility of having a hundred dollars is just doesn't mean anything to you so you might be looking at something else if you're absolutely destitute a hundred dollars could mean a huge amount it could be the difference between you know surviving another day it's huge so

you look at the utility of something like that and you look at the utility of something more abstracted like um you know it is just getting more wood in the resource management game better at a point you go like I couldn't even spend all this if I tried by the time the game sent in versus saying having the opportunity to get less of that like well I could throw away two wood but I could take one stone for every two I throw away at the Surplus is that efficient you have to look at if we're just balancing the scales of just having more stuff is better yeah it's better to just have more stuff is that worth points do you win no and it comes back to having that valuation that I need Stone and wood in order to build this Castle um therefore my Surplus it's it doesn't matter if I'm doing inefficient things just to throw it away because I acquired it somehow in order to then build the thing that actually gets you the victory points and that sort of thing so that's where we have to look at a spreadsheet might just say what is evaluated at this and stone is valuated like this on a spreadsheet and so therefore if I say well if I have 10 wood then I've got 10 units of utility and if I have 10 stone I have 10 units it's like no because you need those things to happen let's say in relative parity that you need to have this path dependent needed wood and a stone or stone in the wood and repair to actually make the equation turn into spits out a victory point or Castle whatever it may be and so that's that kind of third thing I think that people don't really think about is do we just qualitatively look at how much is each of these units worth in relative

isolation or do we look at the fact that they have to be effectively set collected across different things and then transmuted and turned into something else then you look at other contingencies it's like sure if I save up all the resources early game or how many build actions do I actually get you go like oh there's only one build action I can only build one thing so I won't be able to do this or are the plots of land also being contested where it's like these plots of land require less more so if you do it early you're locking yourself in for a better position so you look at those other Vector which is like taking away this whole idea of just sitting here I'm going to balance the books between my wood investment my stone Investments like no look at all these things as a designer bring those other things in there on purpose you know create that uh you know how often can you actually build the things uh what are the interesting combinations what are the discounts what are the rebates you could get what are the other players doing to slow you down as far as getting that sort of thing can you aggregate a bunch of one thing and not worry about it while you then go and do the other things as quickly as you can all those decisions are what makes a game to me more of more of a game than let's say just a puzzle of acquiring the most things and um some games it's like money needs to be spent and then you see a game end so somebody goes gosh I came in last and I had this heap of gold it's like I know the heuristic is to you know Scrooge McDuck this and just keep a bunch of gold but the game actually wants you to spend it and you could have zero gold at the

game as long as you've acquired this other thing say victory points or the win state like I've built the thing that wins the game whatever that is to really encourage people to go that way and side tangent as I would say I would dangle carrots in order to make people do that versus punish them for Having excess gold which would be a stick or to systematically say um your piggy bank is full once you have 10 doubloons therefore you know your 11th and so on is is foregone and that would encourage people to not like hit their ceiling on that but ultimately it's administrative and frustrating has to be checked uh the punishment one makes people scared of the thing to acquire at the first place because they feel like going to oh you can eat sushi or something like this or if you don't finish that last roll they charge you for overage you're like oh it puts you in this whole dilemma versus just dangling the carrot saying like look all this awesome glory and stuff happens and player abilities and luck all the fun stuff happens when you build in this game so you know throw these cubes and doubloons away and go do the fun thing and explore and and have something in front of you that looks really exciting all those like soft incentives to do the fun thing that the game presents and see that the currency is just a means to do that and not get hung up on the fact that this currency just looks cool in the big pile in front of you yeah when I was designing the first hunted game or the first few hunted games one of them is inspired by die hard and what was so funny when I was watching play testers play it and I'm just kind of staring at them and I'm you know trying to figure out okay how are you going to handle

this based on how you probably should handle it based on how the game overall works and 100 of the time when somebody was playing the game for the first time they would play out these cards and they would push their luck too far and they would have to fight all these terrorists and they would just get wrecked and they wouldn't even come close to winning and they look at me and like I don't understand what I did wrong I'm like think about the movie Die Hard there was one hero and a hundred terrorists if he just goes in guns blazing he dies like you have to hide you have to like don't push your luck and all of a sudden you're fighting all these terrorists you're gonna get shot and then when they played the next go round now they're a little more cautious now they're hiding more now they're like getting cards out of the row faster and not running into as many combat situations and then they would either you know get they'd not necessarily win because there's still a few other things you get a comprehend the master but they would at least get a lot closer to winning it's like yeah like doesn't that make more sense and so I think like you're saying getting your game mechanisms even if a player gets to the end like Scrooge McDuck and they're like oh I lost it's like yeah you're you've got a hundred gold there if you'd spend all that you might have won uh but getting them to like at least with the second go round go ah okay yeah that that makes a lot of sense but one thing I want to go back to that you mentioned earlier the whole idea of okay I can take the safe bet or I can take the riskier one that gets me zero or gets me double what I love about that concept is that you are designing a game for multiple player types some people play it safe they're like I'm gonna try to win by doing the smart thing making a quote

unquote right decision but then other players like me are like I want to if I'm gonna win I want it to be cool like I want to win an interesting way I want to win you know because I I threw the Hail Mary at the end and you know there are only two turns left now I drew the map card and I'm like I'm gonna push my luck I'm gonna see if I can I've got one draw and see if I can find the other half of that map and if I do it's amazing it's a cool story it's a fun moment if I don't no worries it's just a game but um but you're designing games for different types of people and that way on game night when different types of folks are around the table everybody has something to enjoy everybody's having fun everybody has a story in a moment to remember I think that's just really smart as well and so Johnny this has been excellent any any kind of closing thoughts anything else you want to leave people with as far as things to think about designing and players experience um so what what are the things that I see at some Proto spiels and things like this which worries me a little bit is that there's a certain type of person sometimes a designer who thinks that the more determined things are is better because it can be thought about it can be solved and it's puzzly it's like this the better player will always win because it does show their skill without anything obfuscating what that skill could be which would be you know those random variances um I think that's a little bit of a straw man argument because like if we saw you at the say end of a game and we all knew that it would be a real tale event if you were to firstly draw the first say map segment and then also that the deck was shuffled or the dice were

rolled in such a way that you were able to find the second at the zero hour and we'd ultimately see that oh does that mean that less skilled you know the best skilled player one or whatever else it's like there's some insecurity there I think that that those players have where it's like no we can tell you're a very good player because you did do all these other things and the reason you lost this time was because the high variance outlier Funny Thing Happened it's like finding the golden ticket even though you didn't have nearly as many as verook assaults you know got the whole Factory looking for the golden tickets but you know Charlie just happens to open up the one that he saved up for and was given to him and that happened to be the golden ticket there it's that kind of thing where it's like we don't have to suddenly think like oh well you know does that mean Veruca Salt's not good at you know Finding golden tickets in a massive factory it's like no it just shows that tail event kids High variance events are generally recognized by players and it doesn't diminish the skill of players who can create that floor and that consistency and if they need to look at uh if they're you know ego is a little bit you need to be in check they can just kind of look look at repeated plays and you'll see that the skilled player will in fact win against these outlier events and so it's like it's true so we don't need to have a really deterministic game that has no dice no card draws zero luck everything is in the market is out front at the very start of the game uh it's fully understood and you know air quotes balanced by the designers and therefore it's just a competition of true skill versus skill

my argument is that you can bring it in fuzzy Lodge if you bring the dice bring in the cards bring in input Randomness output Randomness all that sort of stuff and as long as there's a transparency and understanding that what are those risks that you're taking is it uh you know is this down the middle or is this zero or double that risk that you're just describing there a few and the other players see that people are taking those risks and what the what the payoff Matrix is then that transparency right there to me justifies the whole process and ultimately allows you to have a more thematic enjoyable and interesting variable game than one that could be repeated if players were to say see the starting conditions and then repeat that same play with making maybe the only small tactical adjustments um so I'm big in favor of kind of loosening loosening up that fabric a little bit and bringing the people back into it and bringing the you know variable elements whether that's player uncertainty all the way down to die rolls and all these other things and again the difference between input and output Randomness is really just a matter of uh is it the right tool for the job I think output Randomness is fantastic for combat resolution I think input Randomness is wonderful for uh seeing a variety of choices that you could then respond to and build something make something out of and that everything in between makes sense too in the right context and just designed with that in mind and just know that none of these things are

behind glass heck go make a rolling move I'm sure in this day and age you can make a fantastic roll and move if you work it into the the theme the mechanistic supporting mechanisms would make that work so uh so don't don't don't uh don't think deterministic things are intrinsically better than things that have uncertainty decisions under uncertainty or risks are some of the most enjoyable things I think out there in games yeah absolutely I talked to James Earnest recently and one of the things he talked about is one of the main things that creates fun in games is surprise and really leaning into how can you utilize surprise in your games in the mechanisms because that's that's where a lot of like the oh wow kind of moments can come from and if everything's deterministic you don't have that surprise necessarily and so you're it's going to be a little bit harder to have like no no some people love that like to be fair like it's not like again don't do that it's what kind of experience are you going for and don't feel like you are stuck doing anything you can make anything you can make Randomness work for you even if the game is supposed to be more on the deterministic side as long as it's done well so I think that's something for for designers just to keep in mind which I'm excited for you man because you have a really cool project that you're working on and tell people about that because I can't wait to see what you're gonna do with it okay so this was uh so Gen Con is just starting at the 10 minutes recording and um this was just announced by Fantasia games the publisher that I am the internal game design developer for

um and a while back a little quick story into there we heard that the Wolfgang Cramer is the princess of Florence license was floating around and we asked if it was available and some other publisher had already gotten and so while we had Wolfgang Cramer was one of my favorite designers an incredible designer legendary um I always say had him on the line the email line we asked well do you have any other games and uh publisher wrote back says yeah I only had a few things available there's some Coliseum game uh from you know 2006 seven and I was like what and so at the time uh you know days of Wonder started that game and TMG uh did a version of it and then TMG since has folded and relinquished the rights to you know their catalog so it was back in uh Wolfgang Cramer's catalog to acquire and I was like oh my God please please please please can we get it and so the point was like all right you know we can look into making a cool version of this it's like the days of Wonder but better and bigger and all this and we can have a contemporary artists like we've been working with dimitro and let's see if we can make this thing work and so we negotiated for the rights which is really exciting just to know I'd be this kind of in the background helping pick out the specs of the new Coliseum of the art Direction and things that we can improve and having um really love that game and having both editions I could kind of see what can help push it along so that was super exciting and uh while we're at it um the publisher came up with this idea says hey you know how you know brass was

a classic game and they came up with flat brass uh Lancashire and Birmingham in this campaign they were kind of like selling these two games and one of them was kind of a they brought on Expert designer they redid a bunch of things and Birmingham is one of the highest rated games ever actually um so it's very very well received and the Lancashire is more uh akin to the original so they said what if we did something like that where we did like a Coliseum game that's a little bit more gamery a little bit more contemporary because the other one's you know 2007 release one sec and what what can we do with that so I wrote up a proposal to uh Kramer Marcus I said hey what would you guys think of you know doing this kind of like co-design thing where we'd come up with this idea and it would take some of the elements from Coliseum but it'd be more of a heavier crunchier contemporary Hero game what you'd expect from there and uh I remember like sending that email off and just like who am I kidding oh my gosh I'm just this upstart and there's these you know I'm sending a proposal to Wolfgang Kramer I'm just like oh and that that was like an uncomfortable 24 hours while I waited and I saw the email come back and he says oh this is this sounds really cool and interesting we love these ideas and then eventually leading to the contract which you know it's like I got to sign a contract with with Wolfgang and do this co-design and so we've just uh announced both those games uh today the Eno tools doing the graphic design and art Direction on both games uh the micho is doing the artwork on the original Colosseum which is going to

have cosmetic facelifts it's going to have some small rules upgrades and it's also going to have the original rules available in the box so people want to play like the straight as they love it know it version it'll be available in that box and then these will be kind of launched together next year as a big big campaign and we'll see how it does and I am super excited it's like working on one of my favorite games favorite designers and also get to be you know creative leg in that experience not just um you know proving the rulebook or something like that so it's really exciting yeah that's awesome dude I'm so happy for you really excited to see kind of how you bring this idea to life I think it's going to be a cool new version uh you know I love the old one it's one of the games that I cannot tell you how many times I tried to re-theme it and do like a do it in a different way right when I was first starting out in game design it was one of those it's like okay I want to do Coliseum but instead you're the you're the owner of a football team right so you're creating that I can't tell you how many times and so anyway I'm excited to see the new Direction and all of that but Johnny thank you so much for your time really appreciate you joining here on the show thanks for having me honest fantastic it's great talking to you foreign

Progress saved