Dinosaur World: Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and Brad and I are doing a discussion over Dinosaur World. Uh this was the secondary game that Pantosaurus made uh you know cashing in on the success of Dinosaur Island and we had previously played Dinosaur Island like literally before this one to kind of reintroduced the game so many years later and I can't remember when this one came out. Uh
yeah,
it was
maybe three four years after
2021. So this was four years. uh later or 4 years ago and um 4 years after Dinosaur Island came out and it was weird because whenever this one was introduced I feel like a lot of people were like really that was me that was me
like Dinosaur World okay no one and no one really likes the Jurassic World movies so what the hell are you doing and I remember whenever I had first played and I have reviewed this in the past so this is kind of a re re-re review. I felt that I was like, is this better than Dinosaur Island um back then? Cuz I Dinosaur Island was previously a 10. Um and how does this compare to that?
Brad, what do you think? What do you think about Dinosaur World?
It's new to me. You know, we we learned it and we played it and everything like that. And
um it actually was better than I thought it was going to be.
Yeah. I came in with pretty low expectations just because I like Dinosaur Island quite a bit and
and stuff and I wasn't really sure like how the, you know, the jeep moving around kind of stuff did and I I still don't even understand still like what that does. I mean the boredom
because it's like I was just going through them and I had three boredom on some of them and it's
Well, you should be losing boredom or not boredom, sorry. You should be losing in uh excitement.
Oh, okay. for visiting the same places over and over because it's it's 0 minus 3 is -3. So you lose excitement if you backtrack to
to places. Um
Gotcha. Gotcha.
So if what I'm saying is you actually don't have as high of excitement that means you don't have as much money. No, it's Yeah. So you're penalized for going to the same places over and over. really only in the in the aspect of you're not getting excitement and therefore you're not getting your as steady of an income,
right? Yeah. Cuz I there Yeah. So, um I feel like um you know there's some similarities, you know, the threat and the and the security is all the same.
Yep. It's interesting being able to lay out and create your own because you were so limited and dinosaur island is just that board and placing stuff in that grid. This one you can kind of
just spread out and then at midame you get you go out here and you can start building off your entrance.
They did a really cool thing with that where it's like the stuff that's at the very beginning is like people aren't as excited about but so then you get to go to the stuff you built further out. So, you're not like, "Well, I can't get my jeep level up, so I I only get to hit those areas once or twice." And it's like, "Nope. Halfway through the game, you get to hit the new stuff, right?" Um, I also feel cuz whenever I first play this, I was like, "Ah, okay. It's pretty similar to Dinosaur Island," or I felt this was a lot easier to jump into if you had played Dinosaur Island. We literally have played them back to back. And while Dinosaur Island is still great, I actually think I like this more than than Dinosaur Island, having having just played them one after the other because it does a few things for me. It does a more interesting aspect of the worker placement of the unique colors actually mattering where they go.
I like the micro level of your uh theme park. Uh, one, it has art on each one. So, it's not just some like pulled out view where you're really just your source of income is how many people you can attract from drawing from a a a patron bag
and moving around. Like we were talking more about like our thematic element of our theme park than we just did with Dinosaur Island where it was like I don't know, I have I have two orbs. It's like here it's like yeah I only have a Stegosaurus and uh Triceratops and Velociraptor but here's more Tyrannosaurus Rexus but you're actually kind of visiting them. So it's it feels like a more thematic experience. Um I also think you have a lot more player agency whenever you're doing stuff. you're you can actively go out and get get money if you visit your restaurant that takes up one of your very limited Jeep spots, but you kind of get to design the route to help you for the next for the next round. Um, and it's a fixed number of rounds,
right? Oh, and I was going to say the I think my favorite difference with this from Dinosaur Island is the cards at the beginning of the round,
the worker down
the draft and you get to
pick what
what color workers you're getting.
Y
at the start of the round. That was one of the things that was nice cuz you know I always tried to get a yellow so I can do some of my security stuff and
and you know and there's a power it seems to be a power spot for each color
except for white
it gives yeah white's kind of your generic uh ones that can go to pretty much anywhere in your own like private actions but then all the all the actual tiles are hypersp specific to to certain ones and it's very simple. They're just extremely colorcoded, but you can kind of set those workers off to the side because you're like, "This is the route I'm taking. This is who I who I'm going to need."
Uh, and then it it like I like the simplicity of not having to upgrade your uh your paddics, like your tiles. It's like each tile can hold up to four, but then you could see on it, okay, these this is the generic ones I need, but to create a third one, I need this many. But that's going to bump up your threat. One thing I think is kind of weird though is based off the rules when you go and visit a tile that has multiple um you think you'd roll a dice.
Yeah, you think you'd roll a dice m like per dinosaur that's in there. But unless I'm completely missing it um
cuz you'd think it'd be more of a threat having more.
Yeah, there's more in there. But it just says when you activate a dino paddic, you must make a danger roll to see danger roll if you see any accidents happen. Um, yeah, and roll it once. Even if multiple dinos are present, only roll one die.
Interesting.
Uh, so that's that's kind of weird, but it's there's a I remember you saying whenever we were whenever I was teaching you this game, you were like, "This seems like it's going to be more convoluted."
Do you still think that?
No. No. I I it just looking at it, there's a lot of icons
on here that is different, you know, and stuff. And that's what I was kind of
picturing. But no, it wasn't once you started playing it.
I can see why I would, though, cuz it's like, oh, now there's different colored workers. Great. All those workers do something different. Oh, now there's all the It's like, well, yeah, you don't have specialists um anymore, which those specialists are kind of cool. I love the fact that there's no limit to your DNA where you don't have to worry about increasing it. You can just, you know, eb and flow. It feels like they made it a lot easier to create dinosaurs. You don't have to work as hard. Yeah, cuz I mean the I don't know what your T-Rexes were, but my Giganosaurus took five.
Um, but my first three spots didn't have an extra payment.
Oh, wow. So, it was just I just had to pay those five each.
Five? Yeah. Mine was four and then first spot didn't cause one, then it cost another cost two, then two.
Yeah. Uh, so I like the fact that and I mean just from an an aesthetic point of view, all the dinosaurs are screen printed.
Uh, I know some people probably don't care with Dinosaur Island having the pink where it's like, ah, whatever, just put them in there. But if you do care, if you want to get into the theme, even on the back of the rule book, it tells you which ones they are, so you can find the ones that you need. And then for all the different ice or for the different packs, the water water pack, hybrid pack, and ice pack, they also already have it on the right on the base rule book. Um, so yeah, I just think I think that it's really cool that instead of just having dinosaurs and then kind of generic attractions where either they give you points or money, here all the special buildings are unique and individual. And like there was times where I was really trying to counteract my threat that I was like, man, do I go for that phone booth? Cuz if I go to the phone booth, I can give up one uh I give up one excitement for a point or four excitement for four points. Uh I don't know. Um, so yeah, it it just really kind of gives you of a more dinosaur park feel, which is weird because I feel like Dinosaur Island captured that that theme really well.
Are there uh any negatives or things about this that you didn't like compared to Dinosaur Island? Um, not really particularly. I mean, there was there's just as many things like this is almost an equal comparison. Yeah.
To the other one, you know, where there's things that I like about Dinosaur Island, there's just many things I like about this,
you know, and everything. So, um, which which is a surprise for me because I didn't want to have anything to do with this game when that came out because I was just like, it doesn't make,
you know, and then any of the podcasts I listen to wholeheartedly think that the first one island is better
cuz they didn't like the whole Jeep stuff. But
I'm 100% convinced that they uh they didn't play Dinosaur Island in years,
but but playing it now, you know, it makes sense and stuff like that. So,
so
I like it. I like cuz I always like spatial awareness games like Yeah, it's kind of cuz with Dinosaur Island, you just draw from a bag and it's like, okay, I drew 15 yellows. I got 15 15 points and I'll just slot them in and okay, that's eight points and all right, moving on. Here, it just feels it is a lot more involved. So, it kind of depends on if you want a more complex game, even though I wouldn't really say this game is any more complex. Uh, but you want a more involved game. Your your Jeep placement matters. It's not like you just do a whole blanket of whatever's in your park. It all goes off. Uh, I personally do enjoy that. Now, the boredom part that is fiddly as [ __ ]
Yeah. and should have been done better either with dice cuz when you're looking at it cuz I was sitting here and I was like, "Oh, there's not that many ones." And then I realized, "Oh, you only ever need four of a number cuz you can only ever visit four locations at max."
Mhm.
Um but it's just kind of like it's so fiddly and sometimes if you forget to increase it or it's like wait does it does it increase now or when does it increase? It's like, well, first you get your excitement and then then you up up update the number. It would have been just so much easier to give everyone little dice.
Yeah. Well, and you know, in compare in comparing the two games again, I still even though this isn't this is not difficult at all,
I still like the teaching approach that the first game that Island does,
being able to teach each separate phase,
you know. Um, this one wasn't hard by any means, but I could see this being a,
you know, if nobody's played Diner Island or if you're just jumping down to sit down and they're not like super heavy
gamers, this is going to they're going to glossy eye a little bit.
Yeah. No, I I do 100% agree. Like the teaching aspect of Island just works better for teaching. But this is actually the game. My friend who didn't like the four segments of Dinosaur Island, he liked this one because it was just but he was also
I mean his favorite game that he plays every [ __ ] month is TI. He's he's uh he plays these heavy games. So this the teaching approach just feels a little more natural to a board game than like okay here's phase one and then here's phase two.
And then whenever you hand someone a million different player raids,
uh the player raids are are nice, but I I'd rather just have one sheet. give me give me a sheet of a player rate for everyone. Uh the the only negative and it's not even like that big of a negative but something to be aware of is and this is the same issue in um Dinosaur Island was your threat to security. But in Dinosaur Island you had a much more static level of your threat to security ratio. here. Uh it is you can have a static threat increase, but it can also be extremely random because I guess your threat going up, your threat to security difference doesn't matter in terms of you consistently losing points. You get now death tokens.
And what these death tokens do is they just kind of stay there. And at the end of the game, uh you take whoever has the least amount and uh and that person loses all of them. And then every other player removes as many as they removed. And then you see based off a scale how many victory points you have.
In a two-player game, if one person just does not gain threat or any death tokens, it's a it's a swing.
Yeah. Cuz you were way ahead of me and then you lost 24 points.
Yeah. On that
and there's literally nothing I can do about that.
Right. So that is annoying because again it's not like it's not for you lack of gaining threat. It's that you literally just rolled a red die and it's like oh blank. Oh blank and then I go with a with a green die and I and yeah. So it's like oh hey Stegosaurus. Okay. and then do it again and it's like it was and now it's blank. But both times the the death tra it's like okay and there's no way to remove them.
Mhm.
Like where's my [ __ ] PR guy? Where's my where's my uh my lawyer area where I like and this is where we settle all the lawsuits about all the child deaths that we had. Um because I mean for example if those two rolled my way that's a six-point swing, right? So, and I worked my ass off to e to even out my thread. Like, I totally understand going to the Raptor Culinary Experience because I'm getting five points every time I go there and in cost of a threat. I didn't get the security until way late where it was probably too late. I fully accept all that. My issue isn't necessarily with any of that. It's with the dice.
Mhm. Um because and I would fully if it was like each location, hey, you're going to a Gigantosaurus exhibit. There's three of them. Roll that three times. If it came up blank each time,
that's just the way it is. But if I go to my T-Rex and then it's like two, two, two.
Okay. Or even you go to your Gigantosaurus, it's blank. I go to my T-Rex and it's blank. Lucky. But it could be a two and it's like that's six points. I'm losing.
At least you got the objective.
Yeah, that was seven points. Uh, wish I could have done it again, but you get what I'm saying where it's like
I like the static nature of like
you just lost the victory points per
threat you couldn't
per threat. And in a Yeah. And in a two-player game, it's even worse because like chances are in, you know, if we had a third person or fourth person, chances are they're going to get some [ __ ] threat. So then all like if oh, you know, third person had two um and you had one, it's like, okay, you lose one, everyone else loses one. Cool.
In this particular I I I don't lose three points,
right? it it could be kind of annoying when you look back on the whole experience. It's like, huh? So, it really was completely random on why why I lost that many points or if there was a way to remove it. Why is there not like a where? Yeah,
I just looked at all the
I have to see if there is one.
I have not. Maybe it's in the expansion in some of the packs. Oh, hey, you can do a T-Rex jet ski. You ride on a T-Rex and and get on a jet ski.
I really don't think there are any. Yeah, I just any ways to remove threat.
Resort would have been nice. You pay 10 10 coins to get five points.
Um cuz some of these are double. Uh
okay. Yeah.
In here, but nope. No. No. In the base game, no base game way of removing of removing threat
cuz I never played this game at two,
right? I've only ever played it, funny enough, at four. Uh, and I guess the other pseudo negative is this is a 4x6 table. Four people playing this game.
It's insane. It's It is such a stupid table hog for I mean, I guess I'd rather have massive tiles than really dinky ones.
But yeah, to try and get four people to play this game, it's like everyone's like in the corner like, "Okay, don't here's the divide. Like, here's where my park is." the game ends quick enough that your your uh tiles don't sprawl out too much, but it is it's a very busy one. Um, other than that, yeah, the threat, which is not even really like a hard negative, where like enchantments of Midgard with the shame tokens as a two-player game, basically makes that game unplayable. Here, it's like, ah, okay. Well, that's kind of annoying that it is based off random dice. Uh, hell, I don't even know why they made it to where like the red is still like 5050 blank.
Yeah.
You know, it's like I almost would have preferred like Yeah, green, they're herbivores. They're probably going to accidentally kill you. So, the the two, you know, one out of three chance is fine. Maybe have it like two blanks on the on the purple and then one blank on the red. So,
well, then they'd probably be so much death that everybody would max out their scale. Yeah, you have three Gigantosauruses in a [ __ ] behind a a chainlink fence. Like, of course you're gonna [ __ ] get some deaths. The movies are they're all like everyone dies all the time. Um, but yeah, other than that, I think that all the changes that they did make uh are kind of an improvement for the most part. What do you think about the excitement level resetting every single time? I guess that's kind of handinhand with the boredom.
Well, because the excitement level gives you income. Yeah, it makes sense to bow back because you get
I mean the excitement level in the other one kind of gave you income because it was based off how many people you drew from a bag.
So if my excitement level always stayed 10, that's pretty much on average 10 I'm getting.
Yeah. Uh because I'm always drawing from out of a 70 to 10 bag.
Yeah. I think with it just being a five round game
Mhm.
I think cuz like Dinosaur Island could go on forever
if you have if you're playing the long game and it goes until the objectives are all met except for one. Yeah.
This one's a static five rounds. So,
I don't mind it that much cuz it's it's wanting you to, you know, go to places that are
that you haven't touched in a while,
right? Or
it actually incentivizes you cuz it's kind of weird whenever you have the the ones that give you static points like the veloc the raptor culinary. It's like, oh, every time I go there, that's five points. But that's not getting me a bunch of excitement, which is not getting me a bunch of money anymore because it's like really where like it's like whenever you go to Silver Dollar City too much or the Renf Fair, you're like, I [ __ ] hate this place.
You guys want to go uh hit up Oh, what's um there's like whatever some generic restaurant is at the It's like, God, I don't want to eat there again. I hate this place.
I want to go eat at the Lord's Prayer. Yeah, it's so that's and I do like the boredom idea because it makes thematic sense. I just think the tokens themselves are fiddly.
Yeah.
So, you're incentivized to go visit and it's like, okay, you're wanting to build more raptors cuz you get immediate victory points anyway. Or not raptors, dinosaurs. And then now, hey, there's three T-Rexes here. That's going to be three, four, five, six, seven excitement. But then they also kind of limit you on where you can place the dinosaurs because you can't have them back to back.
Yeah.
U which I think was also a thematic element because you never really see at a zoo,
right?
Like here's the cheetahs and Oh, well there were goats here, but I guess Oh, there they are. They're in the cheetah exhibit.
Big pile of [ __ ] There's some hooves.
Some horns.
Yeah, we we have to buy more goats. The cheetahs keep killing them. it. I think they did a really good job at capturing a lot more thematic atmosphere than in in a in a natural gameplay sense than the idea of like what Dinosaur Island brought. Um, and then they have the uh expansion packs which uh throws in the ice age. So they have uh of course new tiles. I haven't I can't I think I've played with the water pack before that adds an algae so you have to clean like I think the algae What does the algae do it? Um Oh, you have to make an algae roll and then it reduces excitement.
Gotcha. um for your algae. But then so that adds in the aquatic ones and then the ice age pack and then the hybrid pack where it's like a mix where they count as like two different types. Interesting. So and then that actually includes there's a jeal where you have to where you roll a yellow dye and then the ice age adds another die as well. So I haven't play I'm pretty sure I've played with the water pack before but I don't think I've played with the other ones. I actually kind of like these a little bit where it's like, oh, let's throw in the Ice Age. It's just a little small addition. Not going to over like overload, but it might show up.
You got anything else?
I don't think so.
Well, on a scale of 1 to 10, what do you give in Dinosaur World? And do you like it better or worse than Island or the same? I'm actually I was kind of messing around with what I was going to give this. Um, and what I came down to was there's there's a like the things that Dinosaur Island has that I like.
Mhm.
And then there's several things in this that I like better than that, you know.
Um,
they're both different enough that you can have both of them.
Yeah. you know, that was one of the reasons I didn't do it either because I was like, if it's pretty much just going to be pretty similar to that, but they got enough changes.
Um, yeah, because I remember when this came out, they were both in my top 100,
right?
And then I think I eventually merged them,
right?
Like the following year, I was like, "Okay, they're kind of pretty much the same." And then I think last year or maybe the year like what they've kind of fallen off cuz I had touched them in so long.
So I gave Dinosaur Island an eight.
Mhm. Um, I'm probably I'm probably going to give this an eight also. Yeah. Just because there's enough things that it changes and makes better.
Yeah.
You know, and but there's some things I still like Der Island better.
Mhm.
But I think they're pretty much equals. I think
it is a weird kind of situation that they did because
like you just said there's there's positives and negatives to each and it's kind of what kind of game are you looking looking to jump into and if you own Dinosaur Island and you've kind of always eyed world it's like well is it worth owning it if you don't own either which one do you get because most people are I mean dinosaur it's kind of like dinosaur island came first so therefore it's better that's not always True.
There's many, many instances of, "Hey, you were the first to do it. Great on you." Like Seventh Continent, hey, you were first to do it. Great on you. Every other game that's done that map system has always done it better,
right?
So, but this is from the same company.
Mhm.
And it's not like a mechanism. So, it's like, man, why did you make two dinosaurs?
I think it's I think
it just depends on your play group which one you go.
Yeah. Yeah.
Like if they're earlier gamers, like ones that don't like the heaviness as much, then island's probably better cuz it's easier to teach.
Yeah.
And stuff. I mean, once you get once you get the hang of this, this isn't any more difficult. You know, it's just
I think the teach is what it comes down to and what your group what style of group you are. Yeah.
If they get overwhelmed easily,
Dinosaur Island's easier because it they can take it a piece at a time.
Yeah. You know,
and I think I remember my ex-wife when we played this, I made the comment to in that review of like, well, this one felt extremely natural to jump into, and she was like, well, you've played Island, so things are just going to think that would confuse people on security and threat and DNA and all that. That would be like, uh, I don't know what this is. Makes sense because it made sense in Island.
Not giving her any credit though. So, I'd call I'd call them equal, you know, like for,
you know,
for different reasons, but I think they're
Yeah.
It's just so bizarre cuz I'm sitting here and I'm like I I'm giving Dinosaur Island a nine. And that's what I gave it last time, uh, funny enough. And this kind of from playing them back to back cuz I was living off the 10 that I gave Dinosaur Island, which I bumped it down to an eight. here. I'm like, I think it does enough without it does more without making it like gh this is such an ordeal. And also, it's kind of at that point where it's not it's a little easier to set up. I mean, I have a wooden insert that I'm going to replace with a 3D insert, but it's in a box,
so I'm like, "Oh, okay, cool. It's right on the shelf. I know I can get it." I mean, even though I got this out an equal amount of time as Dinosaur Island in the Wooden Crate, which was never, it's I I I think it captures a lot more of of the feel and the theme that I'm I'm kind of wanting. So then I come conflicted of like, well, I do still really like Island and they're doing a a revamped version, so do I even bother or do I just stick to this one? But you're right, they're different. Mhm.
It's not like this is a better island,
right? Right. They're different games. Totally.
You know what? You know who really gets credit? Oh, this has Brian Lewis on it. The principal from uh American Dad. Uh but I don't know who the other two.
Yeah. So, so what's his name? Didn't have a foot in the in this one.
But who really deserves credit? It's not Brian Lewis, even though he was involved in both. He actually probably does deserve credit. is they found some way to capitalize on the dinosaur theme park theme and not make either of them obsolete,
right?
Like that's actually incredibly impressive cuz you could you can only say, "Own both." And they're like, "Yes, own both, you [ __ ] idiot. Buy both of our games cuz they're so radically different from one another yet so like the same."
Mhm. Even though I can't pinpoint to, well, this game does this better than the other one.
Right.
They're different. They're just different
with the same theme.
Yeah.
You know,
from the same company and I guess the same designer, at least one of the same designers,
right?
Yeah. It's It's weird. I I fully expected to revisit this, you know, four years later and be like, "Yeah, you know, it it kind of doesn't work." Um, I think I think uh I think island's better. And now it's like hm shocker. This one is slightly better by a point.
By a point.
I got a nine.
Oh, okay. Cuz you
No, I'm not talking about the point you won.
Island. I thought you were talking about island a nine cuz I forgot you gave it an eight.
Yep. Island got an eight. Uh and and this one got a nine.
Yeah. Uh, but I mean, we'll see in um in like five years whenever they do a revamped dinosaur world and it's it's magnetized.
Wasn't that what uh isn't it coming in that Kickstarter?
Dinosaur Island. No, Dinosaur Island's just getting the revamp.
I thought it was both of them. I thought you get both of them together.
It's uh I think that's the Totally Liquid expansion.
Oh, okay. I forgot.
I mean, if it is both I thought it was both of them put together.
Maybe it is. Uh I apparently I might know. I thought it was just both. like 150 for two games.
I thought I could have sworn that was just the base and the expansion.
I don't know. If it is both, then great. That'd be cool.
So, so yeah, no definitive answer on which one you should get. Uh which one is better. Although I think a lot of people would probably just tell you island's better. Uh but I mean, if you're looking at if you care at all about BGG rankings, Dinosaur Island has a 7.5 and World has a 7.3. So they're pretty much they're pretty much the exact same. Now I guess the biggest difference
between that is world has 4.3,000 rankings and island has 17,000 rankings.
So the overall average are going to give island a better a better score.
Yeah.
Um but the 17,000 is also it's an older game and most people aren't updating their their rankings. Uh, again, that's if you care about BG rankings at all.
Right.
Um, you got anything else?
I don't think so. I think that takes care of everything that I was thinking of.
Sweet. Well, that is it everyone. That's our thoughts on Dinosaur World. Let us know what you think of the game in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.