Skip to main content
Loading video...

Gears of War: The Board Game | Solo Thoughts | Worth it 10+ Years Later?

Transcript 23:07

is Gears of War the Dark Souls of solar board gaming Dungeon Crawlers I'll let you decide but the answer is yes hey man let's go see what the cogs are doing yeah all right sounds like a great idea hey Phoenix what's up give me some skin man yeah like you guys never hang with us anymore what's with that all board the C train baby hello everyone welcome I'm Robert and today I'm going to discuss Gears of War the board game and uh this uh board game has been a main state of uh The People's Choice top 200 solo games uh even as far back as the first time the uh voting took place the the first time was in 2014 and uh this made it to number six back then and ever since it it's pretty much stayed on the list uh since and because uh it's out of print unfortunately uh it's been uh it's been getting knocked back consistently every year just the AV the availability is not there uh this uh copy I I got a copy that the box was a bit busted but all the components were still in shrink wrap so that was great not for a bad price either um and my experience with the game so far has been uh has been uh the first three scenarios uh and I played uh almost all of them one handed and then

the last time I played here uh you can see this is the belly of the Beast scenario uh my last attempt fail attempt here I played two-handed uh for the first time uh and uh I want to discuss first of all uh the the difficulty here so um the the game is pretty brutal uh I I only won the first scenario um uh the emergence scenario Ario which is pretty much like an intro scenario just playing with one character uh but then after that every time I played I've been destroyed uh I I tried D got me started on the emerging scenario where you have to deal with the Berserker Beast uh I played that multiple times and yeah I got destroyed every time I got far farther and farther into the scenario every time I did learn things but um I just got a bit frustrated I moved on to next scenario and see if it was just going to be difficult as well uh this B of the be scenario was also pretty tough and uh yeah I just got destroyed uh playing solo and two-handed as well okay uh so yeah that was my experience pretty brutal uh I I'll talk a bit more at the end about that but uh now I want to discuss the the systems okay uh so uh this I I really like the system that this game has with the card play okay how your hands are your actions uh sorry

your cards and your hand are your actions and your health okay uh so uh this is not like a deck builder or anything like that it's it's a it's pretty much a a Dungeon Crawler and as far as translations from the video game go uh which uh I've only played the original Gears of War the first one I never played the others um I I think it adapted really well uh the cover system uh the the Tactical moving around uh and getting out of cover and shooting um it it translates those uh mechanics beautifully uh into board game form uh and I do enjoy the system here a lot um the cover is a the cover uh is a bit fiddly to learn initially how line of side works not cover sorry how line of side Works took a bit to wrap my head around that um but uh yeah the system here works great uh the rules they're they're okay I uh they were not the easiest uh to this game is not something that you're going to learning like uh uh half an hour is is not going to be a quick tolearn game there's it's very different from any other uh game I've played um it's it's pretty different from any other game I've played okay uh so it definitely took a bit of work um internalizing this uh it's pretty unique uh so even with all the games I have under my my belt uh you know this laid into the game me uh playing this it took

me some time to internalize it okay uh but uh very very fascinating uh system uh with uh the your uh hand acting as your not I think I earlier I said the deck your hand acting as your character's Health okay uh characters have six uh hand uh size of six um Marcus uh has a hand size of seven uh when you get hit you hit discard cards from your hand and if you go to zero you die okay if you run out of cards in your hand all right so I love that very interesting add tension uh then there's the um multi-use cards okay uh so uh when uh in in here you have your player face where you do you play cards and move around and shoot and then there's the enemy AI phase where uh you flip AI cards and the enemies in the map will act okay and during that phase uh you can use some of these cards uh in the corner there uh for example this one you can discard it uh to attack enemies and interrupt them okay so you get a chance of attacking uh during the enemy acting okay so that's pretty interesting and then you can discard cards to roll extra Defense die and you can also during your turn you discard this card to uh with with this corner uh cards with this corner uh this icon to uh move after another um uh player uh uh miniature move so it's like you can follow them you get a free move by discarding that

card okay um now in Solo there are a couple rules changes okay uh so like this you basically get an extra move uh you know there's no need to having another Minature uh so that that's one interesting thing this game does by the way it allows you to play Pure solo not a lot of Dungeon Crawlers work really well like that um I'm going to say that I um I wasn't too happy with how could be playing pure solo okay I think that that added to the difficulty of how tough it was uh I was just a bit um I got a bit carried away with the idea that I could play this completely solo and I just tried to make that work uh but it looks like most people tend to from what I read most people tend to um most people tend to uh land on playing two two-handed which takes a bit more upip but it's not too bad and that's to be the more balanced Sweet Spot all right uh so that you because the thing is if you're playing solo once you your character bleeds out AKA when you run out of cards it's over right uh you lose the game now when you play with two characters and while one character is bleeding out the other character can go and revive them okay so there's a more there's a bit more tactics there okay and being able to spread your two Miniatures around the map and um and uh you know complete objectives or distract the enemies like when you're playing solo all the enemies are going at you so it can be pretty

tough okay uh it's not impossible I I have you know I've read that people have beat it but it's it's just very tough as you can see there's definitely a theme of the game being very tough all right um I really like the AI system here too by the way uh it's uh very it's very quick you just flip an AI card and it'll there's some General events okay that affect multiple enemy types but then uh each enemy type has um each enemy type has a number of AI cards that you Shuffle into the deck so the scenario the scenario setup will tell you um uh which enemies will be in this map and you just set them up at the beginning okay and then you gather their AI cards and you shuffle them into the scenario uh into the uh AI event or card the AI deck uh and then some general events that the um that the scenario setup will instruct you to shuffle into the deck okay so uh yeah you just flip AI cars you follow instructions there there will be some instances where you're going to be flipping multiple AI cards uh because the prompt will tell you okay uh if this if this isn't true then do this if this isn't true then do this and you're there's going to be many times where you're going to be flipping multiple AI cards and there are some AI cards that are just really mean where uh the AI will do something and it'll just tell you to draw another card it's like in Lord of the Rings when you have search

it's like this bad thing happens and they just keep it can just stack and you end up drawing a bunch of AI cards that that can happen too okay so I I mentioned that I I wanted to discuss the difficulty um again all right because I I keep mentioning it uh so uh I I'm I don't mind difficult games uh the problem with this is that um I I have felt that there were scenarios especially when playing pure solo which I mean the game does offer the option right so that's assume you know you you pick the option to play with just one character assuming that it's viable to beat and I'm sure it is it's just that many times where when I played um I just felt that even if I did everything right I was going to get destroyed um so uh now okay fine I get destroyed I'll just play again the problem is that the the the game is not exactly a breeze to set up I'm not going to I'm not going to go as far as saying that it's a pain to set up it's not a pain to set up but it's it's slightly fiddly to set up and to reset so when you die um when you die and sometimes it can be just so sudden that like you plan your turn uh and you know you do the best that you can at that with in in that situation and you just get destroyed regardless and some people will say uh you know it it's fun to lose in this game I can see that the game is very thematic okay uh it it tells

stories of of you know the scenarios will will play out in different ways with the tiles coming out differently the enemies coming out differently so there there's V variability there and the scenarios won't play the same every time necessarily and it does tell stories I can picture this being great uh with a playing with a buddy M multiplayer but um it it's just so sudden sometimes when you lose and when I play with the two characters uh two-handed uh once a character is hit like if if the d u you know are not in your favor and and and you're head and you discard a bunch of cards I felt that I was on life support uh and until I you draw a card that allows you to uh you know refill your hand which there it's far and few between uh this is like one of the uh you know this card is pretty precious because it allows you to refill your hand uh at at the right time right because sometimes it's going to be useless if if you're doing pretty well but this card allows you to refill your hand and skip the enemy activating that turn which is insane this card is pretty powerful at the right time when you're bleeding out when you're like about to uh uh you know when your character is about to be uh killed or or put in bleeding out okay situation uh so uh but but yeah I I I got myself in this scenario which I lost okay Belly of the Beast so I I got myself in a situation where one character gets hit really bad

by an attack and he's like on life support and then the other characters bleeding out and it's like I can't even go rescue the other guy because you you need to discard a card in order to revive your your buddy so uh it's just very very tough and again I don't mind tough games um uh to to an extent of I wish there was a official way of adjusting difficulties some people have uh which I I read what people were doing to um you know see if they could improve their experience some people just house rule it I don't like house ruling uh I've explained that in other videos so there's not really a way of adjusting uh difficulty officially so you just have to keep um you know learning the nuances and playing and playing over and over again until you learn the right tactic for each scenario which is all right uh I just sometimes I don't feel like getting my ass kicked when playing games just that simple okay and uh there was a whole lot of get me getting my ass kicked in in this game all right uh I wish there was a way of adjusting difficulty officially and um there there Ison and yeah the scenarios uh there's there's this card in particular that is just it's just brutal uh in the belly of the Beast scenario uh let me show you firefight yeah so if you threw this card at the the wrong time no matter what you did uh it it's over uh like your character just would get uh piled on and attacked a whole bunch um and you know I I learned that you're

supposed to like you know keep at uh uh you know pay attention to the this card pile you know you learn that as much very early on but even then remember there's going to be times where you draw a bunch of AI cars because the the stat of the board state will you know that's just going to be the board State you're going to draw an AI card and it'll just tell you to draw another one and another one because there's none of the options apply so even if this isn't even if you only have a couple cards left on the draw pile and this is in the discard pile you're going to you're going to have a false sense of safety because oh okay I already Drew this I don't have to worry about it but the last time I lost the um the china shop scenario that's how I that's how I lost because this was on the Discord pile I only had like a couple cards left I passed I I wasn't my character wasn't cover I thought I was safe but then you know I drew a bunch of AI cards like five in a row and I had to reshu the the AI deck and this was the last card that came out like I thought I was safe from this card but I wasn't so uh yeah just uh this card is just like Game ending uh and uh yeah it just feels like it ends so suddenly there's like no um there's no gradual like you in the two player game yeah it feels like a bit more gradual your downfall of like your characters bleeding out not drawing not being able to recover just getting attacked constantly uh that feels like a bit more gradual at least but in Solo

like just all of a sudden you even if you a full card of hands a full um hand of cards you're you can just get destroyed uh out of nowhere like that okay uh so uh that's to say with all of that that uh I think I'm done with this game for now I'm not going to I'm not I'm not going to go as far as um I'm not going to go as far as like trading it or giving it away I think I just need to be in the mood for this game because this game just I I love the system it's just the difficulty that I have an issue with okay it's just very very tough uh and like I said sometimes I'm just not in the mood for like getting uh you know getting my ass kicked b game constantly I'm just not in the mood for that uh I do I don't enjoy games that are like uh too easy either or that don't have interesting decisions this game is full of interesting decisions and the system is solid the system is sound I love the AI I love the weapon the ammo system the cover the the the action cards like I said the multi-use cards um the characters how they all have differences u i i i love the system it's just the difficulty I have an issue with the theme is great it's a great video game translation uh because like I said I've played that original game and I feel like I'm playing the video game in board game form so it's a it's a uh it's a brilliant translation from the video game so just kudos to the work done translating the video game uh the dice can be a bit of a the dice can be a bit of a roller

coaster for sure uh sometimes you'll roll like five defense dies and and you'll discard a card uh to try to you know as a hell um uh you know uh in order to try to uh not take as much damage or or die but even when you roll five defense dies you only roll like one okay like one defense and yeah you have you do have to roll if if you um just roll a result if you roll more than that okay um but uh yeah so the I'm not going to go as far as like giving uh putting this uh game on up for tread or anything I'll come back to it at some point um and I'll I'll give it another shot uh it wasn't the easiest to learn either it's not the easiest to set up but I think it's once you learn it uh and you have your cheat sheit written down like I I don't think I'm going to have a a hard time coming back and playing it again I'll definitely give this another shot and after that if it doesn't work then yeah I'll think about like trading it but this is such a beloved game that I had to try it at some point even with the I paid a bit of a premium for it now there's one other interesting thing I want to discuss and it's the fact that at the time that this came out uh there was a bit of a debate going on uh between people comparing this to uh Dungeons and Dragons uh The Dungeons and Dragons Adventure system okay and I have another video coming up on this because this was one of the first solo board games I had in my collection it's like

with within the first 10 or 20 that I bought uh and I liked it at the time I ended up trading it but then it recently came back okay within the past month I bought this again uh and I started reading the forums on it right cuz I just saw other people playing it on on uh uh the one player Guild on the one player Guild uh uh Sol uh games on your table and I kind of missed it's like man like U um I I I I'll discuss in detail in in that video why I gave it away or traded it back then but I was like man I kind of miss that game so I required it and come to find out uh yeah at the time when these two games Gears of War and this system was out and they were popular there was a debate on people like uh which Dungeon Crawler which solo Dungeon Crawler should you pick okay this or Gears of War um and I found it very interesting even Tristan Hall before he uh dedicated to game design he was there you know pitching in his opinion about um about which game he enjoyed more and um and on one Camp you have people saying that this game has like zero tactical elements and it's like just completely random versus this is like the superior game because it's like more tactical there's like more tough decisions and um and it it almost felt like a console war like Xbox versus PlayStation or something like that I

found it very amusing but uh well um I'm going to let you know that I have had a lot more fun revisiting this game I've played it a ton more compared to Gears of War Gears of War uh having you know with how much I kept losing uh it I just I did not look forward to repeating playing scenarios here as much as I did when I reacquired this game because it you know this all happened while this was still on my table okay I'm just playing it on a separate table but I ended up enjoying this a whole lot more and playing it a whole lot more in between and there's a video coming up about that but uh you know uh that I don't know what that says about me I think that kind of makes it clear where I stand with uh with which one which game I enjoy more uh you can have both obviously um but the other one it's just it's just like a quick well first one thing that I'll mention about the other game is that I learned it in an hour okay like in in an hour I was good to go and and I played and I didn't get destroyed like immediately which could happen in the other game but here uh one thing was how this took me a while to internalize again it's a pretty unique system so the other one set up quick played it a whole bunch uh and I yeah I had a huge enjoyment of the other system compared to this now like I said there are things I I have had fun with this just to be clear uh just the the difficulty yeah um uh the difficulty can be a bit of a bomber sometimes but uh

not not letting go of this game I'll revisit it at some point in the future but I think for now I'm going to put it back in my shelf uh do I recommend it uh I mean I definitely I think you should have Tred it out I wish it wasn't so out of print uh but with how many people enjoy this game so much I think you should even if I you know even if I or many other people might have a issue with how frustrating the difficulty might be I think it's worth trying uh it's unfortunate the prices it commands these days but um I I do at least uh suggest that you know do some research on it see if it's for you and if you're a fan of the IP by the way I think it's an no-brainer uh I'm sure some people are going to be willing to pay the high commanding prices that that this has but uh very fascinating system very interesting uh Dungeon Crawl that is not a it's it's a Dungeon Crawl that's not a fantasy setting by the way it's like a Sci-Fi shooter setting which uh you know it makes it stand out a lot uh so yeah uh Gears of War very very interesting uh game uh and definitely GL glad I tried it uh but yeah I think I'm I'm I'm a bit tired of getting my assc so uh but there you go folks that that those are my thoughts on this um uh game this almost like a historic uh game among board game the board game Community this Legendary game uh so uh if you folks have any comments questions feedback go ahead and put them in the comment section if you

enjoy if you enjoy this content make sure to like And subscribe and I'll see you in the next one

Progress saved