Is My Father's Work fun?
Transcript
my father's work is an app assisted mad science themed board game hi it's Dr Ryan from knights around a table let's find the fun but before we begin I should say that I did something with this game that I had never done for any other board game I've played in my life stay tuned to find out what that is fun the components this is largely why you're buying this board game the components are not too mad scientists kissed beautiful you've got metal coins you've got wooden components that are silk screened with images on them you've got high quality cards and tokens you've got little glass bottles with corks in them to represent potions the gears are metal the animals are silk screened and it's not just one thing that generically represents animal you got a big pile of different animals everything looks beautiful from top to bottom emotionally though it's a little odd to me that these white pieces are kind of top heavy and any small nudge of the board makes them fall over but that's okay because that only happens with the white player pieces oh well they didn't make that mistake with three sets of player pieces okay well surely not all four sets of player pieces do this okay off to a rocky start not fun Randomness now you know me I don't mind a little bit of Randomness in my game but not to this degree the app seems to almost exist to mess with the players so it'll say something like do
you like purple or do you like blue blue is associated with the wind purple is associated with sofas she's like I don't know I guess I like sofas and then the app will be like hahaha I gain three points and then like you'll play a few rounds and the app will be like attention everybody who said they like sofas like a few turns back gets deprived of one worker for the rest of the game or that kind of nonsense you can't predict what the app is going to do to you as a player and like in not a good way not in like a delightful surprise kind of way more in like I might as well not be playing kind of way it reminds me very clearly of an experience I had playing The Wretched Mario Party board game series it's a digital board game that you can play on Nintendo platforms I think we played for about three hours which is too long for that kind of thing with like a roll to move kind of thing I was swamping everybody in points there was no hope of catching up I was in the last stretch I just needed to go a few more places until I reached the finish line and then some mushroom headed thing pops out from behind a rock and says hey trade points with the player in last place and then vanishes in a puff of stars or some nonsense and they're like all my effort in the game was completely negated everything good that I did the game kind of spat on and it feels like that's the case with my father's work you can't plan for anything because you don't know if like at any moment the app could just say well guess what because you placed your scientist figure on the wrong spot you know four rounds ago you
gotta give up four gold you know if your whole strategy revolved around gold well tough nuts to be you I guess I believe there's such a thing as too random and this is it I'm going to tell you how to play my father's work by way of telling you how to play Splendor because truth be told ah they're essentially the same game in splendor you have a tableau of Jewel cards that everybody wants to buy you have five resources that are gems and you spend those resources in order to buy the cards put them out in front of you and then bind the cards you get discounts so that you can buy more expensive cards off the Tableau first person to get to X number of points wins the game so in my father's work instead of five resources that are gems you get a handful of resources that are other things that are more thematic to Mad Science instead of the Tableau being out on the table for everybody to buy from you've got a deck each row in the Tableau is split into level one two and three decks you get cards from each level to kick off the game then you introduce a whole second tier of resources to goof around with and anytime you fill the recipe on the card and you buy the experiment and put it out in front of you it usually gives you a discount to create higher level experiments but then we want to be able to sell something on Kickstarter so we're gonna have to have minis so we need to justify that so those minis are going to become pawns that you have to place somewhere and if you're going to place them somewhere then it's more of a worker placement game what are we going to you will have locations where you can place those minis in order to get resources to spend on the experiments that you want to build and then depending on what happens in the app we'll make the work replacement spots in a book and then we can flip pages so that new locations can get added to that book then we'll add like a private board and a whole extra mechanic where there's tiles that you can spend money on to build to put on your private board to get extra little legs up and let's put some parameters around where you can
place where some of them you can place on your private board something you can place on the main board and then the app can mess around with that so maybe it can give you penalties so it's like people you're allowed to place on your main board you're not allowed to place on the main board anymore or vice versa you can't place them on your your private board sure that's sounding pretty good so it's like the game design kind of sounds like mad science oh it makes a little bit of this so I'll grab this from this game and mix it up and a lot of games do that but a lot of games do it effectively nothing blows up in your face the problem with having all those experiment cards dealt face down to each individual player is that they sort of chained together one card can lead into another can lead into another so you just might luck out and you get one card that when you build it it gives you the prerequisites to build the next card and when you build that one it gives you the prerequisites to get the next card if you're dealt your cards and there's no synergies between them what you have to do is start you know placing workers in different spots of the map and trying to grab more cards so that you can fish through the deck to find those synergies so just do that random nature of the game it could just like deliver a player a much easier path through the game or a much faster Victory and everybody else is sort of left in the Lurch not an Adam's Family reference fun the replayability now despite this being a narrative-based app you might hear that and think oh it's like a one and done kind of thing well no there are three different modules one tells a story about a war one tells a story about paranoia and one tells a story about disease coming to the town you pick which module you want to play with off the top of the game and then when you get to the end of the game you unlock one of multiple different endings I think there are six or seven different endings for each of these modules so what the app is doing is it's making sort of like a random call I believe to
put you on a different path within the module that you choose and all the components that you pull out of those tuck boxes won't necessarily be used for the game that you're playing so you might want to replay the time of War scenario to find out what those tokens that you never put to use actually do in the game I haven't played this game enough times to see if the app is smart enough to sort of Stow an ending once you've unlocked it so that it doesn't randomly draw that same path for you the next time you go through that module I hope it does so on the subject of replayability it's not always a good thing let me give you a little anecdote from when I was a very young game developer I was working at YTV which is like Canada's Nickelodeon channel and I was making games for the website and a lot of them were sponsored games so Skippy peanut butter came to us and said hey we need a game to advertise Skippy peanut butter into children sure I go off and make that game I really like adventure story based sort of graphic adventure point and clicky kind of stuff a lot of narrative heavy elements to them so I made sort of like a murder mystery game with no murder an item was stolen so it was a theft mystery game I mean with a cast of characters I think there were 10 or 12 different Woodland creatures that you could meet in the forest as Skippy the squirrel and each time you played it picked a different one of those 10 or 12 characters to be the murderer the thief and it was sort of cycle around all the different clues that you had to follow so that you followed a different path depending on who the culprit was so the point is I spent a lot of work making sure that the game was really replayable I mean there were 12 different endings that you could see in this game the thing that I didn't figure on being a very young game developer was that I
had to make sure that the game was interesting once in order to justify multiple endings because if players don't enjoy the first experience through it doesn't matter how replayable it is five endings ten endings a thousand endings it doesn't matter if they didn't dig it the first time through they're not going to go for endings two through n so it's a design lesson that I took to heart very early in my career maybe it's a design lesson that these guys are still figuring out not fun the app is buggy now I'm doing this review just about a week after they released the second version of the app I haven't tried the new version of that I kind of don't care to to be honest because my experience with the original version of the app was so lackluster let me give you an example of a couple of ways the app kind of like completely messed up our game to the point where we didn't see a point continuing so in one game it said turn to page 10 of the book and the idea is that the map evolves with different work replacement spots with different pages that you turn to in reaction to the story that's being told in the game so we turn to page 10 and it says something like oh if you place people people in the storehouse and we look at page 10 of the book and there's no location called The Storehouse for example in another instance the app likes to do things where you have to pass the phone that has the app on it to different players and they get to read something secretly that may or may not affect the outcome of the game see my Randomness Point earlier so it was very particular so passed the thing to me okay and I'm going to read this blob of text so it said my username at the top of this text window and it gave me a big
chunk of text that I was supposed to read and then it said like pass the app on to the next player and hit the button so I hit the button now the only thing that changed on the screen was that very small print username the text block of text was the same and the choices at the bottom were the exact same so when I hit okay go I'm handing it to the next person I didn't see anything change so I thought it was still talking to me and I'm like oh I didn't register my choice so I hit the button again and not knowing that I decided for two people so we proceeded and then we thought well it's kind of weird that like player two didn't get the same choice that I did and then thankfully the app has like a go back feature which is a necessity with this kind of thing so he hit go back and I looked at that choice again I said oh that tiny you know four point font changed and it changed to your name that's what happened so I make a choice you make a choice and then something happens in the game so we made the choices we made the choices and then we expected something to happen in the game but the problem is here's what the app is doing it's taking you down a branching path and it rolls the dice on which path that you're going to follow so say you follow it you know two or three steps ahead and you do all the stuff and you change the map and you know you're making all these adjustments and then you think wait okay you know something we're talking a couple steps back I got to go adjust so when you back up to the head of the branch that you were at and you make uh you you correct that or you reread or whatever it doesn't know to send you along the path that it had originally sent you on and it may roll the dice and send you careening off another completely random
path so you're not retracing your steps and going back down the branch that that you were on you could be sent somewhere completely different that's a bug in other cases it did really weird stuff so it's like in one point it told us that okay absolutely everybody this is important everybody at the table has to place their workers on this certain worker placement spot on the map or else there will be consequences like oh okay we better do that then so everybody at the table took that piece and then put it on that location to no benefit by the way they didn't gain resources or cards or anything like that they just stuck there it's kind of like a wasted turn so we thought wow you know it seems pretty important to the game that we do this after we made that choice to play those pieces to that location the app never asked us hey who played their pieces to that location it never said anybody who didn't play those pieces to that location loses this gains this no there's no there's just no conclusion to that requirement in the app it just just went nowhere I thought it was funny when Renegade game says okay you know the board game's ready but the app isn't because it just took me back to my video game development days and it affirmed for me that AB development is a million times more difficult than board game development guys you think makeup board game is hard wait till you try to get served on a video game platform and usually like I don't really side with the people who are like what the board game is app assistant zero zero zero you know just ornery like that don't even give the thing a chance in this case the fears and complaints of all those people are brought to life
there's real cause to Grumble about it here fun the theme mad science it's a winning theme I don't feel like we get it in enough games and I could do with it more in games because I think it's pretty cool especially if you like Gallows humor if you like sort of like dark stuff Woody stuff satirical stuff I think there's a lot of play in that area with the mad science theme and Beyond the component quality I do have to say it's the theme that really drew me to this game I think there's something very compelling about it and it was a good choice not fun okay so you think you're gonna get into like a mad scientist kind of thing and it is a mad scientist kind of thing okay fine but it tacks on certain other themes in those module boxes that are just a little bit too close to real life to make for I believe an enjoyable Friday night at the board game table I remember shortly after the pandemic began I sat down to watch this series on Amazon Prime called Utopia and it was about a plague that was destroying the nation killing a bunch of people and I distinctly remember one moment where a character Stone face looks into the camera and says this virus means the death of 20 000 Americans and I was like sitting back on the couch eating popcorn like
modules in this game is called the cost of disease and it's about a plague that infects people and it's kind of like yeah pass it's the reason I don't Play Pandemic another real life event that happened of course recently is that war broke out in Ukraine one of the modules is a time of War once again like for some weird reason I'm cool with like the you know mostly fictional stuff of like you know reanimating corpses and doing weird unnatural things with the animals bodies and electrifying frogs and making robots and time machines and all that kind of stuff the real sci-fi stuff I could just do without some of the more uh real world corollaries this is escapism for me I want to escape and the game kind of prevented me from doing that a little with mad science as a theme you can go along kind of like a seriousness spectrum and I think the farther away we get from The Source material the less serious it becomes that's why we've got Frankenstein over here and maybe Young Frankenstein over here I think we kind of like mad scientists I mean maybe I'm speaking for myself here but we like it to be more over here than over here especially on a fun game night when you got people invited so I'm not expecting the thing to go completely off the goofy deep end to something you know really Kitty like like Dr Eureka well you're mixing test tubes and Potions but I thought a piece of Pop Culture that straddles that line pretty brilliantly is Dr Horrible's Sing-Along Blog it's mad science it's really funny but it takes dips into seriousness and ultimately it ends off in a really kind of like thoughtful serious note I would have loved for this
game to have struck that kind of tone but it doesn't but there's a reason why Dr Horrible's Sing-Along bog was written by an accomplished screenwriter and this was written by somebody never heard of fun the writing on the flavor text on the cards now these are just one or two line little things and they're kind of uh creepy Darkly humorous gags about the kinds of experiments you're performing let me read you a couple the telegraph machine I found it to be a useful personal tool to relay knowledge of my Infamous creations and to send birthday greetings haha okay cute tensile joint analysis question could joint strength be improved by gluing gears into the hindquarters of the family pet I mean creepy but kind of funny pressurized goggles study the effects of vacuum cylinders on eyeballs I mean when I first found out about the game that was the kind of feel that I was hoping would be in there so good job carts not fun as humorous as the flavor text on the cards is it's almost like a completely different person wrote the stuff in the app the cards this stuff is pithy it's like one sentence you get the gag out it's funny it's thematic it's dark it's Rye I love it in the app though what you have is like pages and pages of stuff that's I think you're trying to set the mood but the tone of it is like desperately dour and serious and heavy and straight face and there are no I mean that I could see there were no kind of like winking like Hey we're all
having fun yeah I'm mad scientist you know mad science and I think some of the best humor comes about from the sort of like the giggling in church effect when things are very very serious and then when funny things happen they make it you know they amplify the funniness but that wasn't the case here either there wasn't anything really there weren't attempts at uh at jokes or levity anywhere it was just like really blah overbearingly dark I would say and I mean for me not in an enjoyable way I think the brevity and wit that was brought to bear on those cards would prove the game tremendously if it showed up in that app fun game trays now game trays is a company that Publishers can commission to create plastic inserts vacuformed inserts for the boxes and a year or more ago when this game was on Kickstarter game Tracer is a major selling point now game Trace seems to be in like every single game you get is almost like a requirement if you make a game it's got to have game trays in it which I mean I'm on board for but they're nice they're nice in this game I mean the the one trade that has all the cool components in it is kind of pill shaped it looks really cool everything fits really nice in it it's not too much of a trouble to figure out which figurine goes into Which slot in the in the tray that holds all the different mini pieces although it would be nice to have maybe this silhouette of the figurine stamped below all the cavities so it just makes it a little bit more easy and if I'm being honest there were a couple of cheats in this insert so I mentioned the three different modules well they're in three different cardboard tuck boxes and when you open one of those tuck boxes out just spills baggies and chits and tokens and pieces and cards and there's
no ordered any of those so it's a bit of a disparity to have everything so neatly organized in the rest of the box and then things just kind of crammed into those flimsy cardboard tuck boxes also I couldn't quite figure out how Trey was supposed to work their indents in shapes for certain pieces but I I can never really figure out how I'm sort of supposed to put them all in there so I mean overall pretty decent job but a couple missed opportunities I think not fun the story now I'm putting quotes around it because what you get from this game I don't think is a story I think the author needs to be reminded that setting is not story let me tell you this story that the game tells in one of the modules and like I don't know click away if you're worried about spoilers but really it's not going to matter so in the time of War scenario it says two sides are a war one is like a rebel peasants and one is the aristocracy different points in the game you have to swear Your Allegiance or should throw your support between one side or the other eventually in the branch that it sent us through we started making Contraptions to help the war effort so one side I'm not sure which used you know our mechanized robots to fight in the war uh one building got destroyed off the map so I was like oh you can't get an extra coin now or something on your turn that was the upshot and by the end of the story uh one side had one I'm not too sure which because the way the way that the writing was phrased was
super generically so that they could reuse that passage whether either side won so that was it there's a war uh you made stuff and one side one don't worry so for a game that's been widely lauded for the story that it crafts like uh I mean maybe I just have much higher standards for storytelling but this doesn't do the trick and then another distinction I think that the author was having trouble with and I'd be interested to know whether it's just one author for this whole thing but there's a difference between story and narration like once upon a time there was a ramshackle house on a Crooked Hill that's not story that's that's setting that's environment and the app scene really like it's really important to the app to set that scene to to generate that mood for what's going to happen in the game and like unnecessarily I think it's mad science like people who are into this game I mean it's not their first Frankenstein Rodeo they know what Frankenstein is they they know of Dracula even if they haven't read it you know they've seen maybe movies based on the book or they've seen movies based on the movies based on the book like maybe you've seen Transylvania six five thousand or maybe you've seen Dracula dead and Loving It you get you get the shtick this is what I'm saying you've seen Young Frankenstein we have a shorthand for different pockets of pop culture and mad science is is one that we have shorthand for so I just have to say to you you know like the Victorian
Gothic and you're like oh yeah oh like Frankenstein and dragon yeah yeah yeah that's it and that's kind of what the app should do it should be like you know like Frankenstein but it doesn't need to drone on paragraph after paragraph after paragraph I'm talking about how gray everything was and how the the winds and rustled the dry leaves and the trees and everything's rotten to km like yeah yeah we get it the moment you say mad science Victorian you know somewhere in Northern or Northeastern Europe we get it we can picture it you don't need to make us picture it I like to contrast this with Manchester Madness which I recently played which is based on the works of H.P Lovecraft and he is famous for like really florid purple prose that just kind of goes overboard and they have a quote from HP Lovecraft right off the top of the of the game experience and in that quote he uses the word tarakius which like you probably never heard it before in your life and you probably will never hear it again unless you read Lovecraft but despite it being based on the works of Lovecraft and the writings of Lovecraft it doesn't it's not written like Lovecraft wrote it it's written in pretty plain English it uses the themes that Lovecraft uses it evokes the same feelings that lovecraft's writing tries to evoke but it doesn't do it with the same unnecessarily obtuse language if that makes sense but what do you have here with my father's work is the author seems like he's trying to write it in the style of Dracula in the style of Frankenstein and so you get him using these 10 cent words that like imagine playing this with your grandma or with a friend who's maybe not that strong of a reader and the app
throws at him a word like chimerical and then your friend says something like Chima rickle you're like what are you talking about here give me that and you read it and like oh you know I think that's chimerical he's like what the heck does that mean you gotta explain everybody feels bad about it and it's just kind of embarrassing could have been done much more simply could have been done with a little bit more regard to the fact that there are real people at this table with varying degrees of comfortability reading stuff from an app just to guess more mind could be paid to the user experience of that aspect of it you know the game promised voiceover and it does have voice over but just like matches of Madness it only has it in like maybe a couple of intro paragraphs maybe off the top of every generation so if you're hoping that the entire thing could be read to you yeah I hope again you're going to be struggling with words like chimerical for the next three hours one more digs of the author because I'm not done yet I question the tastefulness of having a curse word in your rule book I just think that this writing could have used a much more strident editor I feel crappy for saying all this honestly because I'm an artist I create things I know how difficult it is to create things so I don't like dumping on things that people put all their hard work and effort into but when I create something I also Endeavor to make it worth people's money and if I charge a certain amount for it I'm doing my best to offer value for dollar and I think at a much lower price point maybe this game is a better fit for some people of course they'd have to tone down a lot of those components to make it work I don't know but that seems like the point of the exercise take kind of a mediocre game let kind of a mediocre writer wallow in that mediocrity and churn out Reams and reams of text that nobody's
going to want to read and then bundle it up in a really churched up package put a big price tag on it and step four profit you might say oh Ryan the story is really cool because as things happen in the app it adds locations and it takes locations away on that main board where you're placing your workers and I say to you well that's something like charterstone did that years ago and it wasn't interesting when charterstone did it either charterstone would give you this big paragraph like oh the happy little baker how better basket full of Loaves and she was trembling down the street and then she tripped and a little fell out of her basket blah blah blah and you know you're reading this story this supposed story remember there's a difference between story and narrative so you're reading the story narrative and just the conclusion is that now this location on the map gets you two loaves and bread instead of one and so all that blah blah blah all that Yammer that the app major read on the way to that conclusion was just it was pointless craft it was filler it was just wasting your time like I don't think it was making your experience any better and you're not going to end that game saying like oh yeah I fondly recall that moment in the game that described a character who wasn't us doing things that didn't matter you know that's not story that's atmosphere that's setting and if you like that kind of thing fill your boots if your idea of good story is phoning up an old friend who lives in a small town and they say oh things are getting really exciting around here next May we're getting a Taco Bell maybe you'll enjoy the twists and turns that this story throws at you it's not my bag so let's find the fun in my father's
work where fun is represented by Luke I am your father and not fun is represented by in the case of this six-month-old board game DNA test results prove that you are the father
my father's work is not fun so I mentioned off the top of this that I did something with my father's work that I haven't done with any other board game in my life and what was that thing I stopped playing and I have never done that with a game at the very least I'll see it through to the end even if I'm not enjoying it but this game I mean we got to the first turn after the second generation gets introduced second of three generations we all just kind of looked at each other and said you want to keep playing this and the consensus was kind of no now granted we were going through something at the time we had rented an Airbnb and the place was a complete dump and we were on the phone all day with customer service trying to get our money back so it was tainted it was a tainted play so we're not going to hold it against my father's work for that however once we got out of that hellish Airbnb we went over to our friend's houses said what are we going to play well I mean we might as well open my father's work again and uh and you know give the old College try right off the top now that we know what we're doing there's a few rules questions now we can give it another give it another go and we stopped playing again and we stopped playing interestingly at the exact same point generation two first maybe second turn into it the game was just not only was it not interesting it was just not good and I plead not good games before and I can
stick with them but there was just something so off-puttingly unplayable about this game that I couldn't I couldn't Rouse everybody to finish it with me and I kind of if I was honest I didn't want to finish playing it either and you say well Ryan how fair is it for you to do a review of game that you didn't even finish well I think it's absolutely legitimate as a matter of fact I mean with the number of board games out there and especially the number of great fantastic board games out there why would other games that aren't great or fantastic out of the gate even get a shot at taking our precious time our precious Leisure Time from us why wouldn't we want to spend that time on the most exciting stuff that we can do with it but to give it a fair Shake I sat down and did a two-player game with somebody the last two that we aborted were both four player games so I thought okay maybe maybe different player count we played the game and we stopped playing can you guess where we stopped playing that's right generation two turn one maybe turn two by then my friend who hadn't experienced the game before said like yeah I kind of get it yeah it's kind of broken yeah it's not very good it's a simple game with a lot of unnecessary trappings some unintuitive rule stuff the app is just bad he thought they had was bad which it is and we just packed it up and put it away I mean oh for three that's not a great record and then once more I hear you say oh but you didn't finish it man you gotta finish it you gotta get all the way through the game so all right fine I've played this game now four times dnf
dnf dnf and finally we finished a game with four players and the four players or was it three players anyway the players that I had playing with me by the end of the experience were angry at me they were mad that I'd asked them to play this game knowing how bad it was and they played it and they agreed it's it's not an enjoyable game by any means so what's really curious about this is if you go to board game geek and I know I know the reviews aren't everything that scored that number score that you see you should not live and die by that number score and this is a great example why my father's work was a Kickstarter project it cost a lot of money you pay a bunch of bucks up front you pay a bunch of bucks of shipping especially if you're me and you live in Canada it gets delivered to your house you crack it open you're excited you go to play it uh you can't play it because the app isn't ready and even before the app was ready and the game was ready to ship out they said well we're going to wait till the app is ready and then we're going to ship the game out and everybody said no no no no send us the game now so we can touch all the nice components so begrudgingly they sent the game out we touched all the nice components it was great where's the app it's unplayable without it and we waited and we waited and we waited finally they released the app so you sit down you play through it and uh yeah I mean come on it's not it cannot be the best game that you've ever played in your life and if it is generally I'll say that you haven't played enough games but really what's nagging in the back of your brain is how much money you paid for it and so this sunk cost fallacy sets in which tells you that because I paid so much money for the game it must be good right there
must be something I'm missing or I I must be required to sort of like Overlook the shortcomings of the app or I just have to like I can't be an idiot I can't be the idiot for spending the money on this game something else has to be at play here it can't be me so since I'm not an idiot for spending the money on the game the game then must be good so I spent money on a good game that I didn't enjoy and the lack of enjoyment means that I just have to play it more or I have to play a different scenario or something I don't know the mental the mental backflips you have to do in order to justify this purchase and then the really bizarre thing is that the reviews from people who got the game and pulled it out and played it and some people played it you know multiple times and made it all through the end they would say things like ah similar to what I'm saying the app is buggy uh the story is not very interesting uh it's you know it's really swingy or it's like really simple and expect it to be a bit more of a complex game you know they'd have all these similar complaints then they get down to the bottom of the list they'll be like fantastic 10 out of 10.
I was like wait hold on 10 out of 10 wouldn't you knock a couple points off for those six six transgressions you mentioned on your list well no you see it has to be a 10 out of 10 because you paid the money for it expensive games do not get a 7 out of 10 a 5 out of 10. no so I usually don't like to review new games on this platform on the find the fun series I usually stick to older games you can find them in stores everybody's opinion on them this way and that and you can use my video to help make your mind up about it the reason I'm jumping into this one is because I think it points to a larger Trend and sort of a trap for board game enthusiasts and a lot of a lot of people who back a lot of Kickstarter campaigns I think have fallen into this trap I know I have numerous times and I think I'm finally at the point where that Caveat Emptor that buyer beware fear is it runs deep through my veins at this point too many of these projects are really simple games with really churched up components and I go back to the example of splendor splendor thematically I mean the theme is just completely tacked on but it's about gem Cutters and I could see a situation where you could set up a game of Splendor and you could use real precious gems in your game of Splendor so instead of diamond tiles is all actual Diamonds the gameplay would remain the same and it would be a really really phenomenally expensive version of splendor but would it make the game any better playing with the real gemstones my point
is that there's a lot of diminishing returns on this component quality thing foundations of Rome was another great example this is now I haven't played it but this is what appears to be a fairly simple tile laying game that takes place in the city but in order to sell it on Kickstarter oh you know they come out and they make every single tile is this big you know individually modeled building so you get this cool impressive looking cityscape on your board and that's neat but I was interested in how it played so I went to three different two different conventions and I asked people sitting there playing the game like ah how do you like foundations of Rome and I would get this face you know the happy face with this great mouth and be like yeah yeah it's fine yeah it's okay and I'd say well you know they're interesting decisions to make is there is there uh struggle and strife is there tension you know are you are you having fun and they say yes well yes it is quite fun uh yes I'm enjoying myself quite a bit actually thank you and I could just see in their eyes the pain I could see the pain and the suffering and the memory of how much money they paid for this game and how if they turned to me and said well no it's actually quite crap then that would be a tacit admission that they spent a lot of their money on crap and they don't want to be associated with crap so they will not admit that that happened and maybe you're watching this video because you're a customer you bought a copy of this game and you thought I wonder what old Rye Rye has to say about it and as you're seeing me criticize different features of the game maybe you're
sitting there getting angrier and angrier because you're having trouble separating the purchase from you you're having trouble separating that decision from your identity your your identity is that purchase decision you are my father's work you support this on on Kickstarter you know what I'm saying so they don't want to say well it's actually kind of crap what you're hearing is well you're actually kind of crap I think like me you went to a campaign page made a lot of great selling points components look beautiful you love the theme you love this idea of generations carrying work through you know different rounds of the game you love the game trays was involved all these elements added up to what you thought would be a really great experience that you could have fun with with your friends for my part it fell far short of expectations and that's okay because God didn't Make No Junk but Renegade games did people I implore you stop spending exorbitant amounts of money on games with trumped-up components it's Madness did you just watch that whole thing oh hey to 100 this video click the badge to subscribe and then click the Bell to get notifications when I've got new stuff foreign