Top 10 Thematic Board Games
Transcript
the way a board game is designed to suggest a theme is something that i find most compelling about board game design in fact it's something that i'm always looking for whenever i consider whether or not to purchase a board game and the games in this list are the top 10 games that i think do just that before i jump into the list you might want to watch this video on theperfectboardgame.com you can watch the same video but as you're watching you can explore all of the games that are mentioned in this video as well as read descriptions and reviews about the game and all of this is my own personal project so if it's something that you'd like to support i'll also put a link in the description to my patreon site where you can support the perfect board game project and support its future development now let's take a moment to discuss the criteria for the 10 games on this list this is all about games that suggest or invoke a theme it's not about themes that i think are cool so for example the game freshwater fly is a game about fishing i'm not really into fishing i don't think i would normally play a fishing game but when it was brought out by a friend of mine and we played it i loved how the fishing mechanic and the dice drafting kind of supported the luck involved in fishing but also some of the strategy as you you know cast up river or down river in order to target certain fish in their environment their skills involved and i think all of that really makes a game that i might otherwise not find very engaging a lot more
involving for me so when a game can do that draw me in despite what it's about but because of the brilliance of its game design that is what i want to capture in a game that i rate highly for theme for theme implementation that being said there are a few honorable mentions however for example the game nemesis i didn't put it on my list because nemesis is more of a role-playing game which is a lot more intense it's almost cinematic in the way that the mechanics are designed to play out a story it's it's like a simulation game and i decided not to put any games like that in my list because they have a lot more going on mechanically they're a lot more complex and it's not really the kind of games that i like to play honorable mentions aside let's get into number 10.
number 10 is barrage where you try to make the most money by generating electricity using hydroelectric dams the game has two mechanics that i think do a phenomenal job of supporting that theme one is the structure of the way water flows through the game you have four different river heads um or headwaters where water originates from and then it flows down the river and during the course of the game you're building dams to intercept that water and even redirect it through conduits in order to generate electricity this allows you to interfere with other players but the um the stage during which water flows is really powerfully invokes rivers i think that's very well done and then there's also what they call in the game a construction wheel unlike a lot of games when you build something you take resources and you spend their resources putting them back into the common supply the resources are gone but in barrage you have a construction wheel where you take your resources which are machines in this game and you put them in the wheel and you give the wheel a turn those resources aren't gone they're just occupied by the construction project and they don't become available to you again until the wheel has made a full rotation so two excellent mechanics for a game that i think does a great job of embodying it number nine is cryo it's a game that
you've heard me mention before in cryo you are members of the crew of a spaceship and at some point along the voyage there was a disagreement which ultimately resulted in a crash landing on another planet everything is going to freeze at night all of the machines are going to stop working and every human is going to die your only hope for survival is to get the members and the passengers from your ship who are cryogenically frozen in pods into a safe space under the surface of the planet so to do this you need to excavate the planet and you need to transport pods from the broken parts of the ship down to safety now to make that happen since you know everyone is cryogenically frozen the only thing at your disposal are drones so you spend your turn moving your drones to different locations to find materials and build things that will help you get as many crew members and passengers to safety as possible at its heart the game is a worker placement game but the thing that makes this worker placement game exceptional is i think everything makes a lot of sense in the context of its theme so if you want to check that out the game is cryo number eight is by a designer who no thematic list of board games can exclude the designer is vitale lacerda
and while there are so many excellent thematic games that he's designed um kanban venus on mars the one that i think best deserves to be on this list is the gallerist so as is the case with every one of lacerda's games uh the entire game is designed around its theme very thoroughly and in the gallerist for example you are the curator of an art gallery you're trying to get victory points and prestige by discovering new artists promoting them through the media and selling their works of art for profit or adding them to your collection to satisfy objectives and there's also an auction that players are competing in throughout the duration of the entire game i think what the gallerist does is it is a little bit more simpler than some of the other games that i mentioned and a lot more streamlined so if you're considering a lacerated game and maybe if you're intimidated by the complexity of his other games this is a great entry point the game gallerist number seven is a two-player game and it plays very well with couples it's the game fog of love in fog of love two people are enacting a romantic comedy they assume the roles of fictional characters who have made up objectives and the gameplay is playing situational cards and trying to make
decisions that will help satisfy your objectives and be in agreement with your partner however the game is semi-cooperative because there can be different outcomes one outcome might be that at the end of the game you break up and if that satisfy your objectives you can win another outcome of the game might be that you want to stay together forever and in that case the game is definitely much more cooperative but you are not allowed in the course of the game to explicitly tell your partner what you're trying to accomplish you have to communicate non-verbally through the choices that you make in the situation and i think that plays very well in a game that's about building a relationship highly recommended especially if you're looking for a game to play with your significant other the game fog of love number six is a game that deserves extra props for just being so incredibly smart it's the game suburbia and in suburbia ultimately what you want to get is the highest population in a city that you're building and the way that you attract people into your city is by building your city's reputation but in order to have a great reputation you need to have buildings that are reputable and such buildings and parks require money to to purchase and maintain but in order to get money you need things that are a little less attractive
like factories and airports and who wants to live next to a business district or a parking lot you need to get these things in order to increase your income but then those things hurt your reputation so during the course of the game you sort of have to build an engine and balance it just right i think that makes the game fantastically strategic and very thematic but where the theme really shines is in what are on the tiles that you're purchasing and that's why the game is so great every single tile you place just makes sense if you have a parking lot i think it's the parking lot you get more points based off of how many other business districts you have and so on there's a lot going on in the tiles i think the game is just very very clever and that's why it's number six suburbia number five is by another designer of great thematic games much like vitale serde who i mentioned earlier in the list the designer is albin yard album vr designed two games the one on my list is clinic in clinic you're trying to make or get the most reputation by building and managing a clinic and in this game everything must be taken into consideration everything for budgeting for the expenses in your clinic to planning the parking situation for your employees and patients what makes the game even better
is how you do the final scoring because it's not enough just to have a great reputation ultimately what you have to do is make sure that your patients don't spend too much time waiting because who likes to go to a clinic and have to wait for your appointment it's a very involved game and it might have too much for some people some people might think that the game is too puzzly but if you can get past that i can't deny that it's very thematic and it's also a great solo game the game clinic
number four is another two player game and it's the game stronghold stronghold is an asymmetric game so each player has a different role one player is defending a castle the other player is attacking the castle and so you are building these ramparts and trying to build strong defenses and the amount of time that you spend building your defenses is given over to the attacker which is the amount of time that they get to spend sending out their monsters to attack the different areas of your city wall so this game has a lot of tension involved for the defender you're trying to protect any weaknesses and hurt the attacker as much as possible to weaken their forces and for the attackers part you're trying to read what the defender is trying to do and see if you can isolate the weakest points in their wall there's intuitiveness to the gameplay and that's why i put it at number four stronghold we are now at the top three i love getting to the top three these are always so exciting to me all three of these games is in just genius absolutely genius number three is food chain magnate food chain magnet is produced by splatter their games are a small batch so they're very expensive but in food chain magnet what you're
doing is you're building a corporate structure of employees in order to run food chain locations in a neighborhood and you're competing for all of the available clients or potential clients in the neighborhood and the clients in the neighborhood are going to go out every night or at the end of every round and buy fast food from whichever restaurant can satisfy their craving so if you've got one neighborhood where the people want hamburgers and coke and the only place to get hamburgers and coke is your restaurant they'll go there unless there's a restaurant that serves the same thing and has better prices and is closer right so in order to play this game well you're considering everything once again much like clinic by the way you've got to make sure that you're marketing effectively so that you become the only restaurant that can provide these needs you got to manage your prices because either the members of the neighborhood are going to come to you because you're close or because you're cheap you got that being said you have to manage locations you have to manage your staff waitresses are going to help you bring in more income and you have to manage your supply you have to have the right kinds of food you have hamburgers or pizza and the right kinds of drinks you can have lemonade and coke and beer and so there's a lot going on the game is very competitive much like capitalism and it can be very unforgiving too i mean it's it's this is very cutthroat there's only so
much money in the neighborhood to be spent and you want to make sure it all goes to you brilliant game probably too high a price point for many people to get into food chain magnate so let's go to number two number two is an older game and if you've been playing games as long as i have it might be a little iron inducing like oh come on that old thing but listen i maintain that the game does exactly what it's supposed to in order to invoke its theme that's why it's number two the game is twilight struggle twilight struggle it's brilliant twilight struggle is a reenactment of the cold war it's a two-player game soviet union versus the united states now you can win the game by getting victory points or you can win the game by achieving dominance in the european area of the map on your turn and why this game has so much tension as it should for a game about the cold war is that you will have a hand of cards all of the cards in your hand must be played asterix you can save one card for future rounds but you have to play everything now if the card is aligned with your side you can choose the event or the action but if the card is aligned with your opponent's side you have to play the event and this sucks because the event
is always a benefit for your opponent so you're sitting there you're looking your hand and you've got all of these cards that you know are going to benefit your opponent and you can't pass you have to play them how do you play the cards to maximize your benefit while conceding the benefit that your opponent gains so much tension in that decision-making process there is military actions and coups that you can use to manipulate the influence on the board but whenever you're doing these military actions you're increasing the or rather decreasing the defcon status and you could trigger a nuclear war trigger a nuclear war and you immediately lose so you don't want to do that but you can't not play military actions because if your opponent has greater military flex than you have well then that's gonna make you look weak and this is the cold war you have to show them that you're an equal opponent there's so much going on you've got the space race but you know while you're focusing too much on the space race your opponent's doing something else to influence europe and it's very stressful very very stressful and because of the cards there's a little bit of dice rolling involved here so for some people there's just too much luck this is the game where you will constantly be saying oh i have the worst luck ever this hand is terrible but your opponent is probably saying the same thing and you just have to deal with it you can't avoid it you have to deal with it it is a game about luck mitigation it can be very frustrating that's why people don't like it i love
it i love it because it is so thematic it feels like a struggle it's called twilight struggle it's about the cold war it feels like a cold war excellent game excellent game it's old there's that but if you haven't played it and you want something that invokes a theme that's my recommendation
okay number one here's the thing about number one i have never recommended this game yet on this channel this is my favorite game ever ever it does everything right it does everything right the game is imperial imperial is different from any other game i've ever played because it feels like a war game i mean these are countries in europe that are vying for influence across europe but unlike what you might expect you are not assuming the government of a country you are assuming the role of an investor who buys bonds in these countries and it happens to be the case that whoever has the most bonds in a certain country gets to control the actions for that company for as long as they have more bonds invested than any other player but control is constantly shifting from one player to another player and in order to play this game well you have to detach yourself from what you think is best for the country and instead ask what do you think is best for you so to do this successfully while you're controlling the country you want to spread out their influence by strategically placing their militaries in order to dominate a greater part of europe and you get profit based on how much is taxed across all of those territories you have to subtract the expenses for all of your militaries and you're doing this round after round until one country gets to a point where it is achieved more dominance than any other in which case you do final scoring
where final scoring is simply all about how much money you've invested that's what the whole thing it's about it's all about the economic benefit of warfare which is like incredibly well done in this game it's just very brilliantly done for what the game is about here's the only caveat i have here's why you might not want to buy this game you may not want to buy this game because some people who play it they get attached to the countries they want to play as the country and when another investor comes along buys more bond than them and takes control can be very upsetting it can almost feel like player elimination in fact there are times in the game where it's possible that you're not controlling any country at all so you're just waiting until you have a chance to invest again so you can take control back but i've had people get really fed up with the game because it's like i've been eliminated i can't do anything what's the point of playing anymore i feel like if you if you feel that way about the game you're kind of missing the point it's about money it's not about countries but that's that is one of the complaints i've heard so i think this game while it's my number one it does have that element of controversy to it but you know what for best theme implementation i think the game is absolutely genius imperial that is my top 10 list for best board games implementing a theme if you like this don't forget to check out theperfectboardgame.com where you can find other related videos and other lists or you can even organize all my
board games according to their theme oh and lastly if you like a board game t-shirt these are my own design i'm wearing one right here i have another variation which is the full t-shirt print you can find those in the link or on the perfect board game website thanks again bye-bye